Water pollution with chlorinated pesticides is one of the most serious environemntal problems due to their highpersistence as a result of the slow biodegradation. Residue levels of organochlorine compounds including (P, P' -DDT, y-HCH and DDE) and cyclodiene components (aldrin, endrin) in the water and sediments of Lake Mariut, Alexandria (brackish water) were analyzed and determined by capillary gas chromatography. Bacterial isolates collected from sediments of such lake were identified and investigated for their ability to biodegrade the selected pesticides. Water and sediment samples were collected from six different sites in the main basin of Lake Maruit and also through three successive seasons, summer, autumn and winter 1996-97. Bacterial isolates were identified and subjected to two concentrations: 0.05 and 50 ppm of the investigated pesticides to study the interaction between pesticides and bacteria. Results showed that lindane, aldrin. P,P' - DDT and endrine were present in the water and sediments of Lake Mariut at very high levels with residue levels significnatiy higehr in sediments compared to water samples. Seasonal and spatial variation of their distribution in the water and sediments were observed. Biodegradation results showed superior ability of the isolated bacteria to decompose the investigated pesticides with very high efficiency reaching 100% for most of them. Results also revealed selective ability among the tested bacteria for biodegradtion of different pesticides especially at the lowet concentrations.
PDF Abstract XML References Citation
How to cite this article
Microbial metabolism of pesticides has been extensively reviewed (Hill and Wright, 1978; MacRae, 1989; Somasundaram and Coats, 1990; Cork and Krueger, 1991; Linn et al.,1993; Aislabbie and Lloyd, 1995). Fate of pesticides in the environment is affected by microbial activity while their rate of biodegradation is widely varied. Some pesticides are easily biodegradable while others are recalcitrant. DDT (1,1,- trichloro-2,2-bits-(P-chlorophenyl) ehtane) and dieldrin (chlorinated hydrocharbons) and their residues remain in the environment more than 20 years after application and are known to be accumulated into food chains. Other group of pesticides such as organophosphorus are more readily biodegradable while atrazine and simazine are slowly biodegradable and may be leached from soil to ground water where they pose a threat to drinking water supplies (Kookana and Aylmore, 1994).
Biodegradataion of pesticides is determined by two groups of factors, the first relates to microbial consortium and the optimum condition for their survival and activity while the second relates to the chemical structure of the pesticides. Factors related to microorganisms including the presence and number of appropriate microorganisms, the contact between microorganisms and the substrate (pesticide), pH, temperature, salinity, nutrients, light quality and intensity, available water, oxygen tension and redox potential, surface binding, presence of alternative carbon substrates and alternative electron acceptors. The second group of factors including chemical structure, molecular weight and functional groups of the applied pesticides, their concentration and toxicity and their solubility in watr (Aislabbie and Lloyd, 1995). Organic pesticides including chlorinated hydrocarbons enter surface water from application for control of aquatic weeds, trash fish, aquatic insects, percolation and runoff from agricultural lands, drift from aerial and land application, discharge of industrial wastes from naufacturing and formulating plants and wasterwater from clean up of equipment used for pesticide application (Faust and Aly, 1964).
Among the organic pesticides, it is well known that chlorinated hydroacarbons are the most persistent pesticides in the environment (with a half life time over 20 years) and the most important according to their production and field application (Abo El-Amayem et al.,1979). Toxicity of chlorinated hydrocarbons and their accumulation in aquatic biota have been known for years. Because of their low solubility in water, they tend to be absorbed in the aquatic organisms and into sediment particles. Therefore, sediments act as reservoir for such organic pollutants. The environmental impact of chlorinated pesticides on aquatic life fall into two categories: Direct toxicity by lowering dissolved oxygen legels and production of odor and taste in the edible fish and shellfish (WHO, 1984).
Lake Mariut, south Alexandria, Egypt suffered in the recent decades from intensive pollution as a result of a continuous discharge of huge amounts of agricultural watewater that contains large concentration of the washed pesticides and fertilizers in addition to domestic and industrial watewater. Previous studies on L. Mariut proved the availability of chlorinated pesticides which increased with time indicating their accumulation and cycling in such environment (Abo El-Amayem et al.,1979; Abd El-Aal, 1981; Macklad et al.,1984a; El-Sebae et al.,1984; Badawy and El-Dib, 1984). The main objective of the present study was to isolate a naturally occurring microorganisms with a high ability for biodegradation of organic pollutants to be used for bioremediation of the hihly persistent chlorinated pesticides, thus provide a low-cost and naturally renewable method for removing organic pollutants from contaminated media.
Materials and Methods
Study area: Lake Mariut (Fig. 1) is the smallest of the four Delta lakes of Egypt. It is closed, brackish, very shallow lake where the depth rarely exceeds 120 cm. It is situated to the south of Alexandria at latitude 31°10‾ N and longitude 29°55‾ E. The lake area is divided by artificial dykes into four basins: the main basin; the fish farm; the south western basin and the north western basin (Wahby et al., 1978). The current samples were collected from the main basin of the lake. It is an extremely fertile and highly productive water body, one where advanced state of eutrophication treatens its usefulness to man. It receives heavy industrial untreated wastewater, domestic primary treated wastewater and agricultural wastewater. The overflow from the lake is discharged directly to the sea through El Mex pumping station via El Umum Drain. This basin is suffering much, at present, from the intensive pollutants entering it through all kinds of discharges.
Samping: Six defined samples sites (Fig. 1) in the lake were selected in relation to known sites of effluents discharge including agricultural (El Qalaa Drain), domestic and industrial during summer, autumn 1996 and winter 1996-97. Because of the shallowness of L. Mariut, only subsurface water samples were collected. Samples for bacterial analysis were collected in pre-sterilized glass bottles (100 ml). For pesticides, samples of 1 liter were collected in pre-acid washed polyethylene bottles. Sediments were collected from the same sites where water were collected. About 250 g wet weight were collected using a sediment scooper which had a provision for guarding the sediment against leaching during vertical hauling. Sampling technique for water and sediments followed the standard procedure.
Baterial identification: Bactera were isolated from sediments particles by resuspension (by vortexing) of 1 g in sterilized distilled water and then inoculation onto nutrient agar medium (NA) after appropriate dilutation. Purification of bacterial isolates was done after a series of culturing and reculturing. Identification of bacterial isolates took place first by categorizing them into two groups by gram stain followed by classical biochemical reaction (Senath et al., 1989) according to the schemes of Le Chevallier et al. (1980) for the identification of Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria.
Biodegradation assays: Bacterial isolates were inoculated in 100 ml nutrient broth medium (NB), incubated at 37°C under 120 rpm. Cultures were left for 4.5 hrs. to get into early log phase of growth without suppression. Then three different chlorinated pesticides (P,P -DDT, hexachlorobenzene and endrin), selected based on their availability in L. Mariut, were added at two concentrations; lower one of 0.0.5 ppm and higher one of 50.0 ppm. Bacteria were left in contact with pesticides mixture for 48 hrs in addition to control samples without any microorganisms. Ten mis of each of the 48 hrs cultures were drawn aseptically by a sterile pipette, centrifuged at 6000 rpm for 5 min to harvest bacterial cells. Bacterial pallettes were discarded and the supernatants were filtered through 0.22 pm Millipore membrane filter to retain the rest of bacteria. Then pesticides residues or their metabolites in the clear supernatants, after biodegradation were extracted, cleaned up and determined using gas chromatography. The same procedure was repeated every 24 hrs for another 3 days to investigate the effect of the contact time on pesticides biodegradation.
Determination of chlorinated pesticides residues
Extraction and cleanup
Water: Twenty five ml of 25% sodium sulphate was added to 250 ml of each water sample and extracted two times with 50 ml methylene chloride. The extract was filtered through anhydrous sodium sulphate column, dried and dissolved in 50 ml of n-hexane. Cleanup was carried out using small column packed with silica gel and prewashed with n-hexane where 0.5 ml from the sample and 0.5 ml of n-hexane were added to the column followed by partitioning using hexane, benzene and acetone. The solvent was evaporated and concentrated using a micro-syndrer column fitted on a concentrator tube and the volume was adjusted to exactly 2.0 ml (Ernst et al.,1974).
Sediments: A 50 g sample of the sediment was dried and soxhlet extracted with 200 ml n-hexane overnight (4-5 cycle/hr). The extracts were dehydrated with anhydrous sodium sulphate and concentrated in a kuderna-Danish evaporator to a suitable volume of 2 ml in n-hexane. Clean of the resulted extracts was done on florisil column and washed with 25 ml of n-hexane. Clean of the resulted extracts was done on florisil column and washed with 25 ml on n-hexane then partitioned with solvent system (hexane, hexane-methylene chloride and methylene chloride). The solvent extracts were combined in a separatory funnel! and dissolved with 2 ml n-hexane (Keller and Bidleman, 1984; Duursma et al., 1974).
Biological samples: Clear supernatants with the remaining residues of the tested pesticides were washed three times with 5 ml methylene chloride in a separatory funnel. The lower phase was collected and filtered through anhydrous sodium sulphate. The extract were eva;orated and dissolved in 2 ml with n-hexane and appropriate aliquots were injected in Gas chromatography.
Determination: An appropriate aliuot was injected in gas chromatography equipped by Hewlett Packard 5890 series II capillary with electron capture deterctor (GC-ECD). Column, HP-5 (crosslinked 5% pH Me silicon) 30 m X 0.32 mm X0.25 Mm film thickness, made in USA). The injection took place at oven temp. 200°C, injection temp. 250°C and ECD temp. 300°C. The concentration of each compound was calculated by compraing its total area with the total area of standard detected insecticides.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Residue levels of chlorinated pesticides at L. Mariut Water: Table 1 represents residue levels of chlorinated pesticides as detected in the water of L. Mariut's main bain at the selected sites. Lindane, aldrine, P,P'-DD;;t and endrine were detected in the water at very high levels ranged between 0.00162 and 22.317 ppm with averages of 3.30, 2,52, 0.070 and 0.014 ppm for aldrine, lindane, endrin and P,P-DDT respectively. Distribution of chlorinated pesticides in the water of the main basin showed clear and significant spacial and seasonal variation during the study period. Seasonally very clear general trend for all the detected pesticides was noticed.
|Fig. 1:||Study area and sampling sites|
|Table 1:||Residue levels of Chlorinated Pesticides in the water of Lake Mariut during the period Oct. 96-Jan 97|
It was represented by proportional increase in the residue levels of all the investigated pesticides with time from Oct. 96 towards Jan. 97 (Table 1). This trend is attributed to two main factors; microbial population (occurrence and number of appropriate degrading microorganisms) and the temperature. During warm months in autumn, microbial activities of the degrading bacteria increased and led to the decomposition and removal of such pesticides, thus relatively low levels were recorded. While in the colder months, decreasing temperature decreased both bacterial density, bny limiting their growth and their metabolic activities including degradation processes (Sharma and Azeez, 1988; Greene and Darnall, 1998).
Residue levels of chlorinated pesticides in the sediments of lake mariut during Summer and Autumn 1996
Spatially, water at site 2 in the front of EI-Oalaa Drain which transfers huge amounts (500,000 m3/day) of agricultural wastes (nutrients, fertilizers and pesticides) characterized by the highest levels of pesticides. These levels decreases elsewhere away from this outfall. Thus, only samples at site 2 were collected furing the followed months (Nov., Dec., 1996 and Jan., 97).
Sediments: Table 2 represents residue levels of chlorinated pesticides in the sediments of L. Mariut during summer and autumn 1996.
|Table 3:||Bacteria Isolated from the sediments of lake mariut during Summer and Autumn 1996|
|Table 4:||Biodegradation of selected chlorinated pesticides by different bacterial species isolated from sediments of lake Mariut at the initial concentration of 0.05 ppm|
|Table 5:||Biodegradation of selected Chlorinated Pesticides by different Bacterial Species Isolated from sediments of faker mariut at the highest Concentration of 50 ppm|
Lindane, endrine, P,P'-DDT and aldrine were detected in the sediments at much higher levels compared to their levels in the overlying water. Levels of chlorinated pesticides ranged between 0.00652 and 18.03 ppm with a regional average of 5.4883 ppm. Lindane was the most detected compound in the sediment at the defferent sites with a distributiion frequency of 90% followed by P,P'-DDT (50%), endrine and aldrine (30% distribution frequency in the analyzed samples). Also, Lindane had the highest levels in the sediments of L. Mariut cornered with other compunds with an average of 9.302 ppm followed by aldrine (mean = 8.598); P,P'-DDT (rnean =- 0.038) and finally endrine with the lowest levels (mean = 0.021). The order of manitude of these compounds in the water was slightly different and was as follows aldrine>lindane>endrine>P,P'-DDT. As in the water, distribution of chlorinated pesticides detected in the sediments showed highly significant seasonal and spatial variations. Seasonally, all the detected pesticides except for endrine showed remarkable increase in their keels during autumn compared to their levels during summer. This could be attributed to biodegradation and removal of these compounds at the high temperature during summer by microbial action which subsequently decreases with decreasing temperature towards autumn and winter. Spatially, the same trends, as for water, was observed with sites 2,3 and 4 near El-Qalaa Drain were characterized by the highest levels of the detected pesticides. Sites 5 and 6 in the western zone still had high levels of the detected compound but relatively lower than detected in the eastern zone.
Comparison between residue levels of the detected compoounds in the water and sediments of L. Mariut revealed clear and significant increase in the levels detected in the sediments compared to those in the water. Levels of Lindane, P,P'-DDT and aldrine in the sediments were respectively 3.69, 2.71 and 2.6 folds higher than their levels in the overflying water. However, endrine showed the opposite trend with 3.33 fold increase in the water compared to sediments level. These results are in agreement with and supported by the results obtained by (Abo El-Amayem et al., 1979) where levels of the detected organochlorine compounds in the sediments were much higher than those detected in the water. The tendency of chlorinated pesticides to be accumulated in the sediments could be attributed to their high presistence and low water solubilities (Saleh et al.,1980). Thus they tend to be uptaken by aquatic organisms; bound to suspended particulate and colloidal matter and adsorbed onto sediments particles. So sediments act as a reservior for such pollutants in the aquatic environments and could be very important source of organochlorine compounds to the overlying water depending on microbial action.
Comparing residue levels of the detected chlorinated pesticides in the water and sediments of L. Mariut with previous studies confirmed remarkable increases in their levels with time with few exceptins. For example, Lindane and P,P'-DDT were detected during winter 1979 as 0.089 ppm respectively compared to 11.276 and 0.04312 ppm respectively during autumn 1996. This means 126.7 fold increase for Lindane and 0.48 fold decrease in the level of P,P'-DDT.
In the water, levels of lindane, P,P.-DDT were monitored in L. Mariut during 78-79 by (Abo El-Amayem et al.,1979; Saad et al.,1982). Levels of these compounds were approximately 0.00196 and 0.00013 ppm respectively compared to 2.52 and 0.014 ppm for lindane and P,P'-DDT respectively in the present study. This indicated a highly significant increase estimated 1285.7 and 107.7 folds increase in the levels of these compounds respectively. These huge levels of the very toxic and highly persistent chlorinated pesticides detected in L. Mariut water and sediments far excedding the environmental limits of such compounds in surface water of 0.00005 ppm recommended by federfal Committee of water Quality Criteria. Moreover, they are on the other extreme with the statement by (Belluck, 1981) who reported that concentration of chlorinated pesticides in water is usually in ppt range. Not only the levels of the detected pesticide were varied but also their types indicating a change in the applied compounds. For example, (Macklad et al., 1984b), reported that HCH, DDE, DDD and DDT were the major detectable chlorinated pesticides in fish samples from L. Mariut which indicated their availability in the surrounding water. While, during 1985-86, HCH, DDE, Heatachlor epoxide ere the major detected compounds (Macklad et al.,1990). During the present study lindane, aldrine, P,P'-DDT and endrine were the major detected chlorinated insecticides in both the water and sediments of L. Mariut.
Identification of bacterial isloates: Table 3 illustrates the bacterial taxa identified during the present study. Eight morphologically different bacterial isolates were collected and isolated from sediments at the different sites. Identification of these isolates confirmed that they are all different species belong tothe genus Pseudomonas. The dominance of this genus at all the sampling sites in the highly contaminated soil confirmed and reflected its high residstance not only to pesticides but also to heavy metals and other toxic chemicals, all of which find their last destination at the bottom sediment.
The mervlies resistance and superior potentiality of Pseudomonas for biodegradation of toxic organicpollutants and as a biosorbent of heavy metals are extensively proved by many authous (Appaiah and Karanth, 1991; Lindqvist and Enfield, 1992; Zboinska et al.,1992; Barriault and Sylvestre, 1993; Yanze-Kontchou and GSchwind, 1994; Mandelbaum et al., 1995; Aislabbie and Llyoed, 1995; De Souza et al., 1998) and many more. Thus, the occurrence of Pseudomonas with different species in L. Mariut's water and sediments under such huge levels of organic pollution is expected and logical.
Biodegradation of selected organochlorine compounds: Based on their availability in the water and sediments of L. Mariut, three different compounds were selected including P,P'-DDT endrine and lindane for biodegradation assys. Five species of Pseudomonas dominating the highly contaminated sediments of L. Mariut were subjected to two elevated concentrations (0.05 and 50 ppm) of the selected pesticides for different exposure times (Table 5).
At the lowest pesticids concentration (0.05 ppm): Table 4 represents the biodegradation of selected compounds at thier lowest concentration by Pseudomonas spp. Generally all species whowed high ability for obidgradation of the highly toxic and presistent compounds with removal efficiencies ranged between 39 and 100%. They also exhibited selective behavior depends on bacterial species and the organic compound. P. pseudomallei isolated from the highly polluted sites 2,3 and 5 showed superior ability for biodegradation with_ 100% removal of all the tested compounds at a very fast rate where none of them where detected in the growth medium through out the course of the experiment. P. paucimobilis isloated from site 1 in the polluted zone comes next in the order of biodegradation magnitude with complete degradation and removal of the tested compounds after 2 and 3 days. At the fourth and fifth exposure days, about 60% of endrine and only traces of DDT were detected in the medium that could be a release from dead biomass. P. aeruginosa and P. mailei isloated from sites 1 and 2 respectively showed the same behavior where they needed longer intact time (5 days) with defferent compounds to achieve their maximum degradation 1100% RE). P. pickettii from site 5 had high ability for degrading P,P'-DDT and lindane with a very high efficiency (100%) in a shorttime (2 days). While endrin was removed with high efficiency ranged between 87.5 to 97.4%. In conclusion, the identified bacteria showed excellent ability for biodegradation of the tested compounds.
At the highest pesticides concentration (50 ppm): It was very surprising that higher biodegradtion efficiencies were recorded for all the tested compounds by the bacterialspecies at the highest tested concentration. DDT has the highest removal rate by almost the five species with almost 100% biodegradation RE followed by endrine with RE ranged between 60.5 and 100% while lindane had RE ranged between 73.3 and 100%. These results provide a very promisig tool bar for decontaminating polluted aquatic environments from the most dangerous organic pollutants.
Many bacteria alble to degrade pesticides have been isolated and identified. Among these species Pseudomonas exhibited high for degrading different kind of pesticides as for phenaxy compounds Triazine compounds (Mandelbaum et al. 1995), organophosphates (Serdar et al., 1982) and carbamates (Chaudhry and Ali, 1988). Present results confirmed and supported these studies and proved that Pseudomonas spp. Are very effective bacterial species in degrading chlorinated pesticides and can be efficiently used in bioremediation processes for that purposes.
- Aislabbie, J. and G.J. Lloyd, 1995. A review of bacterial degradation of pesticides. Aust. J. Soil Res., 33: 925-942.
- Appaiah, K.A. and N.G.K. Karanth, 1991. Insecticide specific emulsifier production by hexachlorocyclohexane utilizing Pseudomonastralucida Ptm+ strain. Biotechnol. Lett., 13: 371-374.
- Barriault, D. and M. Sylvestre, 1993. Factors affecting PCB degradation by an implanted bacterial strain in soil microcosms. Can. J. Microbiol., 39: 594-602.
- Chaudhry, G.R. and H.D. Ali, 1988. Bacterial metabolism of carbofuran. Applied Environ. Microbiol., 54: 1414-1419.
- Yanze-Kontchou, C. and N. Gschwind, 1994. Mineralization of the herbicide atrazine as a carbon source by a Pseudomonas strain. Applied Environ. Microbiol., 60: 4297-4303.
- Cork, D.J. and J.P. Krueger, 1991. Microbial transformations of herbicides and pesticides. Adv. Applied Microbiol., 36: 1-66.
- De Souza, M.L., L.P. Wackett and M.J. Sadowsky, 1998. The atzABC genes encoding atrazine catabolism are located on a self-transmissible plasmid in Pseudomonas sp. strain ADP. Applied Environ. Microbiol., 64: 2323-2326.
- El-Sebae, A.H., M.A. El-Amayem, I. Sharaf and M. Massoud, 1984. Factors affecting acute and chronic toxicity of chlorinated pesticides and their biomagnification in Alexandria region. Proceeding of the Med. Pol. Meeting on Toxicity and Bioaccumulation of Selected Substances in Marine Organisms, Revinj, Yogoslavia, November 5-9, 1984, FAO. UNEP.
- Faust, S.D. and O.M. Aly, 1964. Water pollution by organic pesticides. J. Am. Water Works Assoc., 56: 267-279.
- Keller, C.D. and T.F. Bidleman, 1984. Collection of airborne polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and other organics with a glass fiber filter-polyurethane foam system. Atmos. Environ., 18: 837-845.
- Kookana, R.S. and L.A.G. Aylmore, 1994. Estimating the pollution potential of pesticides to ground water. Soil Res., 32: 1141-1155.
- Le Chevallier, M.W., R.J. Seidler and T.M. Evan, 1980. Enumeration and characterization of standard plate count bacteria in chlorinated and raw water supplies. Applied Environ. Microbiol., 40: 922-930.
- Lindqvist, R. and C.G. Enfield, 1992. Biosorption of dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane and hexachlorobenzene in groundwater and its implications for facilitated transport. Applied Environ. Microbiol., 58: 2211-2218.
- Mandelbaum, R.T., D.L. Allan and L.P. Wackett, 1995. Isolation and characterization of a Pseudomonas sp. that mineralizes the s-triazine herbicide atrazine. Applied Environ. Microbiol., 61: 1451-1457.
- Saad, M.A., M.A. Elamayem, A.H. El-Sebae and I.F. Sharaf, 1982. Occurrence and distribution of chemical pollutants in Lake Mariut, Egypt. Water Air Soil Pollut., 17: 245-252.
- Saleh, F.Y., G.F. Lee and H.W. Wolf, 1980. Selected organic pesticides, occurrence, transformation, and removal from domestic wastewater. J. Water Pollut. Control Fed., 52: 19-28.
- Serdar, C.M., D.T. Gibson, D.M. Munnecke and J.H. Lancaster, 1982. Plasmid involvement in parathion hydrolysis by Pseudomonas diminuta. Applied Environ. Microbiol., 44: 246-249.
- Sharma, R.M. and P.A. Azeez, 1988. Accumulation of copper and cobalt by blue-green algae at different termperatures. Int. J. Environ. Anal. Chem., 32: 87-95.
- Zboinska, E., B. Lejczak and P. Kafarski, 1992. Organophosphonate utilization by the wild-type strain of Pseudomonas fluorescens. Applied Environ. Microbiol., 58: 2993-2999.