Oviposition Deterrent Activity of Some Volatile Oils against the Filaria Mosquito Vector Culex pipiens
The oviposition deterrent activity of four essential oils derived from chamomile (Matricaria recutita), sesame (Sesamum indicum), jojoba (Simmondsia chinensis) and ginger (Zingiber officinalis), were evaluated against the gravid females of the filaria vector Culex pipiens under laboratory conditions. They were assayed at three doses (0.5, 5 and 50 ppm) where plastic cups containing 1 mL of desired oil concentration and 99 mL of distilled water were used as oviposition substrate. Results indicated that all these oils exhibited potent deterrent activity against gravid female mosquitoes with various degrees of repellency (ranging from 48.73-100%) depending on both plant species and applied dose from each plant. Likewise, Oviposition Activity Indexes (OAI) of such oils were all negative values ranged from -0.17 to -1.28 Although, present results suggesting that these oils are potential source of valuable mosquitoes oviposition deterrents, further detailed research is required for isolating and identifying their active compounds as well as other factors influencing their capacity.
Received: April 24, 2012;
Accepted: June 09, 2012;
Published: August 30, 2012
Mosquitoes are serious vector borne diseases that transmit fatal diseases such
as dengue, Malaria, yellow fever, encephalitis and Filariasis to more than 700
million people annually (Taubes, 1997; Cetin
et al., 2011). Lymphatic filariasis, worldwide disease transmitted
by Cx. pipiens, infects 120 million people in 73 countries (Ottesen
et al., 1997). Controlling Cx. pipiens populations
representing one of the strategies for combating such disease but it becomes
increasingly difficult because of relaying for long time on synthetic insecticides
that finally lead to mosquito resistance to these insecticides (Brogdon
and McAllister, 1998; Perera et al., 2008).
Furthermore, Environmental and health influences of synthetic insecticides have
stimulated the search for new more efficient and safer insecticides derived
from plants (Nogueira and Palmerio, 2001).
Plants are important source of natural insecticides such as pyrethroids (pyrethrin
and allethrin) and rotenoids. In the recent decades, several studies have shown
that many phytochemicals have a toxic effect against insects and their immature
stages by interfering in their growth, development and/or reproduction, or by
producing attractive or repellent scents (ICMR, 2003).
Sukumar et al. (1991) and Shaalan
et al. (2005) reported many other studies carried out to evaluate
the mosquitocidal activity of phytochemicals. Identification of such novel effective
secondary botanical compounds can be used as an alternative to synthetic insecticides
and/or in the integrated vector control programs (Rajkumar
and Jebanesan, 2008; Elango et al., 2009).
Essential oils are among natural compounds derived from a variety of plants
and exhibited mosquitocidal activity. Although most of the mosquitocidal activity
of essential oils was against larvae and adults of different mosquito species
(Sukumar et al., 1991; Shaalan
et al., 2005), their influence as oviposition deterrents against
mosquitoes has not been studied much. A few studies on oviposition deterrent
potential of these essential oils produced from different plants are available.
Strong anti-oviposition activity was induced by crude ethanol extract of the
Australian bottlebrush Callistemon lanceolatus against gravid females
of Culex. quinquefasciatus that were given dual choice of crude
ethanol extract-treated water and non-treated control water (Mohsen
et al., 1990). Elhag (1999) indicated that
neem seed kernels, Azadirachta indica, Rhazya stricta, Heliotropium
bacciferum, Syzygium aromaticum and orange peels extracts significantly
deterrent oviposition by gravid filaria vector females, Cx. pipiens,
at 0.05 and 0.1% (= 50 and 100 ppm) concentrations of water and methanol extracts,
respectively. Out of ten essential oils extracted from medicinal plants, essential
oils of Cinnamomum zeylanicum was found to be highly effective in preventing
egg laying by three mosquito species with an order of deterrence, Anopheles
stephensi > Aedes aegypti >Cx. quinquefasciatus
(Prajapati et al., 2005). Rajkumar
and Jebanesan (2005) found that 0.01, 0.025, 0.05, 0.075 and 0.1% leaf extract
of Solanum trilobatum reduced egg laying by gravid malaria vector females,
Anopheles stephensi, from 18-99% compared to ethanol-treated controls
under laboratory conditions. Essential oils extracted from 18 Thai plant species
belonging to 11 families exhibited oviposition deterrent activity against Ae.
aegypti with various degrees of repellency ranging from 16.6 to 94.7%
(Tawatsin et al., 2006). Rajkumar
and Jebanesan (2008) reported that methanol leaf extract of Chenopodium
ambrosioides reduced egg laying by gravid filaria vector females, Cx.
quinquefasciatus, from 27.7-90.2% at concentrations of 100, 200, 300 and
400 mg L-1 under laboratory conditions. Rosemary oil exhibited oviposition
deterrent activity against the yellow fever vector Ae. aegypti
(Waliwitiya et al., 2009). Elango
et al. (2009) recorded effective oviposition repellency (88.26-96.93%)
of the leaf acetone, ethyl acetate and methanol extracts of Aegle marmelos,
Andrographis lineata and Cocculus hirsutus against Anopheles
subpictus at relatively high dose (500 ppm) whilst the lowest repellency
(47.14-71.09%) was recorded at 31.25 ppm. Similarly, significant difference
in the number of eggs deposited by gravid malaria vector females, Anophels
gambiae s.s., found in control cups when compared with the number of eggs
found in water treated with Ocimum kilimandscharicum or Ocimum suave
leaf extract (Kweka et al., 2010). The
essential oils of peppermint (Mentha piperita), basil (Ocimum basilicum),
rosemary (Rosmarinus officinalis), citronella (Cymbopogon nardus)
and celery seed (Apium graveolens) exhibited oviposition deterrence activity
against the dengue vector Ae. aegypti (Warikoo
et al., 2011).
Hence, the present study was conducted to explore the oviposition deterrent potential of four essential oils, chamomile (M. recutita), sesame (S. indicum), jojoba (S. chinensis) and ginger (Z. officinalis), against the gravid females of the filaria vector Cx. pipiens. Although, these oils are known for their medicinal properties, they did not exhibit mosquitocidal activities except for ginger oil.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Mosquitoes: Blood feed females of Culex pipiens mosquitoes were collected from the field by means of manual aspirator. Collected females were introduced directly into mosquito rearing cages (18-25 female/cage) shortly before the bioassays.
Botanical oils: Commercially available plant oils, obtained from El-Kaptain Company, were used. Such oils were chamomile (M. recutita), jojoba (S. chinensis), ginger (Z. officinalis) and sesame (S. indicum).
Bioassays: For bioassays, 1 mL from the desired concentration (0.5, 5 and 50 ppm) was introduced in plastic cup, 100 mL capacity, containing 99 mL distilled water while control received 1 mL ethanol 95% and 99 mL distilled water. Each concentration replicated 4 times plus control and all cups were randomly distributed inside mosquitoes cages containing 18-25 female mosquitoes/cage. Cages, containing female mosquitoes and chemicals, were left for 3 days and number of deposited egg rafts in both test and control cups was recorded daily until all females stopped depositing egg rafts. Number of female mosquitoes that died without depositing eggs were also recorded but not included in calculations.
The percentage of effective repellency (ER %) for each essential oil and for
each dose was calculated by Xue et al. (2001)
where, ER is percent effective repellency; NC is the number of mosquito egg rafts in control cups and NT is the number of mosquito egg rafts in treated cups.
The Oviposition Activity Index (OAI) is calculated based on the formula of
Kramer and Mulla (1979) as follow:
where, NT is no. of egg rafts in the treatment and NC is no. of egg rafts in the control. Index values lie within the range from +1 to -1. Positive values indicate that more ovipositions were observed in the treatment than in the control (indicating the oil is attractant) and conversely more ovipositions in the control than in the treatment would result in a negative OAI (indicating the oil is repellent).
Statistical analysis: SPSS version 16 was used. One-way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was used for the multiple concentration tests and for percent mortality to determine significant treatment differences. Results with p<0.05 were considered to be statistically significant.
All the oils exhibited oviposition deterrent activity against gravid females
of Cx. pipiens mosquitoes but with different levels of activity
depending on both oils and applied dose (Table 1-3).
In general, gravid female mosquitoes deposited more egg rafts in cups devoid
of oils control compared to treated cups and such difference in
the percentage of deposited egg rafts between test and control is not significantly
different (p>0.05) except for the jojoba oil (df = 3, F = 5.87, p<0.05)
in particular the 50 ppm dose (Table 1). Females of Cx.
pipiens deposited more egg rafts in lower doses, 0.5 and 5 ppm, than
the higher dose, 50 ppm, (Table 1, 2) indicating
that the latter one is the most active for all plant species derived oils. Unlike
chamomile and sesame oils, larger dose 50 ppm of both ginger and jojoba completely
deterrent gravid females to deposit egg rafts (Table 2) and
they were more potent than chamomile and sesame oils.
|| Oviposition deterrent activity of volatile oils against gravid
females Culex pipiens
|aRows are not significantly different at p>0.05
by one way ANOVA with Tukeys multiple range test, bRows
are significantly different at p<0.05 by one way ANOVA with Tukeys
multiple range test
|| Effective repellency of volatile oils against gravid females
|| Oviposition activity index (OAI) of the volatile oils against
gravid females Culex pipiens
The oviposition activity indices for all doses of all oils (Table
3) were negative and ranged from -0.17 to -1.28 which means that these oils
have oviposition deterrent activity and the more the OAI value, the greater
the oviposition deterrent activity. Accordingly, the present results categorized
these oils into 2 groups: the first one showed strong oviposition deterrent
activity including oils that showed OAI>-0.5 up to = -1 such as the 50 ppm
dose of the 4 oils whilst the second group showed moderate oviposition deterrent
activity including oils that showed OAI = -0.5 such as the other doses, 0.5
and 5 ppm, of the 4 oils except for the 0.5 ppm of chamomile oil.
Based on phenomenon of either selection or rejection of oviposition sites by
the sensory receptors located on their antennae (Davis and
Bowen, 1994), researchers investigated and employed this behavior as one
of the mosquito control measures. The present study is one of these trials and
revealed that essential oils of M. recutita (chamomile), S.
indicum (sesame), S. chinensis (jojoba) and Z.
officinalis (ginger) produced oviposition deterrent activity against gravid
females Cx. pipiens. Such activity depended on both plant species
and applied oil concentration (Table 1-3).
The deterrent activity was directly proportional with applied oils concentration.
Gravid females deposited fewer egg rafts in case of 50 ppm compared to 0.5 and
5 ppm and could be considered as applicable dose. Furthermore, the ER and OAI
(Table 2, 3) indicated that Cx. pipiens
gravid females were sensitive to the odour of these oils and highly effective
in preventing egg laying. The reason could be due to a variety of chemicals
compounds in these oils that their degradation within the oviposition medium
producing secondary metabolites acting independently or jointly to inhibit mosquitoes
from laying eggs.
The present findings are compatible with other previously laboratory screened
essential oils and derivatives. For instance, Warikoo
et al. (2011) showed that essential oils of peppermint (M.
piperita), basil (O. basilicum), rosemary (R. officinalis)
and citronella (C. nardus) produced 100% oviposition deterrence
activity against the dengue vector Ae. aegypti when pure oils
(concentration of 100 % = 100000 ppm) were applied in the oviposition medium
whilst present study showed similar activity but at a very smaller dose (50
ppm), in particular the ginger and jojoba essential oils. Similarly, Imperata
cylindrica showed 100% anti-oviposition activity against Cx. quinquefasciatus
at 1000 ppm (Mohsen et al., 1995) that is
20 times larger than the present concentration (50 ppm). Furthermore, the present
findings are 10 times smaller than those of Elango et
al. (2009) who mentioned that effective oviposition repellency (88.26-96.93%)
of the leaf acetone, ethyl acetate and methanol extracts of A. marmelos,
A. lineata and C. hirsutus against An.
subpictus was at relatively high dose (500 ppm). The anti-oviposition activity
induced by crude ethanol extract of the Australian bottlebrush C.
lanceolatus against gravid females of Cx. quinquefasciatus
at 10-100 mg L-1 (Mohsen et al., 1990)
is in coincidence with the present results. Likewise, Elhag
(1999) mentioned that neem seed kernels, A. indica, R.
stricta, H. bacciferum, S. aromaticum and orange
peels extracts significantly deterrent gravid filaria vector females, Cx.
pipiens, at 50 and 100 ppm of water and methanol extracts respectively.
In contrast to the present study, inflorescence oil of Piper marginatum
did not stop the oviposition of Ae. aegypti females when assayed at 50
ppm (Autran et al., 2009) indicating with much
the potential of the present results.
Essential oils of ginger, Z. officinale, exhibited larvicidal
(Govindarajan, 2011), adulticidal (Dadji
et al., 2011), repellent (Govindarajan, 2011)
activities and oviposition deterrent activity (Tawatsin
et al., 2006). The present oviposition deterrent activity results
of Z. officinale are not comparable to previous study conducted
by Prajapati et al. (2005) that indicated that
essential oil of Z. officinale was effective in preventing egg
laying by three mosquito species at a very small dose ranged from 106.7-126.7
μg L-1 = 0.106-0.126 mg L-1. Furthermore, Tawatsin
et al. (2006) found that the ginger oil, Z. officinale,
produced 90% deterrent activity against Ae. aegypti gravid mosquitoes
at a dose (0.01% =10 ppm) 5 times lower than the dose applied in the present
study, 50 ppm but produced 100% deterrent activity.
Results of the resent study suggest that these oils are effective and promising oviposition deterrents against Cx. pipiens mosquitoes and could be useful in the search for new natural mosquitocidal products. Consequently, more research is required to determine active compounds in such oils, their mode of action, their activity against wide range of mosquito species and their residual capacity in natural environment.
1: Autran, E.S., I.A. Neves, C.S. da Silva, G.K. Santos, C.A. da Camara and D.M.A.F. Navarro, 2009. Chemical composition, oviposition deterrent and larvicidal activities against Aedes aegypti of essential oils from Piper marginatum Jacq. (Piperaceae). Bioresour. Technol., 100: 2284-2288.
CrossRef | PubMed |
2: Brogdon, W.G. and J.C. McAllister, 1998. Insecticide resistance and vector control. Emerg. Infect. Dis., 4: 605-613.
Direct Link |
3: Cetin, H., A. Yanikoglu and J.E. Cilek, 2011. Larvicidal activity of selected plant hydrodistillate extracts against the house mosquito, Culex pipens, a West Nile Virus vector. Parasitol. Res., 108: 943-948.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
4: Davis, E.E. and M.F. Bowen, 1994. Sensory physiological basis for attraction in mosquitoes. J. Am. Mosq. Control Assoc., 10: 316-325.
PubMed | Direct Link |
5: Dadji, G.A.F., J.L. Tamesse and F.F. Boyom, 2011. Adulticidal effects of essential oils extracts from Capsicum annuum (Solanaceae) Piper nigrum (Piperaceae) and Zingiber officinale (Zingiberaceae) on Anopheles gambiae (Diptera-Culicidea), vector of malaria. J. Entomol., 8: 152-163.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
6: Elango, G., A. Bagavan, C. Kamaraj, A. Abduz Zahir and A. Abdul Rahuman, 2009. Oviposition-deterrent, ovicidal and repellent activities of indigenous plant extracts against Anopheles subpictus Grassi (Diptera: Culicidae). Parsitol. Res., 105: 1567-1576.
7: Elhag, E.A., 1999. Mosquitocidal and oviposition deterrent effects in medicinal and other plant extract on Culex pipiens L. J. King Abdul Aziz Univ., 10: 55-67.
8: Govindarajan, M., 2011. Larvicidal and repellent properties of some essential oils against Culex tritaeniorhynchus Giles and Anopheles subpictus Grassi (Diptera: Culicidae). Asian Pacific J. Trop. Med., 4: 106-111.
CrossRef | PubMed |
9: ICMR, 2003. Prospects of using herbal products in the control of mosquito vectors. International Center for Materials Research. http://www.icmr.nic.in/bujanuary03.pdf.
10: Kramer, W.L. and M.S. Mulla, 1979. Oviposition attractants and repellants of mosquitoes: Oviposition responses of Culex mosquitoes to organic infusions. Environ. Entomol., 8: 1111-1117.
11: Kweka, E.J., E.E. Lyatuu, M.A. Mboya, B.J. Mwang'onde and A.M. Mahande, 2010. Oviposition deterrence induced by Ocimum kilimandscharicum and Ocimum suave extracts to gravid, Anopheles gambiae s.s (Diptera: Culicidae) in laboratory. J. Global Infect. Dis., 2: 242-245.
Direct Link |
12: Mohsen, Z.H., A.L.M. Jawad, B.M. AL-Chalabi and A. AL-Naib, 1990. Biological activity of Callistemon lanceolatus against Culex quinquefasciatus. Fitoterapia, 61: 270-274.
Direct Link |
13: Mohsen, Z.H., A.L.M. Jawad, M. Al-Saadi and A. Al-Naib, 1995. Anti-oviposition and insecticidal activity of Imperata cylindrical (Graminae). Med. Vet. Entomol., 9: 441-442.
14: Nogueira, de M.A.S. and M. Palmerio, 2001. Practice oriented results on use and production of plant extracts and pheromones in integrated and biological pest control. Proceedings of the Workshop on Neem and Pheromones, May 15-16, 2001, Uberaba, Brasil, -
15: Ottesen, E.A., B.O. Duke, M. Karam and K. Behbehani, 1997. Strategies and tools for the control/elimination of lymphatic filariasis. Bull. World Health Organ., 75: 491-503.
16: Perera, M.D.B., J. Hemingway and S.H.P.P. Karunaratne, 2008. Multiple insecticide resistance mechanisms involving metabolic changes and insensitive target sites selected in anopheline vectors of malaria in Sri Lanka. Malaria J., Vol. 7.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
17: Prajapati, V., A.K. Tripathi, K.K. Aggarwal and S.P.S. Khanuja, 2005. Insecticidal, repellent and oviposition-deterrent activity of selected essential oils against Anopheles stephensi, Aedes aegypti and Culex quinquefasciatus. Bioresour. Technol., 96: 1749-1757.
Direct Link |
18: Rajkumar, S. and A. Jebanesan, 2005. Oviposition deterrent and skin repellent activities of Solanum trilobatum leaf extract against the malarial vector Anopheles stephensi. J. Insect Sci., 5: 15-15.
Direct Link |
19: Rajkumar, S. and A. Jebanesan, 2008. Bioactivity of Chenopodium ambrosioides L. (Family. Chenopodiaceae) against the filariasis vector Culex quinquefasciatus Say (Diptera: Culicidae). Can. J. Pure Applied Sci., 2: 129-132.
20: Shaalan, E.A.S., D. Canyon, M.W.F. Younes, H. Abdel-Wahab and A.H. Mansour, 2005. A review of botanical phytochemicals with mosquitocidal potential. Environ. Int., 31: 1149-1166.
CrossRef | PubMed | Direct Link |
21: Sukumar, K., M.J. Perich and L.R. Boobar, 1991. Botanical derivatives in mosquito control: A review. J. Am. Mosq. Control Assoc., 72: 210-237.
PubMed | Direct Link |
22: Tawatsin, A., P. Asavadachanukorn, U. Thavara, P. Wongsinkongman and J. Bansidhi et al., 2006. Repellency of essential oils extracted from plants in Thailand against four mosquito vectors (Diptera: Culicidae) and oviposition deterrent effects against Aedes aegypti (Diptera: Culicidae). Southeast Asian J. Trop. Med. Public Health, 37: 915-931.
23: Waliwitiya, R., C.J. Kennedy and C.A. Lowenberger, 2009. Larvicidal and oviposition-altering activity of monoterpenoids, trans-anethole and rosemary oil to the yellow fever mosquito Aedes egypti (Diptera: Culicidae). Pest Manag. Sci., 65: 241-248.
Direct Link |
24: Warikoo, R., N. Wahab and S. Kumar, 2011. Oviposition-altering and ovicidal potentials of five essential oils against female adults of the dengue vector, Aedes aegypti L. Parasitol. Res., 109: 1125-1131.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
25: Xue, R.D., D.R. Barnard and A. Ali, 2001. Laboratory and field evaluation of insect repellents as oviposition deterrents against mosquito Aedes albopictus. Med. Vet. Entomol., 15: 126-131.
26: Taubes, G., 1997. A mosquito bites back. New York Times Magazine, August 24, pp: 40-46, http://www.nytimes.com/1997/08/24/magazine/a-mosquito-bites-back.html