Physiological Traits in Integration with Yield and Yield Components in Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) Study of their Genetic Variability and Correlation
The present study was aimed to determine whether physiological traits could be taken into the selection criteria in integration with yield and yield components to achieve a successful breeding programme. Analysis of variance revealed significant differences for MSS values of all 50 lines for all the traits under study. High Phenotypic Coefficient of Variation (PCV) and Genotypic Coefficient of Variation (GCV) on the basis of pooled data was obtained for grain yield per plot, tillers per m2, harvest index and 1000-grain weight. Among the physiological traits high PCV and GCV was obtained for seed vigour index and leaf nitrogen while chlorophyll-a, b and total chlorophyll records moderate estimates of PCV and GCV. Heritability accompanied with high genetic advance as percent mean was observed highest for grain yield per plot, seed vigour index, leaf nitrogen content, harvest index, spike length, grains per spike, 1000-grain weight, chlorophyll b and chlorophyll-a, suggesting selection for these traits may be rewarding. All the physiological traits along with yield components exhibited significantly positive correlation with grain yield per plot at both phenotypic and genotypic levels. On the basis of study it is suggested there is a great need to give emphasis on physiological breeding approach to integrate with conventional breeding methods as compliment factor to break present yield ceiling and develop photosynthetically efficient and stress tolerant wheat varieties. Further the above said physiological traits which have significant correlation with yield and high heritability accompanied with genetic advance should be taken into the selection criteria for breeding methods.
Received: February 27, 2011;
Accepted: July 15, 2011;
Published: July 30, 2011
Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) belongs to family Gramineae is one of the most important crop of the world. The world wide importance of wheat can be realized from the fact that FAO symbol is a bread wheat spike with the Latin motto Fiat Panis meaning let there be bread. Wheat is the dominant grain of the world commerce. It is used to produce a large variety of foods that include many kinds and types of breads, cakes, breakfast foods, biscuits and confectionary items. It is a good source of carbohydrates, protein and other important minerals and vitamins. Wheat is the second largest food crop of our county with the production of about 73 million tons from the area of about 28 million hectares.
Undoubtedly, wheat breeding programme world wide has achieved significant genetic
gains in yield potential without aid of physiological selection tools (Rajaram
and Van-Ginkel, 1996) but plant breeders, as well plant physiologists, generally
agree that future success will be realized to a greater extent by integration
of these two disciplinary research (Jackson et al.,
1996). Physiological selection techniques are now being evaluated for their
role as complementary tools in the wheat breeding research at CIMMYT (Reynolds
et al., 1998).
Photosynthesis is the most important physiological event on the earth. It serves
as worlds largest solar battery. The most important photosynthetic pigments
in the chloroplast are chlorophyll-a and chlorophyll-b. Chemically, they differ
from each other and absorb light of different wave lengths to perform photosynthesis.
They perform important function in the absorption and exploitation of light
energy, thereby influencing photosynthetic efficiency (Pang
and Dong, 1995). Increasing chlorophyll content in crops is effective way
to increase biomass production and grain yield (Wang et
al., 2008). Leaf nitrogen concentration on the other hand is important
because nitrogen is the core component of chlorophyll molecule as the structural
component in porphyrin ring and thus its content in the leaf is directly proportional
to chlorophyll content (Rahman et al., 2007).
Up to 75% of the reduced nitrogen present in photosynthetically active cells
of cereal crop leaves is located in the chloroplast (Peoples
and Dalling, 1988; Hortensteiner and Feller, 2002).
Optimum plant population is one of the most crucial factor for obtaining higher
production and profitability for any crop, which is generally influenced by
vigour status of seed. Wheat breeders are continuously seeking the improvement
in wheat through various ways to ensure a near perfect stand of crop, which
in turn depends upon good quality seed with good germination followed by vigorous
seedlings, which can help the crop to escape the hazards of water stress conditions
etc., Early seedling vigour is considered an essential component of plant development
under most environmental conditions (Khan et al.,
In any crop improvement programme evaluation of germplasm for identification
of genetic variability in various traits is very important, mostly when considering
the adoption of new traits (like some physiological traits in present study)
to create further variability through hybridization is of vital importance.
The extent of possible improvement for a particular character mainly depends
upon the extent of genetic variability and its heritable portion. On the other
hand correlation coefficient gives us an idea about the various associations
existing with yield and yield components, therefore to bring a change in yield
or other yield related traits to a desired level, proper understanding of association
between yield, yield component traits or new traits which are being introduced
in breeding programme is must (Malik and Malik, 2005).
Keeping in view above concept, chlorophyll-a, b, leaf nitrogen and seed vigour
index were taken as physiological traits in the present study to integrate them
into the conventional breeding methods as selection criteria to evolve photosynthetically
efficient and moisture stress wheat lines in future.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experiment was conducted in the Department of Genetics and Plant breeding/Seed
Science and Tech., Sam Higginbottom Institute of Agriculture, Technology and
Sciences (formerly AAI-DU) Deemed University, Allahabad; India during rabi season
in two years (2007-08 and 2008-09) for both laboratory and field experiments.
The experimental material consists of 50 elite spring wheat lines from CIMMYT,
Mexico. Physiological traits viz. Seed vigour index was calculated from procedure
given by Abdul-Baki and Anderson (1973), Chlorophyll
content (a and b) was estimated from flag leaf at flowering stage by the method
given by Arnon and Stout (1939) and Leaf nitrogen was
estimated by Micro-Kjeidahl method (Horwitz, 1970) from
flag leaf too. The field experiment was laid down in Randomized Block Design
with three replications during two consecutive years (2007-08 and 2008-09).
The observations were recorded on five randomly selected plants from each line
in each replication for Spike length, Grains per spike and 1000-grain weight
except Harvest Index and Grain yield per plot which were calculated from plot
basis of 6 m2 size and Tillers per m2 which was calculated
from an area of one meter square from each plot.
Statistical analysis: The pooled data obtained from two years (2007-08
and 2008-09) were subjected to analysis of variance by Fisher
(1936), phenotypic and genotypic coefficient of variance (PCV and GCV) by
Burton and Devane (1953), Heritability (broad scence)
by Burton and Devane (1953), Genetic advance by Johnson
et al. (1955) and correlation coefficient (phenotypic and genotypic)
by Al-Jibouri et al. (1958).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Estimation of variability is one of the most important factors in any crop
for identification of lines, which can generate further variability so that
artificial selection of desirable genotype could be made. Analysis of variance
of two years data revealed significant differences for both physiological as
well as yield and yield component traits, indicating relatively high magnitude
of genetic diversity in these lines under study. Analysis of variance on the
basis of mean sum of squares of two years (2007-08 and 2008-09) was observed
highest for grains per spike (104.21 and 107.631), seed vigour index (53.32
and 58.37), 1000-grain weight (52.24 and 55.54) and tillers/m2 (43.22
and 50.98). while lowest analysis of variance on the basis of mean sum of squares
was observed in chlorophyll-a (0.525 and 1.21), total chlorophyll (0.822 and
2.11), chlorophyll-b (1.26 and 1.99) and grain yield per plant (2.45 and 3.72).
Two years pooled mean performances and range of different traits is given in
the Table 1. The magnitude of genetic and environmental effects
involved in the expression of different characters were determined by phenotypic
and genotypic coefficient of variation. Table 2 reveals that,
the magnitude of Phenotypic Coefficient of Variation (PCV) was found higher
than the Genotypic Coefficient of Variation (GCV) for all the characters.
|| Analysis of variance, Range and Mean of 11 Physiological,
yield and yield component traits in 50 elite spring lines of wheat
|**Significant at 5% level and *Significant at 1%, respectively
||GCV, PCV, Heritability and genetic advance (as percentage
of mean) for 11 physiological, yield and yield component traits in wheat
High coefficient of variation (GCV and PCV) among yield and yield component
traits were observed for grain yield per plot (12.42 and 14.87), tillers per
m2 (10.61 and 12.46), harvest index (10.30 and 12.10) and 1000-grain
weight (10.66 and 12.05). GCV and PCV for yield attributing traits in wheat
were also reported by Walia and Garg (1996). Among the
physiological traits high GCV and PCV were observed for seed vigour index (11.24
and 12.66) and leaf nitrogen (10.04 and 11.32). While chlorophyll-a (7.74 and
8.39), chlorophyll-b (8.95 and 10.31) and total chlorophyll (9.25 and 10.37)
recorded moderate coefficient of GCV and PCV. Coefficient of variation for seed
vigour traits also reported by Khan et al. (2002).
Munir et al. (2007) reported genetic variability
for chlorophyll content in wheat. The estimate of genotypic coefficient of variation
reflects the total amount of genotypic variability present in the material.
However, the proportion of this genotypic variability which is transmitted from
parents to the progeny is reflected by heritability. In the present investigation,
all the 11 characters i.e., Physiological as well as yield and yield components
scored high to moderate heritability. High heritability among physiological
traits scored by leaf nitrogen (79.05) followed by seed vigour index (78.80),
chlorophyll-b (78.40), chlorophyll-a (70.10) and total chlorophyll (74.00).
These findings are supported by Ghai et al. (1969)
who reported high heritability for chlorophyll content. Among yield and yield
component traits, highest heritability was estimated for grain yield (82.05)
followed by harvest index (72.60). Whereas, moderate heritability was recorded
for 1000-grain weight (71.90), spike length (71.50), tillers per m2
(68.20). These findings are in conformity with Sexana et
al. (2007). From the present investigation it was observed that all
the physiological traits with some other important yield component traits show
highest heritability indicating these traits are controlled by additive gene
action. Hence, these physiological traits along with other yield attributes
have great opportunity to be adopted as selection criteria in future wheat breeding
programmes to enhance yield. According to Johnson et
al. (1955), a heritable estimates along with genetic advance as percent
mean is more meaningful than the heritability alone in predicting the ultimate
effect of solution. Our findings on grain yield per plot, seed vigour, leaf
nitrogen content, harvest index and spike length are quite encouraging since
these characters exhibited high heritability estimates along with high genetic
advance and these traits were least influenced by the environment and might
show least genotype x environment interaction. Similar findings were observed
by Raha and Ramgiri (1998).
To bring a change in yield or other yield related traits to a desired level,
proper understanding of association between yield, yield component traits or
new traits which are being introduced in breeding programme is must. This approach
might be useful in selection of traits associated with highest expression of
yield and improvement of the character without sacrificing much in other traits.
The genotypic and phenotypic correlation coefficients were worked out on the
basis of pooled data of two years. In general, genotypic correlation coefficients
were higher in magnitude than the phenotypic correlations. This indicates that
there was high genetic relationship between the traits under study and environment
has not much influencing in reducing their actual association. The data illustrated
in Table 3, indicates that all the traits viz. seed vigour
index (0.814 and 0.671), chlorophyll-a (0.713 and 0556), chlorophyll-b (0.574
and 0.503), total chlorophyll (0.714 and 0.683), leaf nitrogen (0.624 and 0.512),
tillers per m2 (0.412 and 0.362), spike length (525 and 0.443), grains
per spike (0.712 and 0.632), harvest index (0.797 and 0.599) and 1000-grain
weight (0.903 and 0.812) had significantly positive correlation with grain yield
per plot at both genotypic and phenotypic levels. Positive and significant correlation
of above physiological traits with yield and yield components indicates strong
association of these traits with yield. Therefore, by increasing the value of
these traits by breeding and selection, yield may be easily pushed up. Suggesting
that selection for these traits will be useful in improving grain yield. It
has also been proved that physiological traits like chlorophyll (a, b and total),
leaf nitrogen and seed vigour index taken in the present study along with other
yield traits have showed strong positive correlation with grain yield. Hence,
these physiological traits could be integrated with conventional breeding techniques
as new selection criteria to enhance the yield per se.
|| Genotypic and phenotypic correlation coefficient among different
genotypic wheat (Pooled)
|**Significant at 5% level and *Significant at 1%, respectively.,
S.V: Seed Vigour, L.N: Leaf nitrogen Chl-a: Chlorophyll-a, Chl-b: Chlorophyll-b,
T.Chl: Total chlorophyll, T/m 2: Tillers/m2, SL: Spike length, G/S: Grains/spike,
G.W: Grain weight, H.I: Harvest index, G.Y: Grain yield
Our findings are supported by Singh et al. (2007)
who reported significant positive association of seed vigour with yield. Iimulwar
et al. (2003) reported significant positive correlation of chlorophyll
with yield. Saleem et al. (2006) observed positive
and significant correlation of tillers per plant, spike length and 1000-grain
weight with grain yield and Sexana et al. (2007)
who reported strong positive and significant association of harvest index and
tillers per plant with grain yield.
Because of limited knowledge of the physiological processes involved in harnessing maximum grain yield, the identification of traits related to grain yield is most formidable task by the plant breeders. It is envisioned that selection for appropriate physiological traits may be quite helpful in enhancing the yield than by selecting for grain yield itself. The information derived from this study established the fact that physiologic breeding approach is right approach to increase the yield per se by integrating the important physiological traits with conventional breeding methods as selection criteria.
1: Abdul-Baki, A.A. and J.D. Anderson, 1973. Vigor determination in soybean seed by multiple criteria. Crop Sci., 13: 630-633.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
2: Al-Jibouri, H.A., P.A. Miller and H.F. Robinson, 1958. Genoytpic and environmental variances and covariances in an upland cross of inter-specific origin. Agron. J., 50: 633-636.
Direct Link |
3: Arnon, D.I. and P.R. Stout, 1939. The essentiality of certain elements in minute quantity for plants with special reference to copper. Plant Physiol., 14: 371-375.
Direct Link |
4: Rahman, M.A., H. Hasegawa, M.M. Rahman, M.N. Islam, M.A.M. Miah and A. Tasmen, 2007. Effect of arsenic on photosynthesis, growth and yield of five widely cultivated rice (Oryza sativa L.) varieties in Bangladesh. Chemosphere, 67: 1072-1079.
5: Burton, G.W. and E.H. Devane, 1953. Estimating heritability in tall fescue (Festuca arundinacea) from replicated clonal material. Agronomy J., 45: 478-481.
6: Fisher, R.A., 1936. The use of multiple measurement in taxonomic problems. Ann. Eugen., 7: 179-188.
Direct Link |
7: Ghai, B.S., A.K. Srivastava and K.S. Gill, 1969. Inheritance of amount of chlorophyll in wheat(Triticum aestivum L.). Euphytica, 18: 403-405.
8: Iimulwar, S.R., C.N. Hatmode, R.D. Deotale, D.B. Vandana, S.N. Mahalle and P.S. Pawar, 2003. Correlation of biochemical and yield contributing parameters with seed yield in mustard. J. Soils Crops, 13: 158-161.
9: Horwitz, W., 1970. Official Methods of Analysis of the Association of Official Analytical Chemists. 11th Edn., AOAC., Washington, DC., USA., pp: 392
10: Jackson, P., M. Roberston, M. Cooper and G. Hammer, 1996. The role of physiological understanding in plant breeding; from a breeding perspective. Field Crop Res., 49: 11-37.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
11: Johnson, H.W., H.F. Robinson and R.E. Comstock, 1955. Estimation of genetic and environmental variability in soybeans. Agron. J., 47: 314-318.
12: Khan, M.Q., S. Anwar and M.I. Khan, 2002. Genetic variability for seedling traits in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) under moisture stress conditions. Asian J. Plant Sci., 1: 588-590.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
13: Munir, M., M.A. Chowdhry and T.A. Malik, 2007. Correlation studies among yield and its components in bread wheat under drought conditions. Int. J. Agric. Biol., 9: 287-290.
14: Pang, R.Z. and Y.D. Dong, 1995. Plant Physiology. Higher Education Press, Beijing, Wang
15: Sexana, P., R.S. Rawat, J.S. Verma and B.K. Meena, 2007. Variability and character association analysis for yield and quality traits in wheat. Pantnagar J. Res., 5: 58-60.
16: Peoples, M.B. and M.J. Dalling, 1988. The Interplay Between Proteolysis and Amino Acid Metabolism during Senescence and Nitrogen Reallocation. In: Senescence and Aging in Plants, Nooden, L.D. and A.C. Leopold (Eds.). Academic Press, New York, USA., pp: 181-217
17: Hortensteiner, S. and U. Feller, 2002. Nitrogen metabolism and remobilization during senescence. J. Exp. Botany, 53: 927-937.
Direct Link |
18: Malik, R.S. and S.K. Malik, 2005. Genetic variability and association between yield and yield attributing traits in bread wheat. Ann.Agric. Res. New Series, 26: 115-125.
19: Raha, P. and S.R. Ramgiri, 1998. Genetic variability of metric traits in wheat and Triticale crosses over environment. Crop Res. Hisar, 16: 318-320.
20: Rajaram, S. and M. Van-Ginkel, 1996. Yield Potential Debate: germplasm vs. Methodology or Both. In: Increasing Yield Potential in Wheat: Breaking the Barriers, Reynolds, M.P., S. Rajaram and A. Mc Nab (Eds.). CIMMYT, Mexico, DF
21: Reynolds, M.P., R.P. Singh, A. Ibrahim, O.A.A. Ageeb, A. Larque-Saavedra and J.S. Quick, 1998. Evaluating physiological traits to compliment empirical selection for wheat in warm environment. Euphytica, 100: 85-94.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
22: Singh, G.P., H.B. Chaudhary and S. Tripathi, 2007. Genetic variability for seedling traits in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) for moisture stress conditions. Indian J. Agric. Sci., 77: 526-528.
23: Saleem, U., I. Khaliq, T. Mahmood and M. Rafique, 2006. Phenotypic and genotypic correlation coefficients between yield and yield component in wheat. J. Agric. Res., 44: 1-8.
24: Walia, D.P. and D.K. Garg, 1996. Evaluation of genetic divergence in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) germplasm. Indian J. Genet., 56: 452-457.
Direct Link |
25: Wang, F., G. Wang, X. Li, J. Huang and J. Zhang, 2008. Heridity, physiology and mapping of chlorophyll content gene of rice (Oryza sativa). J. Plant Physiol., 165: 324-330.