Metal Contents in Some Brands of Biscuits Consumed in Southern Nigeria
Chukwujindu M.A. Iwegbue
The concentrations of zinc, iron, chromium, calcium, magnesium, nickel, lead, copper, cobalt and cadmium were determined in six major classes of biscuits in Nigerian market after acid digestion by flame atomic absorption spectrophotometry. The mean concentrations of metals in various biscuit classes ranged from 29.06-49.27, 45.02-109.00, 0.39-0.72, 0.01-2.90, 205.64-395.27, 118.10-121.30, 2.15-4.88, <0.001-1.07, 0.53-5.04, nd-1.30, 0.03-0.05 μg g-1 for Zn, Fe, Cr, Mn, Ca, Mg, Ni, Pb, Cu. Co and Cd, respectively. The estimated daily intake in μg kg-1 body weight is below the prescribed Tolerable Daily Intake (TDI) values for each metal except for nickel.
November 09, 2011; Accepted: December 09, 2011;
Published: January 21, 2012
The study of metal composition of foods is of great significance because some
of these metals are essential or toxic (Onianwa et al.,
1999; Gopalani et al., 2007; Iwegbue,
2011). The essential metals (e.g., Mn, Cu, Zn, Co, etc) own their essentiality
being constituents of enzymes and other important proteins involved in key metabolic
pathways, hence, deficient supply results into metabolic dysfunction causing
diseases (Iwegbue, 2011). The toxic metals (e.g., Hg,
Cd and Pb) have no known biological function and exhibit toxicological problems
even at trace concentrations. Biscuits are the most favourite food items of
children and one often presented to them as token of love and affection from
their parents and relatives. Consumption of biscuit is not limited to children
alone; adults do consume biscuits as well.
The common basic ingredients of biscuits are flour, fats, sugar, aerating,
chemicals and milk or water. Most types are prepared from one of the following
classes of dough, soft sweet (digestive), hard sweet (e.g., Rich tea) and laminated
(e.g., cream crackers) (Pearson, 1976).
Ingestion of foods is an obvious means of exposure to metals, not only because
many metals are natural components of food stuffs but also because of contamination
during process (Ashraf, 2006). The contamination of
food occurs at any point of the production chain to point of consumption. Obviously,
concentrations of metals in food items at the point of consumption are necessary
for estimation of actual amount of metals exposure to humans from ingestion
of these food items. In developing countries like Nigeria, there is paucity
of data on metal composition of foods and extent of the exposure of humans to
chemical hazards in foods is still patchy. For many developing countries, data
on contamination of foods and exposure through foods are not collected or may
be incomplete or collected in a way that make it difficult for inter-country
comparison. To assess the risk to human's health arising from the presence of
metals in foods, the actual dietary intake of metal should be estimated and
compared with the corresponding toxicological reference intake, the Provisional
Tolerable Weekly Intake (PTWI). Estimation of actual dietary intake of metals
is essential for risk assessment and can be used to determine whether there
may be a relationship between the observed adverse effects in human and exposure
to particular contaminant (Anonymous, 2009). In view
of this fact, the present study presents an account of concentrations of Ca,
Mg, Cd, Cu, Co, Cr, Ni, Fe and Zn in some brands of biscuits in Nigeria.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Samples of biscuits were collected from various brands within the six major classes of biscuits namely (1) short cake (2) short bread (3) cookies (4) cream crackers (5) digestives and (6) cabin. A total of 10-18 different brands were collected within each major group. The samples collected covered both locally produced and imported biscuits. The choice of the samples was carefully made to reflect the various brands consumed by different income classes and influenced availability as of the time of the study.
All reagents used were of analytical grades. Working standards of Cd, Cu, Cr, Co, Fe Ni, Pb, Ca, Mg, Mn and Zn were prepared by diluting stock solution (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) of 1000 mg L-1 in 0.25 mol L-1 HNO3.
The samples of the biscuit were dried at 60°C for 1 h in the oven. The dried materials were powdered using a porcelain crucible. The digestion of samples for determination of metals (Ca, Mg, Ca Cu, Cr, Co, Ni, Mn, Fe and Zn) was done using a mixture of nitric acid and perchloric acids. Biscuit samples (2.00 g) placed in digestion tubes were pre-digested using 10 mL of concentrated HNO3 at 120°C until the liquor was clear, next, 10 mL HNO3 and 2 mL of HClO4 were added and temperature was maintained at 135°C for 2 h until the liquor becomes colourless. The digested aliquots were filtered through a Whatman No. 1 filter paper and diluted to 25 mL with 0.25 mol L-1 HNO3. In all metal determinations, analytical blanks were prepared in a similar manner omitting the sample.
The concentrations of metals in sample solutions were determined using flame atomic absorption spectrophotometry (GBC scientific equipment SENS AA, Melbourne, Australia). Blanks and calibration standards were also analyzed in a similar manner.
All glassware was soaked in a solution of 10% nitric acid for 48 h followed
by thorough rinsing with deionized water. Instrument readings were corrected
with blank readings. All samples were analysed in triplicate. The relative standard
deviation between triplicate analyses is < 5%. The analytical procedure was
checked using spikes. The spike recoveries for the metals in this study were
96.6% for Cu, 89.9% for Cd, 95.7% for Ni, 103.7% for Fe, 98.4% for Zn, 91.3%
for Pb, 97.2% for Mn, 92.8% for Cr, 89.7% for Co, 106.6% for Ca and 94.7% for
Mn. The detection limit (μg g-1) set at three times the standard
deviation of the blanks, that are as, Cu (0.05), Cd (0.001), Ni (0.02), Fe (0.02),
Zn (0.05), Pb (0.001), Mn (0.001), Cr (0.002) and Co (0.001). The estimated
limits of quantification for the studied metals (μg g-1) were
Cu (0.05), Cd (0.005), Ni (0.10), Fe (0.10), Zn (0.3), Pb (0.05), Mn (0.10),
Cr (0.005) and Co (0.05). Two-ways analysis of variance (ANOVA) and students
t-test were used to determine whether the concentrations of the metals varied
significantly within and between brands, with values less than 0.05 (p<0.05)
considered statistically significant. The statistical calculations were performed
with SPSS 11.5 Version.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The mean concentrations of metals in various types of biscuits are shown in
Table 1. The values in parentheses refer to concentration
ranges. The concentrations of calcium and magnesium in the samples were higher
than any other elements studied.
||Mean concentrations (µg g-1) of metals in
biscuits types in Nigerian market
The highest mean value of calcium was observed in the digestive brands (395.3
μg g-1), while the lowest mean level was observed in the cabin
brands (205.64 μg g-1). Within each group, there is a significant
difference (p<0.05) in levels of calcium. Similarly, the highest level of
magnesium was observed in the digestive and with lowest levels in cabin and
short cake brands. There is no significant difference (p<0.05) with the mean
levels of magnesium in the various biscuit types are compared. Calcium is essential
for bone formation in children. Sehecie and Dragojevic (2005)
reported that calcium and magnesium contents in different kinds of biscuit in
Critic ranged from 204.3 to 879.2 μg g-1 and from 172.9 to 595.3
μg g-1, respectively. The concentrations of Ca and Mg found
in the biscuit samples were lower than levels reported by Sehecie
and Dragojevic (2005).
The concentrations of zinc varied from 2l.8 μg g-1 in the digestive
brand to 49.3 μg g-1 in the short cake. The permissible levels
of zinc in grains and beans are 50 and 100 μg g-1, respectively
(USDA, 2003). The levels of zinc found in the various
biscuit types were less than these limits. Saracoglu et
al. (2004) reported zinc levels ranging between 3.1-16.1 μg g-1
in biscuits in Turkey. Gopalani et al. (2007)
reported zinc concentrations ranging from not detected to 13.4 μg g-1
in biscuits from India. Similarly, Salama and Radwan
(2005) reported zinc levels ranging between 2.347-4.749 μg g-1
in biscuits from Egyptian market. The concentrations of zinc found in the present
study were higher than values reported by these researchers.
The mean concentrations of iron the biscuit samples ranged from 33.9 to 109.0
μg g-1. The cream crackers have significant higher concentrations
of iron compared to any other type studied. The lowest iron concentration was
observed in the cookies. Gopalani et al. (2007)
reported iron concentration ranging from not detected to 36.2 μg g-1.
The mean concentrations of iron in different biscuit types in this study were
higher than upper limits of reported by Gopalani et al.
(2007) except for the cookies. The concentrations of chromium in the different
biscuit types ranged between 0.39 and 0.72 μg g-1. The highest
chromium level was observed in the cookies. Gopalani et
al. (2007) reported chromium concentrations ranging from not detected
to 0.55 μg g-1 in biscuit from India. Chromium is an essential
trace element and the biologically usable form of chromium plays essential roles
in glucose metabolism. It has been estimated that human requires nearly 1 μg
day-1. The sources of contamination by these metals are mainly from
raw materials used, manufacturing processes, leaching of these metals from vessel
in which they are stored. Processing of biscuit is done in containers from which
nickel contamination is possible in addition to contamination of catalyst used
in preparation of hydrogenated vegetable oil (Dahiya
et al., 2005). In addition to this, Ni in the biscuit arose from cocoa
additives which is known to contain elevated concentrations of nickel (Milacic
and Kralj, 2003). The concentrations of nickel in the various biscuit types
ranged from 2.1-4.9 μg g-1. The highest mean concentration nickel
was observed in the cookies. The levels of nickel found in this study were comparable
to 5.7-9.85 μg g-1 ranges reported by Gopalani
et al. (2007).
The concentrations of manganese in the different biscuit type ranges from 0.01-2.9
μg g-1. The highest level of manganese was observed in the cream
crackers (2.9 μg g-1). The concentrations of manganese in different
brands of biscuits showed significant difference within and between the different
biscuits types except for the cookies, short cake and cream crackers. Gopalani
et al. (2007) reported manganese levels ranging between 2.053-8.24
μg g-1 in biscuits available in Nagpur city, India. The concentrations
reported in this study are slightly lower than that of Gopalani
et al. (2007).
The concentrations of lead in different biscuit types spanned between 0.39
and 2.92 μg g-1. The highest concentration was found in the
cream cracker. The permissible limit for lead in cereal and legumes is 0.2 μg
g-1(CAC, 2003). The concentrations of lead
in these products exceeded the permissible limits for Pb in cereal products
except for the cookies.
The concentrations of copper ranged between 0.5 μg g-1 in short
breads to 5.0 μg g-1 in the short cake types. Gopalani
et al. (2007) reported copper levels ranging from not detected to
4.699 μg g-1 in potato chips and biscuits available in Nagpur
City, India. Similarly, Salama and Radwan (2005) recorded
mean concentrations of copper in sweet and salted biscuits in Egypt as 0.787
and 1.386 μg g-1, respectively. Saracoglu
et al. (2004) reported mean concentrations of copper in 20 different
kinds of hard biscuit produced in Turkey as <1.0-4.2 μg g-1.
The observed concentrations of copper in the present study are slightly lower
than values reported by these researchers. The permissible limit for copper
in all foods is 10 μg g-1 (CAC, 2003).
The average cobalt concentrations in the various biscuit types ranged between
0.01 to 1.30 μg g-1. The highest mean concentration of cobalt
was observed in the short cake types. The levels of cobalt observed in this
study were similar to the range reported for potato chips and biscuits in Indian
(Gopalani et al., 2007).
Cadmium contents of the various biscuit types ranged from 0.03-0.05 μg
g-1. The highest mean level was found in the cream crackers type.
The permissible level of cadmium in foods is 0.05 μg g-1 (FAO/WHO,
2001). The mean levels of cadmium in this study were below the permissible
limits. However, some individual samples contained cadmium at levels above the
permissible limit. Salama and Radwan, 2005 reported
cadmium contents ranging from 0.0 13-0.122 μg g-1 in biscuits
from Egypt. Similarly, Karavoltsos et al. (2002)
reported cadmium contents in biscuits from Greece as 0.0126-0.0143 μg g-1.
Gopalani et al. (2007) found cadmium at levels
below the limit of detection in biscuits from India. The levels of cadmium observed
in this study are comparable to levels for found in biscuits in some other countries
in the world (Karavoltsos et al., 2002; Salama
and Radwan, 2005).
Table 2 presents the results of estimated dietary intakes of metals.
The estimated dietary intake based on consumption of 40 g of biscuit per day
for a 15 kg child ranged from 584.3-1054.1 μg kg-1 b.wt. day-1
for calcium while 314.7-323.5 μg kg-1 b.wt. day-1
were recorded for magnesium. The recommended dietary allowance for calcium is
set at 700 mg, 1000 mg and 1300 mg for 1-3 years, 4-8 years and 9-18 years,
respectively. The upper tolerable intake of calcium is set at 2500 mg and 3000
mg for 1-8 years and 9-18 years, respectively (Institute of
Medicine, 2010). The estimated maximum daily intake of Ca in this study
constitutes approximately 0.007% of the recommended dietary allowance for Ca.
The estimated daily intake of zinc from consumption of biscuit ranged from
58.0 to 131.4 μg kg-1 b.wt. day-1 which constitutes
about 5.8-13.1% of Joint Expert Committee of Food Additives Provisional Maximal
Tolerable Intake of 1000 μg kg-1 b.wt. day-1 (WHO,
|| Estimated daily intake of metal based on consumption of 40
g of biscuit per day (μg/kg b.wt./day)
The intake values of intake of iron in this study ranged from 90.5-223.5 μg
kg-1 b.wt. day-1. The estimated dietary intake of iron
in this study ranged from which is far below the recommended dietary allowance
value of 10-19 mg day-1 person (WHO, 1993).
The EVM guidance level for total dietary intake of trivalent chromium is 150
μg kg-1 bw. day-1 (EVM, 2003).
The estimated daily intake of chromium spanned between 1.0 and 1.9 μg kg-1
bw. day-1 which constitutes about 0.69-1.28% of the EVM guidance
The Tolerable Daily Intake (TDI) of nickel is 5 μg kg-1 b.wt.
day-1 (WHO, 1996). The estimated daily intake
of nickel in the present study ranged from 5.8-13.0 μg kg-1
b.wt. day-1. The estimated daily intake exceeded the tolerable daily
intakes of nickel. Similar intake values have been reported for chocolates and
candies in Nigeria (Iwegbue, 2011). There is need to
exercise some caution in the consumption of these products. Higher daily intakes
of Ni have been reported in literature for confectionery. For example, Dahiya
et al., (2005) reported that the dietary contribution of nickel from
chocolates in India as 8.68-55.26 μg day-1. Higher dietary contribution
of nickel ranging from 200 to 900 μg day-1 has been reported
(Myron et al., 1978; Nielson
and Flyvholm, 1984; Larsen et al., 2002).
Krishnamurti and Pushpa (1991) reported nickel intake
as high as 240-3900 μg kg-1 in Indian foods.
The National Research Council of Canada (NRC) has recommended safe and adequate
daily intake levels of manganese that ranged from 0.3-1 mg day-1
for children up to 1 year, 1-2 mg day-1 for children up to age 10
and 2-5 mg for children up to 10 and older (Institute of Medicine,
2001). The estimated daily intakes of manganese in this study spanned from
0.03 to 7.7 μg kg-1 b.wt. day-1 which is far below
the recommended adequate daily intake levels.
The Provisional Tolerable Weekly Intake (PTWI) of lead has been set at 25 μg
kg-1 body weight for children (WHO, 1993)
which is equivalent to 3.6 μg kg-1 body weight/day. The estimated
tolerable daily intake of lead in this study ranged from 0.0-2.9 μg kg-1
b.wt. day-1. The upper limit of estimated daily intake exceeded the
provisional tolerable intakes of lead. Assuming 40% absorption rate for Pb (http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/).
By consuming 40 g of any of the biscuit types with a lead content of <0.001
to 1.1 μg g-1, a child weighing 15 kg would be acquiring approximately
0.0-32.6 % of his or her PTDI from this source.
The JECFA Provisional Maximal Tolerable Daily Intake (PMTDI) of copper is 500
μg kg-1 b.wt. day-1 while the Safe Upper Level (SUL)
of 160 μg kg-1 b.wt. day-1 has been recommended by
the Expert Group on Vitamins and Minerals (EVM, 2003).The
estimated daily intake of copper from consumption of any types of the biscuit
ranged 1.4-13.4 μg kg-1 b.wt. day-1 which is approximately
0.3-2.7% of the PMTDI and 0.83-8.3% of safe upper level.
Normal daily intake of cobalt is reported to be in the range of 2.5 to 3.0
mg day-1 poisoning occurs within the range of greater than 23-30
mg cobalt daily (Hokin et al., 2004). The estimated
daily intake of cobalt in this study ranged between 0.0-3.5 μg kg-1
b.wt. day-1 which is by far less than the normal daily intake. The
provisional tolerable intake for cadmium has been established at 7 μg kg-1
of body weight (WHO, 2001). For a child with body weight
of 15 kg, the PTDI for consumption of any of the biscuit types ranged from 0.08-0.13
μg kg-1 b.wt. day-1 which contributes approximately
8-13% of the PTMDI for cadmium from this source.
The metals are present in biscuit samples at concentrations below permissible limits except for nickel and lead in some types. The estimated tolerable daily intakes of metals were below the provisional tolerable intakes for the metals except for nickel and lead. There is need for caution in the consumption of these metals since nickel can exacerbate dermatitis/eczema and while lead can cause reduction of IQ in humans.
The author is grateful to Mrs. Daisy Bazunnu for her assistance during sampling and analysis.
Anonymous, 2009. Exposure of children to chemical hazards in food. Fact Sheet 4.4 December 2009, CODE: RPG4-Food-Ex1, World Health Organisation Regional office for Europe Demark, http://www.euro.who.int/-data/assets/pdf-file/0004/97042/4.4.-Exposure-of-children-to-chemical-hazards-in-food-EDITED-layouted.pdf.
Ashraf, W., 2006. Levels of selected heavy metals in tuna fish. Arabian J. Sci. Eng. 31: 89-92.
Direct Link |
CAC, 2003. Evaluation of Certain Food Additives and Contaminants FAO/WHO, Codex Standards, Rome.
Dahiya, S., R. Karpe, A.G. Hegde and R.M. Sharma, 2005. Lead, cadmium and nickel in chocolates and candies from suburban areas of Mumbai, India. J. Food Comp. Anal., 18: 517-522.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
EVM, 2003. Safe upper levels for vitamins and minerals. Report of the Expert Group on Vitamins and Minerals. Food Standard Agency.
FAO and WHO., 2001. Report of the nineteenth session of the codex committee on cocoa products and chocolate, Fribourg, Switzerland, 3-5 October 2001. CL 2001/31-CPC, October 2001, Joint FAO/WHO Standard Programme, Codex Alimentarius Commission.
Gopalani, M., M. Shahare, D.S Ramteke and S.R Wate, 2007. Heavy metal content of potato chips and biscuits from Nagpur city, India. Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol., 97: 384-387.
CrossRef | PubMed | Direct Link |
Hokin B., M. Adams, J. Ashton and H. Louie, 2004. Analysis of cobalt content in Australian foods. Asia Pac. J. Clin. Nutr., 13: 284-288.
Institute of Medicine, 2010. Dietary Reference intake of Calcium and Vitamin D: Committee to Review Dietary Reference intake of vitamin D and calcium. National Academies Press, Washington DC.
Iwegbue, C.M.A., 2011. Concentrations of selected metals in candies and chocolates consumed in southern Nigeria. Food Add. Contam., 4: 22-27.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Karavoltsos, S., A. Sakellari, M. Dimopoulos, M. Dasenakis and M. Scoullos, 2002. Cadmium content in foodstuffs from the Greek market. Food Additives Contam., 19: 954-962.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Krishnamurti, C.R. and W. Pushpa, 1991. Toxic Metals in the Indian Environment. McGraw-Hill, New Delhi, India, pages: 161.
Larsen E.H., N.L. Andersen, A. Moller, A Petersen, G.K. Mortensen and J. Peterson, 2002. Monitoring the content and intake of trace element from food in Demark. Food Addit. Contam., 19: 33-46.
Milacic, R. and B. Kralj, 2003. Determination of Zn, Cu, Cd, Pb, Ni and Cr in some Slovenian foodstuffs. Eur. Food Res. Technol., 217: 211-214.
Myron, D.R., T.J. Zimmertman, T.R. Shuleu, L.M. Klevay, D.E. Lee and F.H. Nielson, 1978. Intake of nickel and vanadium by humans: A survey of selected diets. Am. J. Clin. Nut., 31: 527-531.
Direct Link |
Nielson, F.H. and M. Flyvholm, 1984. Risk of high nickel intake with diet. Proceedings of the Joint Symposium of International Agency for Research on Cancer, March 8-11, 1983, IARC Scientific Publication, Lyon, France, pp: 333-338.
Onianwa, P.C., I.G. Adetola, C.M.A. Iwegbue, M.F. Ojo and O.O. Tella, 1999. Trace heavy metals composition of some Nigerian beverages and food drinks. Food Chem., 66: 275-279.
Pearson, D., 1976. The Chemical Analysis of Foods. 7th Edn., Churchill Living stone, London, New York, pp: 575.
Salama, A.K. and M.A. Radwan, 2005. Heavy metals (Cd, Pb) and trace elements (Cu, Zn) contents in some foodstuffs from the Egyptian market. Emirate J. Food Agric., 17: 34-42.
Direct Link |
Saracoglu, S., M. Tuzen, D. Mendil, M. Soylak, L. Elci and M. Dogan, 2004. Heavy metal content of hard biscuits produced in Turkey. Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol., 72: 264-269.
Sehecie, B. and I.V. Dragojevic, 2005. Biscuits as source of calcium, magnesium, sodium and potassium in nutrition. Deutsch. Lebensmittel. Rundsch., 101: 392-397.
Direct Link |
USDA, 2003. Zinc in foods-draft for comments. Foreign Agricultural Service (GAIN Report) CH 3043. China. People Republic of FAIRS. Products Specific MRL.
WHO, 2001. Safety evaluation of certain food additives and contaminants: Cadmium. WHO Food Additives series 46. Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives.
WHO, 1982. Safety evaluation of certain food additives and contaminants: Zinc. World Health Organization Geneva, 1982, Food additives Series 17.
WHO, 1993. Evaluation of certain food additives and contaminants. World Health Organization, Geneva, Technical Report No 827.
WHO, 1996. Guidelines for Drinking-Water Quality. 2nd Edn., Vol. 2, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland.