HOME JOURNALS CONTACT

Journal of Environmental Science and Technology

Year: 2016 | Volume: 9 | Issue: 4 | Page No.: 323-328
DOI: 10.3923/jest.2016.323.328
Risk Assessment of Some Radioactive and Elemental Content from Cement and Phosphate Fertilizer Consumer in Saudi Arabia
K.S. Al Mugren and A. El-Taher

Abstract: Objective: The present study deals with measuring the activities of 226Ra, 232Th and 40K in cement and phosphate fertilizer consumed in Saudi Arabia, using γ-ray spectrometry. From the measured γ-ray spectra, specific activities were determined. Methodology: The samples were collected from local markets in Saudi Arabia. The results indicate that the cement and phosphate fertilizer consumed in Saudi Arabia does not pose any significant radiological risk and they are safe for use. Results: The obtained results were compared with the reports gotten from similar studies conducted in other countries. The radiation hazard parameters were calculated for all samples and it was shown that the radium equivalent Raeq and the representative level index, Iγr are lower than the acceptable level of 370 Bq kg–1 for radium equivalent Raeq, 1 for level index Iγr. Thermo Scientific Quant’X EDXRF spectrometer were used also to determine the concentrations of the elements Si, Al, Fe, Ti, Ca, Na, S, Pb, Sn, As and Zn as major, trace and toxic elements. Conclusion: The data presented here was useful to those dealing with portland cement, phosphate fertilizer chemistry and related fields.

Fulltext PDF Fulltext HTML

How to cite this article
K.S. Al Mugren and A. El-Taher, 2016. Risk Assessment of Some Radioactive and Elemental Content from Cement and Phosphate Fertilizer Consumer in Saudi Arabia. Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, 9: 323-328.

Keywords: Consumed products, portland cement, phosphate fertilizer, γ-ray spectrometry and EDXRF spectrometer

INTRODUCTION

Human beings are exposed to radiation from different sources in their daily lives. Some of these radiations come from the natural radioactive materials on the earth, such as the natural radioactive series or their products, which can be transferred through air or water to the people in direct or indirect ways. Most of these products are produced from the recycling of materials, which may contain some radioactive isotopes, especially because of the nuclear industries waste used in these products or as a result of the Natural Occurring Radioactive Material (NORM), which are obtained from some oil and gas industries or in water treatment plants1.

Nowadays, the use of consumer products, which are usually made of natural materials or recycled materials can be contaminated with some level of radioactive or toxic elements. Investigations into the radioactivity of some consumer products have previously been conducted worldwide2. The activity of naturally occurring radioisotopes in building materials have also been investigated3-6.

However, very few studies have investigated both the radioactivity and the toxicity of these products as well as measured the natural radioactivity in the marble used in Saudi Arabia. They investigated the activities of 238U, 232Th and 40K as well as the radium equivalent activity and radiation hazard indices. This study concluded that the majority of the measured commercial samples of marbles are considered safe for construction use7.

This study deals with the risk assessment of radioactive materials from portland cement and phosphate fertilizers consumer products in Saudi Arabia, using gamma spectroscopy for radioactive analysis and x-ray fluorescence for heavy and toxic elements.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Sampling and sample preparation: In this study, 18 cement and phosphate fertilizer samples were collected from local markets in Saudi Arabia for the investigation of both radioactive and heavy elements that occur naturally. Gamma spectroscopy was used for radioactivity analysis and Thermo Scientific Quant’X EDXRF spectrometer to determine the heavy elements concentration.

Gamma-ray spectrometry: Each sample about 1 kg in weight was dried in an oven at a temperature of about 110°C to ensure that moisture is completely removed, the samples were crushed, homogenized and sieved through a 200 mm mesh, which is the optimum size to be enriched in heavy minerals. Weighted samples were placed in a polyethylene beaker having a volume of 250 cm3. The beakers were completely sealed for 4 weeks to reach secular equilibrium, where the rate of decay of the radon daughters become equal to that of the parent. This step is necessary to ensure that radon gas is confined within the volume and the daughters remain in the sample.

Instrumentation and calibration: Gamma spectrometric measurements were performed with NaI (Tl) detector. The measuring time for gamma ray spectra range was 12 h. In order to determine the background distribution, due to naturally occurring radio nuclide in the environment around the detector, an empty polystyrene container was counted in the same manner as the samples. After measurement and subtraction of the background, the activity concentration was calculated8. The specific activity of 226Ra was evaluated from gamma-ray lines of 214Bi at 609.3, 1120.3 KeV and 214Pb at 351 KeV, while the specific activity of 232Th was evaluated from gamma-ray lines of 228Ac at 338.4, 911.1 and 968.9 KeV. The specific activity of 40K was determined directly from its 1460.8 KeV gamma-ray line9,10.

Calculations of count rates for each detected photopeak and radiological concentrations (activity per mass unit or specific activity) of the detected radio nuclides depend on the establishment of secular equilibrium in the samples. The activity concentration in Bq kg–1 (A) in the environmental samples was obtained as follows:

(1)

where, Np is (cps) sample-(cps) back ground, e is the abundance of the γ-peak in a radio nuclide, η is the measured efficiency for each gamma- ray peak observed for the same number of channels either for the sample or the calibration source and m is the sample mass in kilograms.

Radiation hazard parameters: The natural radioactivity of building materials is usually determined from 226Ra, 232Th and 40K contents. As Ra and its daughter products produce 98.5% of the radiological effects of the U series, the contribution from the 238U has been replaced with the decay product 226Ra. The γ-ray radiation hazards due to the specified radio nuclides were assessed using three different indices11,12. Radium equivalent activity is an index that has been introduced to represent the specific activities of 226Ra, 232Th and 40K by a single quantity, which takes into account the radiation hazards associated with them.

Table 1: Activity levels of 226Ra, 232Th, 40K and radiation hazard parameters of cement consumer products in Saudi Arabia

This first index can be calculated according to Beretka and Mathew13 as:

(2)

where, ARa, ATh and AK are the specific activities of 226Ra, 232Th and 40K in Bq kg–1, respectively. The Raeq is related to both the external γ-dose and internal dose due to radon and its daughters. The maximum value of Raeq in building materials must be less than 370 Bq kg–1 for safe use.

Conversion factors to transform specific activities AK, ARa and ATh of K, Ra and Th, respectively into absorbed dose rate at 1 m above the ground (in nGy h–1 by Bq kg–1) are calculated by the Monte Carlo method and the values are UNSCEAR14:

(3)

Another radiation hazard index called the representative level index, Iγr is defined as follows NEA-OECD15:

(4)

where, ARa, ATh and AK have the same meaning as in Eq. 2.

EDXRF spectrometer: The XRF data presented here are quantitative, in that they are derived from "Filtered" intensity values which are ratios to the appropriate x-ray continuum regions, through a least squares fitting formula rather than plotting the proportions of the net intensities in a ternary system16. All analysis for this study were conducted on a Thermo Scientific Quant’X EDXRF spectrometer, located in the Department of Physics, Qassim University. It is equipped with a thermo-electrically Peltier cooled solid-state Si (Li) x-ray detector, with a 50 KeV, 50 W, ultra-high-flux end window bremsstrahlung, Rh target x-ray tube and a 76 μm beryllium (Be) window (air cooled), that runs on a power supply operating at 4-50 KeV/0.02-1.0 mA at 0.02 increments. The spectrometer is equipped with Edwards’s vacuum pump, allowing for the analysis of lower-atomic-weight elements between sodium (Na) and titanium (Ti). Data acquisition is accomplished with a pulse processor and an analogue-to-digital converter. Elemental composition is identified with digital filter background removal, least squares empirical peak deconvolution, gross peak intensities and net peak intensities above background. The samples were ground into a fine powder using an agate motor. All powder samples were dried at a temperature of 105°C and stored in desiccators, until they were analysed. Fill up ¾ parts of the cup with the sample analyzed. Then, cover the cup with the film. Fix the slim ring by sliding it down and fix the thick ring at the top of the cup. When the cups are prepared, place them on the sample stage inside the spectrometer chamber with the side to be analyzed facing down toward the x-ray tube).

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Radioactivity concentrations: The activity concentrations of 226Ra, 232Th and 40K and radiation hazard parameters in the consumer products used in Saudi Arabia have been determined and divided into two categories as follows.

Cement: Table 1 shows the specific activities of 226Ra, 232Th and 40K and the radiation hazard parameters of portland and white cement from different factories in Saudi Arabia, Qassim, University Riyadh, Hail and Yamamah were consumed in Saudi Arabia. The activity concentration of 226Ra ranged between 8.58±0.37 Bq kg–1 from Hail to 17.72±0.86 Bq kg–1 from Riyadh with an average value of 14.34 Bq kg–1. While the activity concentration of 232 Th ranged between 7.44±0.038 Bq kg–1 from Qassim to 19.63±1.00 Bq kg–1 from Yamama, with an average value of 14.11 Bq kg–1.

Table 2: Activity levels of 226Ra, 232Th, 40K and radiation hazard parameters of phosphate fertilizer consumer products in Saudi Arabia

Table 3: Activity concentrations of consumed products in Saudi Arabia compared with those of other countries

However, the activity concentration of 40K ranged between 90.55±4.50 Bq kg–1 from Hail to 236±11 Bq kg–1 from Riyadh with an average value of 161.25 Bq kg–1. The radionuclide concentrations of cement products consumed in Saudi Arabia are below the world averages for building materials 35 (Bq kg–1), 50 (Bq kg–1) and 500 (Bq kg–1) for 226Ra, 232Th and 40K, respectively17. These materials do not pose a significant radiological hazard when used for building construction radium equivalent (Raeq) ranged between (28.60-60.80 Bq kg–1) for portland cement and from (39.74-46.38 Bq kg–1) for white cement. The absorbed dose rate, the external hazard index, Hex ranged between (13.74-30.01 Bq kg–1) and (0.01-0.06 nGy h–1), respectively. The average values of the radiation hazard parameters, for all cement products under investigation are lower than the acceptable level 370 Bq kg–1 for radium equivalent (Raeq) and 59 (nGy h–1) of the absorbed dose rate and ≤1 for the external hazard index15.

Phosphate fertilizer: Table 2 shows the specific activities of 226Ra, 232Th and 40K and the radiation hazard parameters in DAP, MAP, Single Super Phosphate (SSP) and triple super phosphate fertilizers consumed in Saudi Arabia. The concentration of 226Ra and 40K in single and triple super phosphate is higher than that (the concentration) in DAP and MAP. While, the concentration of 232Th in single and triple super phosphate is lower than that in DAP and MAP. The radium equivalent (Raeq), for phosphate fertilizer ranged between (55-157 Bq kg–1). The average values of the radiation hazard parameters for all phosphate fertilizers under investigation, are lower than the acceptable level, 370 Bq kg–1 for radium equivalent (Raeq)15. The variations in the NOR specific activities in phosphate fertilizers from different brands is due to the different sources of phosphate ore, different geological origin of the phosphate ore and/or chemical processing of the ore during fertilizers manufacture.

Table 3 shows a comparison between the consumed products in Saudi Arabia with those from other countries. With respect to cement, the activity concentration of 226Ra, 232Th and 40K for portland cement consumed in Saudi Arabia is comparable with the corresponding values of other countries.

Table 4: Major, minor and toxic elements content in cement and phosphate fertilizer consumed in Saudi Arabia

The radioactivity in portland cement varies from one country to another because of different materials that are used in the cement manufacture. The radioactivity in portland cement varies from one country to another because of different materials that are used in the cement manufacture18. The activity concentrations of 226Ra, 232Th and 40K for the investigated phosphate fertilizers were compared with similar investigations in other countries and presented in Table 3.

The radioactivity in fertilizers varies from one country to another. It is important to point out that these values are not representative values for countries mentioned, but are representative of the region from where the samples were collected30.

Heavy elements concentration: Cement and phosphate fertilizer samples purchased from markets in Saudi Arabia were tested, using XRF analysis. This was performed using a cost-effective XRF system, assembled at the University of Qassim. The major elements that form the elemental contents of cement and phosphate fertilizer samples are summarized in Table 4. The uncertainties shown in the results are estimates of experimental errors contributed by calibration and the peak height of the respective spectrum. The values quoted are the average of two analyses (repeat) of the same sample. The Si, Al, Fe, Ti, Ca, Na and S were measured as major elements. The Pb, Sn, As, Zn as trace and toxic elements. It is important to point out that the different values presented in Table 4 due to the location and the regions from where the samples were collected.

CONCLUSION

In this study, activity levels of 18 cement and phosphate fertilizer samples, which were collected from local markets in Saudi Arabia have been measured, using gamma-ray spectrometer. The radium equivalent activity Raeq and the representative level index, Iγr were evaluated to assess the potential radiological hazard associated with these materials. The results show that the activity concentrations of 226Ra, 232Th and 40K in all the samples do not pose any significant radiological risk and they are safe for use. The average Raeq values of the studied samples ranged from 11.5-228 Bq kg–1, which are below the internationally accepted values (370 Bq kg–1) and the representative level index, Iγr are less than unity. No risk assessments were found. In conclusion, this study shows that, most of these materials do not pose any significant threat of radiation hazard and are safe for use in the construction of dwellings. Thermo Scientific Quant’X EDXRF spectrometer was used to determine the concentrations of Si, Al, Fe, Ti, Ca, Na, S, Pb, Sn, As and Zn for the same samples as major, trace and toxic elements.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

The authors are thankful to the General Directorate of Research Grants Programs at King Abdulaziz City for Science and Technology (KACST) for funding this study project number (MS--34-70).

REFERENCES

  • NRC., 2001. Systematic radiological assessment of exemptions for source and byproduct materials. NUREG-1717, Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC., USA. http://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/doc-collections/nuregs/staff/sr1717/.


  • NCRP., 2009. Ionizing radiation exposure of the population of the United States. NCRP Report No. 160, National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements, Bethesda, MD.


  • Saito, K., N. Petoussi-Henss and M. Zankl, 1998. Calculation of the effective dose and its variation from environmental gamma ray sources. Health Phys., 74: 698-706.
    PubMed    Direct Link    


  • Rahman, S.U., M. Rafique, A. Jabbar and Matiullah, 2013. Radiological hazards due to naturally occurring radionuclides in the selected building materials used for the construction of dwellings in four districts of the Punjab Province, Pakistan. Radiat. Protect. Dosimetry, 153: 352-360.
    CrossRef    Direct Link    


  • El-Taher, A., 2011. Terrestrial gamma radioactivity levels and their corresponding extent exposure of environmental samples from Wadi El Assuity protective area, Assuit, Upper Egypt. Radiat. Prot. Dosim., 145: 405-410.
    CrossRef    PubMed    Direct Link    


  • El-Taher, A., 2012. Assessment of natural radioactivity levels and radiation hazards for building materials used in Qassim Area, Saudi Arabia. Rom. J. Phys., 57: 726-735.
    Direct Link    


  • El-Taher, A., A.A. Ibraheem and S. Abdelkawy, 2013. Elemental analysis of marble used in Saudi Arabia by different nuclear analytical techniques. Applied Radiat. Isotopes, 73: 17-20.
    CrossRef    Direct Link    


  • Zarie, K.A. and K.S. Al Mugren, 2010. Measurement of natural radioactivity and assessment of radiation hazard in soil samples from Tammy Area (KSA). Isotope Radiat. Res., 42: 1-9.
    Direct Link    


  • El-Taher, A. and S. Makhluf, 2010. Natural radioactivity levels in phosphate fertilize r and its environmental implications in Assuit governorate, Upper Egypt. Indian J. Pure Applied Phys., 48: 697-702.
    Direct Link    


  • El-Taher, A. and S. Makhluf, 2011. Radiological significance of Egyptian limestone and alabaster used for construction of dwellings. Indian J. Pure Applied Phys., 29: 157-161.
    Direct Link    


  • El-Taher, A., 2010. Gamma spectroscopic analysis and associated radiation hazards of building materials used in Egypt. Radiat. Prot. Dosimetry, 138: 166-173.
    CrossRef    PubMed    Direct Link    


  • Al Mugren, K.S., 2015. Assessment of natural radioactivity levels and radiation dose rate in some soil samples from historical area, Al-Rakkah, Saudi Arabia. Nat. Sci., 7: 238-247.
    CrossRef    Direct Link    


  • Beretka, J. and P.J. Matthew, 1985. Natural radioactivity of Australian building materials, industrial wastes and by-products. Health Phys., 48: 87-95.
    PubMed    Direct Link    


  • UNSCEAR., 1988. United nations scientific committee on the effects of atomic radiation. Report to the General Assembly, with Annexes, Sources and Effects of Ionizing Radiation, New York, USA.


  • NEA-OECD., 1979. Exposure to radiation from natural radioactivity in building materials. Report by NEA Group of Experts, Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, Paris. https://www.oecd-nea.org/rp/reports/1979/exposure-to-radiation-1979.pdf.


  • Thermo Fisher Scientific, 2008. Thermo fisher Quantx technical manual. Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc., Madison, WI.


  • UNSCEAR., 1993. Sources and effects of ionizing radiation. Report to the General Assembly, with Scientific Annexes, New York, USA.


  • El-Taher, A., S. Makhluf, A. Nossair and A.S. Abdel Halim, 2010. Assessment of natural radioactivity levels and radiation hazards due to cement industry. J. Applied Radiat. Isotopes, 68: 169-174.
    CrossRef    PubMed    Direct Link    


  • Lu, X., S. Chao and F. Yang, 2014. Determination of natural radioactivity and associated radiation hazard in building materials used in Weinan, China. Radiat. Phys. Chem., 99: 62-67.
    CrossRef    Direct Link    


  • El-Taher, A., 2010. INAA and DNAA for uranium determination in geological samples from Egypt. Applied Radiation Isotopes, 68: 1189-1192.
    CrossRef    PubMed    Direct Link    


  • Majid, A.A.B., A.F. Ismail, M.S. Yasir, R. Yahaya and I. Bahari, 2013. Radiological dose assessment of naturally occurring radioactive materials in concrete building materials. J. Radioanal. Nucl. Chem., 297: 277-284.
    CrossRef    Direct Link    


  • Agbalagba, E.O., R.O.A. Osakwe and I.O. Olarinoye, 2014. Comparative assessment of natural radionuclide content of cement brands used within Nigeria and some countries in the world. J. Geochem. Explorat., 142: 21-28.
    CrossRef    Direct Link    


  • Trevisi, R., S. Risica, M. D'Alessandro, D. Paradiso and C. Nuccetelli, 2012. Natural radioactivity in building materials in the European Union: A database and an estimate of radiological significance. J. Environ. Radioact., 105: 11-20.
    CrossRef    Direct Link    


  • Ali, K.K., 2012. Radioactivity in building materials in Iraq. Radiat. Protect. Dosimetry, 148: 372-379.
    CrossRef    Direct Link    


  • Baykara, O., S. Karatepe and M. Dogru, 2011. Assessments of natural radioactivity and radiological hazards in construction materials used in Elazig, Turkey. Radiat. Measur., 46: 153-158.
    CrossRef    Direct Link    


  • Favaro, D.I.T., 2005. Natural radioactivity in phosphate rock, phosphogypsum and phosphate fertilizers in Brazil. J. Radioanal. Nucl. Chem., 264: 445-448.
    CrossRef    Direct Link    


  • Khan, K., H.M. Khan, M. Tufail, A.J.A.H. Khatibeh and N. Ahmad, 1998. Radiometric analysis of Hazara phosphate rock and fertilizers in Pakistan. J. Environ. Radioact., 38: 77-84.
    CrossRef    Direct Link    


  • Jibiri, N.N. and K.P. Fasae, 2012. Activity concentrations of 226Ra, 232Th and 40K in brands of fertilisers used in Nigeria. Radiat. Protect. Dosimetry, 148: 132-137.
    CrossRef    Direct Link    


  • Becegato, V.A., F.J.F. Ferreira and W.C.P. Machado, 2008. Concentration of radioactive elements (U, Th and K) derived from phosphatic fertilizers in cultivated soils. Braz. Arch. Biol. Technol., 51: 1255-1266.
    Direct Link    


  • El-Taher, A. and M.A.K. Abdelhalim, 2013. Elemental analysis of phosphate fertilizer consumed in Saudi Arabia. Life Sci. J., 10: 701-708.
    Direct Link    

  • © Science Alert. All Rights Reserved