Abstract: In order to evaluate the effect of different bacterial strains on common bean yield and it`s components and to estimate the best bacteria and cultivar`s combination, field experiment was carried out at Shahrekord in Iran (latitude 32°44 / N, 2100 m asl) during May - October 2002 on a sandy -loam soil. The experiment was a spilt plot in randomized complete block design with four bacterial strains L-78, L-47, L-125, L-109 and non-inoculated controls including application of nitrogen fertilizer treatment (100 kg N ha-1) and without application of nitrogen fertilizer (-N) as the main plots. Three cultivars included Shahrekord local (Cranberry bean), Talash (Cranberry bean) and Shahrekord local (Red Mexican type) were assigned as the subplots. The results revealed that high significant difference (p<0.01) in seed yield, seed and pod number per plant, LAI at 40-50% flowering (50 days after emergence), harvest index (HI) and dry matter yield among seed inoculated with different strains and non-inoculated controls (+N and -N treatment). Seeds inoculated with L-125 showed higher seed yield than other strains, but similar was observed in seed inoculated with L-109, L-78 strains and non-inoculated control (+N).
INTRODUCTION
The common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) is the most important legume for human nutrition, major protein and calorie source in the world (Graham and Ranalli, 1997; Velazquez et al., 1988). Its now growing extensively in all major continental areas. In Iran, the crop occupies 0.125 million ha of area, the yield is moderate, on average 1470 kg ha-1. Phaseolus vulgaris L. is a legume capable of symbiotically fixing N2 atmospheric. Nodules formed on the bean roots contain bacteria that convert N2 from the air to plant-available form. These bacteria can be purchased as an inoculum that is applied to the seed. A board range of Rhizobium species are able nodule and fix N2 with beans including R. legominosarum biovar phaseoli (Jordan, 1984), R. tropic (Martinez-Romero et al., 1991) and R. etli (Segavio et al., 1993).
In Iran, the usual practices of bean cultivation dose not involve inoculation of seeds with a specific rhizobial inoculation and farmers depend on the application of inorganic nitrogen fertilizer to sustain growth to improve yield. In Iran soils, for example high rate of levels of inorganic nitrogen fertilizer used at the rates of 100-300 kg N ha-1. Since chemical N fertilizers are expensive to most farmers. In addition, N fertilizer application had no significant effect on the dry matter yield and N content of Phaseolus vulgaris cv. B9 (Shisanya, 2002). However, the most soils in Iran nitrogen have deficiency and N2 fixation by Rhizobium bacteria can increase the yield at a low cost and preserve water resources from nitrate pollution.
Yield response of bean to inoculation with a specific Rhizobium is often variable and depend an environmental and agronomic factor (Giller and Cadisch, 1995; Handerson, 1993). The lack of response to inoculation can be attributed to intrinsic characteristics of both the host plant and bacteria, as well as the great sensitivity of the symbiosis to environmental stress, soil dryness and low soil fertility (Hungria et al., 2000). Other important factors to be considered are general limitation to N2 fixation per se, like the high rate of levels used in intensive agriculture and the residual N remaining in soils (Rodriguez-Navarro et al., 1999). Genotype variation in bean for traits affecting nodulation and N2 fixation has been found (Chavera and Graham, 1992). However, when highly effective Rhizobium/Phaseol combination have been selected, they provided bean yield of 60-70% of those obtained with N fertilizer control under field conditions (Santamaria et al., 1997). Determination of N2 fixation effectiveness in the process of strain selection is normally a several step procedure involving an initial selection under greenhouse conditions and a final testing in field trails (Rodriguez-Navarro et al., 1999). In the process of strain selection, variation in the efficiency of the strain * bean cultivars association was detected for parameters like total N, yield, plant growth, nodule number and weight and N fixed (Santamaria et al., 1997).
The aims of this research was to evaluate the effect of different bacterial strains obtained collection from Institute of Soil Biology Researches of Iran on common bean cultivars yield and its components and to estimate the best Rhizobium/Phaseol combination in field condition.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Field experiment was conducted at Shahrekord (latitude 32° 44 / N, 2100 m asl), located at about 100 km of Isfahan and 500 km of the capital town of Iran on spring and summer 2002. The medial annual rainfall is about 337.2 mm year-1. Average annual temperature is 11.9°C. Soil samples were collected to a depth of 0-30 cm before planting. The experiment was performed in soil that had not been cultivated with beans for at least 5 years. C, N, P and K content, Electrical Conductivity (EC), pH and percentage of sand, silt and clay were determined (Table 1). Total N was measured calorimetrically following Kjeldahl digestion. Also, soil pH and EC were estimated using a glass electrode pH meter and an EC meter in 1:1 soil water suspension. Organic carbon was determined by modified Walkley and Black method (McKeague, 1978). The rhizobia population evaluated was approximately 103-104 cells g-1 of soil.
The experiment was arranged in a randomized complete block design with a split plot layout and four replications. Four bacterial strains of rhizobia (Table 2) and non-inoculated controls including application of nitrogen fertilizer treatment (40 kg N ha-1 as urea at sowing and 60 kg N ha-1 at 35 days after sowing) and without application of nitrogen fertilizer were assigned to main plots. Inoculation was added to the seeds with 15% (w/v) source solution to increase adherence. Three cultivars included local cranberry bean; Talash cranberry and local red Mexican were assigned as the subplots. Each block consisted of six main plots spaced 2 m apart. The main plots had three subplots that consisted of five rows spaced 50 cm apart.
| Table 1: | Physical and chemical characteristics of the soil of experimental site |
| Table 2: | Bacterial strains used in this study |
Phosphate and starter N fertilizer were applied at rates 100 kg P ha-1 and 40 kg N ha-1 as urea before of planting, respectively. Four seeds of each genotype were planted per hole on 10 June 2002, weeding and thinned 20 days after emergence 135,000 plants ha1 for red bean and 100,000 plants ha-1 for cranberry bean (Graham and Ranalli, 1997). Topsoil of the experimental plot area was kept moist throughout the growing season when necessary.
The characteristics under investigation were seed yield, pod and seed number per plant, Dry Matter Total (TDM) and Leaf Area Index (LAI) at 40-50% flowering (50 days after emergence) and Harvest Index (HI). Plants were sampled at 25 days after planting, 45-50 days after planting and at physiological maturity (70-80 days after planting). Five plants were randomly samples from each treatment replicated and various parameters assessed. Plant samples were dried to constant weight at 75°C at 72 h in oven. Shoots were dried for dry weight determination and for total nitrogen determination by the Kjeldahl method. Yield and its components were evaluated at final harvest and values were corrected for 13% moisture.
All data were subjected to ANOVA using the statistical computer package SAS (Release 6.12, Statistical Analysis System Institute, 1996) and treatment means separated using Duncans Multiple Range Test (DMRT) at p≤0.05 level.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Seed and pods number per plant were influenced (p≤0.01) by seeds inoculated with strains and non-inoculated controls (Table 3). Non inoculated N-fertilizer treatment showed higher seed number per plant than control and seeds inoculated treatments, but similar seed number per plant was observed in seeds inoculated with strains L-47, L-125 and L-78 (Table 4). Seeds inoculated with L-125 showed higher pod number per plant than other treatments (Table 4), but similar result was observed in seed inoculated with L-109 and L-78 strains.
| Table 3: | Analysis of variance for different traits under seeds inoculated with different strains of Rhizobium legominosarum bv. phaseoli |
| ns* and ** : Not significant, significant at 5% and 1% level of probability, respectively | |
| Table 4: | Mean comparison of characteristic in different strains of bean (Phasseolus vulgaris L.) using DMRT at p≤0.05 level |
| In each column means followed by same letter are not significantly different at the 5% level using DMRT | |
| Table 5: | Mean comparison of characteristic in strain *cultivar interaction effects using DMRT at p≤0.05 level |
| In each column means followed by same letter are not significantly different at the 5% level using DMRT., 1: Local red Mexican bean, 2: Talach Cranberry bean and 3: Local Cranberry | |
There were no significant differences between cultivars and strains in seed and pods number per plant as well as an interaction strain * cultivar for both parameters (Table 3), but the results (DMRT) at p≤0.05 level showed that the highest seed and pod number were associated to local red Mexican bean * +N and local red Mexican bean * L-109 strain, respectively (Table 5). Also, 100-Seed weight showed no response to seeds inoculated with strains and non-inoculated controls (N-fertilizer and without N-fertilizer treatments) (Table 3).
Table 3 showed that shoot and pods dry matter were influenced (p≤0.01) by seeds inoculated with strains and non-inoculated controls. Non-inoculated (+N) showed higher shoot and pods dry matter than other treatments (Table 4). There were high significant differences (p≤0.01) between cultivars and strains in shoot and pods dry matter as well as an interaction strain * cultivar for both parameters (Table 3). Non-inoculated N-fertilizer treatment produced high shoot and pods dry matter in Talash cranberry cultivar (Table 5).
In the present study, high significant difference (p≤0.01) in seed yield was observed among seeds inoculated with different strains and non-inoculated controls (+N and -N treatments) (Table 3). Seeds inoculated with L-125 showed higher seed yield than other treatments (Table 4), but similar result was observed in seed inoculated with L-109, L-78 strains and non-inoculated control (N fertilizer treatment). The results of ANOVA indicated that there were high significant differences (p≤0.01) between cultivars in seed yield (Table 3). The interaction between strain* cultivar effect was no significant difference, but the results Table 5 showed the highest and lowest seed yield were associated to Talash*L-125 strain and local red bean*control. However, local red bean*L-125, local red bean*L-78 and local red bean*L-109 similar combinations were observed in seed yield with Talash * L-125 strain.
Seeds inoculated with L-125 probably aided the establishment of the most efficient inoculated rhizobia, improving symbiotic performance and could increased nitrogen available for plant. In the Central Regional of Brazil, the Cerrados, where over 0.8 * 106 ha are being cultivated with beans and soil N content is low, bean yield is generally increased by inoculation (Hungria et al., 2000). Hungria et al. (2000) reported that the common bean inoculated with PRF31, PRF55 and PRF81 showing high rates on N2 fixation and inoculated with PRF81 allowed yield increased of up to 906 kg ha-1, compared with the non-inoculated (control) with a population of native rhizobia in Brazilian soils. Also, the study revealed that tepary bean inoculated with R3254 and non-inoculated (control without inoculated and N fertilizer) the highest and lowest seed yield, respectively (Shisanya, 2002). These results confirm a report also with Iranian cultivar (Asadi Rahmani, 2000) and disagrees with obtained in other countries (Olivera and Graham, 1990; Streit et al., 1992). However, the strains different substantially in symbiotic properties, such as, nodulation and N2 fixation capacity, as well as in the synthesis of nod factors after inoculation.
The results of analysis of variance indicated that a high significant difference (p≤0.01) between seed inoculated and control treatments in Harvest Index (HI) (Table 3). Seeds inoculated with L-125 and L-109 strains showed higher and N fertilizer treatment lower harvest index than other treatments, respectively. Leaf Area Index (LAI) was influenced (p≤0.01) by seeds inoculated with strains and non-inoculated controls (Table 3). In thin research revealed that seed inoculated with L-78 and non-inoculated (control without inoculated and N fertilizer) the highest and lowest LAI, respectively (Table 4).
The difference in vegetative and reproductive (pods) growth between treatments reflected changes in assimilate partitioning, which led to significant differences in harvest index (Rodriguez-Navarro et al., 1999). The results showed that + N control gave highest shoot and pods dry matter (Table 4). The results of study by Tamimi et al. (2002) showed that shoot dry matter was the highest for common bean inoculated with isolate JOV1. Rodriguez-Navarro et al. (1999) working in greenhouse found that non-inoculated +N control higher shoot growth than the plants inoculated with strains, but similar pods growth was observed in plants inoculated with strains ISP-1 and CIAT 899 and the non-inoculated + N plants. Also, Harvest Index (HI) was the highest for common bean inoculated with strain ISP-1.
In tepary bean, inoculated with strain R3254 and non-inoculated control (-N) demonstrated the highest and lowest shoot and pods dry matter, respectively (Shisanya, 2002). A significant interaction Rhizobium strain* common bean cultivar for seed yield, shoot and pods dry matter were found (Rodriguez-Navarro et al., 1999). While, other authors (Buttery Brian et al., 1998; Shisanya, 2002) found no interaction strain* cultivar effects on plant growth and seed yield. Therefore, plant breeding of bean can be done with and effective strain. The other investigation by Rodriguez-Navarro et al. (1999) showed that the highest shoot dry matter was associated to c.v Cnellini * strain CIAT and c.v Cnellini * strain ISP-1 and c.v Bina * non-inoculated +N treatment for pods dry matter.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
This study received support from the vice chancellor for research at the University of Tehran, Aboorayhan campus and the Soil Biology Part of Institute of Soil and Water of Iran. We thank Dr. Ali Shariff Zadeh, Dr. Asadi Rahmani, MSC. Mehnat Kesh, MSC. Yadegari and Mc. Farzan for present study help.