Abstract: Background and Objective: Flax plays an important role in the national economy because it has many uses, seeds for oil and stems for fiber. Mineral nitrogen fertilizers and foliar application of yeast extract are important for growth and yield. Yeast extract as a foliar application on plants is very safe for humans, animals and the environment. This study aimed to explore the effect of different mineral nitrogen fertilizer sources with or without foliar application of yeast extract on the growth, yield and seed quality of some flax cultivars. Materials and Methods: The effect of mineral nitrogen fertilizer with or without foliar application of yeast extract on growth and yield were investigated and chemical analysis for chlorophyll, some endogenous hormones, NPK, oil, protein and total carbohydrates were achieved. Results: Sakha 5 cultivar gave the highest number of fruiting branches per plant, number of capsules per plant, seed yield per plant and total chlorophyll content. Also, it had the highest oil and total carbohydrates content for flaxseed in the 1st season only. Sakha 3 had the tallest plant height, technical length and the heaviest fiber yield (t ha1) followed by Sakha 1. Also, results revealed that 75% urea with yeast extract had a superior effect on most studied characters followed by adding 100% urea. Conclusion: It’s concluded that flax plants received 75% mineral nitrogen fertilizer (especially urea) with foliar application of yeast extract gave the highest productivity and seed quality.
INTRODUCTION
The flax (Linum usitatissimum L.) is a crop where it is grown for fiber and oil as well as many industrial and medical uses1. The percentage of oil in flax seeds ranged from 30-48%2 and the protein ranged 20-30%3. Oil of flaxseed has a very healthy fatty acid, approximately 73% of polyunsaturated fatty acids, 18% of monounsaturated fat and 9% of saturated fat and is edible. Flaxseed meal is a source of protein used in the feed of livestock, it is the remaining after oil extraction4.
We can increase flax productivity by selecting high yielding cultivars and enhancing the agricultural treatments5,6. The uses of nitrogen fertilizers are important for growth and higher yield7. Nitrogen in plant metabolism is constituent of nucleic and amino acids, cellular compounds and many cofactors8. There are many sources of mineral nitrogen fertilizers, which differ in their characteristics such as rates of solubility, volatilization and absorption by plants9. Nowadays urea is used as nitrogen fertilizer due to its high nitrogen content10. Great attention, under Egyptian conditions is being devoted to reducing the rates of mineral nitrogen fertilizers, environmental pollution and the cost of production via reducing rates of nitrogenous fertilizers by using biofertilized11,12. Therefore, it’s very important to reduce the dependence of agricultural production on nitrogen fertilizer and decrease the adverse effect of nitrogen loss on the environment13.
Recently, we can improve the productivity and quality of the plant, by using natural safe substances. However, its application enhances plant growth and physiological processes14. Yeast is used as a kind of biofertilizer in foliar application on plants or in soil fertilization15. Also, it is very safe for animals, humans and decreases environmental pollution via decreasing the cost and mineral fertilization. In this connection, yeast has a rich source of amino acids, enzymes, vitamins, phytohormones and minerals16. Growth, nutrition, yield and quality were improved due to yeast has an important role in releasing CO2 which increases photosynthesis17.
The present study was carried out to estimate the yield, its attributes and some physiological traits of flax cultivars with mineral nitrogen fertilizer sources with or without a foliar spray of yeast extract.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study area and experimental design: The present study was carried out at the experimental farm of Etay El-Baroud Agricultural Research Station (30°89' E, 30°65' N, 5 m above sea level) El-Beheira Governorate, Egypt during the two successive winter seasons 2018/2019 and 2019/2020 to study the effect of mineral nitrogen fertilizer sources with or without foliar application of yeast extract on yield, its attributes and some physiological traits of flax cultivars.
Table 1: | Physical and chemical properties of the experimental site during the two growing seasons of 2018-2019 and 2019-2020 |
Soil properties |
2018 |
2019 |
Soil texture |
Clay |
Clay |
Sand (%) |
12.15 |
11.83 |
Silt (%) |
33.62 |
34.80 |
Clay (%) |
54.23 |
53.37 |
PH |
8.20 |
8.10 |
Organic matter (%) |
1.85 |
1.79 |
Available N (ppm) |
40.00 |
53.00 |
Available P (ppm) |
29.00 |
31.00 |
Available K (ppm) |
290.00 |
239.00 |
EC dSm1 (1:5) |
2.23 |
2.21 |
Some physical and chemical properties of the experimental site during the two growing seasons were determined according to Carter and Gregorich18 (Table 1).
A Field experiment was carried out in a split-plot design with four replications. The studied cultivars i.e., Sakha 1, Sakha 3 and Sakha 5 occupied the main plots. Whereas, fertilization treatments (urea (CH4N2O) 46.5%, ammonium nitrate (NH4NO3) 33.5% and ammonium sulphate (NH4)2SO4) 20.6% with or without foliar application of yeast extract (YE) were randomly distributed in the sub-plots.
Nitrogen fertilization treatments i.e., 100% urea, 100% ammonium nitrate, 100% ammonium sulphate (recommended dose = 150 kg mineral nitrogen ha1), 75% urea, 75% ammonium nitrate, 75% ammonium sulphate from the recommended dose, 75% urea+yeast, 75% ammonium nitrate+yeast and 75% ammonium sulphate+yeast. Where yeast extract was prepared according to Hafez et al.17 and sprayed as 10 g L1 at 60 and 75 days after sowing (DAS). The sub-plot area was 6 m2 with 3 m long and 2 m wide. Flax seeds were sown on November 5th 2018 and 7th 2019. Flax was harvested on April 9th and 13th in both seasons, respectively.
Plant materials: Flax seeds were obtained from the Field Crops Research Institute, Agricultural Research Center, Giza, Egypt and were sown by using the broadcasting method at the recommended rate of 145 kg ha1.
Management: All plots received phosphorous fertilizer in the form of calcium superphosphate (15.5% P2O5) at a rate of 240 kg ha1 and potassium fertilizer in the form of potassium sulphate (48% K2O) at the rate of 120 kg ha1 were added during land preparation. The mineral nitrogen fertilizer was applied in two equal doses at the rate of 150 kg ha1 (according to previous treatments for all nitrogen sources) before the 1st and 2nd irrigation. Other cultural practices were applied according to the recommendations of the Egyptian Field Crops Research Institute for the commercial production of flax. The preceding summer crop was maize in both seasons.
Studied characters
Shoot dry weight: Shoot dry weight was determined at 90 and 120 days, (an average of 10 randomly chosen and guarded plants). Plant samples were dried in an electric oven with a drift fan at 70°C for 48 hrs, till constant dry weight.
Yield and its attributes: Plant height (cm), technical length (cm), fruiting zone (cm), number of fruiting branches, number of capsules per plant, number of seeds per capsules, 1000-seed weight (g) and seed yield per plant (g) (average of 10 randomly chosen and guarded plants). Seed and fiber yields (t ha1): Conversion of seed and fiber yields obtained from each sub-plot to its equivalent seed and fiber yields (t ha1).
Chlorophyll content: Chlorophyll a, b and a+b (mg g1 fresh leaves) was determined after 90 days from sowing, according to Lichtenthaler and Buschmann19.
Endogenous hormones: Indole acetic acid (IAA), gibberellic acid (GA3) and cytokinin content (mg g1 fresh leaves) were determined in flax leaves at 90 days old according to Wang et al.20.
Nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium (%) in flax seeds: Nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium percentages were determined in flax seeds. Total nitrogen content (N) was determined using the Micro-Kjeldahl method described by Motsara and Roy21. Phosphorus (P) was determined colourimetrically by method Motsara and Roy21 and potassium (K) were determined by using a flame photometer according to Junsomboon and Jakmunee22.
Seed oil (%): Oil content in flax seeds was determined by extracting using the Soxhlet apparatus according to the method described by Das et al.23.
Seed protein percentage (%): Total nitrogen was determined according to Motsara and Roy21. Protein content was calculated by multiplying the values of total nitrogen by 6.25.
Seed total carbohydrates (%): Total carbohydrates in dried flax seeds were determined using the phenol sulphuric method according to Albalasmeh et al.24.
Farmer’s benefit: The net return of flax ha1 was calculated by subtracting the total cost of flax from the total return of flax yield ha1 (seed+straw). By using the average price for the two seasons, the price of flax was 1476 $ t1 (1273 dollars t1 seed and 203 dollars t1 straw). The above estimations were based on the prices determined by the Ministry of Egyptian Agriculture and Land Reclamation.
Statistical analysis: All data were subjected to the analysis of variance (ANOVA) for split-plot design followed by compared means with LSD at a 5% level of probability according to Snedecor and Cochran25.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Shoot dry weight: Table 2 indicated that, shoot dry weight plant1 was significantly differing by cultivars at 90 and 120 days from sowing in the 1st season. Sakha 5 gave the heaviest shoot dry weight per plant (2.02 and 3.17 g) at 90 and 120 days from sowing, respectively in the 1st season. El-Borhamy et al.26 found that flax genotypes differed in their genetic factor and their response to environmental conditions.
Nitrogen fertilizer sources with or without foliar application of yeast extract significantly affected shoot dry weight per plant at 90 and 120 days after sowing in both growing seasons. When flax plants received 75% urea plus foliar spraying yeast extract gave the heaviest shoot dry weight per plant (2.40 and 2.45 g) and (3.60 and 3.84 g) at 90 and 120 days after sowing in both seasons, respectively. Soethe et al.27 showed that urea exceeded ammonium sulphate on flax dry weight per plant. The nitrogenous fertilizers especially urea improved the growth of flax plants28. Nitrogen is an essential element for building up protoplasm and protein which is important for meristematic activity and cell division increased flax growth29. The addition of mineral nitrogen fertilizer especially urea with yeast extract increased plant dry weight30. Foliar application of yeast extract increased shoot dry weight of flax plants6 through its basic functions i.e. CO2 production and formation of natural hormones also contains amino acids and vitamins B31.
Yield and its attributes: Table 3 and 4 indicated that plant height, technical length, number of fruiting branches per plant, number of capsules per plant, 1000-seed weight and seed yield per plant were significantly affected by the cultivars in the two studied seasons, however, there were insignificant differences between the studied cultivars in the fruiting zone and numbers of seeds per capsule in the 2nd season.
Table 2: | Shoot dry weight of flax cultivars as affected by mineral nitrogen fertilizer and a foliar spray of yeast extract in 1st and 2nd seasons |
Shoot dry weight per plant at 90 days (g) |
Shoot dry weight per plant at 120 days (g) |
|||
Treatments |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
Cultivars | ||||
Sakha 1 |
1.82b |
1.98 |
2.93b |
3.13 |
Sakha 3 |
1.93a |
2.02 |
3.05ab |
3.16 |
Sakha 5 |
2.02a |
2.03 |
3.17a |
3.27 |
L.S.D (0.05) |
0.10 |
NS |
0.14 |
NS |
Fertilizations | ||||
100% | ||||
Urea |
2.26ab |
2.37a |
3.47a |
3.51ab |
Nitrate |
2.05bc |
2.36a |
3.10b |
3.19b |
Sulphate |
1.95c |
2.02b |
3.02b |
3.19b |
75% | ||||
Urea |
1.61d |
1.63c |
2.54c |
2.71c |
Nitrate |
1.49de |
1.46cd |
2.51c |
2.71c |
Sulphate |
1.32e |
1.33d |
2.42c |
2.64c |
75% | ||||
Urea+yeast |
2.40a |
2.45a |
3.60a |
3.84a |
Nitrate+yeast |
2.19abc |
2.26ab |
3.49a |
3.52ab |
Sulphate+yeast |
2.02bc |
2.20ab |
3.27ab |
3.37b |
L.S.D (0.05) |
0.21 |
0.25 |
0.25 |
0.33 |
Means in the same column followed by the same letter(s) are not significant according to L.S.D at the probability of 0.05 |
Table 3: | Yield and its attributes of flax cultivars as affected by mineral nitrogen fertilizer and a foliar spray of yeast extract in 1st and 2nd seasons |
Plant height (cm) |
Technical length (cm) |
Fruiting zone (cm) |
No. of fruiting branches per plant |
|||||
Treatments |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
Cultivars | ||||||||
Sakha 1 |
93.0a |
99.3a |
81.4b |
87.0a |
11.5a |
12.3 |
4.59b |
5.15b |
Sakha 3 |
93.8a |
98.3a |
83.8a |
87.1a |
10.0b |
11.1 |
4.11c |
5.56b |
Sakha 5 |
85.5b |
91.9b |
73.5c |
79.9b |
12.0a |
12.0 |
5.00a |
6.37a |
L.S.D (0.05) |
1.0 |
3.1 |
1.0 |
2.2 |
1.3 |
NS |
0.37 |
0.67 |
Fertilizations | ||||||||
100% | ||||||||
Urea |
100.1a |
106.9a |
88.1a |
90.9b |
12.0 |
16.0a |
5.33a |
6.56abc |
Nitrate |
92.7b |
98.9bc |
82.4b |
87.1c |
10.2 |
11.8b |
4.67abc |
5.67abcd |
Sulphate |
90.4b |
95.9c |
79.1b |
85.7c |
11.3 |
10.2b |
4.44abc |
5.89abcd |
75% | ||||||||
Urea |
82.0c |
89.9d |
70.8c |
79.2d |
11.2 |
10.7b |
3.78bc |
5.00cd |
Nitrate |
79.0c |
86.2e |
68.8c |
75.9e |
10.2 |
10.3b |
3.67c |
4.56d |
Sulphate |
81.0c |
85.4e |
70.0c |
75.4e |
11.0 |
10.0b |
3.78bc |
4.33d |
75% | ||||||||
Urea+yeast |
101.1a |
101.0a |
89.9a |
94.1a |
11.2 |
12.9b |
5.56a |
7.22a |
Nitrate+yeast |
98.2a |
100.0b |
86.8a |
87.7c |
11.4 |
12.3b |
5.11ab |
6.78ab |
Sulphate+yeast |
92.3b |
98.2bc |
80.4b |
86.0c |
11.9
|
12.2b |
4.78abc |
5.22bcd |
L.S.D (0.05) |
2.6 |
2.7 |
2.9 |
2.2 |
NS |
2.3 |
0.91 |
1.15 |
Means in the same column followed by the same letter(s) are not significant according to L.S.D at the probability of 0.05 |
Sakha 5 cultivar gave the highest number of fruiting branches per plant (5.00 and 6.37), the number of capsules per plant (20.00 and 20.10) and seed yield per plant (1.06 and 1.11 g) in both studied seasons, respectively. Also, it gave the highest fruiting zone (12.00 cm) and the number of seeds per capsule (6.89) in the 1st season and the heaviest 1000-seed weight (7.56 g) in the 2nd season. However, Sakha 3 gave the highest plant height (93.8 cm) in the 1st season and (83.8 and 87.1 cm) for technical length in both seasons, respectively. Sakha 1 had the highest plant height (99.30 cm) and the heaviest 1000-seed weight (7.45 g) in the 1st season, respectively. These results are in harmony with those obtained by El-Borhamy et al.26 and Omer and Mahmood32.
Table 4: | Yield and its attributes of flax cultivars as affected by mineral nitrogen fertilizer and a foliar spray of yeast extract in 1st and 2nd seasons |
No. of capsules per plant |
No. of seeds per capsule |
1000-seed weight (g) |
Seed yield per plant (g) |
|||||
Treatments |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
Cultivars | ||||||||
Sakha 1 |
18.9a |
19.1ab |
6.56ab |
6.96 |
7.45a |
7.48a |
0.93b |
1.01b |
Sakha 3 |
16.8b |
17.7b |
6.11b |
6.48 |
7.03b |
7.26b |
0.89b |
0.90c |
Sakha 5 |
20.0a |
20.1a |
6.89a |
7.26 |
7.34a |
7.56a |
1.06a |
1.11a |
L.S.D (0.05) |
1.4 |
1.8 |
0.55 |
NS |
0.19 |
0.14 |
0.05 |
0.04 |
Fertilizations | ||||||||
100% | ||||||||
Urea |
20.3ab |
20.7ab |
7.22a |
7.78a |
7.34ab |
7.70a |
1.03ab |
1.08a |
Nitrate |
18.0cd |
18.7bc |
7.00ab |
7.78a |
7.34ab |
7.62a |
0.99bc |
1.07a |
Sulphate |
17.6cd |
18.9bc |
6.33ab |
6.44ab |
7.42a |
7.53a |
0.98c |
1.07a |
75% | ||||||||
Urea |
17.3cd |
17.8c |
6.44ab |
7.11ab |
6.95b |
7.07b |
0.87d |
0.89b |
Nitrate |
16.1d |
17.2c |
5.67b |
6.44ab |
7.00b |
7.06b |
0.88d |
0.88b |
Sulphate |
17.0cd |
17.4c |
5.89ab |
6.78ab |
6.98b |
7.09b |
0.88d |
0.88b |
75% | ||||||||
Urea+yeast |
21.6a |
21.8a |
7.33a |
6.89ab |
7.59a |
7.68a |
1.06a |
1.08a |
Nitrate+yeast |
20.3ab |
19.6abc |
6.33ab |
6.78ab |
7.50a |
7.56a |
0.99bc |
1.06a |
Sulphate+yeast |
18.8bc |
19.0bc |
6.44ab |
6.11b |
7.32ab |
7.58a |
0.95c |
1.05a |
L.S.D (0.05) |
1.8 |
1.9 |
0.92 |
0.90 |
0.29 |
0.29 |
0.03 |
0.06 |
Means in the same column followed by the same letter(s) are not significant according to L.S.D at the probability of 0.05 |
Table 5: | Yield and its attributes of flax cultivars as affected by mineral nitrogen fertilizer and a foliar spray of yeast extract in 1st and 2nd seasons |
Seed yield (t ha1) |
Fiber yield (t ha1) |
Straw yield (t ha1) |
Biological yield (t ha1) |
|||||
Treatments |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
Cultivars | ||||||||
Sakha 1 |
0.98 |
1.03b |
1.37b |
1.40b |
8.68 |
8.91 |
9.66 |
9.94 |
Sakha 3 |
0.92 |
0.95c |
1.47a |
1.52a |
9.44 |
9.56 |
10.36 |
10.51 |
Sakha 5 |
1.02 |
1.10a |
1.17c |
1.20c |
8.30 |
8.44 |
9.31 |
9.54 |
L.S.D (0.05) |
NS |
0.05 |
0.04 |
0.06 |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
Fertilizations | ||||||||
100% | ||||||||
Urea |
1.04a |
1.06a |
1.45a |
1.47a |
9.39ab |
9.59ab |
10.44a |
10.65ab |
Nitrate |
1.02ab |
1.07a |
1.40a |
1.43a |
9.15abc |
9.09ab |
10.17ab |
10.16abc |
Sulphate |
1.00ab |
1.09a |
1.40a |
1.41a |
8.81abc |
9.07ab |
9.81ab |
10.16abc |
75% | ||||||||
Urea |
0.90bc |
0.94b |
1.19b |
1.20b |
8.25bc |
8.31b |
9.15b |
9.25c |
Nitrate |
0.90bc |
0.93b |
1.16b |
1.21b |
8.15c |
8.55ab |
9.05b |
9.47bc |
Sulphate |
0.85c |
0.89b |
1.13b |
1.18b |
8.17c |
8.28b |
9.02b |
9.17c |
75% | ||||||||
Urea+yeast |
1.05a |
1.11a |
1.47a |
1.51a |
9.52a |
9.87a |
10.58a |
10.98a |
Nitrate+yeast |
1.00ab |
1.10a |
1.45a |
1.47a |
9.15abc |
9.13ab |
10.15ab |
10.22abc |
Sulphate+yeast |
0.99ab |
1.05a |
1.40a |
1.46a |
8.62abc |
8.84ab |
9.62ab |
9.88abc |
L.S.D (0.05) |
0.08 |
0.09 |
0.08 |
0.07 |
0.78 |
0.88 |
0.78 |
0.90 |
Means in the same column followed by the same letter(s) are not significant according to L.S.D at the probability of 0.05 |
Concerning different nitrogen fertilizer sources with or without foliar application of yeast extract significantly affected the previous traits except for the fruiting zone in the 1st season only. In this regard, 75% urea plus a foliar spray of yeast extract had a superior effect on most studied traits followed by 100% urea. On the contrary, the lowest values of these traits were obtained from plants that received the lowest nitrogen fertilizer. Fertilizing flax plants with mineral nitrogen increased yield and its related traits12,33,34. Soethe et al.27 found that urea as a nitrogen source had a positive influence on flax productivity. Nitrogen is a major input in crop production and balanced nitrogen fertility is required to improve flax yield and quality35. The addition of mineral nitrogen fertilizer and foliar application with yeast extract enhances yield and its traits31,36.
Seed yield per plant was significantly affected by the interaction between flax cultivars under study and different sources of mineral nitrogen fertilizer with or without foliar spraying yeast extract in the two studied seasons (Fig. 1a-b).
Table 5 indicated that significant differences among flax cultivars in seed yield in the 2nd season and fiber yield in both seasons. Data illustrated that Sakha 5 cv. gave the heaviest seed yield (1.10 t ha1 ) in the 2nd season, while Sakha 3 cultivar gave the heaviest fiber yield (1.47 and 1.52 t ha1) followed by Sakha 1 (1.37 and 1.40 t ha1) in the two seasons, respectively.
Fig. 1(a-b): | Interaction between flax cultivars and fertilization on (a) Seed yield per plant in 2018/2019 and (b) 2019/2020 seasons YE: Yeast extract |
These results are in harmony with those obtained by Bakry et al.37 and El-Borhamy et al.26.
Seed, fiber, straw and biological yields t ha1 were significantly affected by fertilization treatments in both seasons. 75% urea plus foliar spraying yeast extract had a superior effect on seed yield (1.05 and 1.11 t ha1), fiber yield (1.47 and 1.51 t ha1), straw yield (9.52 and 9.87 t ha1) and biological yield (10.58 and 10.98 t ha1) in the two seasons, respectively followed by 100% urea. The addition of mineral nitrogen fertilizer with yeast extract increased plant productivity30,31,38. Amino acids and vitamins in yeast extract increased the metabolic process and improve the growth which in turn reflected on increasing the productivity15.
Chlorophyll content: Table 6 showed that flax cultivars and nitrogen fertilization treatments had a significant effect on chlorophyll content (a, b and a+b) in the two growing seasons. Sakha 5 gave the highest chlorophyll-a (1.463 and 1.540), chlorophyll b (0.879 and 0.901) and chlorophyll a+b (2.342 and 2.442) in the two seasons, respectively followed by Sakha 3, whereas Sakha 1 had higher chlorophyll-a in the 2nd season than Sakha 3 with average (1.498). Similar results were obtained by Nofal et al.38.
Application of 75% from urea, ammonium nitrate and ammonium sulphate with foliar spray of yeast extract or 100 % recorded the maximum increase in chlorophyll a, b and a+b compared with 75% from different nitrogen fertilizer sources. The highest chlorophyll content was observed with urea followed by ammonium nitrate and the lowest with ammonium sulphate. In this regard, the increase in nitrogen rate increased chlorophyll content might be due to the role of mineral nitrogen in chlorophyll formation29. The addition of urea or ammonium sulphate with foliar spray of yeast extract increased total chlorophyll36.
Moreover, foliar application of yeast extract increased the enzymes related to the photosynthetic process that resulted in improving uptake of iron and magnesium as well as other nutrients which are important for chlorophyll biosynthesis39,40.
The interaction between flax cultivars and nitrogen fertilization treatments had a significant effect on chlorophyll a, b and a+b content in the two growing seasons (Fig. 2a-e).
Endogenous hormones: Table 7 revealed that the flax cultivars under study had a significant effect on gibberellic acid (GA3) in the 1st season and cytokinin in the two studied seasons.
Fig. 2(a-e): | Interaction between cultivars and fertilization on (a, b) chlorophyll a, (c, d) chlorophyll b, in 1st and 2nd seasons, and (e) chlorophyll a+b in 2nd season YE: Yeast extract |
Table 6: | Chlorophyll content of flax cultivars (mg g1 fresh leaves) as affected by mineral nitrogen fertilizer and a foliar spray of yeast extract in 1st and 2nd seasons |
Chlorophyll a |
Chlorophyll b |
Chlorophyll a+b |
||||
Treatments |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
Cultivars | ||||||
Sakha 1 |
1.427b |
1.498b |
0.799c |
0.805c |
2.226c |
2.303b |
Sakha 3 |
1.435b |
1.479c |
0.830b |
0.841b |
2.265b |
2.320b |
Sakha 5 |
1.463a |
1.540a |
0.879a |
0.901a |
2.342a |
2.442a |
L.S.D (0.05) |
0.015 |
0.015 |
0.017 |
0.008 |
0.030 |
0.017 |
Fertilizations | ||||||
100% | ||||||
Urea |
1.587a |
1.637a |
0.879ab |
0.904b |
2.466a |
2.541b |
Nitrate |
1.536bc |
1.574b |
0.867ab |
0.876c |
2.402b |
2.450d |
Sulphate |
1.508cd |
1.597b |
0.868ab |
0.854d |
2.376bc |
2.451d |
75% | ||||||
Urea |
1.280e |
1.330c |
0.771c |
0.770e |
2.051d |
2.100e |
Nitrate |
1.247f |
1.292d |
0.737d |
0.753ef |
1.983e |
2.046f |
Sulphate |
1.238f |
1.276d |
0.762cd |
0.746f |
2.000e |
2.021f |
75% | ||||||
Urea+yeast |
1.567ab |
1.646a |
0.898a |
0.934a |
2.464a |
2.580a |
Nitrate+yeast |
1.530bc |
1.609b |
0.881ab |
0.909b |
2.411b |
2.518bc |
Sulphate+yeast |
1.486d |
1.590b |
0.859b |
0.897b |
2.344c |
2.487cd |
L.S.D (0.05) |
0.031 |
0.028 |
0.026 |
0.019 |
0.041 |
0.038 |
Means in the same column followed by the same letter(s) are not significant according to L.S.D at the probability of 0.05 |
Table 7: | IAA, GA3 and cytokinin content of flax cultivars as affected by mineral nitrogen fertilizer and a foliar spray of yeast extract in 1st and 2nd seasons |
IAA (mg g1 fresh leaves) |
GA3 (mg g1 fresh leaves) |
Cytokinin (mg g1 fresh leaves) |
||||
Treatments |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/ 2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
Cultivars | ||||||
Sakha 1 |
0.751 |
0.805 |
1.241a |
1.243 |
1.448b |
1.634b |
Sakha 3 |
0.765 |
0.787 |
1.148b |
1.216 |
1.542a |
1.700a |
Sakha 5 |
0.733 |
0.761 |
1.185b |
1.199 |
1.543a |
1.549c |
L.S.D (0.05) |
NS |
NS |
0.051 |
NS |
0.023 |
0.021 |
Fertilizations | ||||||
100% | ||||||
Urea |
0.878a |
0.877ab |
1.265b |
1.303b |
1.469bc |
1.632c |
Nitrate |
0.803b |
0.811cd |
1.218bc |
1.239b |
1.486b |
1.600cd |
Sulphate |
0.729c |
0.758d |
1.150c |
1.239b |
1.465bc |
1.570d |
75% | ||||||
Urea |
0.661d |
0.705e |
0.991d |
0.968c |
1.393d |
1.468e |
Nitrate |
0.610de |
0.692e |
0.987d |
1.017c |
1.415cd |
1.481e |
Sulphate |
0.599e |
0.651e |
0.962d |
0.980c |
1.412cd |
1.474e |
75% | ||||||
Urea+yeast |
0.845ab |
0.913a |
1.420a |
1.424a |
1.671a |
1.842a |
Nitrate+yeast |
0.815b |
0.844bc |
1.383a |
1.426a |
1.649a |
1.806ab |
Sulphate+yeast |
0.806b |
0.807cd |
1.346a |
1.380a |
1.640a |
1.777b |
L.S.D (0.05) |
0.051 |
0.047 |
0.071 |
0.067 |
0.050 |
0.045 |
Means in the same column followed by the same letter(s) are not significant according to L.S.D at the probability of 0.05 |
Sakha 1 had the highest content of GA3 (1.241) in the 1st season, also Sakha 3 had the same effect for cytokinin (1.700) in the 2nd season. These significant variations between cultivars were confirmed by Bakry et al.41.
Endogenous hormones in flax leave are significantly affected by different nitrogen fertilizers sources with or without foliar application of yeast extract. Flax plants received 100% urea or 75% urea plus the foliar application of yeast extract gave the highest content for IAA in the two seasons. With respect of 75% urea plus yeast extract gave the maximum value followed by ammonium nitrate and ammonium sulphate which had a superior effect on GA3 and cytokinin content in flax leaves for the two growing seasons. Yeast extract is a rich source of hormones, this leads to increased plant growth regulators such as auxin, cytokinin and gibberellin in plant tissues6,42.
Interaction between flax cultivars and different mineral nitrogen fertilizer sources with or without a foliar spray of yeast extract significantly affected indole acetic acid (IAA), cytokinin in the two seasons and GA3 in the 1st season (Fig. 3a-e).
Fig. 3(a-e): | Interaction between flax cultivars and fertilization on (a, b) IAA in 1st and 2nd seasons, (c) GA3 in 1st season and (d, e) cytokinin in 1st and 2nd seasons YE: Yeast extract |
Fig. 4(a-d): | Interaction between flax cultivars and fertilization on (a) N%, (b) K% in 1st season and (c, d) P% in seeds in 1st and 2nd seasons YE: Yeast extract |
Nitrogen, phosphorous and potassium content in flaxseed: There were significant differences between the studied cultivars in nitrogen (N) phosphorous (P) and potassium (K) content of flaxseed except for nitrogen content in the 2nd season (Table 8). Sakha 3 cultivar gave the highest nitrogen content (3.35%) in the 1st season, phosphorous (0.450 and 0.460%) and potassium (2.41 and 2.50%) followed by Sakha 5 cv. in the two seasons, respectively. The variations between flax cultivars may be due to the differences in origin, genetic constituent and growth habit6.
Nitrogen fertilization treatments significantly affected NPK in flax seeds. 75% urea plus the foliar application of yeast extract produced the highest N% (3.53 and 3.67%), P (0.473 and 0.484%) and K (2.63 and 2.71%) in the two seasons, respectively followed by 75% ammonium nitrate plus yeast for N and 100% urea for P and K. Foliar application of yeast extract increased NPK content15,43.
Concerning interaction between flax cultivars and different nitrogen fertilizer sources with or without a foliar spray of yeast extract significantly affect N, K in the 1st season and phosphorus percentage in the two seasons (Fig. 4a-d).
Table 8: | N, P and K percentages in seeds of flax cultivars as affected by mineral nitrogen fertilizer and a foliar spray of yeast extract in 1st and 2nd seasons |
N (%) |
P (%) |
K (%) |
||||
Treatments |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
Cultivars | ||||||
Sakha 1 |
3.29b |
3.50 |
0.427b |
0.441c |
2.28c |
2.37b |
Sakha 3 |
3.35a |
3.54 |
0.450a |
0.460a |
2.41a |
2.50a |
Sakha 5 |
3.20c |
3.44 |
0.429b |
0.453b |
2.35b |
2.46a |
L.S.D (0.05) |
0.01 |
NS |
0.011 |
0.004 |
0.01 |
0.06 |
Fertilizations | ||||||
100% | ||||||
Urea |
3.42c |
3.56a |
0.467b |
0.481a |
2.58b |
2.63ab |
Nitrate |
3.34d |
3.53a |
0.450d |
0.464b |
2.41f |
2.49c |
Sulphate |
3.19e |
3.47ab |
0.440e |
0.464b |
2.43e |
2.55bc |
75% | ||||||
Urea |
3.17f |
3.34b |
0.410f |
0.426d |
2.09g |
2.16d |
Nitrate |
3.05g |
3.32b |
0.393g |
0.416d |
1.99i |
2.13d |
Sulphate |
2.99h |
3.35b |
0.384h |
0.414d |
2.01h |
2.18d |
75% | ||||||
Urea+yeast |
3.53a |
3.67a |
0.473a |
0.484a |
2.63a |
2.71a |
Nitrate+yeast |
3.46b |
3.64a |
0.457c |
0.464b |
2.51c |
2.63ab |
Sulphate+yeast |
3.35d |
3.57a |
0.440e |
0.448c |
2.48d |
2.54bc |
L.S.D (0.05) |
0.02 |
0.14 |
0.005 |
0.012 |
0.02 |
0.08 |
Means in the same column followed by the same letter(s) are not significant according to L.S.D at the probability of 0.05 |
Table 9: | Oil, protein and total carbohydrates content in seeds of flax cultivars as affected by mineral nitrogen fertilizer and a foliar spray of yeast extract in 1st and 2nd seasons |
Oil (%) |
Protein (%) |
Total carbohydrates (%) |
||||
Treatments |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
2018/2019 |
2019/2020 |
Cultivars | ||||||
Sakha 1 |
37.01b |
37.58 |
20.53b |
21.87 |
21.62b |
21.92 |
Sakha 3 |
36.99b |
37.48 |
20.94a |
22.14 |
21.43c |
21.84 |
Sakha 5 |
37.48a |
37.96 |
19.98c |
21.51 |
21.85a |
22.21 |
L.S.D (0.05) |
0.23 |
NS |
0.06 |
NS |
0.04 |
NS |
Fertilizations | ||||||
100% | ||||||
Urea |
38.14b |
38.75ab |
21.38c |
22.23a |
22.34c |
22.71a |
Nitrate |
37.64d |
38.37abc |
20.85d |
22.06a |
22.09e |
22.58a |
Sulphate |
37.37f |
37.65c |
19.96e |
21.66ab |
21.89f |
22.51a |
75% | ||||||
Urea |
36.03g |
36.46d |
19.78f |
20.89b |
20.59g |
20.93b |
Nitrate |
35.78h |
36.34d |
19.09g |
20.74b |
20.06h |
20.36b |
Sulphate |
35.63i |
36.17d |
18.69h |
20.97b |
20.05h |
20.43b |
75% | ||||||
Urea+yeast |
38.37a |
39.13a |
22.06a |
22.93a |
22.98a |
23.25a |
Nitrate+yeast |
37.97c |
38.42abc |
21.64b |
22.74a |
22.47b |
22.71a |
Sulphate+yeast |
37.52e |
37.80bc |
20.91d |
22.34a |
22.23d |
22.44a |
L.S.D (0.05) |
0.10 |
0.74 |
0.13 |
0.88 |
0.05 |
0.65 |
Means in the same column followed by the same letter(s) are not significant according to L.S.D at the probability of 0.05 |
Oil, protein and total carbohydrates content in flax seeds: Table 9 showed that the differences among cultivars were significant for oil, protein and total carbohydrates for flax seeds in the 1st season. Sakha 3 gave the highest protein content (20.94%) in the 1st season. As for oil and total carbohydrates content Sakha 5 produced the highest values (37.48 and 21.85%) in the 1st season, respectively. Similar results were obtained by El-Borhamy et al.26.
Table 9 also, revealed that different nitrogen fertilizer sources with or without foliar application yeast extract had a significant effect on oil, protein and total carbohydrates content for flax seeds in the two seasons.
Fig. 5(a-c): | Interaction between flax cultivars and fertilization on (a) oil%, (b) protein% and (c) total carbohydrates (%) in seeds in 1st season YE: Yeast extract |
About 75% urea plus a foliar spray of yeast extract increased oil (38.37 and 39.13%), protein (22.06 and 22.93%) and total carbohydrates content for flax seeds (22.98 and 23.25%) in the two studied seasons, respectively followed by 75% ammonium nitrate+yeast extract and 100% urea. The increase of mineral nitrogen fertilizer increased seed oil29 and protein production35. Yeast extract contains amino acids and vitamins which increased the metabolic process and may improve the growth which in turn enhances the plant quality15. Yeast extract as foliar application increased the oil, protein and total carbohydrates content of flax seeds6.
Concerning the interaction between flax cultivars and different mineral nitrogen fertilizer sources with or without a foliar spray of yeast extract recorded a significant effect on protein, oil and total carbohydrates percentage for flax seeds in the 1st season (Fig. 5a-c).
Table 10: | Some economics of flax productivity ha1 at various fertilization treatments (data over two seasons) |
Treatments |
Total costs ($ ha1) |
Return seed ($ ha1) |
Return straw ($ ha1) |
Total return ($ ha1) |
Net return ($ ha1) |
Sakha 1 | |||||
100% | |||||
Urea |
2240 |
1344 |
2100 |
3444 |
1204 |
Nitrate |
2318 |
1338 |
2034 |
3372 |
1054 |
Sulphate |
2491 |
1339 |
2002 |
3341 |
850 |
75% | |||||
Urea |
2178 |
1177 |
1884 |
3061 |
883 |
Nitrate |
2236 |
1171 |
1897 |
3068 |
832 |
Sulphate |
2366 |
1114 |
1875 |
2989 |
623 |
75% | |||||
Urea+yeast |
2186 |
1382 |
2137 |
3519 |
1333 |
Nitrate +yeast |
2244 |
1345 |
2038 |
3383 |
1139 |
Sulphate +yeast |
2374 |
1306 |
1965 |
3271 |
897 |
Sakha 3 | |||||
100% | |||||
Urea |
2240 |
1250 |
2236 |
3486 |
1246 |
Nitrate |
2318 |
1245 |
2165 |
3410 |
1092 |
Sulphate |
2491 |
1245 |
2130 |
3375 |
884 |
75% | |||||
Urea |
2178 |
1096 |
2003 |
3099 |
921 |
Nitrate |
2236 |
1060 |
2017 |
3077 |
841 |
Sulphate |
2366 |
1036 |
1992 |
3028 |
662 |
75% | |||||
Urea+yeast |
2186 |
1287 |
2276 |
3563 |
1377 |
Nitrate+yeast |
2244 |
1251 |
2167 |
3418 |
1174 |
Sulphate+yeast |
2374 |
1216 |
2111 |
3327 |
953 |
Sakha 5 | |||||
100% | |||||
Urea |
2240 |
1418 |
2019 |
3437 |
1197 |
Nitrate |
2318 |
1412 |
1956 |
3369 |
1050 |
Sulphate |
2491 |
1413 |
1925 |
3338 |
847 |
75% | |||||
Urea |
2178 |
1242 |
1813 |
3065 |
887 |
Nitrate |
2236 |
1236 |
1825 |
3061 |
928 |
Sulphate |
2366 |
1195 |
1803 |
2998 |
632 |
75% | |||||
Urea+yeast |
2186 |
1451 |
2053 |
3504 |
1318 |
Nitrate+yeast |
2244 |
1419 |
1990 |
3409 |
1165 |
Sulphate+yeast |
2374 |
1379 |
1916 |
3295 |
921 |
Farmer’s benefit: Results in (Table 10) revealed that the total costs are affected by the applied treatments (average of the two growing seasons). The highest values of net return were obtained from the interaction between Sakha 3×75% urea with foliar application of yeast extract (1377 $ ha1) followed by Sakha 1(1333$ ha1 ) and Sakha 5 (1318 $ ha1) which might be due to the highest seed and straw yield44.
CONCLUSION
It might be thus concluded that using the most suitable cultivars in the framework of balanced mineral nitrogen fertilization (especially 75% urea from recommended dose) with using the foliar application of yeast extract is recommendable for getting relatively high seed, fiber and straw yields. Also, it can improve seed quality and the net return of flax cultivars. Yeast is eco-friendly and less expensive. In this way, we can decrease mineral nitrogen fertilizer which helps to reduce environmental pollution and the cost of production.
SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENTS
This study discovered the superior yield and seed quality of flax under 75% urea fertilizer from recommended dose plus the foliar application of yeast extract that can be beneficial for farmers to generate better income and reduce environmental pollution.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors of this study are acknowledging Agricultural Research Center, 9 Algamaa Street, Giza, Egypt, for support to achieve this study.