Comparison of Different Wheat Seed Categories (Vs) Farmers Seed: Yield and Yield Components
Amir Zaman Khan ,
H. Khan ,
R. Khan ,
To evaluate the effect of different wheat seed categories with farmers seed for yield and yield components. An experiment was conducted at Agriculture Research Farm, NWFP Agricultural University, Peshawar, during 2003-04. The experiment was laid out in Randomized Complete Block (RCB) design with four replications. The seed categories were pre-basic, basic and certified seed of wheat varieties Bakhtawar-92 and Fakhri Sarhad from CCRI, Pirsabak and were compared with farmers seed of the same varieties collected from 4 location of the province. Maximum emergence m-2 (183) was recorded from pre-basic seed of Bakhtawar-92 and Fakhri Sarhad collected from CCRI, Pirsabak followed by basic and certified seed category of the same location. Farmers seed collected from Peshawar locality gave minimum emergence m-2 (73) among different seed categories. Pre-basic cateroy of Bakhtawar-92 obtained from CCRI, Pirsabak gave maximum spikes m-2 (347.3), grains spike-1 (52.30), biological yield (11500 kg ha-1), grain yield (4931 kg ha-1), thousand grain weight (52.75 g) and harvest index (43.11%), followed by basic and certified categories of the same varieties and location. Among farmers seed, Bakhtawar-92 collected from Charsadda and Nowshera locality performed better in all yield parameters as compared to other locations. Farmers seed collected from Peshawar and Mardan performed poorly in maximum yield parameters. It is concluded that pre-basic seed of Bakhtawar-92 and Fakhri Sarhad obtained from CCRI, Pirsabak showed better performance in all agronomic parameters and may be recommended for higher production under the agroclimatic conditions of NWFP-Pakistan.
Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) is the main staple food of Pakistan. It
contributes 12.5% to the value added in agriculture and 3.1% to GDP. Wheat has
a great potential for yield than any other cereal crop but the average yield
is very low in Pakistan than other wheat growing countries of the world (Minfal,
2003). The low yield is partly due to poor quality seed which results poor germination
and improper establishment of the crop in the field. Proper and uniform stand
establishment are the key factors for successful crop production in all cropping
systems. To ensure such stands, even under adverse conditions, high vigor seeds
must be planted (Salepelto and Peltonen, 1995). Different seed lots may be mechanically
graded by seed size on a commercial scale with relative ease; consequently,
the effects on seed vigor, as expressed in percent emergence, speed of emergence
and yielding ability have been studied quite extensively (Douglas et al.,
1994). Seeds of crops are graded and sized to facilitate uniform planting. Grading
eliminate damaged seeds and contributes to a relatively uniform product (Newman
and Moser, 1988). There is increasing interest in the use of low priced grades
of wheat seed. In our country farmers either use their own farm produced seed
or buy seed from markets. Different categories of seed are available to farmers
for sowing purpose depending upon, where a farmer can go for obtaining quality
seed. Recently many private seed companies and semi-government organizations
have come forward in the seed trade. There are some private seed businessmen,
who sell seed in markets, spread out in the country. Farmers also get seeds
from government agencies and fellow farmers. Thus wide ranges of seed categories
are available to farmers for planting purpose at sowing time. Seed size is highly
correlated with seedling weight. Large seeds yield more than an equal number
of small seeds; however most studies on seed size reveal that large and small
seeds (un-graded) produce almost the same yield if the same seed rate by weight
is used. Limited information is available pertaining to the evaluation of different
classes of wheat seed collected from different locations. Therefore, the present
study was undertaken to evaluate the performance of different wheat seed categories
(vs) farmers seed for yield and yield components.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Seed of wheat varieties Bakhtawar-92 and Fakhri Sarhad were evaluated during 2003-2004 at Agricultural Research Farm, NWFP Agricultural University Peshawar. Seed of the same varieties was collected from two different farmers in each of the four districts of Charsadda, Mardan, Nowshera and Peshawar. Information about seed age is given in Table 1. The performance of the farmers seed collected from different location were compared with the pre-basic, basic and certified seed of both varieties obtained from CCRI, Pirsabak. The experiment was laid out in randomized complete block design, having four replications. A plot size of 3x5 m having 10 rows 30 cm apart and 5 m long was used. The soil of the experimental site was silty clay loam with a clay type montmorillonite, low in nitrogen (0.03-0.04%), low in organic matter (0.8-0.9%) and alkaline in reaction with a pH of 8.0-8.2 (Shah et al., 1993). A basal dose of 120 kg ha-1 of urea (46% N) and 60 kg ha-1 of D.A.P (18% N and 46% P2O5) were applied 1 day before seeding, whereas the remaining half of Urea were applied at booting stage.
Normal cultural practices for raising a successful crop were followed uniformly for all the experimental units. Irrigation was applied whenever required. Data were recorded on the following observations according to standard procedure: emergence (m-2), spikes (m-2), No of grains spike-1, biological yield (kg ha-1), grain yield (kg ha-1), 1000-grain weight (g) and harvest index (%).
Data were statistically analyzed using analysis of variance appropriate
to RCB Design. Upon obtaining significant differences, Least Significant Difference
(LSD) test at 0.05 level of probability was used for comparison among the treatments
|| Histry of the varieties, location and their aging time
|No. of year in parenthesis indicate that the farmer is using
that variety for the last many years; NA: Not Applicable
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The data recorded on yield and yield components of different seed categories of certified and farmers seed are reported below.
Better emergence m-2 is necessary for good crop stand which is
further depend upon the external factor like environment and as well as internal
factor like genetic makeup, seed vigour and viability. Data pertaining to emergence
(m-2) are reported in Table 2. Statistical analysis
of the data revealed that seed categories had significant effect on emergence
m-2. Maximum emergence m-2 (183) was recorded for the
pre-basic seed categrory of Fakhri Sarhad and Bakhtawar-92 obtained from CCRI
Pirsabak and followed by basic and certified seed categories of the same varieties
obtained from CCRI, Pirsabak. Minimum emergence m-2 (73) was recorded
in farmers seed of Fakhri Sarhad obtained from Peshawar and Nowshera Districts.
Maximum emergence m-2 from the pre-basic seed of Fakhri Sarhad and
Bakhtawar-92 from CCRI, Pirsabak, indicate the viability and vigor of the seed
produced in this locality of NWFP as compared to farmers seed of other
locations. These results are in agreement with those of Arora et al.
(1998) who reported maximum germination in certified seed as compared to farmers
Number of spikes m-2 is a major yield component and directly
contribute to the final yield of a crop. Data recorded on spike m-2
are presented in Table 2. Analysis of the data shows that
different seed categories significantly affected the number of spike m-2.
Pre-basic seed categrory of both varieties obtained from CCRI, Pirsabak, produced
maximum (347.3) spike m-2 as compared to basic and certified seed
categories of the same location. Farmer seed category of Fakhri Sarhad variety
obtained from Charsadda gave minimum (160) spike m-2 followed by
Mardan, Peshawar and Nowshera localities. Maximum spikes m-2 from
the pre-basic category of Bakhtawar-92 and Fakhri Sarhad obtained from CCRI,
Pirsabak might be due to condusive environment during plant growth and development
and its genetic potential as compared to farmers seed. The possible reason
might be due to poor storage and management practices for raising a successful
crop. These results are in conformity with those of Zofajova and Uzik (1996)
who reported maximum productive tillers and yield from the approved seed categories.
|| Emergence m-2, Spikes (m-2) and No.
of grains spike-1 of wheat as affected by different seed categories
|Means in same column followed by different letter (s) are
significantly different at 0.01 level of probability
Number of Grains Spike-1
Number of grains spike-1 is a major yield contributing
component. Data recorded on number of grains spike-1 are presented
in Table 2. Statistical analysis of the data indicates that
grains spike-1 of wheat varieties were significantly affected by
different seed categories. Pre-basic and basic seed categories of Bakhtawar-92
and Fakhri Sarhad obtained from CCRI Pirsabak, gave maximum number of grains
spike-1 (52) followed by certified seed category of both varieties.
Farmers seed obtained from Mardan locality gave minimum grains spike-1
(29) as compared to other localities of the Province. The minimum grains spike-1
in farmers seed category may be due to aging of the seed which resulted
poor quality seedling and poor management practices and the environment during
its development. These results are in agreement with those of (Beyene et
al., 1999) who reported manimum productivity from poor quality seed.
Biological Yield (kg ha-1)
Biological yield play a prominent role in the productivity of a crop. Data
recorded on biological yield are presented in Table 3. It
is revealed from the figure that biological yield of wheat varieties were significantly
affected by different seed categories. Pre-basic seed category of Bakhtawar-92
and Fakhri Sarhad obtained from CCRI Pirsabak, gave maximum biological yield
(11520 kg ha-1) followed by basic and certified seed category. Minimum
biological yield (6333 kg ha-1) was recorded in Farmers seed
obtained from Mardan and the trend of decrease was similar in all categories
of farmers seed. The reason for maximum biological yield in pre-basic
seed categories of Bakhtawar-92 and Fakhri Sarhad from CCRI, Pirsabak might
be high vigor of the seed and its potential and available of favourable
environment for growth and development, which play a major role in the availability
of nutrients and water from the soil. Stanton (1985) found higher grain yield
from certified seed as compared to farmers seed.
Grain Yield (kg ha-1)
Grain yield is the ultimate output of each and every crop. Data pertaining
to grain yield are presented in Table 3. Analysis of the data
shows that grain yield of wheat varieties were significantly affected by different
seed categories. Pre-basic seed category of Bakhtawar-92 and Fakhri Sarhad obtained
from CCRI Pirsabak, gave maximum grain yield (4931 kg ha-1) followed
by basic and certified seed category of the same varieties. Farmers seed
obtained from Charsadda gave minimum grain yield (2209 kg ha-1) and
the trend of decrease was similar in both varieties.
|| Biological yield, 1000-grain weight and harvest index of
wheat as affected by different seed categories
|Means in same column followed by different letter (s) are
significantly different at 0.01 level of probability
Maximum grain yield in pre-basic seed categories of Bakhtawar-92 and Fakhri
Sarhad from CCRI, Pirsabak might be due to high vigor and genetic makeup of
the seed and environmental suitability which resulted more uniform and vigorous
seedling. The performance of farmers seed was not up to the mark because
of poor storage which resulted poor quality seedling. The other possible argument
for less grain yield might be due to absorption of less nutrient availability
and other insufficient inputs for the growth and development of the crop. These
results are in line with Chastain et al. (1995) Agrawal and Misra (1996)
Karababa et al. (2000) who observed more grain yield for the approved
Thousand Grain Weight (g)
Thousand grain weight is an essential factor towards the final grain yield
and further depend upon crop growth, in term of productivity. Data recorded
on 1000 grain weight are presented in Table 3. Analysis of
variance shows that different seed categories have significantly affected 1000
grain weight. Maximum grain weight of (52.75 g) was recorded in pre-basic seed
category of Bakhtawar-92 obtained from CCRI, Pirsabak, followed by pre-basic
seed of Fakhri Sarhad (49 g) obtained from the same location. Farmers
seed of both varieties obtained from Charssadda gave minimum grain weight of
(31.25 g) followed by the same varieties obtained from Mardan. The reason for
maximum grain weight in the pre-basic seed category of Bakhtawar-92 from CCRI,
Pirsabak might be due to maximum leaf area and effective seed fill duration,
which contributed toward final yield. Whereas, minimum grain weight from farmers
seed of different location might be due to bad storage conditions, which resulted
in less vigor seed. These findings are in agreement with those of Podlaski and
Wyszkowska (1994) who obtained large size seed from certified seed category
and also by Zofajova and Uzik (1996) who recorded maximum seed weight for certified
Harvest Index (%)
Harvest index is the ratio of grain to biological yield and is used to determine
the usefulness of any crop in any environment. Data recorded on harvest index
are presented in Table 3. Perusal of the data revealed that
different seed categories have significantly affected the harvest index of both
varieties. Maximum harvest index of (43.11%) was recorded in the pre-basic seed
categories of Bakhtawar-92 and Fakhri Sarhad obtained from CCRI, Pirsabak followed
by basic and certified seed categries of both varieties. Farmers seed
obtained from Mardan gave the lowest harvest Index of 40.25% and was at par
with the seed obtained from Nowshera. Maximum harvest index from pre-basic seed
categories of both varieties might be due to more grain and biological yield
produced by the pre-basic Bakhtawar-92 seed (Stanelle et al., 1988).
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
It is concluded from the present study that seed categories of pre-basic, basic and certified of Bakhtawar-92 obtained from CCRI, Pirsabak performed better as compared to Fahri-Sarhad. Farmers seed collected from different locations performed poor in all yield parameters. It is recommended that for maximum yield, farmers must try their best to obtain the basic, certified and approved seed categories of wheat from research station before sowing.
We are grateful to Higher Education Commission (HEC) of Pakistan for Financial Support of this Project. Professor Dr. Paigham Shah for his technical assistance in Experimentation and analysis is also gratefully acknowledged.
1: Agrawal, A.P. and R.K. Misra, 1996. Direct and indirect impact of seed characters on seed yield in wheat. J. Hill Res., 9: 412-412.
2: Arora, R.N., R. Het, C.S. Tyagi, S. Jaivir, H. Ram and J. Singh, 1998. Comparative performance of farmers saved seed vis a vis quality seed for yield and seed quality parameters in guar ((Cyamopsis tetragonoloba L.,) Taub.). Forage Res., 24: 159-162.
3: Beyene, H., H. Verkuijl and W. Mwangi, 1999. Farmers sources of wheat seed and wheat seed management in wolmera woreda ethiopia. Proceedings of the 10th Regional Wheat Workshop for Eastern Central and Southern Africa, September 14-18, 1999, University of Stellenbosch South Africa, pp: 63-70.
4: Chastain, T.G., K.J. Ward and D.J. Wysocki, 1995. Stand establishment responses of soft white winter wheat to seedbed residue and seed size. Crop Sci., 35: 213-218.
Direct Link |
5: Douglas, C.L. Jr., D.E. Wilkins and D.B. Churchill, 1994. Tillage seed size and seed density effects on performance of soft white winter wheat. Agron. J., 86: 707- 711.
Direct Link |
6: Karababa, E., Y. Coskuner, G. Karatopak, N. Dincer, R. Ercan and H. Ekiz, 2000. Yield and quality characteristics of bread wheat cultivars in the cukurova region. Proceedings of the Orta Anadolu da Hububat Tarmnn Sorunlar Ve Cozum Yollar Sempozyumu, April 24-28, 2000, Konya, Turkey, pp: 8-11.
7: Minfal, 2003. Ministry for Food Agriculture and Livestock Agricultural Statistics of Pakistan 2002- 2003. Government of Pakistan, Islamabad.
8: Newman, P.R. and L.E. Moser, 1988. Grass seedling emergence morphology and establishment as affected by planting depth. Agron. J., 80: 383-387.
Direct Link |
9: Podlaski, S. and Z. Wyszkowska, 1994. Technical and physiological ways of improving seed vigour and increasing grain yield of winter wheat cv liwilla i laboratory estimation of seed vigour katedra hodowli roslin i nasiennictwa sggw warsaw poland. Roczniki Nauk Rolniczych. Seria Produkcja Roslinna, 110: 3-4.
10: Salopelto, J. and J. Peltonen, 1995. Impact of seed vigour on the grain yield of spring wheat under short and northern growing season. Acta Agric. Scandinavica. Soil Plant Sci., 45: 57-62.
11: Shah, Z., J.K. Khattak and R. Ali, 1993. Fate of fertilizer nitrogen applied to soil and its effect on maize. Sarhad J. Agric., 9: 435-445.
12: Stanelle, J.R., R.L. Vanderlip, L.A. Burchett and J.P. Shroyer, 1988. Kansas wheat seed a comparison of the quality of wheat seed planted in 1973 and 1984. J. Applied Seed Prod., 6: 62-67.
13: Stanton, M.L., 1985. Seed size and emergence time within a stand of wild radish (Raphanus raphanistrum L.): The establishment of a fitness hierarchy. Oecologia, 67: 524-531.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
14: Zofajova, A. and M. Uzik, 1996. Variability of selected yield formation traits of winter wheat variety Ilona in the first reproduction certified seed. Vedecke Prace Vyskumneho Ustavu Rastlinnej Vyroby v Piest'any, 28: 117-123.