Aggressiveness of Certain Fusarium graminearum Isolates on Wheat Seedlings and Relation with their Trichothecene Production
M.I. Eraky Amal
Fusarium fungi, including F. graminearum, cause seedling blight, foot rot and head blight diseases in wheat resulting in yield loss. Trichothecene mycotoxins are a group of toxic fungal secondary metabolites. This group of toxins is found associated with Fusarium diseases in wheat in numerous countries worldwide. Five isolates of F. graminearum were examined for their degree of disease severity (virulence) and trichothecene production on Sakha 69 wheat cultivar. In greenhouse experiments, following soil infestation all isolates caused pre and post-emergence death of wheat seedlings. Dry weight of infected seedlings was reduced as compared with uninoculated control seedlings. The F. graminearum isolates resulted in varying degree of disease severities in seedlings. All tested isolates caused seedling blight symptoms. However, they differed in their degree of pathogenicity. The reaction of wheat cultivars against seedling blight varied. While cv. Sakha 69 was the most susceptible (35.22%), cv. Giza 164 exhibited the highest level of resistance (14.61%) and cv. Giza 168 showed a moderate degree of resistance (23.17%). The F. graminearum isolates were examined with regard to possible relation between seedling blight severity and trichothecene production. The trichothecenes contents were detected by using gas chromatography equipped with an Electron Capture Detector (GC-ECD). The amount of trichothecenes produced by the various isolates on autoclaved oat grains ranged from 1393-57081 μg kg-1 ground grain. All isolates produced trichothecene in vitro but differed significantly in their level of production. The highest amounts of total trichothecene were detected in grains inoculated with isolate Fg 4.3 (57081 μg kg-1 ground grain) while grains inoculated with isolate Fg 33 and 18.7 had the lowest amounts of total trichothecenes. There was a close relationship between the degree of disease severity and trichothecene concentration.
Received: February 08, 2011;
Accepted: March 26, 2011;
Published: May 06, 2011
Wheat is one of the most important feeding crops in Egypt and many other countries
in the world. It is primarily grown as a food crop but the straw is also used
for industrial products as feed for livestock. Wheat is subjected to relatively
large number of diseases during its growing seasons which attack all plant parts
causing serious losses in crop productivity (Bakr, 1997).
Fusarium graminearum Schwabe (teleomorph Gibberella zea (Schwein.)
Petch) has received an overwhelming attention over time. The reason attributed
to this attention is that F. graminearum has been found to be the most
dominant pathogen in many wheat growing areas (McMullen
et al., 1997; Gilbert and Tekauz, 2000).
It survives in soil and is seed-transmitted, it may causes reduction of germination
through seed decay and seedling blight.
Variation in virulence among the F. graminearum isolates has been reported
(Carter et al., 2000; Walker
et al., 2001; Wanyoike, 2002). The physiological
factors leading to different virulence levels among isolates are still unclear
although synthesis and secretion of cell wall regarding enzymes as well as the
production of mycotoxins have been assumed to play an important role (Desjardins
and Hohn, 1997).
Trichothecene mycotoxins are a group of toxic fungal secondary metabolites
characterized by a sesquiterpenoid structure with a double bound at the C-9/C-10
position and an epoxide ring at the C-12/C-13 position. Trichothecene derivatives,
such as deoxynivalenol (DON), 3-acetyldeoxynivalenol (3-ADON), 15- acetyldeoxynivalenol
(15-ADON), nivalenol (NIV), T-2 toxin and HT-2 toxin were found associated with
Fusarium diseases in wheat in numerous countries worldwide. It is reported
that a trichothecene deficient F. graminearum isolate generated by gene
disruption was pathogenic on wheat and rye but was less pathogenic than the
wild-type isolate (Proctor et al., 1995; Riungu
et al., 2008). These findings indicate that DON formation is not
required for pathogenicity but may play a role in the virulence of F. graminearum.
Furthermore, isolates of F. graminearum have been isolated which did
not form DON although they possessed some degree of virulence (Szecsi
and Bartok, 1995; Wanyoike, 2002). The objectives
of this study were to investigate the relationship or interactions between virulence
and trichothecene production of the fungal isolates.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Source of fungal isolates: Five isolates of F. graminearum (Table
1) were obtained from the culture collection at the Institute of Phytomedicine,
University of Hohenheim, Germany. Three of the isolates previously tested by
Asran and Buchenauer (2003) and other two isolates were
previously tested by Wanyoike (2002). The isolates had
been maintained in soil cultures at 4°C and reactivated by growing them
on PDA medium.
Pathogenicity tests under greenhouse conditions: Pathogenicity testes of certain F. graminearium isolates were carried out during 2008-2009 wheat growing seasons in greenhouse. For each isolate, three agar discs grown with mycelium were cut using a cork borer and transferred to 50 mL of sterilized liquid potato dextrose medium in 300 mL Erlenmeyer flasks. The inoculated flasks were then incubated for 7 days at 20°C on a rotary shaker at 200 rpm. Four hundred grams of oat grain with 200 mL water were placed in 1L milk glass bottles. The bottles with the grain were autoclaved three times every 24 h for each one h at 121°C and 1.2 bar., Five milliliter of the conidial suspension from the liquid culture containing approximately 2.5x105 spore mL-1 were added to the grain of each bottle and mixed under sterilized conditions and the bottles were incubated at 20°C for 3 weeks. The bottles were shacked every two days to ensure equal distribution of inoculum.
Inoculum for each isolate was mixed thoroughly with sterilized clay soil at
the rate of 3% soil weight then placed in sterilized pots (25 cm in diameter).
Sterilization of pots and soil was carried out using 5% formalin solution (30
days before planting date). Non infested soil mixed with 3% sterilized oat grains
was used as control. Fifteen surface disinfested wheat grains (cv. Sakha 69)
were sown in each pot. Grains were disinfested by dipping in 1% sodium hypochlorite
for 2 min. Plants were irrigated as necessary. Four replicates were used for
each treatment. During the experimental period until 45 days after sowing, the
percentage of germinated seeds, ratio of seedlings that died after germination
as well as seedling blight index and dry weight of seedlings of each isolate
treatment were determined. The experiment was carried out twice. The different
pathogenic effects of fungal isolates on the wheat cv. Sakha 69 were analyzed
by ANOVA (LSD range test after analysis) (Gomez and Gomez,
Calculation of disease index: Disease severity was evaluated using the
scale described by Liu et al. (1995) ranging
from 0 to 5 as follows: 0 = 0%; 1= 1t o 25 %; 2 = 26 to 50%; 3 = 51 to 75%;
4 = 76 to 100% seedling blight and 5 = whole seedling dead. The data were converted
to disease index using the following formula:
where, A, B, C, D, E and F are the No. of plants corresponding to the numerical
grade 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5, respectively and 5T is the total No. of plants (T)
multiplied by the maximum disease grade 5.
Reaction of some wheat cultivars to F. graminearum isolates under greenhouse conditions: Wheat cultivars Sakha 69, Giza 164 and Giza 168 were examined for their resistance to the five F. graminearum isolates at wheat growing season of 2008-2009. The wheat cultivars were sown in the pots containing infested soil for each F. graminearum isolate as described in the pathogenicity experiments. Seedling blight was determined using a scale rating from 1 to 5 as mentioned above. Experimental design was a split-plot with 4 replicates of each treatment. Cultivars were in the main plots and isolates were in the subplots. The experiment was carried out twice. The different pathogenic effects of fungal isolates on all tested wheat cultivars were analyzed by ANOVA (LSD range test after analysis).
Production of trichothecene mycotoxins by various F. graminearum
isolates: In vitro production of trichothecene was determined by
culturing the F. graminearum isolates on oat seeds. Oat seeds were inoculated
and incubated as previously described before. Each isolate consisted of three
replicates and they were prepared along with two non-inoculated flasks which
served as control. The dried infected oat grains were ground, extracted and
analyzed for trichothecene content using Gas Chromatography Equipped with an
Electron Capture Detector (GC-ECD) as described by Walker
and Meier (1998) and Asran and Buchenauer (2003).
Statistical analysis: Data were subjected to statistical analysis using
analysis of variance and means were compared using LSD range test as described
by Gomez and Gomez (1984).
Pathogenicity of different F. graminearum isolates on wheat seedling of cv. Sakha 69 under greenhouse conditions: Five F. graminearum isolates were examined for their pathogenicity on wheat seedlings of cv. Sakha 69 under greenhouse conditions. Data in Table 2 shows that all isolates were pathogenic on cv. Sakha 69. In the control treatment, neither emergency of seeds nor disease symptoms in the seedlings were observed which indicated that the sterilization procedure resulted in fungus-free seed and soil. Inoculation of soil with F. graminearum isolates reduced emergence of germlings and caused post-emergence seedling death in different extents. While isolate Fg 33 did not significantly reduced emergence of seeds, the other isolates diminished significantly reduced emergence compared with the uninoculated control.
Post-emergence death of seedlings caused by the different F. graminearum
isolates varied considerably. Isolate Fg 33 caused post-emergence death of seedlings
but was not significantly different from uninoculated control while the other
isolates caused significant differences in post-emergence seedling death. The
highest post-emergence seedling death was exhibited by isolates 4.3, 20.3 and
Fg 27 and then isolates Fg 18.7. Compared with the uninoculated control seedlings,
inoculation with the different F. graminearum isolates resulted in drastically
dry weights of the surviving wheat seedlings.
||Pathogenicity of various F. graminearum isolates on
wheat seedlings cv. Sakha 69 under greenhouse conditions
Virulence of F. graminearum isolates on wheat using seedling blight rating: Figure 1 show that all tested isolates caused seedling blight disease. The tested F. graminearum isolates differed significantly in causing seedling blight symptoms in seedling wheat. The disease index of the inoculated variants ranged from 21 to 88%. The most virulent isolates were Fg 4.3, 27.4 and 20.3 followed by Fg 18.7 while the isolate Fg 33 exhibited the lowest disease index percent.
Reaction of certin wheat cultivars to seedling blight disease under greenhouse conditions: Table 3 reveal that the F. graminearum isolates varied in their seedling blight severity. The isolates Fg 4.3 and 27.4 caused the most severe disease index followed by Fg 20.3 and 18.7. The isolate Fg 33 has the lowest virulence.
The three wheat cultivars reacted differently to the infection by F. graminearum
isolates. The cv. Sakha 69 was the most susceptible one (35.22%). While cv.
Giza 168 showed a moderate degree of susceptibility (23.17%), the cultivar Giza
164 exhibited significant lower seedling blight symptoms (14.61 %).
||Seedling blight caused by various F. graminearum isolates
on the wheat cv. Sakha 69 under greenhouse conditions
||Disease index of seedling blight in some wheat cultivars after
inoculation by several F. graminearum isolates
|*Disease severity%, LSD (p = 0.05), Isolates (I) = 9.88, Cultivars
(C) = 8.66, Interaction (IxC) = 20.11
In vitro trichothecene contents in inoculated oat grains: The amount of trichothecenes produced by the various isolates on autoclaved oat grains ranged from 1393-57081 μg kg-1 ground grain (Table 4). All isolates produced trichothecenes in vitro but differed significantly in their level of production. DON was the principle trichothecene produced by all isolates (range 1200-56338 μg kg-1 ground grain). NIV was detected in trace amounts in grains infected by the tested isolates (range 85-102 μg kg-1 ground grain). 15-A DON was found in grains infected by all tested isolates except Fg 18.7 isolate. 3-A DON was detected only in grains infected by Fg 4.3 and Fg 27.4. The highest amounts of total trichothecenes were detected in grains inoculated with isolate Fg 4.3 (57081 μg kg-1 ground grain) while grains inoculated with isolate Fg 33 and 18.7 had the lowest amounts of total trichothecenes. The other isolates showed intermediate trichothecene production.
Figure 2 also show that grain inoculated by isolate Fg 4.3
the highest disease severity (88 %) and highest concentration of trichothecene
(57081 μg kg-1 ground grain) were detected. The isolates Fg
18.7 and 33 the lowest disease severity and lowest concentrations of trichothecenes
1717 and 1393 μg kg-1 ground grain, respectively) were detected.
||Trichothecene contents (μg kg-1 ground grain)
in oat grain after inoculation with several F. graminearum isolates
|*Nivalinol, **Deoxynivalinol-not detectable, Means followed
by the same letter in a column are not statistically different by LSD test
||Relationship between wheat seedling blight disease index in
greenhouse and the trichothecene levels in the inoculated oat grain in
The results in Fig. 2 suggest relationship between wheat
seedling blight disease severity and the trichothecene levels in the inoculated
For better understanding of pathogenicity and virulence mechanisms of F.
graminearum involved in seedling blight disease of wheat pre and post-emergence
as well as the severity of wheat seedling blight caused by the different isolates
and the capability of the isolates to produce trichothecene mycotoxins were
investigated. The isolates of F. graminearum used in this study were
found to be highly variable in their pathogenicity towards wheat. The results
of this investigation revealed that all isolates caused pre-and post-emergence
death of wheat seedlings. The isolates however, varied considerably in seedling
blight disease severity. Dry weight of infected seedlings was markedly reduced
compared with uninoculated control seedlings. It has been known over a long
time that the virulence of F. graminearum isolates is genetically variable
(Mesterhazy, 1978; Miedaner and
Schilling, 1996; Carter et al., 2000; Walker
et al., 2001; Wanyoike, 2002). The alternating
lifecycle of F. graminearum with a parasitic and saprophytic phase in
crop rotations with a high percentage of cereals a long with a large genetic
diversity have been linked to this large variation in virulence (Miedaner
et al., 2000). Variation in virulence of F. graminearum isolates
has also been reported on maize (Carter et al., 2000;
Asran and Buchenauer, 2003) and on wheat and rice (Carter
et al., 2000). The wheat cultivars responded differently to the F.
graminearum isolates. The cultivar Sakha 69 was the most susceptible one.
While cv. Giza 168 showed a moderate of susceptibility, the cv. Giza 164 exhibited
significant lower seedling symptoms. These results are partially in agreement
with those reported by Eraky (1993) and Allam
F. graminearum isolates can produce trichothecenes such as NIV, DON,
15-A DON and 3-A DON (Wanyoike, 2002; Asran
and Buchenauer, 2003). Results from the analysis of the trichothecenes in
vitro studies show that F. graminearum isolates produced trichothecenes
at varying amounts. The principal trichothecene produced by all isolates was
DON. Isolates were clearly different on the basis of their ability to produce
trichothecenes. Two isolates (Fg 4.3 and 27.4) consistently produced high trichothecene
levels while others produced low levels. These results confirm previous findings
by other authors that the abilities of F. graminearum isolates to produce
trichothecenes varied considerably (Mesterhazy et al.,
1999; Miedaner et al., 2000; Wanyoike,
2002; Asran and Buchenauer, 2003). On the other
hand, some authors suggested that DON formation is not required for pathogenicity;
it may be due to gene structure (Cumagun et al.,
2007). The results of this investigation indicate that there is a relation
between disease severity caused by the F. graminearum isolates and the
trichothecenes concentrations (Fig. 2). Trichothecenes production
therefore, may be regarded as an essential factor of virulence for spreading
of F. graminearum in wheat seedlings. Similar results have been reported
by Wanyoike (2002) testing trichothecene- producing and
non- producing isolates of F. graminearum for their ability to cause
head blight in wheat. Less virulent isolates produced low amounts of trichothecenes.
These results showed that these mycotoxins play a vital role in the virulence
mechanism of F. graminearum. Significant positive relationships have
also been demonstrated between head blight severity and trichothecenes content
of wheat caused by F. = graminearum (Desjardins
et al., 1996; Wanyoike, 2002) and also demonstrated
between seedling blight of corn (Asran and Buchenauer, 2003).
It could be concluded that trichothecene contents, especially DON derivatives are playing the most important role in pathogenesis of F. graminearume.
1: Allam, A.D., 1994. Reaction of some wheat cultivars to root rot disease caused by Cochliobolus sativus. Assiut. J. Agric. Sci., 25: 249-263.
2: Asran, M.R. and H. Buchenauer, 2003. Pathogenicity of Fusarium graminearum isolates on maize (Zea mays L.) cultivars and relation with deoxynivalinol and ergosterol contents. J. Plant Diseases Protect., 110: 209-219.
Direct Link |
3: Bakr, D.W., 1997. Studies on some root rots of wheat. M.Sc. Thesis, Faculty Agriculture Assiut University, Assiut, Egypt.
4: Carter, J.P., H.N. Rezanoor, A.E. Desjardins and P. Nicholson, 2000. Variation in Fusarium graminearum isolates from Nepal associated with their host of origin. Plant Pathol., 49: 452-460.
5: Cumagun, C.J.R., H.P. Parzies and T. Miedaner, 2007. Genetic variation and segregation of DNA polymorphisms in Gibberella zeae detected with AFLP and RAPD markers. Asian J. Plant Sci., 6: 1174-1181.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
6: Desjardins, A.E. and T.M. Hohn, 1997. Mycotoxins in plant pathogenesis. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact., 10: 147-152.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
7: Desjardins, A.E., R.H. Proctor, G. Bai, S.P. Mccormick, G. Shaner, G. Buechley and I.M. Hohn, 1996. Reduced virulence of trichotheceneBnonproducing mutant of Gibberella Zeae in wheat field tests. Mol. Plant Microbe Interact., 9: 775-781.
8: Eraky, A.M.I., 1993. Studies on certain disease of wheat caused by seed-borne fungi in Upper Egypt. M.Sc. Thesis, Faculty Agriculture Assiut University, Assiut, Egypt.
9: Gilbert, J. and A. Tekauz, 2000. Review: Recent developments in research on Fusarium head blight of wheat in Canada. Can. J. Plant Pathol., 22: 1-8.
Direct Link |
10: Gomez, K.A. and A.A. Gomez, 1984. Statistical Procedures for Agriculture Research. 2nd Edn., John Wiley and Sons Inc., New York, USA., Pages: 680
11: Liu, L., J.W. Kloepper and S. Tuzun, 1995. Introduction of systemic resistance in cucumber against Fusarium wilt by plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria. Phytopathology, 85: 695-698.
Direct Link |
12: McMullen, M., R. Jones and D. Gallenberg, 1997. Scab of wheat and barley: A re-emerging disease of devastating impact. Plant Dis., 81: 1340-1348.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
13: Mesterhazy, A., 1978. Comparative analysis of artificial inoculation methods with Fusarium spp. on winter wheat varieties. J. Phytopathol., 93: 12-25.
14: Mesterhazy, A., T. Bartok, C.G. Miropcha and R. Komoroczy, 1999. Nature of wheat resistance to Fusarium head blight and the role of deoxynivalenol for breed. Plant Breed., 118: 97-110.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
15: Miedaner, T. and A.G. Schilling, 1996. Genetic variation of aggressiveness in individual field populations of Fusarium graminearum and Fusarium culmorum tested on young plants of winter rye. Eur. J. Plant Pathol., 102: 823-830.
Direct Link |
16: Miedaner, T., C. Reinbrecht and A.G. Schilling, 2000. Association among aggressiveness, fungal colonization and mycotoxin production of 26 isolates of Fusarium graminearum in winter rye head blight. Zeitschrift fur Pflanzenkrankheiten Pflanzenschultz, 107: 124-134.
Direct Link |
17: Proctor, R.H., T.M. Hohn and S.P. McCormick, 1995. Reduced virulence of Gibberella zeae caused by disruption of a trichothecene toxin biosynthetic gene. Mol. Plant Microbiol. Int., 8: 593-601.
PubMed | Direct Link |
18: Riungu, G.M., J.W. Muthomi, R.D. Narla, J.M. Wagacha and J.K. Gathumbi, 2008. Management of Fusarium head blight of wheat and deoxynivalenol accumulation using antagonistic microorganisms. Plant Pathol. J., 7: 13-19.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
19: Szecsi, A. and T. Bartok, 1995. Trichothecene chemotypes of Fusarium graminearum isolated from corn in Hungary. Mycotoxin Res., 11: 85-92.
20: Walker, F. and B. Meier, 1998. Determination of Fusarium mycotoxins nivalenol, deoxynivalenol, 3-acetyldeoxynivalenol and 15-O-acetyl-4-deoxynivalenol in contaminated whole wheat flour by liquid chromatography with diode array detection and gas chromatography with electron capture detection. J. AOAC Int., 81: 741-748.
Direct Link |
21: Walker, S.L., S. Leath, W.M. Hagler and J.P. Murphy, 2001. Variation among isolates of Fusarium graminearum associated with fusarium head blight in North Carolina. Plant Dis., 85: 404-410.
Direct Link |
22: Wanyoike, M.W., 2002. Investigation on the pathogenicity of Fusarium graminearum, the cause of head blight in wheat. Ph.D. Thesis, University Hohenheim, Stuttgart, Germany.