Use of Neem Extract in Controlling Root-knot Nematode (Meloidogyne javanica) of Sweet-gourd
M.H. Rashid ,
M. Nazim Uddin ,
M.S. Hossain ,
Extract of neem (Azadirachta indica.L) seed was used to control the root knot nematode Meloidogyne javanica of sweet gourd. Extract of neem seed was found to be leathal to the juvenile of M. javanica compared to the extracts of bark and leaf of neem. Pot experiment with standard `S` concentration of all the extracts both in side drench and root-dipping methods appeared to give significant suppression in root galling, L2 and L3 population of the nematode. Identical response among the treatments with respect of plant growth characters was attributed to the synthesis of less toxic metabolites in the immature neem seeds used in the study. Positive correlation between gall number and eggmass indicated higher activity of the nematode allowing more adult females to develop with the production of increased number of eggmasses.
Sweet-gourd (Cucurbita moschata Duchesne) is a vitamin A rich, popular, year-round but specially summer vegetable in Bangladesh. The production of cucurbits in different years is 7.78 to 9.66% of total vegetables production in Bangladesh (Meah, 1994). Though the popularity of sweet-gourd is increasing quite rapidly but its production remain limited due to many diseases caused by fungi, bacteria, virus and several species of nematodes especially root-knot (M. javanica). The common species of root-knot nematodes in Bangladesh are M. javanica, M. incognita and M. graminicola (Timm and Ameen, 1966; Mian, 1986). Page (1979) reported that 36 different crops that were sampled in different districts of Bangladesh, half of them were found susceptible to root knot nematodes. The nematode attack different crops including the vegetable in the Jessore region where Meloidogyne spp. occurs predominantly. The root-knot disease is of economic importance to the growers of this country as the loss is increased becouse root-knot nematode predisposes the plants by other pathogenes (Chester, 1950). But no specific control measures have yet been adopted in Bangladesh to save sweet-gourd and other common vegetables from the root-knot disease. Chemical control of root knot is costly and hazardous to agro-ecosystem and environment.
Many plant extracts have been reported to have nematicidal properties (Irshad et al., 1982 and Stephan et al., 1989). Neem is being used by the farmers in various ways in Sri Lanka (Ganesalingam, 1986). Neem seed kernel extracts have been effectively used to control field crop pests, in extension experimental plots as well as in fields of vegetable growers (Fagoone, 1986). Seed, bark and leaf of neem are easily available and cheap in this country. Since, it is not feasible to use expensive as well as harmful chemicals for the control of nemic diseases in Bangladesh, due to economic consideration. It was thought worthwhile to study the effect of certain less extensive materials such as indigenous plant extracts of neem against plant parasitic nematodes. The present research programme was undertaken to see the effect of extract of neem seed, bark and leaf on the incidence of root-knot of sweet-gourd caused by Meloidogyne javanica.
Materials and Methods
The experiment was conducted both in the laboratory and glass house of the Department of Plant Pathology, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh. The efficacy of different concentrated solutions of neem seed, bark and leaf extract in reducing the incidence of root-knot of sweet-gourd was evaluated in two individual sets of pot experiments. One set was conducted with treatments applied as side dressing and soil drench after 5 days of inoculation and other set was conducted with seedlings root-dipping in liquid treatments defore 2 days of inoculation. Sand, sandy loam soil and well-decomposed cowdung (2:2:1) mixed and sterilized with formaldehyde solution at the rate of 30% and covered by polyethene for 72 h without disturbance. After 72 h the polyethene was removed and the soils were air-dried for 48 h in order to remove toxic gasses of formaldehyde. Earthen pot was filled with 5kg sterilized and dried soil. Experiment was set up in the glass house. One seedling was planted in each pot. There were seven treatments with 5 replications i.e. T1 = control, T2 = neem seed extract (side drench), T3 = neem seed extract (root dipping at the time of transplanting), T4 = neem bark extract (side branch), T5 = neem bark extract (root-dipping) T6 = neem leaf extract (side drench) and T7 = neem leaf extract (root-dipping). Different growth characters of plants, gall incidence and the growth stages of the nematode within the treated as well as treated plants were studied.
Preparation of solution of neem extract for juvenile mortality test
The effect of four concentrated extracts of neem seed, bark and leaf along
with a control (distilled water) were taken for the mortality test of juveniles
of M. javanica in the laboratory. Extracts of neem seed (unripe), bark
and leaf were prepared after pressing with a pestle and mortar, separately.
Concentrated seed extract (25g) bark extract (25g) and leaf extract (25g) of
neem as pastes were treated as standard(s). Subsequent dilutions of S/2, S/10
and S/100 were also prepared by adding distilled water in 6 cm diameter petridishes,
separately. Petridish containing only distilled water served as control and
each type of dilution as treatment was also replicated three times.
Counting of juveniles in the mortality test
Dead and surviving nematodes were counted after 12, 24, 48, 72 and 96 h
with the help of laboratory counter and mean percent mortality was calculated
ignoring the fraction of the juvenile numbers. Mortality of the juveniles was
assessed by touching the juveniles with a fine needle.
Preparation of inoculum and inoculation
Eggmasses were collected from the roots of eggplant, which were previously
inoculated individually with a single eggmass of M. javanica. For inoculation,
10 reddish brown mature eggmass were placed in each pot around the standing
plant in 2 holes (2.5 cm deep) five eggmass in each side of the plant.
Preparation of seed, bark and leaf extracts of neem
Extract of neem seed, bark and leaf were prepared from the fresh green seed,
bark and leaf with help of a blender. A quantity of 25 g of each macerated seed,
bark and leaf was mixed with 100 ml distilled water. Each type of the paste
was then filtered and all the filtrates were collected separately for use as
extracts in the pot experiments.
Application of extracts of neem seed, bark and leaf
Standard extracts of neem seed, neem bark and leaf were applied in two following
method one as side drench and the other as root dipping. The extracts were used
separately in 15 pots as side drench, five pots for each treatment. Five-milliliter
extract was applied to each plant. The treatment was repeated for three times
during the experimental period at ten days interval. In the other method of
application, 15 seedlings of 12 days old were uprooted and roots of the seedlings
were dipped in the extracts of neem seed, bark and leaf for 12 h from 6 a.m.
to 6 p.m. in a shady place. Five seedlings were dipped into each extract and
transplanted to five respective pots. Hence, a total number of 15 seedlings
were used in root-dipping method.
After 60 days of inoculation, plants were uprooted carefully to study the length of shoot, fresh weight of shoot, length of root, fresh weight of root, Number of galls/g fresh root, Number of eggmasses/g fresh root and number of adult male or female nematode, eggmass, L2, L3 and L4 stages in ten well developed galls per treatment.
Counting of galls
After washing, the roots were preserved in 5% formalin solution. The roots
were cut into small pieces of 1 cm size and randomly 1g of root was taken from
the bulk to count the number of galls formed.
Staining of galled-roots
To stain the galled-roots the following steps were followed: 1.Liquied phenol
(500 ml), glycerine (100 ml) and distilled water (500 ml) were poured orderly
into a two liter capacity conical flask and shaken thoroughly for mixing them
well. Then cotton-blue was added to the content of the beaker to such an amount
that turned the solution into the desired blue colour. 2. A quantity of 150-175
ml prepared lactophenol cotton-blue solution was taken in a beaker. 3. The beaker
containing 150-175 ml lactophenol cotton-blue solution was heated to the boiling
point. 4. A number of 10 galls per treatment was taken in a special type of
cloth bag. At the time of boiling of the liquid of the beaker, the cloth bag
containing galls was rinsed for about 1 minute. Then the bag was lifted from
the beaker with galls and washed under gentle running tap water to remove excess
blue colour. 5. Fresh lactophenol was poured onto petridishes, six for each
set, where galls were retained for 15 days for destining. 6. Ten galls from
each treatment were crushed one after another with fine pointed needle and counted
the number of adult male or female, eggmass, L2, L3 and
L4 stages, if any, under stereobimocular microscope. Data were analysed
statistically to find out the level of significance.
Effect of extracts of seed, bark and leaf of neem on juvenile mortality
of M. javanica
In the mortality test, neem seed extract was found to be more toxic
to the juveniles followed by neem leaf extract (Table 1).
Standard concentration (S) of all extracts caused 100% mortality within 12 h.
In case of bark extract a mortality range of 80-100, 82-100, 84-100, 85-100
and 90-100% observed among the tested solutions of S/2 after 12, 24, 48, 72
and 96 h, respectively between neem bark and seed. The juvenile mortality was
found to increase with the increase of concentration and exposure period (Table
1). Similarly a mortality range 50-80, 52-80, 55-80, 58-80 and 60-95% were
recorded among the S/10 solutions after 12, 24, 48, 72 and 96 h, respectively
between neem bark and seed. Incase of S/100 solution, it ranged from 30-62%,
32-65%, 35-70%, 40-75% and 48-80% after 12, 24, 48 and 96 h, respectively. The
results indicated that neem seed extract gave more toxic on the L2
Effect of extracts of seed, bark and leaf of neem on plant growth, galling
and development of nematodes
After 60 days of inoculation, effect of treatments was found to be significant
on the different growth parameters, galling incidence and stages of nematode
The highest length of shoot and root was observed 546.6 cm and 55.0 cm, respectively and in case of neem seed extract as side drench white it was lowest 276 cm and 21.6 cm, respectively in control plots (Table 2). The highest and lowest fresh weight of shoot and root was observed 222.8 to 129.0g and 10.0 to 4.80g, respectively. Number of galls/g of root and number of eggmass/root was recorded 30.20 to 8.0 and 190.0 to 100.0 respectively (Table 2).
The control treatment was noted with the highest significant number 190.0 of eggmasses. This was followed by T4 having 150.0 eggmasses. The rest treatments are identical in response.
Effect on the growth stages of M. javanica
In case of number of adult female, eggmass L2 stage, L3
stage and L4 stage on the growth stages of M. javanica all
treatments caused significant reduction in population of adult females. The
highest effect was noted with T7 followed by T3, T5,
T6, T4 and T2 all treatments except T1
gave significant decrease in number of eggmass.
|| Effect of extracts of seed, bark and leaf of neem on juvenile
mortality of M. juvanica
|Each value is an average of 3 replications; S = standard solution
|| Effect of extracts of seed, bark and leaf of neem on the
growth and galling incidence of sweet-gourd inoculated with M. javanica
|Each value is an average of five replications. In a column,
values having same letters do not differ significantly at P = 0.01 level
|| Effect of extract of neem seed, bark and leaf on the population
of root-knot nematode (M. javanica) in sweet-gourd
|Each value is an average of ten replications. In a column,
values having same letters do not differ significantly at P = 0.01 level
Treatment T1 was found to give the highest significant number 17.30
of L2 stage, L3 stage (10.30) and L4 stage
(8.80) and lowest significant and identical response was found with the rest
treatments. Overall, the treatment effect was found to be statistically identical
in responses (Table 3).
In the juvenile mortality test with the extracts of neem seed, bark and leaf, it was revealed that 100% mortality started within 12 h at concentration S. Other than neem bark extract, almost similar trend of mortality was observed with S/2 concentration. At concentration S/10 of neem seed extract with 80-95% mortality in the study periods proved its superiority over the other extracts. Similarly, neem seed extract was found to be more lethal to the juveniles even at S/100 concentration. From the overall mortality test, it appeared that the extracts of neem seed, bark and leaf even at S/100 concentration were found to be toxic to the nematode (Table 1). While studying the antifeedant efficacy of the extracts of seed kernel, seed coat and fallen leaves of neem against desert locust Singh (1986) also observed that neem kernel extracts were found most active, seed coat extracts followed and fallen leaf extracts were last effective. Seed kernel extract yielded more extract than fallen leaves or seed coat.
In the pot experiment with `S' concentration of all the extracts were found to give statistically identical response in plant growth characters like length of shoot and root, fresh weight of shoot and root compared to the control treatment (Table 2 and 3). Similarly, no significant effect was observed on the development of eggmass, adult female and L4 population of the nematode (Table 2 and 3). But the significant effect was observed with the all extracts of neem in both the methods of application in respect of number of galls per g of root and L2 and L3 populations of the nematodes compared to the non-treated control treatment (Table 2 and 3).
The increased galling incidence with the non-treated control treatment T1 (Table 2) clearly indicated that extracts of neem seed, bark and leaf were effective in suppressing the nematodes activity, but their effect could not sufficiently act upon plant nematode physiology as evident with non-significant responses in plant growth characters and reduction of adult females which ultimately resulted in the non significant development of eggmasses and L4 population. Incase of L2 and L3 populations, significant responses among the treatments with neem extracts compared to the control one revealed that the extracts were found to be effective in suppressing their development. But onward development to L4 and adult females as well as eggmass their action was found to be receded.
While working with the leaf extract of margosa or marigold, Hussain et al. (1984) found that the development of Meloidogyne incognita was considerably reduced in root-dip treatment with extract as compared to treatment with piperazine citrate, chenopodium oil and ground-nut cake. They further observed that treatments with half-standard concentration S/2 of Artemiria maritina were better for plant growth, but for disease control, standard concentration `S' was more effective. Their results corroborate with out findings. Sharma et al. (1985) used powders of 9 plants to pot experiment. They observed that with increase of time (after 45 days of application) there was decline in population. Alam (1987) similarly reported that chopped plant leaves when incorporated into naturally infested soil effectively suppressed [population of plant parasitic nematodes in tomato cv. marglobe. Sartaj Ali et al. (1986) observed that the different standard solutions of leaf extract of lemon grass (Cymbopega flexuosus) were found to be highly toxic to all the tested nematodes, Meloidogyne incognita, Rotylenchulus reinformis, Tylenchorhynchus indicus.
Goswami and Vijaylakshmi (1986) reported that the number of galls per g of root was reduced by 9 different plant extracts especially with Euclipta alba, Shorea rubuta and Datura metal. Chabra et al. (1988) also noted that leaf extracts of Ricinus communis, Leucaena leucocephala, Populus deltoides, Azadirachta indica, Lantana camara and Eucalyptus hybrida were highly toxic to J2 of M. incognita. Leaf extracts of Ricinus communis was found the most toxic to M. incognita. The lower populations of L2 and L3 stages in our experiment with all the neem extracts clearly indicated its harmful effect on the nematodes.
As the existing practice of chemical control is too costly, particularly for poor farmers of Bangladesh, as well as its harmful effect responsible for air, soil and water pollution as stated by Alam (1987), the use of extracts of neem seed, bark and leaf have been found encouraging in the control of root-knot of sweet-gourd caused by Meloidogyne javanica. The present research was conducted with unripe (immature) neem seed. The difference in result with respect to the growth characters of plants as observed with neem seeds by other workers (Rossner and Zebitz, 1987, Siddiqui and Alam, 1987 and Pathak et al. (1988) might be due to use of immature neem seeds in the present study. It is quite obvious that mature seeds of neem synthesize more metabolic substances like azadirachtin and other closely related metabolites-vepaol, isovepaol and nimibidin which have been stated to be antifeedant and growth inhibitor of insects by Sankaram et al. (1986). Such synthesized metabolites in mature seeds of neem accumulate in more concentrate from and are likely to be more lethal to the plant pathogen including nematodes allowing better plant growth.
Alam, M.M., 1987. Pollution-free control of plant parasitic nematodes by soil amendment with plant wastes. Biol. Wastes, 22: 75-79.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Chabra, H.K., P.S. Grewal and A. Singh, 1988. Efficacy of some plant extracts on root-knot nematode (Meloidogyne incognita). J. Tree Sci., 7: 24-25.
Chester, K.S., 1950. Nature and prevention of plant disease. 2nd Ed., McGrow Hill Book Co. Ltd., New York, pp: 525.
Fagoone, I., 1986. Use of neem in vegetable crop protection. Proceedings of the 3rd International Neem Conference, July 10-15, 1986, Nairobi, Kenya, pp: 47-47.
Ganesalingam, V.K., 1986. The use of neem (Azadirachta indica) in Sri Lanka. Proceedings of the 3rd International Neem Conference, July 10-15, 1986, Nairobi, Kenya, pp: 46-46.
Goswami, B.K. and K. Vijaylakshmi, 1986. Effect of some indigenous plant materials and oil cake amended soil on the growth of tomato and root-knot nematode population. Ann. Agric. Res., 7: 363-366.
Hussain, S.I., R. Kumer, T. Khan and A. Titow, 1984. Effect of root-dip treatment of eggplant seedling with plant extracts, nematicides, oil cake extracts and anthelmintic drugs on plant growth and root-knot development. Pak. J. Nematol., 2: 79-83.
Mahmood, I., S.K. Saxena ad Zakiuddin, 1982. Effect of certain plant extracts on the mortality of Rotylenchulus reniformis, Linford and Oliveira, 1940 and Meloidogyne incognita (Kofoid and White, 1919) Chitwood 1949. Bangladesh J. Bot., 11: 154-157.
Direct Link |
Meah, K.M.M., 1994. Comparative efficacy of granular land liquid application carbofuran against rootknoot of bottle gourd. M.Sc. Thesis, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh, Bangladesh, pp: 1.
Mian, I.H., 1986. Plant parasitic nematodes associated with some crop species in Bangladesh. Bangladesh J. Plant Pathol., 2: 7-13.
Page, P.P., 1986. An Assessment of the Importance and Control of Plant Parasitic Nematodes of Vegetable Crops in Bangladesh. Bangladesh Agriculture Research Institute, Joydebpur, Gazipur, Bangladesh, pp: 35.
Pathak, A.K. B.C. Yadav and J.S. Brar, 1988. Water hyacinth and neem leaves for the control of root-knot nematodes (M. incognita) on brinjal. Plant Dis. Res., 3: 74-76.
Rossner, J. and C.P.W. Zebitz, 1987. Effect of neem products on nematodes and growth of tomato (Lycopercicon esculentum) plants. Proceedings of the 3rd International Neem Confersnce, (NC'87), Nairobi, Kenya, pp: 611-621.
Sankaram, A.V.B., M.M. Murthy, K. Bhaskaraiah, M. Subramanyam, N. Sultana, H.C. Sharma and K. Leuschner, 1986. Chemistry, biological activity and utilization of some promising neem extracts. Proceedings of the 3rd International Neem Conference, July 10-15, 1986, Nairobi, Kenya, pp: 22-22.
Sharma, C., P.C. Trivedi and B. Tiogi, 1985. Effect of green manuring on populations of M. incognita on muskmelon. Inter. Nematol. Network Newslett., 2: 7-9.
Siddiqui, M.A. and M.M. Alam, 1987. Efficacy of seed dressing with extracts of neem and persian lilak against Meloidogyne incognita and Rotylenchulus reniformis. Nematol. Mediterranea, 15: 399-403.
Singh, R.P., 1986. Comparison of antifeedant efficacy and extract yields of neem (Azadirachta indica A. Juss) ecotypes and parts of a neem tree. Proceedings of the 3rd International Neem Conference, July 10-15, 1986, Nairobi, Kenya, pp: 26-26.
Stephan, A., Zuhair and A. Al-Askari, 1989. Effect of Haplophyllum tuberculatum plant extracts on root knot nematode. Int. Network News, 6: 31-32.
Timm, R.W. and M. Ameen, 1960. Nema todes associated with commercial crops in East Pakistan. Agric. Pak., 11: 355-363.
Direct Link |