Subscribe Now Subscribe Today
Research Article

Nutritive and Biological Value of Mare’s Milk Ice Cream

Aigerim Akanova, Nabidulla Kikebayev, Kymbat Shaikenova, Zhanagul Seiitkazhy and Eleonora Okuskhanova
Facebook Twitter Digg Reddit Linkedin StumbleUpon E-mail

Background: Among milk products, ice cream is growing in popularity. Mare’s milk instead of cow’s milk can be used to make ice cream due to its low fat content and balanced amino acid, vitamin and mineral composition. Objective: The purpose of this study was to develop new methods of making ice cream and study the nutritive and biological value of mare’s milk-based ice cream. Materials and Methods: Amino acid and vitamin composition levels were quantified using the Shimadzu LC-20 Prominence liquid chromatography system equipped with fluorometric and spectrophotometric detectors. Mineral composition was detected by Inductively-Coupled Mass-Spectrometry (ICP-MS). Ice cream samples were produced in the following proportions: Sample 1, 100% mare’s milk (MM-100); sample 2, 40% MM and 60% cow’s milk (MM-40); sample 3, 30% MM and 70% cow’s milk (MM-30). Results: The fat contents of MM-100, MM-40 and MM-30 were 2.1, 7.3 and 8.5%, respectively. The carbohydrate content decreased from 26.0 g in MM-100 to 22.7 g in MM-40 and to 21.2 g in MM-30. Protein content of MM-100 was slightly lower than those of the MM-40 and MM-30 ice creams; however, no differences were found among the three types of ice creams in ash content. Using both mare’s and cow’s milk in ice cream mixtures resulted in increased mineral content in MM-40 and MM-30 in comparison with MM-100. Thus, combination of mare’s and cow’s milk enriched the ice cream with methionine, glycine, histidine, proline, threonine and valine. Conclusion: These findings suggest a beneficial role of mare’s milk in making ice cream with low-fat content.

Related Articles in ASCI
Similar Articles in this Journal
Search in Google Scholar
View Citation
Report Citation

  How to cite this article:

Aigerim Akanova, Nabidulla Kikebayev, Kymbat Shaikenova, Zhanagul Seiitkazhy and Eleonora Okuskhanova, 2017. Nutritive and Biological Value of Mare’s Milk Ice Cream. Pakistan Journal of Nutrition, 16: 457-462.

DOI: 10.3923/pjn.2017.457.462

Received: March 08, 2017; Accepted: April 08, 2017; Published: May 15, 2017

Copyright: © 2017. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the creative commons attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.


Nutrition is an important factor in a person’s overall health and well-being and can help to enhance the human body’s resistance to the negative impact of the environment1. Milk and milk products are the most nutritive and biological valuable foods. Presently, there are hundreds of types of functional milk products, including yogurt, curd, cheesecake, pudding and ice cream. These functional products are not just sweet treats but have a therapeutic effect on the human body2.

In Kazakhstan, goat, mare and camel milk are widely available. These types of milk are known for their dietary and therapeutic properties but, hubat and koumiss (milk products from camel and mare’s milk, respectively) are less often used in manufacturing3,4.

Mare’s milk has a neutral acidity and sweet taste, is fresh, and ranges from bluish-white to slightly brown in coloration. Important components of this type of milk include lactose, protein, fat, vitamins, enzymes and minerals4,5.

Mare’s milk also has high nutritive value. Its protein and fat are well digested and its fat has a low melting temperature (21-30°C) in comparison with cow’s milk. Mare’s milk has 6.5% lactose, higher than cow’s milk6 and mare’s milk lactose is a high active bifidogenic factor that is irreplaceable in infant and health nutrition products7. Infants with severe food allergies often tolerate mare’s milk since mare’s milk is closer in composition to human milk than that of any other mammal8,9. A variety of milk desserts are widely manufactured in countries with a milk industry. These milk desserts are produced from milk and different supplements, fillings, taste and flavor additives. In Kazakhstan, the assortment of milk dessert products is expanding through the development of new recipes and processing of milk products, including low-fat milk products10. The purpose of developing dietary milk products involves correcting for protein, fat, mineral and vitamin composition and enrichment with biologically active compounds to improve flavor, nutritive and biological value. Among the milk products, ice cream is growing in popularity. Ice cream is characterized as a frozen milk dessert product comprised of milk, sugar, stabilizer, emulsifier and flavoring9. It has a complex food colloidal system including air bubbles, ice crystals and partially destabilized fat globules dispersed in a continuous aqueous phase11,12.

Rivalry within the ice cream market requires product extension and production of quality food at a reliable price and calls for development of new methods to produce this product.

The purpose of this study was to develop new technology and study the nutritive and biological value of a new healthy food-mare’s milk-based ice cream.


The experiments were conducted in 2015-2016 at S. Seifullin Kazakh Agrotechnical University and with Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) "Gormolzavod" Milk Company in Kokshetau city in the Republic of Kazakhstan.

The Ethics Commission of S. Seifullin Kazakh Agrotechnical University approved the methods of this study under No. PEPPS SMK 11010/46-2013.

Ice cream preparation: For ice cream preparation, mare’s and cow’s milk was used in different proportions as follows: 100% of mare’s milk (MM-100); 40% mare’s milk and 60% of cow’s milk (MM-40); 30% mare’s milk and 70% cow’s milk (MM-30). For a control sample, ice cream produced by national standard GOST 31457-2012 was used.

The flow process of ice cream production is shown in Fig. 1.

For ice cream preparation, mare’s and cow’s milk with good organoleptic quality and Therner degree of no more 21°T, which conforms to requirements of regulatory documents, were used. Milk was poured into an agitation vat and mixed with granulated sugar.

Before pasteurization, the composition was filtered by separating the mechanical and insoluble parts of the composition.

Image for - Nutritive and Biological Value of Mare’s Milk Ice Cream
Fig. 1:Ice cream preparation flow process

The ice cream mixture was pasteurized at 85°C for 20 sec. Pasteurization kills spore and spoilage microorganisms and helps hydrate some of the components (proteins and stabilizers)13,14.

After pasteurization, the ice cream composition was homogenized under a pressure of 12.5-15.0 MPa. The homogenization process breaks down or reduces in size the fat globules found in milk or cream to less than 1 μm. After homogenization, the ice cream composition becomes soft and homogenous with milk fat-pronounced flavor.

From the homogenizer, the ice cream composition was cooled to 2-6°C in the pasteurizing-cooling installation and mix was aged for at least 4 h. This allows time for the fat to cool and crystallize and for the proteins and polysaccharides to fully hydrate. Aging the mix cools it down before freezing, allowing the milk fat to partially crystallize and gives the proteins stabilizers time to hydrate, improving the whipping properties of the mix.

During the next stage, the mixture was frozen and pumped into continuous freezers. The temperature inside the freezers was kept at -40°C using liquid ammonia as a freezing agent. While the ice cream was in the freezer, air was injected into it. When the mixture leaves the freezer, it has the consistency of soft-serve ice cream.

Packaging and storing of ice cream: After the particulates have been added, the ice cream was packaged in 1 kg containers and was placed into a blast freezer at -30 to -40°C where most of the remainder of the water was frozen. Below -25°C, ice cream is stable for indefinite periods without the danger of ice crystal growth; however, above this temperature, ice crystal growth is possible and the rate of crystal growth is dependent upon the temperature of storage, limiting the shelf life of the ice cream13.

Sensory evaluation: Sensory evaluation was performed by a panel of six skilled persons using a 100-point system as follows: The maximum score for taste and flavor was 60 points; for structure and consistency was 30; for color was 5 and for packaging was 5. In case of defects in flavor and aroma (inadequate pronounced flavor, weedy flavor and slightly acid flavor), consistency and structure (powdery, faulty ice cream overrun and ice crystals presence), color and packaging, the score mark was reduced for each defect according to the special sensory evaluation scale.

Determination of mineral elements: One to two grams of the sample was placed in a high-pressure Teflon container. Each sample was combusted at 400°C for 4 h and then to 600°C for 2 h using a muffle furnace. Approximately 1 g sample (dry weight) of ashes was digested with 3 cm3 HNO3 and 2 cm3 of HF and was placed in a microwave at 200°C for 20 min (Berghof Speed Wave microwave system, Germany). After microwave digestion, the samples were diluted with 1% HNO3 in a 10 cm3 vessel.

The content of elements in the samples was determined with an Inductively-Coupled Plasma-Mass Spectrometric Method (ICP-MS, Varian-820 MS, Varian Company, Australia). The method was validated with certified reference materials. Calibration standards Var-TS-MS, IV-ICPMS-71A were used to calibrate the mass-spectrometer (Inorganic Ventures Company, USA). The sensitivity of the mass-spectrometer was tuned using a diluted calibration solution Var-TS-MS with concentrations of Ba, Be, Ce, Co, B, Pb, Mg, Tl and Th of 10 μg L–1. Three calibration solutions were used for the detector calibration as follows: IV-ICPMS-71A of Cd, Pb, Cu and Zn elements diluted to 10, 50 and 100 μg L–1. Discrepancies between certified values and concentrations quantified were below 10%. The operating parameters of the Inductively-Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometer Varian (ICP 820-MS) were as follows: Plasma flow, 17.5 L min–1; auxiliary flow, 1.7 L min–1; sheath gas, 0.2 L min–1; nebulizer flow, 1.0 L min–1; sampling depth, 6.5 mm; RF power, 1.4 kW; pump rate, 5.0 rpm and stabilization delay, 10.0 sec.

All analysis were performed in triplicates and results given in mg kg–1 wet weight, were expressed as Mean±SE.

Determination of amino acids and vitamins: Liquid chromatography was used to quantify amino acids and vitamins. The instrument used was a Shimadzu LC-20 Prominence liquid chromatography system (Shimadzu, Japan) equipped with fluorometric and spectrophotometric detectors. The chromatographic column used was SUPELCO C18 5 μm (Sigma-Aldrich, USA) with a surface area of 200 g–1 m2. The chromatographic analysis was performed under the linear gradient with an eluent flow rate of 1.2 mL min–1 and the temperature of the column heated in an oven was 400°C. Amino acids were detected by fluorometric and spectrophotometric detectors at wavelengths of 246 and 260 nm following acidic hydrolysis and treatment with a phenylisothiocyanate solution in isopropyl alcohol to give phenylthiohydantoins.

Statistical analysis: Differences between samples were evaluated using the t-test which were considered to be statistically significant at p<0.05. Statistical analyses were performed using the free software R 3.02 developed by R Core Team.


There were significant differences (p<0.05) in fat levels across the three different types of ice creams. The fat contents of MM-100, MM-40 and MM-30 were 2.1, 7.3 and 8.5%, respectively. The carbohydrate contents decreased from 26.0 g in MM-100 to 22.7 g in MM-40 and to 21.2 g in MM-30; however, no differences were found among the three types of ice creams in ash content. The protein contents of MM-100 were slightly lower than those of MM-40 and MM-30 ice creams (Table 1).

Mineral elements, among other food components are responsible for the high biological value of milk. According to previous studies, the mineral composition of mare’s milk is similar to human milk15. The mineral element composition is presented in Table 2.

Adding mare’s and cow’s milk to ice cream increased mineral content in MM-40 and MM-30 in comparison with MM-100. The calcium concentration increased from 89.97 mg/100 g in sample 1 to 136.7 mg/100 g in MM-40 and to 130.3 mg/100 g in sample 3. Potassium levels increased as well, in MM-40 and MM-30 to 123.22 mg/100 g and 128.4 mg/100 g, respectively, compared to 64.72 mg/100 g in MM-100.

Table 3 shows the amino acid composition of ice cream samples with different proportions of mare’s milk.

Ice cream types differed in amino acid composition. Ice cream with only mare’s milk had the lowest content of amino acid compared with MM-40 and MM-30. Thus, a combination of mare’s and cow’s milk enriched the ice cream with methionine, glycine, histidine, proline, threonine and valine.

In MM-40 and MM-30, alanine content decreased by 20%. In MM-40, alanine content was 114.8 mg/100 g, in MM-30 content was 110.6 mg/100 g against an MM-100 content of 140.0 mg/100 g. There was no significant change in arginine content.

Unlike other vital food nutrients (essential amino acids and polyunsaturated fatty acids), vitamins are not used as an energy source. Vitamins are involved in different chemical reactions and regulate metabolism, thus ensuring biochemical and physiological processes in the body.

Vitamins A, C and B5 were measured in the control sample (ice cream was made from cow’s milk) and developed ice creams. As shown in Table 4, these vitamins were increased in the mare’s milk-based ice cream. Vitamin C content in sample 1 was 0.71 mg/100 g, while in control sample it was 0.41 mg/100 g. Vitamin C strengthens the immune system and increases protective functions of the human body against viruses and infection.

Sensory analysis of the ice creams is presented in Table 5. Skilled panelists gave high scores to MM-40 ice cream. Mare’s milk contributed significantly to reduce the evaluation score because the ice cream made from 100% mare’s milk had a slightly acid taste with non-dense flakes and sensible ice crystals.

In a study conducted by Burmagina et al.16, a positive effect was found in ice cream by adding 40% malt extract instead of granulated sugar; the fat content level ranged around 10%.

Kazakova17 emphasized on the importance of low-calorie food and developed a recipe for low-calorie ice cream using food fibers, polyols, maltodextrins and sweeteners that reduced the energy value from 30-80%; fat content varied between 0.2-2.0%.

Table 1:Chemical composition of ice cream samples
Image for - Nutritive and Biological Value of Mare’s Milk Ice Cream
*Values are statistically significant at p<0.05

Table 2:Mineral composition of ice cream samples
Image for - Nutritive and Biological Value of Mare’s Milk Ice Cream
K: Potassium, Ca: Calcium, Mg: Magnesium, Na: Sodium, P: Phosphorus, I: Iodine, Mn: Manganese, Cu: Copper

Table 3:Amino acid composition of ice cream samples
Image for - Nutritive and Biological Value of Mare’s Milk Ice Cream

Table 4:Vitamin content in ice cream samples
Image for - Nutritive and Biological Value of Mare’s Milk Ice Cream

Litvinova and Bogdanova18 studied the effect of sea-buckthorn and sweet briar syrup on ice cream production. Starter bacteria (Streptococcus thermophilus, Lactobacillus bulgaricus and Bifidobacterium) were used during acidification. In an analysis of the nutritive value, Litvinova and Bogdanova18 found the fat content to be 6.5%, protein content to be 3.17% and carbohydrate content to be 14.92%; calcium and phosphorous content were 290 mg/100 g and 129.96 mg/100 g, respectively.

Ivanovna and Vasil'evna19 made ice cream with probiotic, prophylaxis and biological properties. They reported that the ice cream consisted of milk, cream, sand sugar, stabilizer, vitamin complex and bacterial concentrate, with vitamin complexes including vitamins A, B and C groups and combined bacterial concentrate containing Bifidobacterium lognum B 379 M, Lactobacillus acidophilus 97 and Propionibacterium shermanii 12 AE. The bacterial concentrate was introduced in ratio of 1:1:1 in an amount of 1-5% based on mixture mass; the total fat content was 8%.

Miwa and Ohashi20 described a low-fat ice cream or ice cream-like product, which has a fat content of 3-8% weight, based on the total weight of low-fat ice cream or ice cream-like product, which was produced by treating a milk material or a liquid ice cream mix with a protein deamidating enzyme to obtain deamidated milk protein.

Table 5: Sensory characteristics of ice creams
Image for - Nutritive and Biological Value of Mare’s Milk Ice Cream

Overall, these studies illustrate the flexibility of the ice cream process and how different additives impact the chemical and nutritive value of the food.


A current trend in milk dessert is the development and production of dietary low-fat ice cream enriched with different additives. A combination of cow’s and mare’s milk in an ice cream mixture decreased fat content and enhanced amino acid composition, including methionine, glycine, histidine, proline, threonine and valine. These findings suggest a beneficial role of mare’s milk in ice cream production with low-fat content.


This study found the nutritive value of mare’s milk ice cream could be beneficial for low-fat nutrition. For ice cream production, mare’s and cow’s milk was used in different proportions. Based on the chemical, amino acid, mineral and vitamin composition findings, the ice cream with 40% of mare’s and 60% of cow’s milk was proposed for healthy nutrition.


The authors would like to thank the staff of the Engineering Laboratory "Scientific Center of Radioecological Research" of Shakarim State University, Semey, Kazakhstan for conducting the analysis.

1:  Abdel-Salam, A.M., 2010. Functional foods: Hopefulness to good health. Am. J. Food Technol., 5: 86-99.
CrossRef  |  Direct Link  |  

2:  Salem, M.M.E., F.A. Fathi and R.A. Awad, 2005. Production of probiotic ice cream. Polish J. Food Nutr. Sci., 14: 267-271.
Direct Link  |  

3:  Tultabayeva, T.C., 2004. Current state and development trends of national sour milk production. KazgosINTI, Almaty, Kazakhstan.

4:  Malacarne, M., F. Martuzzi, A. Summer and P. Mariani, 2002. Protein and fat composition of mare's milk: Some nutritional remarks with reference to human and cow's milk. Int. Dairy J., 12: 869-877.
CrossRef  |  Direct Link  |  

5:  Uzakbaev, K.A. and T.T. Mamyrbaeva, 2012. Mare's Milk and Koumiss. Nur-As, Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan.

6:  Kanareykina, S.G. and V.I. Kanareykin, 2016. Mare's milk-unique food raw material for healthy nutrition products. Bull. Orenburg State Agric. Univ., 4: 150-152.

7:  Slinkin, A.A. and S.G. Kanareykina, 2011. Improving the quality of dried mare's milk. Izvestia Orenburg State Agrarian Univ., 31: 194-196.

8:  Gorbatovskaya, N.A., G. Karimova and M. Kassymova, 2013. Mare's milk as the basis of baby foods. Mech. Technol., 3: 130-134.

9:  Ellinger, S., K.P. Linscheid, S. Jahnecke, R. Goerlich and H. Enbergs, 2002. The effect of mare's milk consumption on functional elements of phagocytosis of human neutrophil granulocytes from healthy volunteers. Food Agric. Immunol., 14: 191-200.
CrossRef  |  Direct Link  |  

10:  Sizenko, Y.I., 2006. Scientific support strategy of competitive production of high quality domestic foods. Storage Process. Farm Prod., 1: 7-12.

11:  Clarke, C., 2004. The Science of Ice Cream. Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK.

12:  Soukoulis, C., E. Lyroni and C. Tzia, 2010. Sensory profiling and hedonic judgement of probiotic ice cream as a function of hydrocolloids, yogurt and milk fat content. LWT-Food Sci. Technol., 43: 1351-1358.
CrossRef  |  Direct Link  |  

13:  Nurzhanova, A., 2010. Milk and Milk Products Technology. Foliant Publishing House, Astana, Kazakhstan.

14:  Bogatova, O.V., N.G. Dogareva and S.V. Stadnikova, 2014. Industrial Technology of Milk Products Manufacturing. Prospect Nauki, St. Petersburg, Russia.

15:  Sharmanov, T.S. and A.K. Zhangabylov, 1991. Health Properties of Koumiss and Shubat. Gylym, Almaty, Kazakhstan.

16:  Burmagina, T.Y., A.I. Gnezdilova, V.B. Shevchuk and Y.A. Yakovleva, 2012. Ice cream with malt extract. Dairy Farming J., 2: 85-91.

17:  Kazakova, N.V., 2008. Developing scientific proved lowered caloricity ice cream technology. Ph.D. Thesis, All-Russian Scientific Research Institute of Refrigeration Industry, Moscow.

18:  Litvinova, A.V. and Y.V. Bogdanova, 2016. Food and energy value of ice cream with vegetable fillers. Proceedings of the International Conference on Innovative Technology of Science Development, (ITSD'16), Ufa, Russia, pp: 67-68.

19:  Ivanovna, T.O. and B.G. Vasil'evna, 2007. [Ice cream with functional characteristics]. Patent 2294647, Russia, March 10, 2007.

20:  Miwa, N. and W. Ohashi, 2012. Ice cream or ice cream-like product and method for producing same. Patent US 20130022710 A1, USA., September 28, 2012.

©  2021 Science Alert. All Rights Reserved