Mental Disorder Assessed by General Health Questionnaire
and Back Pain among Postmenopausal Iranian Women
Ahmad Ali Noorbala
The aim of this study was to investigate the association
between mental disorder and back pain among postmenopausal Iranian women.
Three thousand six hundred and fifty five postmenopausal women were interviewed
in the second National Health Survey (2nd NHS) in the year 2000, in Iran.
Of whom, 2953 women were included in this study. Back pain (BKP) was considered
as dependent variable and mental disorder as independent variable. Factors
like age, Body Mass Index (BMI), residential area, employment, literacy,
smoking habit, marital status and spinal fractures were considered as
confounders. Logistic regression models have been applied for data analysis.
The BKP prevalence was 40.1% and the prevalence of mental disorder was
44.3%. After adjustment for confounders, mental disorder was positively
associated with BKP, OR (CI): 1.615 (1.36, 1.91). This study confirmed
that BKP and mental disorder are common problems and these two factors
are associated amongst postmenopausal women. Further longitudinal studies
are recommended to specify casual inferences.
Low Back Pain (LBP) is a frustrating cause of chronic physical
complaints (Folman et al., 2004). Thirty to sixty percent of the
general population encounter with BKP during their life. Of non traumatic
spine-related impairments, 80% occur in the low back. The onset of spinal
symptoms occurs mostly in middle-aged groups, but structural back problems
increase with age as disc degeneration take place (Wing, 2001). Of mobility
disabilities in the middle-aged and older groups
in England, 38% were related to high levels of lower limb pain and 15%
to high levels of BKP (Melzer et al., 2005). Tavafian et al.
(2005) and Mirzamani Bafghi et al. (2003) showed that chronic LBP
has a negative impact on the quality of life among Iranians and severe
LBP can cause disability. Some women complain of increased BKP during
the menopausal transition and often attribute it to menopause (Brynhildsen
et al., 1998). It is shown that back pain is one of the most common
physical symptoms in Australian women in different stages of the menopause
transition and it is the most frequently occurring menopausal symptom
in Taiwanese women (Chow et al., 1997).
Not only is Menopause a biological event but also is a psychosocial
one (Avis, 1996). Psychological distress is said to be based on the nature
of the symptoms of distress rather than on menopausal status (Becker et
al., 2001). Higher prevalence of presenting chronic LBP in Psychosocially
distressed patients is reported (Sikorski et al., 1996). The exact
mechanism of this association is not definitely known, Although stress
itself is addressed to be a cause of lowered pain tolerance (Ursin et
al., 1993). It has been suggested that mental problems in chronic
LBP patients precede their pain (Mirzamani Bafghi et al., 2003).
A malfunction to acknowledge the psychosocial setting of
BKP and its related complaints is considered to be a cause of confined
efficacy of treatment for BKP (Bouras et al., 1984). It is recommended
that older people especially postmenopausal women who have a sudden onset
of BKP, should be investigated not only with radiography, but also with
regard to mental conditions (Wing, 2001).
Considering the increase in number of women reaching postmenopausal
period annually and existence of mental and physical problems associated
with menopause, it would be crucial to understand whether mental problems
are associated with physical problems. The present study is designed to
shed further light on this issue by examining postmenopausal women with
and without BKP complaints to determine the relationship between mental
disorder and BKP in Iran.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This study is based on the information obtained from the
(2nd NHS) in the year 2000, in Iran. Three thousand six hundred and fifty
five postmenopausal women were interviewed. Of whom, 2953 were included
in this study (699 women for their skeletal deformation and three women
for lack of sufficient information were excluded). The information was
obtained by means of questionnaire which included demographic, personal
habits and physical conditions. Postmenopausal status was defined as no
menstruating for at least 12 past months. Factors like age (year), BMI
(kg m–2), residential areas (urban, rural), employment
(employed, not employed), literacy (literate, illiterate), smoking habits
(smoker, nonsmoker), marital status (married, single consisting of unmarried/widowed/divorced)
and spinal fractures (no fracture, fractures) were considered as confounders.
Mental disorder assessed by the score in the General Health Questionnaire,
including 28 questions as those designed by Goldberg et al. (1997)
was considered as the independent variable. Those scoring 6 and over all
the 28 questions (GHQ>=6) were classified as suspected mental disorder
(Goldberg et al., 1997). A validated Persian version of Community
Oriented Program for Control of Rheumatic Diseases (COPCORD) questionnaire
was used to obtain information about BKP and spinal symptoms. BKP was
defined as non traumatic pain in back and lumbar region with no stiffness
or with stiffness relieved by rest. Stiffness in this study was a kind
which lasted less than half an hour. Logistic regression models have been
applied to compare Subjects with BKP to Subjects with no BKP due to their
mental disorder at 95% level.
The 2nd NHS population included all Iranian households. Household was
defined as any individual living single or those living in the same residence,
participating in the household expenses and usually eating together.
Sampling method and sample size: Sampling was conducted on the basis of cluster method, each
cluster covering 8 households. Overall 13,496 households, with 61,800
members (one out of 1000 all Iranians) were selected for the study. Data
were gathered by a group of two physicians, one interviewer and one laboratory
The study proposal and informed consent obtained from the
subjects has been approved by the Ethical Review Board of National Research
Center of Medical Science in Iran.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Of a total of 2953 postmenopausal women 45.8% reported no
pain and 54.2% reported back and spinal symptoms including traumatic pain
(5.2%), non traumatic pain with stiffness not relieved by rest (8.9%)
and BKP (40.1%).
Characteristics of subjects are shown in Table
1. BKP prevalence for women with GHQ>=6 was 44.3% and for women
having GHQ<6 was 37.8%.
Univariate logistic analysis revealed that BKP was positively
associated with mental disorder, OR (CI): 1.59 (1.34, 1.87). In order
to adjust this result, all confounders were forced into the model and
backward logistic analysis was applied. The result can be summarized in
the following way: BKP was associated with mental disorder, OR (CI): 1.615
(1.36, 1.91); residential area, OR (CI): 1.37 (1.15, 1.62); smoking habit,
OR (CI): 1.4 (1.06, 1.84) and BMI, OR (CI): 1.027 (1.01, 1.04).
The association of mental disorders with BKP was examined
by using data for 2953 postmenopausal women. A significant higher prevalence
of BKP could be found between individuals with GHQ>=6. Logistic regression
analysis showed that having GHQ>=6 was positively associated with BKP.
The issue of significant
||Characteristics of 2953 postmenopausal
woman by their back pain
pain, †Mental disorder, §Body mass index
association has been observed broadly by other studies.
Bongers et al. (1993), in their review study stated that emotional
problems and stress symptoms are associated with back problems in
a large number of studies. Failde et al. (2000) showed that Having
GHQ-28 score of >=6, is an independent risk factor for suffering from
LBP. Although our finding is confirmed by studies mentioned above, but
some other studies are in contrast with it. A short-term follow-up study
showed that the psychosocial factors are not related to LBP (Gonge et
al., 2002). Foppa et al. (1996) indicated that BKP is associated
with emotional problems in women but not in men.Tavafian et al.
(2005) detected no significant difference of emotional scores between
two groups of women with mild and severe BKP.
The definition of BKP in this study was subjective rather
than diagnostic and it was reported at the time of administration of the
interview. Establishing data by this measure without validation from independent
sources may be a disadvantage of this study. BKP was a part of general
NHS, of which relatively few direct questions could be allocated to BKP.
Therefore, it was impossible to include questions about other risk factors
of BKP. Other possible disadvantages are the use of a self-report measure
for mental disorder and the cross sectional nature of the NHS, (which
does not allow us test casual inferences).
Despite the limitations the study has its own advantages.
To our knowledge this is the first major study based on NHS in our country,
which investigates the relationship between BKP and mental disorder among
postmenopausal women. Given that the number of potential confounding factors
we tested had a little impact on this relationship, we are confident that
our findings are valid.
The BKP prevalence was 40.1%. Although due to differences
in BKP definitions, it is difficult to compare this prevalence with those
obtained by other studies, but as examples, the study of 645
postmenopausal Japanese-American women in Hawaii showed that, the BKP
prevalence was 32.9% (Huang et al., 1996). And almost half of white
postmenopausal Caucasian women reported having had LBP during the previous
month (Vogt et al., 2002). Noticing that 35.1% of subjects had
GHQ>=6, shows that BKP and Mental disorder are common among postmenopausal
women in Iran.
A considerable amount of evidence now exists to support
the importance of BKP as a public health problem. Mental disorder is associated
with higher rate of BKP among postmenopausal Iranian women. Although further
longitudinal studies are recommended in order to specify casual inferences,
but these findings may persuade the planners and Health provider to pay
more attention to this issue, to prevent its unwilling consequences.
Avis, N.E., 1996.
Women's perceptions of the menopause. Eur. Menopause J., 3: 80-83.
Becker, D., J. Lomranz, A. Pines, D. Shmotkin, E. Nitza, G. BennAmitay and R. Mester, 2001.
Psychological distress around menopause. Psychosomatics, 42: 252-257.Direct Link |
Bongers, P.M., C.R. de Winter, M.A. Kompier and V.H. Hildebrandt, 1993.
Psychosocial factors at work and musculoskeletal disease. Scand. J. Work Environ. Health, 19: 297-312.CrossRef | PubMed | Direct Link |
Bouras, N., J.R. Bartlett, G. Neil‐Dwyer and P.K. Bridges, 1984.
Psychological aspects of patients having multiple operations for low back pain. Br. J. Med. Psychol., 57: 147-151.CrossRef | Direct Link |
Brynhildsen, J.O., B. Erika, S. Constance and L.H. Mats, 1998.
Is hormone replacement therapy a risk factor for low back pain among postmenopausal women? Spine, 23: 809-813.Direct Link |
Chow, S.N., C.C. Huang and Y.T. Lee, 1997.
Demographic characteristics and medical aspects of menopausal women in Taiwan. J. Formosan Med. Assoc., 96: 806-811.Direct Link |
Failde, I., J.L. Gonzalez, J.P. Novalbos, F. Casais, J. Marin and J. Elorza, 2000.
Mental and occupational predictive factors for back pain among employees of a University Hospital in Southern Spain. Occup. Med. (Oxford, England), 50: 591-596.Direct Link |
Folman, Y., S. Shabat and R. Gepstein, 2004.
Relationship between low back pain in post-menopausal women and mineral content of lumbar vertebrae. Arch. Gerontol. Geriatrics, 39: 157-162.Direct Link |
Foppa, I. and R.H. Noack, 1996.
The relation of self-reported back pain to psychosocial, behavioral and health-related factors in a working population in Switzerland. Social Sci. Med., 43: 1119-1126.CrossRef |
Goldberg, D.P. and V.F. Hillier, 1979.
A scaled version of the general health questionnaire. Psychol. Med., 9: 139-145.PubMed |
Gonge, H., L.D. Jensen and J.P. Bonde, 2002.
Are psychosocial factors associated with low-back pain among nursing personnel. Work Stress, 16: 79-87.CrossRef |
Huang, C.P., D. Ross and R.D. Wasnich, 1996.
Vertebral fractures and other predictors of back pain among older women. J. Bone Mineral Res., 11: 1026-1032.Direct Link |
Melzer, D., E. Gardener and J.M. Guralnik, 2005.
Mobility disability in the middle-aged: Cross-sectional associations in the English longitudinal study of ageing. Age Ageing, 34: 594-602.CrossRef |
Mirzamani-Bafghi, S.M., A. Sididi and J. Sahrai, 2003.
Psychological aspects of low back pain. Arch. Iran. Med., 6: 91-94.Direct Link |
Sikorski, J.M., H.G. Stampfer, R.M. Cole and A.E. Wheatley, 1996.
Psychological aspects of chronic low back pain. Aust. N. Z. J. Surg., 66: 294-297.Direct Link |
Tavafian, S., H. Eftekhar, K. Muhammad, A.R. Jamshidi, A. Montazeri, D. Shojaeezadeh and F. Ghofranipure, 2005.
Quality of life in women with different intensity of low back pain. Iran. J. Public Health, 34: 36-39.Direct Link |
Ursin, H., I.M. Endersen, S. Svebak, G. Tellnes and R. Mykletun, 1993.
Muscle pain and coping with working life in Norway: A review. Work Stress, 7: 247-258.CrossRef |
Vogt, M.T., W.C. Lauerman, M. Chirumbole and L.H. Kuller, 2002.
A community-based study of postmenopausal white women with back and leg pain: Health status and limitations in physical activity. J. Gerontol. Series A: Biol. Sci. Med. Sci., 57: M544-M550.Direct Link |
Wing, P.C., 2001.
Rheumatology: Minimizing disability in patients with low-back pain. Can. Med. Assoc. J., 164: 1459-1468.PubMed | Direct Link |