Effect of Aqueous Extracts of Tropical Plants for Management of Maruca vitrata Fab. and Clavigralla tomentosicollis Stal. on Cowpea, Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp. Plants
Oparaeke Alphonsus Mbonu
The present study aimed at increasing the data bank of botanical pesticides evaluates the effect of crude aqueous extracts of some tropical plants for their insecticidal properties under field conditions for the control of two major post-flowering insect pests of cowpea. The extracts were applied at 10 % (w/v) with four weekly spraying intervals and compared with a synthetic insecticide and an untreated check. The results showed that the extracts of neem, Azadirachta indica (A. Juss), bread fruit, Artocarpus altilis Park and fermented cassava tuber, Manihot esculentus Crantz (in that order) caused significant (p<0.05) reduction of both Maruca vitrata Fab. and Clavigralla tomentosicollis Stal. on cowpea plants compared with other plant extract treatments and were equi-toxic with the synthetic insecticide treatment in the control of both pests in the two years of trials. Pod damage was considerably reduced (< 35%) with consequent increases in grain yields on seed extracts of neem and breadfruit treated plots compared with the other plant extract treatments but were inferior to the synthetic insecticide treatment on the yield parameters tested. Seed quality followed similar trend and was significantly higher in neem seed extract treated plots (79.97%), followed by breadfruit extract (72.3%) and fermented cassava tuber extract (61.97%) among other plant extract treatments.
Insect pests infestation on cowpea, Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp plants especially at the post-flowering phase is a major hindrance to its production worldwide. The legume pod borer, Maruca vitrata Fab. (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae), the pod sucking bug complex predominated by the spink bug, Clavigralla tomentosicollis Stal (Hemiptera: Coreidae) and the legume flower bud thrips, Megalurothrips sjostedti Trybom (Thysanoptera: Thripidae) are the main pests of cowpea in tropical Africa (Jackai and Daoust, 1986). The larvae of M. vitrata feed on flowers and pods while adults and nymphs of C. tomentosicollis feed on succulent pods. Complete crop failure may occur where insecticide protection is not introduced (Jackai and Adalla, 1997) especially for the improved, high yielding varieties. Efforts to popularize these improved varieties of cowpea among limited resource farmers have been a difficult task due to their high demand for insecticidal sprays. These synthetic insecticides are not only expensive due to the high exchange rate of the local currency against the major foreign ones, but also are unavailable at critical period of need.
Insecticide application on a large scale causes a number of problems including environmental degradation, destruction of natural enemies of pests, pest resistance and resurgence and health risk to the farmers and livestock. M. vitrata larvae have shown some resistance to different classes of insecticides (Ekesi, 1999). These situations coupled with the current economic hardship in Africa which led to the withdrawal of various subsidies previously enjoyed by farmers and the demand for pesticide-free food have stimulated interest on alternative sources of insecticide that would become a component of socio-economically sustainable and environmentally friendly crop protection strategies (Jackai and Oyediran, 1991). Botanical pesticides could offer such a management option.
Aqueous or oil extracts from plants have been used for centuries as bio-agents (Crosby, 1971) by farmers worldwide. In the past two decades, researches were directed at developing new botanical pesticides that were effective against pests but present minimal hazards to the user and damage to the environment. These plants contain complex mixture of compounds which the plants sequestered and stored over the years and have formed part of their survival strategy (Yang and Tang, 1987). These compounds may act synergistically (Berenbaum, 1985) and become more lethal to pests than the individual components of the mixture (Berenbaum et al., 1991; Chen et al., 1995). However, due to geographical differences in the distribution of biologically active compounds (Ermel et al., 1987), field activities of extracts from some plant species on pests of crops are varied (Raymundo and Alcazar, 1983; Olaifa and Adenuga, 1988; Williams and Mansingh, 1993).
The present study is part of the ongoing research in the Institute for Agricultural Research, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria to evaluate the insecticidal attributes of many herbal landraces and introduced species in Nigeria and their mixtures for pests control on field crops.
Materials and Methods
Plant materials including the rhizomes of Cyperus rotundus Linn. (Cyperaceae), Artemisia judaica L. (Compositae), the seeds of Azadirachta indica (A. Juss) (Meliaceae), Artocarpus altilis Park (Moraceae), Garcinia cola (Heckel-Holl.) (Guttiferae), Parkia biglobosa L. (Leguminosae) and tubers of Manihot esculentus Crantz (Tuberaceae) were purchased (fresh or dried) from the market in Zaria (except neem seeds that was picked around trees located near the institute). The cassava tubers were peeled, washed with tap water before drying in the oven. The plant materials were oven-dried at 60°C for 12 h to stabilize the moisture contents. The seeds of Breadfruit (A. altilis) and neem were decorticated before weighing. Five hundred gram each of the plant materials were weighed separately and pounded in a wooden mortar with pestle. Each of the powders was soaked in 3.5 L water overnight (except for cassava powder which was soaked for 2 weeks to ferment) before filtering with 1.0 L water using a muslin cloth. 250 mL flaked bar soap and starch solutions (20% w/v) were each added to the extracts to improve its rain fastness and even spread on the sprayed plants. All the extracts (10% w/v) were labeled and sprayed same day.
The trials were conducted on the Research Farm of the Institute for Agricultural
Research, Zaria (Latitude 11°11 N, Longitude 7°38 E; Altitude
686 m) during the rainy season of 1998 and 1999 which commenced on average in
early June and lasted till the first week of October. Cowpea crop is usually
sown from mid July to the third week of August in this ecological zone. The
soil is described as a leached Ferruginous tropical soil, developed on very
fine sandy Aeolian drift over gneiss with a well developed B-horizon (sandy
clay loam) with iron concoctions (McDonald and Flower, 1975). The field was
sprayed with glyphosate three weeks before harrowing and ridging. The experiment
comprised of 9 treatments: seven plant extracts, Uppercott (Cypermethrin 30
g a.i.+ Dimethoate 250 g a.i. L-1) and an untreated control. Plot
sizes were 6.0x5.0 m and each plot consisted of five ridges (three main ridges
and two discards, one on each side of the main ridges). Inter-row spacing was
0.75 m apart. Each plot was separated by 1.50 m wide border margin along the
ridge. The experimental design was a Randomized Block Design with three replications.
SAMPEA 7-cowpea, a semi determinate, medium duration and semi erect variety was sown three seeds per hole at 0.25 m intra-row spacing in the first week of August 1998 and 1999 cropping seasons. Pre-emergent herbicide (GalexMetolachlor 250 g a.i. + Metobromuron 250 g a.i. L-1) and post emergent herbicide Gramoxone (Paraquat 150 g a.i. L-1) were applied at 2.5 kg a.i. ha-1 each immediately after sowing. Seedlings were thinned to two per hole three Weeks After Sowing (WAS). Compound fertilizer (NPK 15:15:15) was applied at 37.5 kg a.i. ha-1 by side placement two WAS. A tank mixture of benlate + mancozeb at 0.30 kg a.i. ha-1 was applied at 4 weekly intervals from the fourth week after sowing. Manual weeding was carried out at five WAS to ensure a weed free condition. Spraying of extracts and the synthetic insecticide against insect pests commenced at flower bud initiation (7 WAS). Spraying was conducted once weekly for four weeks using CP Knapsack sprayers. The sprayers were rinsed with copious amount of water after each application to avoid extract contamination. A single row of cowpea per pass was taken during field spraying.
The larvae of Maruca pod borer were sampled by randomly removing 20
flowers from plants located within the three inner rows per plot. These were
placed in vials containing 30% alcohol and taken to the laboratory where flowers
were dissected the next day and the number of larvae found was recorded. Maruca
pod borers were also sampled by randomly picking 20 pods from a random sample
of 10 plants per plot. These were dissected and the number of borer larvae observed
was recorded. Adults and nymphs of C. tomentosicollis were assessed visually
on plants located in three 1.0x1.0 m quadrants, which were randomly placed within
the sample rows in each plot (Amatobi, 1994). Pod damage was rated at 70 Days
After Planting (DAP). Grain yields were recorded from harvested dried pods in
the sample rows after threshing and winnowing. Grain quality (clean seeds) was
measured by weighing out 300 g seeds from each treatment replicates and removal
of damaged seeds (deformed, small sized, cracked, wrinkled or holed seeds) from
the bulk seeds and reweighing the good seeds. These were also expressed in percentages.
All the data obtained were angular transformed before analysis of variance was
performed while treatment means were separated by Student Newman Keuls test
(p<0.05) (SAS, 1990).
Results and Discussion
The synthetic insecticide and plant extract treatments significantly (p<
0.05) reduced the numbers of M. vitrata and C. tomentosicollis
on treated plots compared with the untreated check in the two seasons. Although,
the synthetic insecticide treatment had lower number of M. vitrata and
C. tomentosicollis among the treated plots, their values (Table
1) were not significantly different compared to neem seed, breadfruit and
fermented cassava extract treatments for the former (M. vitrata) and
neem seed, breadfruit extracts for the latter (C. tomentosicollis). Neem
seed, breadfruit and fermented cassava extracts (in that order) were superior
to other plant extracts in causing reasonable reduction of the tested pests
as well as reducing damage (<35%) to cowpea pods in both seasons (Table
2). Similar trend was observed on grain yields assessment where the three
plant extracts (neem seed, breadfruit and fermented cassava) gave higher grain
yields and better quality grains (>60%) compared to the other plant extracts
but their values were inferior to that in the synthetic insecticide treatment.
||Mean number of Maruca vitrata larvae and C. tomentosicollis
(adults and nymphs) on cowpea plants sprayed with aqueous extracts of different
|Means in a column followed by the same letter (s) are not
significantly different by SAS-SNK test (p<0.05)
||Mean pod damage, grain yields and seed quality of cowpea sprayed
with aqueous extracts of different plant species
|Means in a column followed by the same letter(s) are not significantly
different by SAS-SNK test (p<0.05)
Extracts of G. cola, C. rotundus, P. biglobosa and A.
judaica were found to be less effective but were significantly superior
to the untreated control in all the parameters considered.
The results obtained in this study have shown the potential of neem seed, breadfruit and fermented cassava extracts in that order as biopesticides for the control of two major post-flowering pests of cowpea. The results were consistent with the reports of several authors working with various plant materials on different crop pests (Ekesi, 200; Dike, 1997; Oparaeke et al., 2002; Oparaeke et al., 2005). The activity of neem seed extracts against M. vitrata and C. tomentosicollis and other crop pests is well documented (Jackai and Oyediran, 1991; Saxena, 1981; Schmutterer, 1990; Jackai et al., 1992). However, limited data are available on the mode of action of breadfruit and cassava extracts on pests of crops. Field observations made after few minutes of spraying these extracts did not reveal any abnormal behaviour on M. vitrata and C. tomentosicollis, which might rule out any contact activity contrary to the reports of Williams and Mansingh (1993) who showed in a laboratory study that the extract of A. altilis caused 47, 70 and 93% mortality of Tribolium confusum Duval in day 1, 2 and 3, respectively ahead of Annona reticulata L., Eupatorium odoratum L. and A. indica. However, subsequent observations made after two days of spraying showed sluggish movements on both pests found on the plants even after prodding with a stick which might suggest lack of feeding thereby implicating antifeedant mechanism. This is the first time breadfruit extract is reported to show insecticidal activity against M. vitrata and C. tomentosicollis on field cowpea.
Breadfruit contains alkaloids belonging to the triterpenes known for their antifeedant and repellent activity while cassava contains Prussic acid (from cynanide chemical group), which have shown lethal effect on some mammals (priviledged information). Neem on the other hand, contains Azadirachtin, nimbin, salannin and meliantriol, which have exhibited insecticidal, antifeedant, repellent and growth regulatory properties on different species of insect pests (Warthen et al., 1978; Reed et al., 1982). Compared with the synthetic insecticide, the poor performance of neem seed, breadfruit and fermented cassava extracts in protecting pods from damage caused by insect pests with relatively lower grain yields as observed in this study might be due to the slow action of plant extracts, low concentration of extract applied (10% w/v) and non persistence of the extracts on cowpea plants as a result of incessant rainfall which might have washed away or diluted the extracts soon after application. Therefore, for effectiveness these materials should be applied at >20%.
Neem and breadfruit are planted to provide shade along the major highways and for food respectively in Nigeria. The leaves of both trees have been used for centuries by communities in Nigeria for the treatment of various health disorders in patients. Cassava tubers on the other hand, are boiled and eaten with palm oil or fermented and processed as fufu and garri, both local staple foods consumed by millions of people across the West African sub region. These plants are readily available, cheap and biodegradable and have no known health hazards associated with the synthetic insecticides.
Further studies are required to identify, isolate and characterize the active principles in breadfruit and its mode of action, which is useful in the formulation of pesticides since that of neem are known. There is also the need to test the optimum concentration and spraying schedule of breadfruit extract for greater efficacy against crop pests. These extracts could be tried in mixtures with other less effective plant extracts to improve their overall efficacy in pest management of field crops.
The author is grateful to Professors M.C. Dike and C.I. Amatobi for their useful suggestions during fieldwork. The technical assistance of Mr. Gideon Gbilin in field data collection is acknowledged. I thank the Director, Institute for Agricultural Research, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria for permission to publish this report.
Amatobi, C.I., 1994. Field evaluation of some insecticides for the control of insect pests of cowpea (Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp.) in the Sudan savanna of Nigeria. Int. J. Pest Manage., 40: 13-17.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Berenbaum, M., 1985. Brementown revisited: Interaction among allelochemicals in plants. Recent Adv. Phytochem., 19: 139-169.
Berenbaum, M.R., J.K. Nitao and A.R. Zangerl, 1991. Adaptive significance of furanocoumarin diversification in Pastinaca sativa . J. Chem. Ecol., 17: 207-215.
Chen, W., M.B. Isman and S.F. Chiu, 1995. Antifeedant and growth inhibitory effects of the limonoid toosendanin and Melia toosendan extracts on the variegated cutworm, Peridroma saucia (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). J. Applied Entomol., 119: 367-370.
Crosby, D.G., 1971. Minor Insecticides of Plant Origin. In: Naturally Occurring, Insecticide, Jacobson M. and D.G. Crosby (Eds.). Marcel Dekker Inc., New York, pp: 17-239.
Dike, M.C., 1997. Evaluation of neem products for the control of field insect pests of cowpea. Proceedings of 1997 Review and Planning Conference of Nationally Coordinated Research Programme, 1997, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, pp: 6-9.
Ekesi, S., 1999. Insecticide resistance in field populations of the legume pod-borer, Maruca vitrata Fabricius (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae), on cowpea, Vigna unguiculata (L.), Walp in Nigeria. Int. J. Pest Manage., 45: 57-59.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Ekesi, S., 2000. Effect of volatiles and crude extracts of different plant materials on egg viability of Maruca vitrata and Clavigralla tomentosicollis. Phytoparas, 28: 305-310.
Ermel, K., E. Pahlich and H. Schmutterer, 1987. Azadirachtin content of neem kernels from different geographical locations and its dependence on temperature, relative humidity and light. Proceedings of 3rd Neem Conference, 1987, Nairobi, Kenya, pp: 171-184.
Jackai, L.E.N. and C.B. Adalla, 1997. Pest Management Practices in Cowpea: A Review. In: Advances in Cowpea Research, Singh, B.B., D.R. Mohan-Raj, K.E. Dashiell and L.E.N. Jackai (Eds.). Sayce Publishing, Devon, UK., pp: 240-258.
Jackai, L.E.N. and O.A. Oyediran, 1991. The potential of neem, Azadirachta indica for controlling post flowering pests of cowpea, Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp-1. The pod borer, Maruca testulalis Geyer. Insect Sci. Applied, 12: 103-109.
Jackai, L.E.N. and R.A. Daoust, 1986. Insect pests of cowpea. Ann. Rev. Entomol., 31: 95-119.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Jackai, L.E.N., E.E. Inang and P. Nwobi, 1992. The potential for controlling post-flowering pests of cowpea Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp using neem Azadirachta indica (A. Juss). Trop. Pest Manage., 38: 56-60.
Direct Link |
McDonald, D. and A.M. Fowler, 1975. The use of seed dressings on groundnuts in Northern Nigeria: Importance of seed quality. Nig. J. Plant Protect., 1: 52-57.
Olaiya, J.I. and A.O. Adenuga, 1988. Neem products for protecting field cassava from grasshopper damage. Insect Sci. Applied, 9: 267-270.
Oparaeke, A.M., M.C. Dike and C.I. Amatobi, 2002. Preliminary study on clove, Syzigium aromaticum (L.) Merr and Perr. (Myrtaceae) as a source of insecticide. Nig. J. Agric. Extension, 13: 178-181.
Oparaeke, A.M., M.C. Dike and C.I. Amatobi, 2005. Field evaluation of extracts of five Nigerian spices for control of post-flowering insect pests of cowpea, Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp. Plant Protect. Sci., 41: 14-20.
Direct Link |
Raymundo, S.A. and J. Alcazar, 1983. Dusting with ashes to reduce leaf miner fly damage on potatoes. Appropriate Technol., 10: 17-17.
Reed, D.K., J.D. Warthen, E.C. Uebel and G.L. Reed, 1982. Effect of two triterpenoids from neem on feeding by cucumber beetle, (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae). J. Econ. Entomol., 75: 1109-1113.
Direct Link |
SAS Institute, 1990. SAS/STAT User`s Guide Version 6. 14th Edn., Vol. 2, SAS Institute, Cary, NC., USA.
Saxena, R.C., 1981. Neem seed oil for leaf folder control. Plant Proc. News (Philippines), 10: 48-50.
Schmutterer, H., 1990. Properties and potential of natural pesticides from the neem tree, Azadirachta indica. Annu. Rev. Entomol., 35: 271-297.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Warthen, Jr. J.D., F.E. Redfern, E.C. Uebel and G.D. Mills, 1978. Antifeedant for fall Armyworm Neem Seeds. United States Department of Agriculture, USA.
Williams, L.A.D. and A. Mansingh, 1993. Pesticidal potentials of tropical plants B1. Insecticidal activity in leaf extracts of sixty plants. Insect Sci. Applied, 14: 697-700.
Yang, R.Z. and C.S. Tangs, 1988. Plants used for pest control in China: A literature review. Econ. Bot., 42: 376-406.