Speed Control Simulation for Induction Motor by Multi Level VSI-Fed to Analyse Current Harmonics and Selective Harmonics Elimination
This study presented the simulation studies on closed-loop speed control for 3-phase induction motor by applying V/F method. This induction motor is fed by three and five-level diode clamped Voltage Source Inverter (VSI). Sinusoidal pulse with modulation technique is used to control inverter power switches. The harmonics of phase current is analysed. Then selective harmonics is eliminated by comparison of sine wave with modified triangle carrier. In this method, we could eliminate selective harmonics with no need to complex equations solving. In this study, by present the quasi triangle carrier Total Harmonic Distortion (THD) is decreased.
Multilevel power conversion was first introduced 26 years ago (Corzine,
2002). The general concept involves utilizing a higher number of active
semiconductor switches to perform the power conversion in small voltage steps.
There are several advantages to this approach when compared with traditional
(two-level) power conversion. The smaller voltage steps lead to the production
of higher power quality waveforms and also reduce the dv/dt stresses on the
load and reduce the electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) concerns. Another important
feature of multilevel converters is that the semiconductors are wired in a series-type
connection, which allows operation at higher voltages. However, the series connection
is typically made with clamping diodes, which eliminates overvoltage concerns.
Furthermore, since the switches are not truly series connected, their switching
can be staggered, which reduces the switching frequency and thus the switching
Figure 1 shows the general structure of the multilevel converter
system. In this case, a three-phase motor load is shown on the AC side of the
converter. Generally, variable-speed induction motor employs the inverter as
power-varying component (Tipsuwanporn et al., 2006;
Carbone and Scappatura, 2005). However, the converter
may interface to an electric utility or drive another type of load. The goal
of the multilevel Pulse-Width Modulation (PWM) block is to switch the converter
GTOs in such a way that the phase voltages vas, vbs and
vcs are equal to commanded voltages v*as, v*bs and
v*cs. The commanded voltages are generated from an overall supervisory
control and may be expressed in a general form as:
|| Multi level inverter structure
where, v*s is a voltage amplitude and θc is an electrical angle.
The fundamental multilevel inverter topologies are diode-clamped, flying capacitor,
cascaded H-bridge and multilevel H-bridge (Aghdam and Fathi,
2006; Corzine and Baker, 2002). Diode clamped multi-level
inverter is a very general and widely used topology for real power flow control
and is considered for investigation
|| Three-level diode clamped inverter
purpose in this study. The three-level diode clamped inverter is shown in Fig.
2. Comparing this topology with that of a standard two-level converter,
it can be seen that there are twice as many GTOs as well as added diodes (Choi
et al., 1991; Corzine and Wielebski, 2003).
However, it should be pointed out that the voltage rating of the GTOs is half
that of the GTOs in a two-level converter. In three-level inverter, the GTO
blocking voltage is one half the DC-link voltage. When compared with the two-level
converter, the additional voltage level allows the production of line-to-ground
voltages with lower harmonic distortion. Selective harmonic elimination pulse-width
modulation methods remain of great interest for the control of high-voltage
high-power voltage-source converters (Xu and Agelidis, 2007;
Dahidah and Agelidis, 2007). The main challenge associated with SHE-PWM
techniques is to obtain the analytical solution of the resultant system of the
non-linear transcendental equations that contain trigonometric terms, which
in turn provide multiple sets of solutions (Sahali and Fellah,
2006; Dahidah and Agelidis, 2006; Agelidis
et al., 2006). This study is presented a method that by applying
it, we could eliminate selective harmonics with no need to complex equations
SINUSOIDAL PULSE WITH MODULATION
The control principle of the SPWM is to use several triangular carrier signals
keeping only one modulating sinusoidal signal.
|| Three-level sine-triangle modulation technique
For the three level inverter, two triangular carriers are needed (Fig.
3) (Generally speaking, if a m-level inverter is employed, (m-1) carriers
will be needed) (Massoud et al., 2004). The carriers
have the same frequency fc and the same peak-to-peak amplitude Ac.
The zero reference is placed in the middle of the carrier set. The modulating
signal is a sinusoid of frequency fm and amplitude Am.
At every instant, each carrier is compared with the modulating signal. Each
comparison switches the switch on if the modulating signal is greater than the
triangular carrier assigned to that switch. Obviously, the actual driving signals
for the power devices can be derived from the results of the modulating-carrier
comparison by means of a logic circuit. SPWM technique can be classified according
to carrier and modulating signals.
The main parameters of the modulation process are:
||The frequency ratio k = fc/fm, where
fc is the frequency of the carriers and fm is the
frequency of the modulating signal
||The modulation index M = Am/(m' *Ac),
where Am is the amplitude of the modulating signal, Ac,
is the peak-to-peak amplitude of the carriers and m' = (m-1)/2, where m
is the number of level
SPEED CONTROL FOR INDUCTION MOTOR
In recent years, application of three, four and five level VSI has become common
in speed control for Induction Motors in order to reduce torque variation and
accelerate dynamic response (Fang et al., 1995;
Singh et al., 1998; Song-Manguelle
and Rufer, 2003).
|| Schematic of speed control of induction motor
||(a) Phase voltage and (b) phase current of induction motor
fed by 3-level diode clamped inverter
An egregious problem of this method is balancing of capacitor voltage so use
of the isolated power supply is proposed. The isolated power supply is used
here. The induction motor is controlled by V/F method (Dubey,
1989; Ong, 1997). The schematic of speed control of
induction motor is shown in Fig. 4. The parameters of the
induction motor are given:
||(a) Phase voltage and (b) phase current of Induction Motor
Fed by 5-level Diode Clamped Inverter
The phase voltage (Vag) and stator phase current (ias)
wave forms are shown in follow Fig. 5 and 6.
In this study, the frequency ratio is 33(K = fc/fm = 33). The three and five
level voltage waveforms that feed the induction motor are shown in Fig.
5a and 6a. The current waveform of induction motor is
shown in Fig. 5b and 6b.
||Phase current harmonic spectrum of induction motor fed by
3-level diode clamped inverter
||Phase current harmonic spectrum of induction motor fed by
5-level diode clamped inverter
SELECTIVE HARMONIC ELIMINATION
Application of multilevel VSI in induction motor drive to cause to generation
of current and voltage harmonics (Dubey et al., 1986;
Corzine et al., 1998; Iturriz
and Ladoux, 2000; Krein et al., 2004). Selective
Harmonic Elimination (SHE) is normally a two-step digital process. First, the
switching angles are calculated offline, for several depths of modulation, by
solving many nonlinear equations simultaneously. Second, these angles are stored
in a look- up table to be read in real time. Consider a quasi-triangular waveform
to be used as the carrier signal in a PWM implementation. A PWM implementation
is a technique to control inverter power switches. By applying this technique,
we could generate a quasi Sinusoidal waveform with desired frequency. In principle,
the frequency and phase can be modulated. To represent this, consider a triangular
carrier function written as:
where, ωsw is the base switching frequency, β(t) is a phase-modulation signal and ö is a static phase shift. The modulating signal will be represented as m(t) = mdxsin(ωt) where md is the depth of modulation and ω is the desired output fundamental frequency.
where, Jn is a Bessel function of the first kind. The natural number
M is infinity in principle. The functions σ(md) and G(md)
have been determined by curve fitting as:
Figure 7 and 8 show a magnitude spectrum for K = 33(ωsw = 33ω). By applying this switching frequency ratio are eliminated second, 3th, ..., 32th harmonics. By using this method, we could eliminate the selective harmonics(second, 3th, ..., 32th Harmonics). In this method we dont require to solve complex equations.
By using the quasi-triangular waveform (Eq. 2) to be used as the carrier signal in a PWM implementation, the current THD of Induction Motor by 3-level Diode Clamped Inverter- fed is 6% and for Induction Motor by 5-level Inverter fed is 2.7%. If we use a common triangular waveform to be used as the carrier signal, the current THD of Induction Motor by 3-level Diode Clamped Inverter-fed would be 9% and for Induction Motor by 5-level Inverter fed is 5%.
In this study, the simulation studies on closed-loop speed control for 3-phase
Induction Motor by applying V/F method was presented. This induction motor was
fed by Multi-level diode clamped Voltage Source Inverter (VSI). Sinusoidal pulse
with modulation technique was used to control inverter power switches. Then
the harmonics of the phase current were analysed. The Selective harmonics were
eliminated by comparison of sine wave with modified triangle carrier (Eq.
2). In this study, the frequency ratio was 33(ωsw = 33ω).
By applying this switching frequency ratio, second, 3th, ..., 32th current harmonics
were eliminated. In this method, we dont require to solve complex equations.
In this study, by present the Novel triangle carrier Total Harmonic Distortion
(THD) was decreased.
Using the quasi-triangular waveform (Eq. 2) as the carrier signal in a PWM implementation, the Phase current THD of Induction Motor fed by 3-level Diode Clamped Inverter is 6% and for Induction Motor by 5-level Diode Clamped Inverter 2.7%.
1: Agelidis, V.G., A. Balouktsis, I. Balouktsis and C. Cossar, 2006. Multiple sets of solutions for harmonic elimination PWM bipolar waveforms: Analysis and experimental verification. IEEE Trans. Power Electr., 21: 415-421.
Direct Link |
2: Carbone, R. and A. Scappatura, 2005. A high-power PWM adjustable speed drive with low current harmonics. Proceedings of the IEEE International Symposium on Industrial Electronics, June 20-23, Calabria, Italy, pp: 535-540.
3: Choi, N.S., J.G. Cho and G.H. Cho, 1991. A general circuit topology of multi-level inverter. Proceedings of the 22nd Annual IEEE Conference on Power Electronics Specialists, June 24-27, Cambridge, MA, USA., pp: 96-103.
4: Corzine, K.A., S.D. Sudhoff, E.A. Lewis, D.H. Schmucker, R.A. Youngs and H.J. Henger, 1998. Use of multi-level converters in ship propulsion drives. Proceedings of the All Electric Ship Conference, Sept. 1998, London, England, pp: 155-163.
5: Corzine, K.A. and J.R. Baker, 2002. Multi-level voltage-source duty-cycle modulation: Analysis and implementation. IEEE Trans. Indus. Electr., 49: 1009-1016.
Direct Link |
6: Corzine, K.A., 2002. Multilevel Converters, The Power Electronics Handbook. CRC Press, Washington, USA., pp: 1-23.
7: Corzine, K.A. and M.W. Wielebski, 2003. Control of cascaded multi-level inverters. Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Electric Machines and Drives, June 1-7, USA., pp: 1549-1555.
8: Dahidah, M.S.A. and V.G. Agelidis, 2006. Generalized formulation of multilevel selective harmonic elimination PWM: Case I -non-equal DC sources. Proceedings of the 37th IEEE Power Electronics Specialists Conference, June 18-22, Belgium, pp: 1-6.
9: Dahidah, M.S.A. and V.G. Agelidis, 2007. Non-symmetrical selective harmonic elimination PWM techniques: The unipolar waveform. Proceedings of the Power Electronics Specialists Conference, June 17-21, Belgium, pp: 1885-1891.
10: Dubey, G.K., S.R. Doradla and A. Joshi, 1986. Thyristorised Power Controllers. John Wiley & Sons, New York.
11: Dubey, G.K., 1989. Power Semiconductor Controlled Drives. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J., ISBN: 0136868908.
12: Fang, Z.P., S.L. Jih, J. McKeever and J. van Coevering, 1995. A multilevel voltage-source inverter with separate DC sources for static VAR generation. Proceedings of the 33th Conference on Industry Applications, Oct. 8-12, USA., pp: 2541-2548.
13: Aghdam, H.M.G. and S.H. Fathi, 2006. Comparison of modulation methods for three-phase multi-level voltage-source inverter from conduction and switching losses aspect. Proceedings of the 1st IEEE Conference on Industrial Electronics and Applications, May 24-26, ICIEA, pp: 1-8.
14: Iturriz, F. and P. Ladoux, 2000. Phase-controlled multilevel converters based on dual structure associations. IEEE Trans. Power Electr. Power, 15: 92-102.
Direct Link |
15: Krein, P.T., B.M. Nee and J.R. Wells, 2004. Harmonic elimination switching through modulation. Proceedings of the IEEE Workshop on Computer in Power Electronics, Aug. 15-18, USA., pp: 123-126.
16: Massoud, A.M., S.J. Finney and B.W. Williams, 2004. Multi-level converters and series connection of IGBT evaluation for high-power, high-voltage applications. Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Power Electronics, Machines and Drives, March 31-April 2, USA., pp: 1-5.
17: Ong, C.M., 1997. Dynamic Simulations of Electric Machinery: Using Matlab/Simulink. Prentice Hall PTR, USA.
18: Singh, S.S., F. Li, C. Garrett and R. Thomas, 1998. A study of sigma-delta modulation control strategies for multi-level voltage source inverters. Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Power Electronics and Variable Speed Drives, Sept. 21-23, USA., pp: 347-352.
19: Song-Manguelle, J. and A. Rufer, 2003. Multilevel inverter for power system applications highlighting asymmetric design effects from a supply network point of view. Proceedings of the IEEE Canadian Conference on Electrical and Computer Engineering, May 4-7, USA., pp: 435-440.
20: Tipsuwanporn, V., A. Numsomran and W. Sawangsinkasikit, 2006. Design and implementation multilevel inverter for 3φ induction motor speed control with RBM chopper technique. Proceedings of the IEEE International Symposium on Industrial Electronics, July 9-13, USA., pp: 2094-2098.
21: Xu, L. and V.G. Agelidis, 2007. VSC transmission system using flying capacitor multilevel converters and hybrid PWM control. IEEE Trans. Power Delivery, 22: 693-702.
Direct Link |
22: Sahali, Y. and M.K. Fellah, 2006. Application of the optimal minimization of the THD technique to the multilevel symmetrical inverters and study of its performance in comparison with the selective harmonic elimination technique. Proceedings of the International Symposium on Power Electronics, Electrical Drives, Automation and Motion, May 23-26, Itlay, pp: 1342-1348.