Morphology of the Gonads of Synodontis eupterus (Boulenger) from River Rima, North-western Nigeria
This study was carried out to gain knowledge on some aspects of reproduction of S. eupterus from River Rima which includes sexual dimorphism, size at first maturity, morphology of the gonads, gonad maturation stages and reproductive cycle. The study was conducted between November 2005 and December 2008. 1,610 samples, comprising of 781 females, 816 males and 13 samples whose sexes could not be identified were examined, giving a female: male ratio of almost 1:1. Means of total length and total weight for females was 10.66±1.61 cm and 18.04±6.39 g, respectively. For males, means of total length and total weight were 10.13±1.29 cm and 13.21±6.02 g, respectively. Sexual dimorphism was observed with the females larger than males and males possessing genital papilla. Size at first maturity for females 7.20 cm total length and 5.70 g total weight and 7.00 cm and 5.10 g in males. Female gonads were larger than those of males. In both sexes, the left gonads were slightly larger than the right ones. Based on macroscopic examination of gonads, six stages of gonad maturation were established in both sexes. Multiple spawning was confirmed for the species, with the peak spawning period between July and September in River Rima.
Received: August 02, 2011;
Accepted: November 12, 2011;
Published: December 22, 2011
The genus Synodontis belonging to the Family Mochokidae is among the
most favored edible fish species in northern Nigeria, owing to their tremendous
abundance in the artisanal fisheries (Reed et al.,
1967). It contributes a large proportion of the annual fish landing in the
region (Owolabi, 2008). The Genus has 20 species, of
which S. eupterus (Synonym: Synodontis macrepipterus, as reported
by Babatunde and Aminu (2004) is a member. It is commonly
referred to as the feather fin, squeaker or the upside down catfish. The species
is very common in commercial catches and its flesh has excellent flavor which
after smoking, has excellent keeping qualities (Reed et
al., 1967). Holden and Reed (1972) described S.
eupterus as a small species, with short to medium scaleless body of about
20 cm in length and a bony shield on the head and sides; the colour of the adults
of the species is uniformly olive with small round black spots on the body and
all the fins and the spots are confluent on the tail and form transverse lines
while the juveniles have the spots arranged in an irregular pattern of tiger
like stripes. They further described the species as having a magnificent dorsal
fin, with each hard ray extending into long filaments which can vary in different
individuals, hence the common name, feather fin; thus, their coloration pattern,
grace in movement and extreme toughness make them particularly attractive for
aquaria (Reed et al., 1967).
This study provides information of the morphology of the gonads and gonad maturation
stages of S. eupterus, a species of great commercial importance due to
its availability the whole year round in the study area, as well as a good candidate
in the aquarium industry.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study area: The fish samples were collected from River Rima, in Sokoto,
northwestern Nigeria. Sokoto lies between longitudes 4°8E and 6°5E
and latitudes 12°N and 13°58N (Mamman, 2000).
The climate of Sokoto is tropical continental, with much of the rains between
June and September while the long dry season is from October and May (Ita
et al., 1982).
River Rima flows in a south-western direction over 100 km and joins the major
River Sokoto to form the Sokoto-Rima river system. The Sokoto-Rima River flows
south-westernly in a direction up to Zogirma, where it changes direction and
run southwards before emptying into the River Niger. The River is seasonal,
usually over flooding its banks during the rainy season in August and September
and up to October at times (Mock, 1963).
Fish samples: Samples were collected on a monthly basis for 36 months
(November 2005 to December 2008). The samples were examined fresh in the laboratory
immediately after collection. On each sample, measurements of total length and
standard length (cm) and total weight (g) were taken. Sex was assigned to each
sample based on the presence of ovary and testis for female and male, respectively.
Possibility of sexual dimorphism, exhibited by most catfishes as a difference
in size in the two sexes and also the presence of genital papilla in males (Linder,
2002) was also considered. Gonads were detached and weighed (g). Length
and width (cm) of each gonad lobe were measured. Other morphological features
of the gonads such as the degree of opacity of the gonads, consistency and vascularization,
oocytes or sperm visibility and overall colouration of the gonads were observed.
Same features were used to determine the gonad maturity stages (White
et al., 1998).
For estimating the size at first maturity, the gonadosomatic index of all the
samples collected was compared to their total lengths and weights. The smallest
size (length and weight) at which mature gonads of both the sexes were found
was taken as the first size at maturity (DeSilva, 1973).
Observation of the gonad maturation stages on a monthly basis was carried out
to determine the annual pattern of gonadal development of the species.
Statistical analysis: SPSS statistical computer package version 11 was employed for the descriptive statistics of the morphometric features and gonad dimensions while DMRT at 95% was employed to separate the means.
Size distribution of S. eupterus samples from River Rima based on
sex: A total number of 1,610 samples were analyzed, of which 781 (48.50%)
were females while 816 (50.70%) were males. The sex of 13 samples (0.80%) could
not be identified. The observed female:male ratio was 0.96:1 which was not significantly
(p<0.05) different from 1:1 (X2 = 1.26-4). Table
1 shows the values of all the body lengths and weights measured based on
sex. The mean total length for females was 10.66±1.61 cm which was significantly
(p<0.05) higher than that of the males at 10.13±1.29 cm. Females were
significantly (p<0.05) heavier (18.04±0.39 g), than males (13.21±6.02
g). Females were significantly (p<0.05) larger than males as indicated by
the mean values of all the other morphometric features (SL, FL, HL, GTH and
GW) in the Table 1.
Size at first maturity: The smallest mature female with reproductive activity had a total length of 7.20 cm and a total weight of 5.70 g and was in the mature stage. In males, the smallest mature male had a total length of 7.00 cm and a total weight of 5.10 g. The sizes at different stages of gonad maturation are shown in Table 2.
Morphology of the gonads
Shape: Ovaries of S. eupterus were paired, smooth, elongated and
joined to each other throughout their length by a connective tissue in the immature
stage of maturation. They had prominent blood vessels across them. In the maturing
stage, they were fuller and less elongated in shape, still covered with blood
vessels and joined by connective tissue which receded posteriorly as they mature.
Mature ovaries (Fig. 1) were ovoid or almond shaped and free
anteriorly, but connected only at the posterior, where they opened into the
|| Means of morphometric features of S. eupterus samples
from River Rima based on sex
|Mean values with different letters within a row are significantly
different at p<0.05
|| Size at different stages of gonad maturity in both sexes
of S. eupterus
||Mature ovary of S. eupterus. Note: The blood vessels
covering the ovaries and the fatty tissues in the visceral cavity; and the
olive green colour of the ovaries due to olive green eggs and dots of yellow
eggs. The yellow fatty tissues were abundant in the visceral cavity
||Ripe and running ovary of S. eupterus. Note: Different
colours and sizes of eggs showing through the ovarian membrane (yellowish
and greenish eggs) in the two lobes. The undeveloped eggs at the tip of
the ripe and running lobe may be the ones that may mature later or may be
residuals that may not mature at all
Yellow fatty tissues surround the ovaries. As the ovaries entered ripe and
running stage (Fig. 2), they were less oval and became elongated
in shape, with the anterior or upper part deflated. Spent ovaries were like
deflated sacs and when stretched, were elongated in shape. Resting ovaries resembled
immature ovaries, except for the absence of the connective tissue joining the
pair and fewer visible blood vessels.
The testes of S. eupterus were paired, elongated, thread like and fused and could not be easily separated in the immature samples. In the maturing stage, they were thicker with rough edges, appearing shorter than the immature ones. Mature testes were flattened, compact structures and leaf-like, striations across them. They were joined along their length by connective tissues. The edges of the testes were rough while the whole testes were covered with prominent blood vessels. Ripe and running testes oozed out milt with the application of pressure on the abdomen and were less firm than mature testes. Spent testes were slimmer, deflated and shrunken and also less leaf-like in appearance. The rough edges were less apparent. Resting testes were slim and thread like and their texture was firmer than the spent testes and more like the immature testes, except that immature testes were also slimmer and firmer, with more visible blood vessels across them than in the resting stage.
Colour: The colour of the ovaries in S. eupterus varied with stage of gonad maturation. In the immature stage, the ovaries were pinkish to pale red in colour. The ovaries became darker red, in the maturing stage, containing tiny indiscernible eggs that were reddish in color. Mature ovaries were transparent in colour (Fig. 1), but due to the olive green color of the eggs, they appeared to be olive green in colour. Ripe and running ovaries were also transparent, but as the eggs were released, the ovaries became dark yellow in colour (Fig. 2), reflecting the color of the eggs. Spent ovaries were blood red in colour. As the ovaries entered resting stage, they became pale red, but were still darker than the immature ovaries.
Colour of the testes also varied with stage of gonad maturation. Immature testes were transparent to very pale yellow. Maturing testes were pinkish. In the mature stage, the testes were whitish while in the ripe and running stage they were darker, turning to milky colour. Spent testes were bright red while resting testes were very pale red in colour.
Size: Of the 816 males of weight analyzed, only the gonads of 806 samples
could be measured while gonads of all the 781 females were measured. Table
3 shows the means of gonad weight and the dimension or size of ovaries and
testes of the samples based on the six stages of gonad maturation. From the
Table 3, ovaries are heavier and larger in size than testes.
It was observed that in both sexes, left gonad lobes were larger than the right
ones, but the difference in the size of the two lobes are not significant (p>0.05).
In the two sexes, the largest gonads were those in the mature stage, followed
by ripe and running stage while the smallest were those of the immature and
resting stages. All the differences in size of the gonads in both sexes based
on stages of gonad maturation were highly significant (p<0.05).
Monthly occurrence of gonad maturation stages: Monthly occurrence of
the different stages of gonad development of female and male samples S. eupterus
are presented in Tables 5 and 6, respectively.
Samples with immature gonads were caught in January to March in both sexes,
but in March maturing gonads were also obtained in both sexes, when only one
mature female was caught. Same trend was observed in April, where in both females
and males, only immature and maturing samples were obtained. The first three
stages that is, immature, maturing and mature abound the catches of May and
June. In both sexes, the samples were observed to have enhanced body colouration
and the colouration patterns were more prominent, thus making them to appear
more attractive from June up to September.
|| Gonad dimensions of S. eupterus based on gonad maturation
|Means in column with same superscript are not significantly
By July, the number of immature and maturing samples had declined and there
were larger numbers of mature samples with few ripe, running and spent gonads
in the two sexes. In August, no immature female was caught, but two samples
with maturing gonads were caught and mature and ripe and running gonads dominated
the catches. In males, very few samples with immature and maturing gonads were
obtained in August but mature females dominated the catches, with few ripe and
running and spent samples.
|| Macroscopic description of gonad maturation stages of females
and males of S. eupterus from River Rima, Nigeria
||Monthly occurrence of gonad maturation stages in females of
S. eupterus from River Rima, Nigeria
Monthly occurrence of gonad maturation stages in males
of S. eupterus from River Rima, Nigeria
The catches of September were dominated by spent samples in both sexes with
very few mature and ripe and running samples in females, but immature stages
were completely absent. In males, a single immature sample was caught and very
few mature and ripe and running samples. Resting ovaries dominated the catches
of October in females while in males few resting testes were observed. Immature
and spent gonads were also caught in October, but maturing, mature and ripe
and running gonads were absent. Catches of November were dominated by immature
gonads in both sexes while in females, spent and resting stages were also observed.
In the males, only resting individuals apart from immature samples were observed
while immature, mature, ripe and running and spent stages were absent.
In December, only immature gonads were encountered in both sexes while all the other five gonad maturation stages were absent. From the gonad maturation stages recorded, spawning of S. eupterus has its peak in July and August and up to September when it begins to decline. Spent gonads started appearing from July and increased through September. Spawning was over by October and gonads entered resting condition. By November, immature gonads started appearing through February and from then on, maturing gonads were observed which would mature by May to June. Description of all the maturation stages has been given in Table 4.
In S. eupterus, the sex ratio of 1:0.96 of female to male was not significantly
(p<0.05) different from 1:1, even though the number of males exceeded that
of females. This difference in number may be due to disparity to differential
survival over certain environmental conditions. Abayomi
and Arawomo, 1996 reported higher sex ratio in favour of males of Clarias
gariepinus in Opa reservoir.
In addition to the presence of genital papilla in adult male samples which
is a characteristic of most catfishes (Holden and Reed, 1972)
female samples were significantly (p<0.05) larger and heavier than the males.
Thus, indicating the presence of sexual dimorphism in the species. Linder,
2002 also reported sexual dimorphism in several families of catfishes. Larger
size in females than in males of Synodontis was reported for S.
clarias in River Rima (Shinkafiet al., 2002)
and S. schall and S. nigrita in Oueme River (Laleye
et al., 2006). Larger size of females at first maturity which is
a characteristic of most catfishes was reported by Oymak
et al. (2001), Laleye et al. (2006)
and Offem et al. (2008a, b).
Morphological examination of the gonads revealed disparity in size of the two
lobes of each pair of the gonads and that generally, the left lobes were larger
than the right ones in both sexes. Similar finding was reported by Ratty
et al. (1990) and Omotosho (1993). Observation
of the ovary in ripe and running stage showed that during spawning, not all
of the eggs in one lobe of ovary were released at once, but there was a pattern
of releasing on the ripe eggs at a time and probably later, more of the eggs
ripen and will be released later. It is not clear whether the two lobes release
the eggs alternately, or the one lobe finish releasing all of its eggs before
the other. However, no sample was found with an empty lobe. A further study
is required to find out the full pattern of spawning and egg release in the
Six stages of gonad maturation were established for S. eupterus in
this study. Based on macroscopic examination of the gonads, visible morphological
changes during development in colour, shape, vascularization and size occurred
during the maturation process and these follow the same pattern in most oviparous
fishes (Barr, 1968). The sizes of the gonads increased
from immature to the maturing and it was largest at the mature stages. Thereafter,
they declined from ripe and running stage to spent, finally up to resting stages
and back to immature. According to Omotosho (1993),
the increase in weight and volume of gonads from one stage to another as they
advance in maturity before spawning is as a result of accumulation of trophic
substances in the reproductive cells while the decrease in the thickness of
the walls of the ovaries is due to maximal distension of the walls due to due
to increase in number and size of oocytes.
The sequential year round development of the various stages of gonad maturation
as recorded through the monthly survey of the gonads confirmed the annual reproductive
cycle of the species while the peak spawning period was during the high flood
period which in this case was from July to September. This is in accordance
with the reports of Reed et al. (1967), Imevbore
(1970) and Olatunde (1989). The Authors reported
the spawning period of most fish species to be during the flood season and that
the flood among other things provides expanded habitat and abundant food. So
as to ensure the survival of the huge number of young fish produced, as well
as reproductive niche and shelter for juveniles, consequently enhancing reproductive
success (Ikomi and Odum, 1998).
In this study, sexual dimorphism was confirmed for S. eupterus and females mature at a slightly larger size than males. Asymmetry of the two lobes of a single gonad was observed. Six stages of gonad maturation were established for this species and its peak spawning season is from July to September. The species was also found to be a multiple spawner in River Rima.
1: Abayomi, O.S. and G.A. Arawomo, 1996. Sex ratio and fecundity of the clariid catfish, (Clarias gariepinus.M) in opa reservoir, Ile-Ife, Nigeria. Trans. Fish. Soc. Niger., 1: 122-130.
2: Barr, W.A., 1968. Patterns in Ovarian Activity. In: Perspectives in Endocrinology: Hormones in the Lives of Vertebrates, Barrington, E.J.W. and C.B. Jorgensen (Eds.). Academic Press, London, pp: 164-238
3: DeSilva, S.S., 1973. Aspects of the reproductive biology of the sprat, Sprattus spratus (L.) in Shore waters of the West Coast of Scotland. J. Fish. Biol., 5: 689-705.
4: Holden, M. and W. Reed, 1972. West African Freshwater Fish. Longman Group Ltd., London, ISBN: 0582604265, pp: 67
5: Ikomi, R.B. and O. Odum, 1998. Studies on aspects of the ecology of the catfish Chrysichthys auratus Geoffrey St. Hilaire (Osteichthyes; Bagridae) in the River Benin (Niger Delta, Nigeria). Fish. Res., 35: 209-218.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
6: Imevbore, A.M.A., 1970. Some Preliminary Observations on Sex Ratios and Fecundity of Fishes in River Niger. In: Kainji, a Nigerian Man-Made Lake, Visser, S.A. (Ed.). Nigerian Institute of Social and Economic Research, Ibadan, Nigeria, pp: 136-164
7: Ita, E.O., J.K. Balogun and A. Ademola 1982. A preliminary report of pre-impoundment fisheries study of goronyo reservior, Sokoto State, Nigeria. A Report Submitted to the SOKOTO Rima River basin Development Authority (SRRBDA), Sokoto, Nigeria.
8: Laleye, P., A. Chikou, P. Gnohossou, P. Vandewalle, J.C. Philippart and G. Teugels, 2006. Studies on the biology of two species of catfish Synodontis schall and Synodontis nigrita (Ostariophysi: Mochokidae) from the Oueme River, Benin. Belg. J. Zool., 136: 193-201.
Direct Link |
9: Linder, S., 2002. The catfish basics series. Part 8: Telling the boys from the girls. Shane's World Catfishology, http://www.planetcatfish.com/shanesworld/shanesworld.php?article_id=298&title=The+Catfish+Basics+SeriesTelling+the+Boys+From+the+Girls.
10: Mamman, A.B., 2000. Nigeria: A People United, A future Assured (Sokoto State) Gabumo Publishing Co. Ltd., Lagos, Nigeria, pp: 298
11: Mock, F.J., 1963. Hydrological study on the flooding of the Rima Fadama. Unpublished report. United Nations Special Funds Project. F.A.O., Sokoto.
12: Offem, B.O., E.O. Ayotunde and G.U. Ikpi, 2008. Dynamics in the reproductive biology of Heterobranchus longifilis val, (Pisces: 1840) in the Inland Wetlands of Cross river, Nigeria. Res. J. Fish. Hydrobiol., 3: 22-31.
Direct Link |
13: Offem, B.O., Y. Akegbejo-Samsons and I.T. Omoniyi, 2008. Diet, size and reproductive biology of the silver catfish, Chrysichthys nigrodigitatus (Siluformes: Bagridae) in the Cross River, Nigeria. Revista Biologia Tropical, 56: 1785-1799.
PubMed | Direct Link |
14: Babatunde, D.O. and R. Aminu, 2004. Field Guide to Nigerian Freshwater Fishes. 2nd Edn., Federal College of Freshwater Fisheries Technology, New Bussa, Nigeria
15: Olatunde, A.A., 1989. Some aspects of the biology of Synodontis schall (Bloch-Schneider) in Zaria, Nigeria. J. Aquatic Sci., 4: 49-54.
16: Omotosho, J.S., 1993. Morphological and histological features of gonadal maturation of O. niloticus (Linn.) Trewavas. J. W. Afr. Sci. Assoc., 36: 23-36.
17: Owolabi, O.D., 2008. Dietary habits of the upside-down catfish, Synodontis membranaceous (Osteichthys: Mochokidae) in Jebba Lake, Nigeria. Rev. Biol. Trop., 56: 931-936.
18: Oymak, S.A., K. Solak and E. Unlu, 2001. Some biological characteristics of Silurus triostegus (Heckel, 1843) from Ataturk Dam Lake, Turkey. Turk. J. Zool., 25: 139-148.
Direct Link |
19: Ratty, F.J., R.M. Laurs and R.M. Kelly, 1990. Gonad morphology, histology and spermatogenesis in South Pacific Albacore Tuna, Thunnus alalunga (Scombridae). Fish. Bull. USA., 88: 207-216.
Direct Link |
20: Reed, W., J. Burchad, A.J. Hopson, J. Jennes and I. Yaro, 1967. Fish and Fisheries of Northern Nigeria. Gaskiya Corporation, Northern Nigeria, Zaria, Pages: 226
21: Shinkafi, B.A., J.K. Ipinjolu, L.A. Argungu and U. Abubakar, 2002. Length-weight relationship and fecundity of Synodontis clarias (Linnaeus) in river rima, Nigeria. J. Agric. Environ., 3: 147-154.
22: White, D.B., D.M. Wyanski and G.R. Sedberry 1998. Age, growth and reproductive biology of the blackbelly rosefish from the Carolinas, U.S.A. J. Fish. Biol., 53: 1274-1291.
CrossRef | Direct Link |