Variability, Heritability and Genetic Advance for Some Yield and Yield Related Traits in Ethiopian Barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) Landraces and Crosses
The aim of this study was to find out variability, heritability and genetic advance for some yield and yield related traits in Ethiopian Barley. Thirty six barley landraces and crosses were tested at three locations in Bale highlands of Southeast of Ethiopia in 6x6 simple lattice design with two replications during 2006 Bona (July-December) cropping season. Variances component method was used to estimate variability, broad sense heritability and genetic advance of yield and some yield related characters. Statistically, significant (p<0.01) variation was observed among materials tested for important quantitative traits across locations indicating the presence of variability. In addition, Genotypic Coefficient of Variability (GCV) and Phenotypic Coefficient of Variability (PCV) was relatively higher for grain yield per plot (20.13, 23.27%), number of kernels per spike (18.30, 20.70%) and spike weight (11.80, 15.20%), respectively, across locations. And relatively high heritability was obtained for spike length (0.868) followed by thousand kernel weight (0.856), number of kernels per spike (0.785), grain yield per plot (0.714) across locations showing better condition for effective selection in these characters. This implies the presence of more additive gene effects for potential crop improvement. Beside this, high genetic advance was observed for spike length, number of kernels per spike and thousand-kernel weight. These indicate that there is good scope for crop improvement through selection. This study revealed that greater yield response could be obtained through direct selection scheme in barley landraces and crosses tested. This may be the nature of landraces with better adaptive traits to variable environmental factors which has paramount importance for the local farmers to reduce risk.
Barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) belongs to the genus Hordeum, in
tribe Triticeae of the family Poaceae (Gramineae) (Von Bothmer
et al., 1995; Kling and Hayes, 2004). Ethiopia
is considered as center of diversity for food barley crop (Firdissa
et al., 2010). It is one of the major cereal crop produced on about
1.1 million hectares producing annual production of 1.3 million tons (CSA,
2005). Lack of improved varieties, disease, insect, pest problem, weed competition
and poor soil fertility has been indicated as major constraints in barley improvement
(Birhane et al., 1996). The presence of long
history of cultivation of barley crop, wide ecological and cultural diversity
in Ethiopia has resulted in a large number of landraces which can adapt to various
environmental conditions (Asfaw, 2000).
Creation of genetic variability and selection for important traits is crucial
activities that any plant breeder should apply to achieve better yield and other
desirable agronomic traits. However, to carry out effective selection, the information
on available genetic variation among barley genotypes, the nature of component
traits on which selection would be effective and the influence of environmental
factors on each trait need to be known. There is no literature available in
this regard in the study area where barley is the second major food crop and
farmers commonly use their landraces. Thus, effective selection not only depends
on estimation of genetic variation among genotypes but also on the proportion
of heritable variation and the expected genetic gain that would be obtained.
Variation is the basis for plant breeding and it is the occurrence of differences
between individuals due to variation in their genetic composition and/or the
environment in which they are grown (Falconer and Mackay, 1996;
Singh, 2000). Heritable variation is useful for permanent
genetic improvement (Singh, 2000). A major factor limiting
the rate of progress in plant breeding has been low heritability of quantitative
traits such as yield. Heritability in broad sense estimates the ratio of total
genetic variance, including additive, dominance and epistatic variance to the
phenotypic variance (Falconer and Mackay, 1996; Raiz
and Chowdhry, 2003). The most important function of the heritability in
the genetic study of quantitative characters is its predictive role to indicate
the reliability of the phenotypic value as a guide to breeding value (Falconer
and Mackay, 1996; Dabholkar, 1992). Characters not
greatly influenced by the environment usually have a high heritability. This
may influence the choice of selection procedure used by the plant breeder to
decide which selection method would be most useful to improve the character
to predict gain from selection and to determine the relative importance of genetic
effects (Poehlman and Sleper, 1995). The magnitude of components
of variances has been obtained from analysis of variance to estimate the different
genetic parameters as described by Burton and de vane (1953),
Dabholkar (1992), Falconer and Mackay
(1996) and Singh, 2000. Variability studies have been
reported by Alemayehu, (2005) on Ethiopian landraces
and Jaradat et al. (2004) for thousand kernel
weight (0.769) and spike length (0.782) in barley population. On the other hand,
heritability estimates were also reported in barley by Singh
and Ceccarelli (1995) and Vimal and Vishwakarma (1998).
Landraces represent over 90% of the barley cultivated in Ethiopia (Tanto
et al., 2010). Ethiopian barley landraces are reported to have better
adaptation and useful traits like vigorous seedling establishment, high tillering
capacity, quick grain filling period, high seed weight and resistance to shoot
fly, aphids and frost (Birhane et al., 1996;
Hailu et al., 1996).As grain yield is a complex
product of many yield components and has low heritability, direct selection
for yield may not be sufficiently effective (Singh, 2000;
Raiz and Chowdhry, 2003). However, to design an effective
selection strategy for the utilization of the existing breeding materials, the
knowledge on the extent of variation, heritability of the trait and genetic
gain is important. Therefore, this study was conducted with the following objectives:
||To estimate the extent of genetic variability, heritability
and expected genetic advance existing in this barley landraces and crosses
||To suggest an effective or better selection scheme that could be useful
in barley landrace improvement program
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Breeding materials and testing sites: Thirty six advanced barley landraces
and crosses were planted in Bale highlands at Agarfa, Robe and Sinana locations
in the southeast of Ethiopia during 2006 Bona (August-December) cropping season.
Seven of these barley lines were developed from local crossing, whereas, the
other materials were landraces developed in barley landrace enhancement programs
(Table 1). These evaluation sites are characterized by bimodal
rainfall with two cropping seasons; the Bona season extends from August
to December; and the Ganna season extends from March to July. The average rainfall
of Bona ranges from 270-560 mm and that of Ganna ranges from 250-560 mm. Agarfa
is located at 460 km in the south east of Addis Ababa which is 38° 40
to 46° 3 E longitude and 4° to 8o 11 N
latitude with the altitude of 2350 meters above sea level (m.a.s.l).
|| Description of breeding materials used in the experiment
|NA: Not available, m.a.s.l: Meter above sea level,*: Line
obtained from crossing in barley breeding program at sinana agricultural
The annual temperature ranges from a minimum of 5.5 to 8.7°C to a maximum
of 17.5 to 32°C. In addition, the mean annual rainfall varies from 800 to
1000 mm and the soil type is Cambisol. On the other hand, Sinana is located
at 07° 07N latitude and 40° 10E latitude (Geremew
et al., 1998) with 2400 m.a.s.l and 463 km from Addis Ababa. Average
annual minimum and maximum temperature of Sinana is 9 and 21°C, respectively
and the soil is with light clay type. Robe site is situated nearest to Robe
(main town) which have somewhat similar climatic, topographic and edaphic conditions
Experimental design and agronomic practices: Barley seeds were planted in 3 m2 plot area of six rows with 20 cm spacing between rows and of 2.5 m length in 6x6 simple lattice design with two replications at each location during 2006 Bona season. Recommended rate of 125 kg ha-1 barley seeds and 50 kg ha-1 DAP (Di-Ammonium Phosphate) fertilizer was used. Planting was conducted in mid August 2006 during Bona rainy season. Data was collected from the central four rows. The normal crop management and cultural practices were carried out uniformly at all locations.
Data collection and statistical analysis: Data was recorded on eighteen
characters on plot and plant basis, however, test of homogeneity of error variance
showed that the error mean squares were homogeneous only for the following eight
characters such as number of spikelets per spike, spike length, spike weight,
number of kernels per spike, biomass yield per plant, days to maturity, thousand
kernel-weight and grain yield per plot for which combined analysis of variance
was done (Table 2). Data were recorded on plot basis for days
to maturity, grain yield per plot and thousand kernel weight, while, the other
characters were taken on plant basis by considering an average of ten randomly
sampled plants from each plot. Analysis of variance was done after subjecting
mean values of the recorded data to MSTATC (Freed et al.,
1988). Since the relative efficiency of lattice design was very similar
with randomized complete block (RCB) design so that for the flexibility of lattice
design (Cochran and Cox, 1957) data were analyzed as per
The phenotypic (δ2p) and genotypic (δ2g) variances
were estimated according to the method suggested by Burton
and de vane (1953) whereas, broad sense heritability (h2) was
estimated following Allard (1960) as:
||Combined analysis of variance, heritability and genetic advance
(GA) for number of spikelets per spike (NSPK), spike length (SPL), spike
weight (SPW), number of kernels per spike (NK), biomass yield per plant
(BM/pl),days to maturity(DM), thousand kernel weight (TKW) and grain yield
per plot (GY/P) studied in barley landraces and crosses across locations
(Sinana, Robe and Agarfa) in Bale during 2006 Bona cropping season
|*,**Significance test at 0.05 and 0.01 level, respectively,
ns: Non significant, CV: Coefficient of variation, SE: Standard error
and Genetic advance (GA) was calculated in accordance with the methods illustrated
by Johnson et al. (1955) as:
where, K is the standardized selection differential at 5% selection intensity (K = 2.063).
Combined analysis of variance across locations showed that there was significant (p<0.01) variation among barley landraces and crosses tested for all characters considered. On the other hand, genotype x environment interaction revealed significant (p<0.01) difference only for grain yield per plot, thousand kernel weight and number of kernels per spike (Table 2). Overall mean grain yield for genotypes ranged from 1.1 to 2.6 t ha-1 (data not shown). Aruso/EH/956 F2 8H-6-4 SNR FBC 99G 0003-21 advanced line which was obtained from crossing gave the highest mean grain yield (2.6 t ha-1), whereas, Aruso/HB42 SNR FBC 99B 0003-9 and Acc.1718-15 barley lines gave the lowest mean grain yield per (1.1 t ha-1). When the different rowed types were compared, the six and two rowed types showed different response for some characters such that six rowed barleys tended to produce higher mean grain yield per plot, grain yield per plant, number of kernels per plant and spike weight. As opposed to this, lowest mean values were recorded for thousand kernel weight and spike length in six rowed barleys. Whereas, two rowed barleys tended to give highest values for thousand kernel weight and spike length but low values were obtained for number of kernels per plant and spike weight (data not shown).
Phenotypic Coefficient of Variability (PCV) and Genotypic Coefficient of Variation (GCV) across locations was relatively high for grain yield per plot (23.27, 19.50%), number of kernels per spike (20.70, 18.30%), biomass yield per plant (22.10, 14.20%) and spike weight (15.20, 11.80%) (Table 3), respectively. On the other hand, days to maturity showed very minimum GCV (0.90%) and PCV (1.30%) values across locations.
||Estimates of genotypic, phenotypic, and environmental coefficient
of variability for number of spikelets per spike (NSPK), spike length (SPL),
spike weight (SPW), number of kernels per spike (NK), biomass yield per
plant (BM/pl),days to maturity (DM), thousand kernel weight (TKW) and grain
yield per plot (GY/P) studied in barley landraces and crosses at Sinana
, Robe, Agarfa and across locations in 2006 Bona cropping season
|GCV: Genotypic coefficient of variability (%), PCV: Phenotypic
coefficient of variability (%) and ECV: environmental coefficient of variability
Broad sense heritability and expected genetic advance (at 5% selection intensity)
was estimated across locations for all agronomic traits considered (Table
2). Therefore, for pooled analysis, heritability ranged from 0.401 to 0.868.
It was high for spike length (0.868) which was followed by thousand kernel weight
(0.856), number of kernels per spike (0.785), grain yield per plot (0.714),
spike weight (0.600), days to maturity (0.461), biomass yield per plant (0.413)
and number of spikelets per spike (0.401).
Genetic Advance (GA) was relatively high for spike length (15.59) and number of kernels per spike (11.27) and thousand kernel weight (5.71) and this was coupled with high heritability (Table 2).
Ethiopian barley landraces are contributing as major sources of genes in barley crop improvement which has many advantages than exotics. In crop genetic improvement, breeding gain requires heritable variation in important agronomic characters of the crop. Therefore, the available genetic variation, heritability and expected genetic gain in important agronomic characters are useful to design better effective breeding strategies in barley landraces.
The presence of significant (p<0.01) variation among barley landraces and
crosses for all characters considered implies that there is high variability
among genotypes tested. Genotype x environment interaction revealed significant
(p<0.01) difference only for grain yield per plot, thousand kernel weight
and number of kernels per spike (Table 2) indicating barley
genotype and crosses showed inconsistent performances across locations for these
characters. Similarly, Ceccarelli, (1989), Ceccarelli
and Grando (1991), Jackson et al. (1993)
and Van Oosterom et al. (1993) reported genotype-environment
interaction in barley for grain yield. The presence of difference in yield performance
of the six and two rowed types may be considered during selection. The maximum
yield was obtained from the advanced line, Aruso/EH/956 F2 8H-6-4
SNR FBC 99G 0003-21 (2.6 t ha-1) which was developed through crossing
with Aruso (local) in landrace enhancement program. This indicates the requirement
of crossing program with landraces as one option to improve barley yield.
Phenotypic Coefficient of Variability (PCV) and Genotypic Coefficient of Variation
(GCV) across locations was relatively high for grain yield per plot, number
of kernels per spike, biomass yield per plant and spike weight (Table
3). In addition to this, these characters were accompanied by high heritability
(Table 2) expressing the presence of more additive gene effects
for possible improvement. Days to maturity showed the least variable trait.
Generally, the differences between phenotypic and genotypic coefficient of variability
for all the corresponding characters was small indicating that these characters
were less influenced by the environment. Most of the research reports on major
crop species indicate that genetic variability of important agronomic traits
is predominantly additive genetic variance, while the non-additive genetic variance
is generally smaller than the additive genetic variance (Moll
and Stuber, 1974). Genotypic coefficient of variability estimate gives good
implication for genetic potential in crop improvement through selection (Johnson
et al., 1955). For all characters measured, PCV value was greater
than GCV. The result of genotypic and phenotypic coefficients of variation obtained
suggests that there is a good scope for yield improvement through phenotypic
selection for grain yield per plot, number of kernels per spike, spike weight
and biomass yield per plant. In other reports, Singh et
al. (1986) found small PCV for days to maturity. Progress from selection
depends on genetic variability existing in the population and selection is more
effective when the genetic variation in relation to environmental variation
is high (Allard, 1960; Poehlman and Sleeper,
1995). The genetic effects are not independent of non-genetic effects (Moll
and Stuber, 1974) in crop improvement. In this study, comparably the contribution
of non-genetic factors was small for important quantitative traits such as grain
yield per plot, thousand kernel weight and number of kernels per spike.
Heritability (broad sense) was high for all important quantitative characters
measured Dabholkar (1992) classified heritability estimates
as low (5-10%), medium (10-30%) and high (>30%). Accordingly, all of the
agronomic characters considered for analysis showed high heritability constituting
high breeding value which has more additive genetic effects which is important
for crop improvement. In similar study, Rytger et al.
(1967) reported smaller heritability for grain yield than this result. Singh
and Ceccarelli (1995) found smaller heritability than this report for grain
yield in F6 barley crosses conducted at Atlas, Tel Hadya, Berda and
Bouider in Syria. In another report, Singh et al.
(1986) also found heritability estimates for thousand kernel weight and
spike length which is relatively lower as compared to this report. While, Vimal
and Vishwakarma (1998) reported higher heritability for spike length, grain
yield and number of spikelets per spike. Low heritability was reported by Ceccarelli
(1994), Ceccarelli (1996) on barley in low yielding
environments. Atlin and Frey (1990) also concluded that
heritability in low yielding environment is lower than high yielding environment
in Oat (Avena sativa L.) and Abdelmula et al.(1999)
found similar value in Faba bean (Vicia faba L.). Because, the magnitude
of heritability is affected by the type of genetic material, character to be
measured and environmental conditions to which the individuals are subjected
(Dabholkar, 1992; Falconer and Mackay,
1996). In this study, the heritability estimate is relatively high may be
due to conducive rainfall and other environmental conditions including the adaptability
of barley landraces and crosses used. In characters with highest heritability,
phenotypic is a good index of genotypic merit; so that genetic gain can be made
easily through selection (Johnson and Frey, 1967).
Genetic advance (GA) was relatively high for spike length (15.59) and number
of kernels per spike (11.27) and thousand kernel weight (5.71) and this was
coupled with high heritability (Table 2). According to Johnson
et al.(1955), characters with high heritability accompanied with
high genetic advance also result in better genetic gain through selection as
high heritability will not always be associated with high genetic advance (Amin
et al., 1992). Beside this, high heritability coupled with high genetic
coefficient of variation estimates also gives a reliable estimate of the amount
of genetic advance through phenotypic selection (Burton,
1952) which indicates the effectiveness with which selection of genotypes
can be based on phenotypic performance (Johnson et al.,
This result demonstrates that there exist variability among barley landraces and crosses tested for important quantitative traits indicating high potential for effective crop improvement and/or for further manipulation of the genetic resources through breeding as Ethiopian landraces are good sources of genes for many desirable traits. The advanced line, Aruso/EH/956 F2 8H-6-4 SNR FBC 99G 0003-21 which was obtained from barley crossing gave highest grain yield (2.6 t ha-1) which is encouraging and showed the possibility of improvement of landraces through crossing. High heritability values obtained for most of quantitative traits in this study indicate the presence of high yielding condition during testing. In general, the study revealed that direct selection scheme would be more promising and encouraging than indirect selection for improving yield. This could be the nature of landraces because of their better adaptive traits to variable environmental conditions which have important implications for sustainable crop production.
The authors thank the Oromia Agricultural Research Institute: Sinana Agricultural Research Center for their financial assistance to carryout the experiment. Amare Biftu and Tilahun Bayisa are also acknowledged for their technical support in field data collection.
1: Abdelmula, A.A., W. Link, E. Von Kittlitz and D. Stelling, 1999. Hetrosis and inheritance of drought tolerance in faba bean, Vicia faba L. Plant Breed., 118: 485-490.
Direct Link |
2: Asfaw, Z., 2000. The Barleys of Ethiopia. In: Genes in the Field: On-Farm Conservation of Crop Diversity, Brush, S.B. (Ed.). Lewis Publisher, Boca Raton, Florida, USA., pp: 77-108.
3: Allard, R.W., 1960. Principle of Plant Breeding. John Wiley and Sons Inc., New York, USA.
4: Alemayehu, A., 2005. Biochemical and morphological variation among barley landraces. Afr. Crop Sci. J., 13: 227-238.
Direct Link |
5: Atlin, G.N. and K.J. Frey, 1990. Selecting oat lines for yield in low-productivity environments. Crop Sci., 30: 556-561.
6: Amin, M.R., N.C.D. Barma and M.A. Razzaque, 1992. Variability, heritability, genetic advance and correlation study in some quantitative characters in durum wheat. Rachis, 11: 30-32.
7: Birhane, L., G. Hailu and A. Fekadu, 1996. Barley production in Ethiopia. Barley research in Ethiopia: Past work and future prospects. Proceedings of the 1st Barley Research Review Workshop, Oct. 16-19, Addis Ababa, pp: 1-8.
8: Von Bothmer, R., N. Jacobsen, C. Baden, R.B. Jargensen and I. Linde-Laursen, 1995. An Ecogeographical Study of the Genus Hordeum. 2nd Edn., International Plant Genetic Resources, Rome.
9: Burton, G.W., 1952. Quantitative inheritance in grasses. Proc. Int. Grassland Congr., 1: 277-283.
10: Burton, W.G. and E.H. Devane, 1953. Estimating heritability in tall fescue (Festuca arundinacea) from replicated clonal material. Agron. J., 45: 478-481.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
11: Ceccarelli, S., 1989. Wide adaptation: How wide. Euphytica, 40: 197-205.
Direct Link |
12: Ceccarelli, S. and S. Grando, 1991. Selection environment and environmental sensitivity in barley. Euphytica, 57: 157-167.
Direct Link |
13: Ceccarelli, S., 1994. Specific adaptation and breeding for marginal conditions. Euphytica, 77: 205-219.
14: Ceccarelli, S., 1996. Adaptation to low or high input cultivation. Euphytica, 92: 203-214.
Direct Link |
15: Cochran, W.G. and G.M. Cox, 1957. Experimental Designs. 2nd Edn., John Wiley and Sons Inc., New York, USA., Pages: 611.
16: CSA, 2005. Federal democratic republic Ethiopia: Central statistics authority, agricultural sample survey 2004. Report on Area and Production of Crops (Private Peasant Holdings, Meher Season) Statistical Bulletin 331, Addis Ababa, May, 2005, pp: 1-48.
17: Dabholkar, A.R., 1992. Elements of Biometrical Genetics. Concept Publishing Company, New Delhi, India, pp: 138-140.
18: Falconer, D.S. and T.F.C. Mackay, 1996. Introduction to Quantitative Genetics. 4th Edn., Benjamin Cummings, London, UK., ISBN-13: 9780582243026, Pages: 464.
19: Firdissa, E., W. Sinebo and G. Heinrich, 2010. On-farm diversity and characterization of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) landraces in the highlands of West Shewa, Ethiopia. J. Plants People Applied Res., 8: 25-34.
Direct Link |
20: Geremew, E., G. Tilahun and H. Aliye, 1998. A Decade of Research Experience. Oromia Agricultural Development Bureau, Finfinne, Ethiopia, pp: 55.
21: Hailu, G., L. Birhane, F. Fekadu, B. Birhanu, A. Fekadu and G. Tesfaye, 1996. Food barley breeding. Barley research in Ethiopia: Past work and future prospects. Proceedings of the 1st Barley Research Review Workshop, October 16-19, 1996, Addis Ababa, pp: 9-23.
22: Jackson, P.A., D.E. Byth, R.P. Johnston and K.S. Fischer, 1993. Genotype x environment interactions in progeny from a barley cross. 1. Patterns of response among progeny genotypes for grain yield and time to anthesis. Aust. J. Exp. Agric., 33: 619-627.
Direct Link |
23: Jaradat, A.A., M. Shahid and A. Al-Maskri, 2004. Genetic diversity in the Batini barley landrace from Oman: I. Spike and seed quantitative and qualitative traits. Crop Sci., 44: 304-315.
Direct Link |
24: Johnson, G.R. and K.J. Frey, 1967. Heritability of quantitative attributes of Oats at varying levels of environmental stress. Crop Sci., 7: 43-46.
Direct Link |
25: Johnson, H.W., H.F. Robinson and R.E. Comstock, 1955. Estimation of genetic and environmental variability in soybeans. Agron. J., 47: 314-318.
26: Kling, J.G. and P.M. Hayes, 2004. Barley Genetics and Breeding. Encyclopedia of Grain Science, USA., pp: 27-37.
27: Moll, R.H. and C.W. Stuber, 1974. Quantitative genetics-emperical results revant to plant breeding. Adv. Agron., 26: 277-313.
28: Poehlman, J.M. and D.A. Sleper, 1995. Breeding Field Crops. 4th Edn., Panima Publishing Corporation, New Delhi.
29: Riaz, R. and M.A. Chowdhry, 2003. Estimation of variation and heritability of some physio-morphic traits of wheat under drought condition. Asian J. Plant Sci., 2: 748-755.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
30: Rytger, J.N., C.W. Schaller and A.D. Dickson, 1967. Variation and covariation in agronomic and malting quality characters in barley. II. Interrelation of characters. Crop Sci., 7: 325-326.
Direct Link |
31: Singh, M. and S. Ceccarelli, 1995. Estimation of heritability using varietal trials data from incomplete blocks. Theor. Applied Genet., 90: 142-145.
Direct Link |
32: Singh, B.D., 1990. Plant Breeding: Principles and Methods. Kalyani Publishers, New Delhi, India.
33: Singh, S., S. Mahabalram and D.P. Singh, 1986. Agronomic traits contributing to drought tolerance in husk less barley. Rachis, 5: 12-13.
34: Vimal, S.C. and S.R. Vishwakarma, 1998. Heritability and genetic advance in barley under partially reclaimed saline sodic soil. Rachis, 17: 56-61.
35: Van Oosterom, E.J., D. Klejin, S. Ceccarelli and M.M. Nachit, 1993. Genotype by environment interactions of barley in the Mediterranean region. Crop Sci., 33: 669-674.
36: Freed, R.D., S.P. Eisensmith, E.H. Everson, M. Weber, E. Paul and D. Islcib, 1988. MSTATC: Version 2.10. Michigan State University, USA.
37: Tanto, T., D. Rau, E. Bitocchi and R. Papa, 2010. Adaptation and diversity along an altitudinal gradient in Ethiopian barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) landraces revealed by molecular analysis. BMC Plant Biol., 10: 121-121.