Some of the Egyptian dairy products are made by traditional methods. This makes them suitable media for multiplication of foodborne pathogens. So, this study aims to assess the microbial quality of selected dairy products prevalent in Ismailia City, the personal hygiene of dairy handlers and the potential hazards to consumers. A total of 120 Ras cheese, Kareish cheese and ice cream samples were collected randomly from different localities in Ismailia city. In addition, 40 nasal and hand swab samples were collected from some dairy workers. All samples were examined for presence of Staphylococcus aureus (on Baird Parker agar medium) and Enterobacteriaceae sp. (on Violet Red Bile Glucose agar medium). Molecular typing of S. aureus was performed using PCR Assay. The prevalence and significance of Staphylococcus aureus and Enterobacteriaceae species in Ras cheese, Kareish cheese and ice cream samples and in swabs of dairy handlers in Ismailia city were studied. The results of this study revealed out that the mean values of S. aureus counts (log10 cfu g-1) in Ras cheese was 5.54, in Kareish cheese was 5.59 and in ice cream samples was 4.07. Meanwhile, the mean values of Enterobacteriaceae sp. counts (log10 cfu g-1) in Ras cheese was 2.48, in Kareish cheese was 6.78 and in ice cream was 1.11. Salmonella could not be recovered in the examined dairy products. Staphylococcus aureus was isolated from 60 and 70% of dairy handlers hand's and nasal swab samples, respectively. Only one Salmonella strain was recovered from a dairy handler swab. Overall, the recovered E. coli serotypes from all the examined samples were O15:H11, O22:H5, O25: NM, O26:H11, O86:H34, O91:H10, O113:H21, O114:H2, O119:H6, O124:H7, O128:H2, O127:NM and O145:NM. In conclusion, the isolated serotypes constitute public health hazards to consumers.
PDF Abstract XML References Citation
How to cite this article
Ras cheese, Kareish cheese and ice-cream are considered the most popular Egyptian dairy products. Their manufacture and handling techniques in Egyptian markets are still primitive and unhygienic (Al-Ashmawy et al., 1994; Enas and Asmaa, 2001). Many contaminants find their way to raw milk, from which they gain access to dairy products (Joshi et al., 2004; Al-Khatib and Al-Mitwalli, 2009; Shathele, 2009; Sospedra et al., 2009; Zeinab et al., 2009).
Foodborne diseases are a common and widespread global problem. Several outbreaks have been reported as a result of eating contaminated dairy food that may look, taste and smell perfectly normal but is in fact contaminated with large number of harmful bacteria (CDC, 2009).
Staphylococci are expected to be among the organisms that contaminate dairy products from handlers. Under favorable conditions, Staphylococci can grow and secrete heat resistant enterotoxins which cause vomiting and diarrhea within 30 min to 8 h after ingestion of incriminated foods.
Enterobacteriaceae sp. have been implicated in many cases of food poisoning outbreaks (Koneman et al., 1994). Escherichia coli is an important organism in the microbiology of the food, besides being involved in foodborne gastroenteritis, it is considered a good indicator of possible fecal contamination of dairy products (El-Bagoury and Mosaad, 2002).
Salmonella is considered among the most important enteric foodborne pathogen whose presence in the food constitutes a severe health hazard. Many outbreaks of human illness have been associated with the consumption of raw or inadequately heat treated milk or their dairy products (Ellis et al., 1998).
Therefore, the objectives of the present study were designed to determine the prevalence and public health significance of S. aureus and Enterobacteriaceae sp. in Ras cheese, Kareish cheese, ice-cream samples and in swabs from dairy handlers.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Collection of the Samples
One hundred and twenty samples (40 samples each) of Ras cheese (250 g chilled in plastic bags), Kareish cheese (100 g in plastic bags from street vendors) and ice-cream (frozen in plastic cups, about 100 g) were obtained from different markets in Ismailia city. In addition, forty nasal and hand swab samples (20 samples each) were collected from dairy handlers. Each swab was put into a sterile tube containing 9 mL of sterile saline. Samples were transferred promptly to the laboratory in an ice-box for microbiological examination. The study was conducted during the period from September, 2008 to May, 2009 at the bacteriological laboratory of Food Hygiene Department, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Suez Canal University, Egypt.
Preparation of the Samples
The technique recommended by APHA (1992) was used for sample preparation. Twenty five grams of each cheese sample were aseptically added to 225 mL of sterile 2% sodium citrate solution and then blended in stomacher for 2 min to form a dilution of 1:10. Samples of ice-cream were thawed in a thermostatically controlled water bath at 44°C for not more than 15 min. Then, 25 g of each sample were aseptically mixed with 225 mL of 0.1% peptone water to form a dilution of 1:10. Tenth-fold serial dilutions were prepared using sterile 0.1% peptone water.
Staphylococcus aureus was determined on Baird Parker agar medium (Oxoid), incubated at 37°C for 48 h according to APHA (1992). Enterobacteriaceae sp. were enumerated on Violet Red Bile Glucose agar medium (Oxoid), incubated at 37°C for 48 h according to APHA (1992). Salmonella and E. coli were recovered according to technique of USFDA (2001).
|Table 1:|| |
Sequence and nucleotide positions of Staphylococcus aureus primers
Molecular Typing of S. aureus by PCR Assay
DNA template was prepared according to Sambrook et al. (1989). Identified colonies of S. aureus were subjected to DNA extraction by boiling method, a loopful of bacterial colony was suspended in 100 μL of PBS, Centrifugation occurred at 3000 rpm for 5 min, bacterial pellet was then dissolved in 100 μL of PBS and subjected to heating in a boiling water bath at 100°C for 10 min, then centrifugation at 13000 rpm for 15 min, the supernatant was transferred into a new sterile tube. The DNA purity and concentration were measured by spectrophotometer (Davis et al., 1986).
Oligonucleotide Primers (Monday and Bohach, 1999)
The sequences of the 16S rRNA from S. aureus were retrieved from GenBank (accession No. X68417). The oligonucleotide primers were designed by alignment of published DNA sequences of the S. aureus using Multian program (Corpet, 1988). Primers were purchased from the Biobasic Inc., Canada. The sequences and nucleotide positions of both forward and reverse primers were summarized in Table 1. These primers amplified a 228 bp amplicon from S. aureus.
Polymerase Chain Reaction
DNA samples (100 ng per reaction) were amplified in a 25 μL reaction mixture consisting of 1.5 unit Taq polymerase (Sibenzyme, Russia), 1 X TAQ polymerase buffer, 200 μM of dNTPs mixture, 20 pmole of each primers and sterile distilled water up to 25 μL. Amplification was performed in thermal cycler (Techne Progene, UK). Parameters for amplification included an initial denaturation at 95°C for 5 min, followed by 30 cycles of denaturation at 95°C for 30 sec, annealing at 64°C for 30 sec and extension at 72°C for 30 sec, followed by a final extension at 72°C for 5 min. Amplified products were separated by electrophoresis in a 1.7% agarose gel (Biobasic) stained by ethidium bromide (0.5 μg mL-1), in 1 X TAE buffer at constant voltage of 4 v cm-1 and photographed with Sony digital camera. A 100 bp DNA marker (Axygen) was used as a DNA molecular size standard (Sharma et al., 2000).
Chi square test was performed to analyze the epidemiologic data by using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences SPSS (version 10.0 for Windows; SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL. USA) and a p-value <0.05 was considered significant (Landau and Everitt, 2003).
Staphylococcus aureus and Enterobacteriaceae sp. in Examined Samples
It was clear in Table 2 that there was a highly significant difference (χ2 = 14, p<0.001) in the prevalence rates of S. aureus between the examined dairy product samples. The prevalence of S. aureus was 85% in Kareish cheese samples, followed by Ras cheese samples (80%) then ice-cream samples (50%). The mean values of S. aureus counts (log10 cfu g-1) in Ras cheese was 5.54, in Kareish cheese was 5.59 and in ice cream samples was 4.07. The prevalence rates of S. aureus in hand and nasal swabs collected from dairy handlers were 60 and 70%, respectively (Table 5).
|Table 2:||Prevalence and counts (log10 cfu g-1) of S. aureus and Enterobacteriaceae sp. in examined dairy products|
|No.: Number of positive samples (χ2 = 14, p<0.001)|
|Table 3:||Prevalence of Enterobacteriaceae sp. in examined samples|
|No.: Number of positive samples|
The prevalence of Enterobacteriaceae sp. was 100% in Kareish cheese samples, followed by Ras cheese samples (95%) then ice-cream samples (75%). The mean values of Enterobacteriaceae counts (log10 cfu g-1) in Ras cheese was 2.48, in Kareish cheese was 6.78 and in ice cream was 1.11.
Significance of the Isolated Enterobacteriaceae sp.
A total of 82 strains of the family Enterobacteriaceae were recovered from dairy products and handlers (Table 3, 4). The results showed that 7 (29.2%), 4 (44.4%), 7 (31.8%) and 12 (44.4%) strains of E. coli were recovered from Ras cheese, Kareish cheese, ice-cream and hand swab samples, respectively. Serotypes isolated from Ras cheese belonged to the STEC group (O22:H5, O91:H10 and O113: H21), the ETEC group (O15:H11) and 2 untypable strains. Serotypes isolated from Kareish cheese belonged to the STEC group (O128:H2), EPEC (O127:NM), EIEC group (O124:H7) and one untypable strain. Serotypes isolated from ice-cream belonged to the STEC group (O26:H11, O145:NM), EPEC group (O86:H34, O119:H6) and one untypable strain. Serotypes detected in hand swabs belonged to the STEC/EHEC group (O26:H11), EPEC group (O86:H36, O114:H2 and O119:H6), ETEC group (O25:NM) and EIEC group (O124:H7).
Other members of Enterobacteriaceae sp. were identified from the examined dairy products and hand swabs of dairy handlers (Table 3). Salmonella could not be isolated from the examined Ras cheese, Kareish cheese and ice-cream samples. Only one sample taken from a dairy handler confirmed the presence of Salmonella sp.
Molecular Typing of S. aureus Isolates
PCR protocol was used for amplification and detection of 16S rRNA genes of S. aureus isolates. Figure 1 illustrated the positive amplification of 228 bp fragment of 16S rRNA gene from the extracted DNA of S. aureus strains isolated from different sources.
|Table 4:||Prevalence of E. coli serotypes in relation to total number of E. coli isolates|
|No.: Number of positive samples, EHEC/STEC: Enterohemorrhagic E. coli/Shiga toxin producing E. coli, EPEC: Enteropathogenic E. coli, ETEC: Enterotoxigenic E. coli, EIEC: Enteroinvasive E. coli|
|Table 5:||Prevalence of S. aureus in swabs of dairy handlers|
|+: Positive, -: Negative, N: Number of corresponding items|
|Fig. 1:|| |
Agarose gel electrophoresis pattern of 16S rRNA: 228 bp specific PCR product amplified with the forward and reverse primers, M: DNA molecular weight ladder (100 bp), Lane 1: Control positive Staphylococcus aureus strain, Lane 2: Control negative, Lane 3-9: Positive samples
It was clear that the mean value of S. aureus counts in the examined Ras cheese samples was log10 5.54 cfu g-1. Nazem and Thanaa (1993) recorded that the min., max. and mean counts of S. aureus in Ras cheese were 1x102, 8.8x104 and 2.4x104 cfu g-1, respectively. On the other hand, Al-Hawary et al. (2002) found that Staphylococcus aureus count ranged from 1x102 to 5.4x107 cfu g-1.
In the current study, Staphylococcus aureus was detected in 85% of examined Kareish cheese samples. This result was higher than that reported by Kaldes (1997) and Azza et al. (2004) who reported that the prevalence rates of Staphylococcus aureus were 10 and 11.25% in fresh Kareish cheese samples, respectively. In addition, Bahout and Moustafa (2006) reported that Staphylococcus aureus was present in 28% of the examined Kareish cheese samples with min., max and mean counts of 1.1x102, 6.5x105 and 3.4x104 cfu g-1, respectively.
In this study, Staphylococcus aureus was detected in 50% of examined ice cream samples. Azza et al. (2002) isolated Staphylococcus aureus from 100% of examined ice cream samples, the min., max. and mean counts were 9x103, 2.8x106 and 6.8x105 cfu g-1, respectively. The high count of Staphylococcus aureus is indicative of poor hygienic measures during production, handling and distribution (Vought and Tatini, 1998; Joshi et al., 2004). The difference in the prevalence rates of S. aureus between the examined products may originate from the method of manufacture, storage and handling. Kareish cheese is made by farmers from raw milk that is not subjected to heat treatment. Street vendors put Kareish cheese in pans exposed to dust and flies. The lowest prevalence rate of S. aureus which was recorded in ice-cream might be attributed to the effect of freezing which inhibits the multiplication of this microorganism.
The growth of S. aureus in food represents a potential public health hazard since many strains of S. aureus produce heat resistant enterotoxins. Outbreaks of food poisoning occur when contaminated food is held at inappropriate temperature long enough to allow the bacteria to grow and release toxins (Adesiyun et al., 1998). Present study revealed out that the prevalence rates of S. aureus in hand and nasal swabs collected from dairy handlers were 60 and 70%, respectively. Food handlers are usually the main contamination source in food poisoning outbreaks through, skin, mouth, nose, respiratory infections and suppurative lesions. Therefore, S. aureus is a good indicator for the personal hygiene of the factory workers (Mahari and Gashe, 1990). Therefore, thoroughly hand washing before and after food preparation should be adopted. Food handlers who have skin infection should be prohibited from handling of food.
The current study pointed out that 95% of examined Ras cheese samples yielded Enterobacteriaceae sp. These results were confirmed by Nazem and Thanaa (1993) and Al-Hawary et al. (2002). It was clear that Enterobacteriaceae sp. were recovered in 100% of the examined Kareish cheese samples. Nearly similar results were recorded in 100 and 98.8% of examined samples by Ahlam (1998) and El-Kosi (2001), respectively. The Enterobacteriaceae sp. were detected in 75% of examined ice cream samples. Similar results were reported by Mansour et al. (2000). Higher results were confirmed by Amal et al. (2001) who reported that 100% of examined ice cream samples yielded Enterobacteriaceae. Enterobacteriaceae are distributed worldwide. They have medical and economic importance. Their presence in large numbers indicates faecal contamination of food, inadequate processing and post-processing contamination (Koneman et al., 1994).
No Salmonella could be detected in the examined dairy products. This agreed with (Al-Hawary et al., 2002; Bahout and Moustafa, 2006). On the contrary, Enas and Asmaa (2001), Azza et al. (2002) and El-Bagoury and Mosaad (2002) detected Salmonella sp. in dairy products. In this study, one sample taken from a dairy handler confirmed the presence of Salmonella sp., as a potent pathogen, it should be taken seriously.
Escherichia coli is the most common species of facultative anaerobe found in the human gastrointestinal tract and the most commonly encountered pathogen in the Enterobacteriaceae family. Present result confirmed that Egyptian dairy products manufactured by traditional methods are regularly contaminated by E. coli and this agreed with (El-Essawy and Riad, 1990; Nazem and Thanaa, 1993; Kaldes, 1997; El-Kosi, 2001; El-Bagoury and Mosaad, 2002; Azza et al., 2004; Bahout and Moustafa, 2006; Sabry and Laila, 2008). Escherichia coli is the most common species of facultative anaerobe found in the human gastrointestinal tract and the most commonly encountered pathogen in the Enterobacteriaceae family. STEC/EHEC serotypes (particularly O26, O111, O128 and O103) comprise an important emerging group of zoonotic enteric pathogens of animals and humans and indeed may be more prominent than O157 (Bettelheim, 2007). In humans, some EHEC infections result in bloody or non bloody diarrhea, which may be complicated by haemorrhagic colitis and severe renal and neurological sequelae, including haemolytic uraemic syndrome (Lynn et al., 2005). EPEC are a leading cause of severe diarrhea in infants (Nguyen et al., 2006). ETEC are a major cause of travelers and childhood diarrhea worldwide (Beatty et al., 2004). EIEC have been identified as a cause of diarrhea (Estrada-Garcia et al., 2005).
The difference between our results and the previous studies may be attributed to sampling techniques, sources of samples (home or factory-made), handling of samples and types of media used.
It is considered that the S. aureus species specific PCR is useful for speeding up identification of S. aureus by replacing the current biochemical phenotypic schemes which are time consuming. Additionally, if appropriate conditions are established, direct PCR identification of S. aureus from food and clinical specimens can be performed (Jos et al., 1996).
In conclusion, our results revealed out that Egyptian Ras cheese, Kareish cheese and ice cream products sold in Ismailia city markets are contaminated with S. aureus and Enterobacteriaceae sp. These isolates constitute public health hazards to consumers. Periodical examination of dairy products to ensure safety for consumers must be practiced. The isolation of bacterial pathogens from dairy workers reflects bad hygienic standards and necessitates regular inspection of them for prevalence of foodborne pathogens. Adoption of reward and punishment policy may help to improve their hygienic standards. Overall, good quality raw materials used in product processing, adoption of Good Manufactured Practices (GMP) and strict personal hygiene are the way to ensure safety and high quality dairy products.
- Adesiyun, A.A., L.A. Webb and H.T. Romain, 1998. Prevalence and characteristics of Staphylococcus aureus strains isolated from bulk and composite milk and cattle handlers. J. Food Prot., 61: 629-632.
- Al-Ashmawy, A.M., M.A. Mansour, I.H. Amer and A.M. Abd-El-Haleem, 1994. Studies on the microbiological quality of Egyptian Kareish and Mish cheese. Zagazig Vet. J., 22: 125-132.
- Al-Khatib, I.A. and S.M. Al-Mitwalli, 2009. Microbiological quality and sample collection policy for dairy products in Ramallah and Al-Bireh district, Palestine. East Mediterranean Health J., 15: 709-716.
- Beatty, M.E., C.A. Bopp, J.G. Wells, K.D. Greene, N.D. Puhr and E.D. Mintz, 2004. Enterotoxin-producing Escherichia coli O169:H41, United States. Emerging Infect. Dis., 10: 518-521.
- Bettelheim, K.A., 2007. The non-O157 shiga-toxigenic (Verocytotoxigenic) Escherichia coli: Under-Rated pathogens. Crit. Rev. Microbiol., 33: 67-87.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 2009. Surveillance for foodborne disease outbreak, United States, 2006. Morbidity Mortality Weekly Rep., 58: 609-615.
- Corpet, F., 1988. Multiple sequence alignment with hierarchial clustering. Nucl. Acids Res., 16: 10881-10890.
- El-Essawy, H.A. and A.A.M. Riad, 1990. Incidence of coliform organisms in cream and ice-cream wirth special reference to enteropathogenic strains of Escherichia coli. Assiut Vet. Med. J., 24: 140-144.
- Ellis, A., M. Preston, A. Borczky, B. Miller and P. Stone et al., 1998. A community outbreak of Salmonella berta associated with a soft cheese product. Epidemiol. Infect., 120: 29-35.
- Jos, M.B.M., V. Vossen and H. Hofstra, 1996. DNA based typing identification and detection systems for food spoilage microorganisms: Development and implementation. Int. J. Food Microbiol., 33: 35-49.
- Lynn, R.M., S.J. O'Brien, C.M. Taylor, G.K. Adak and H. Chart et al., 2005. Childhood hemolytic uremic syndrome, United Kingdom and Ireland. Emerging Infect. Dis., 11: 590-596.
- Mahari, T. and B.A. Gashe, 1990. A survey of the microflora of raw and pasteurized milk and the sources of contamination in a milk processing plant in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. J. Dairy Res., 57: 233-238.
- Monday, S.R. and G.A. Bohach, 1999. Use of multiplex PCR to detect classical and newly described pyrogenic toxin genes in staphylococcal isolates. J. Clin. Microbiol., 37: 3411-3414.
- Nguyen, R.N., L.S. Taylor, M. Tauschek and R. Robins-Browne, 2006. Atypical enteropathogenic Escherichia coli infection and prolonged diarrhoea in children. Emerg. Infect. Dis., 12: 597-603.
- Sabry, A.H. and M.E. Laila, 2008. Informally raw milk and Kareish cheese investigation on the occurrence of toxigenic E. coli in Qena City, Egypt with emphasis on molecular characterization. Assiut Univ. Bull. Environ. Res., 11: 35-42.
- Sharma, N.K., C.D. Rees and C.R. Dodd, 2000. Development of a single-reaction multiplex PCR toxin typing assay for Staphylococcus aureus strains. Applied Environ. Microbiol., 66: 1347-1353.
- Shathele, M.S., 2009. Weather effect on bacterial mastitis in dairy cows. Int. J. Dairy Sci., 4: 57-66.
- Sospedra, I., J.V. Rubert, C. Soler, J.M. Soriano and J. Manes, 2009. Microbial contamination of milk and dairy products from restaurants in Spain. Foodborne Pathogens Dis., (In Press).
- Vought, K.J. and S.R. Tatini, 1998. Salmonella enteritidis contamination of ice cream associated with a 1994 multistate outbreak. J. Food Protect., 61: 5-10.
- Sadek, Z.I., I.M. Hosny, W.I. El-Kholy and R.K. El-Dairouty, 2009. Comparative investigations for detection of foodborne microorganisms in Egyptian hard cheese Ras using conventional and fast biochemical tests. Global Veterinaria, 3: 189-195.
gaikwad sunil manikrao Reply
this is very good research work and is very essential work done by the author(s). best wishes for future investigatiion