Effects of Calcium Salts of Palm Fatty Acids and Protected Methionine Supplementation on Milk Production and Composition and Reproductive Performances of Early Lactation Dairy Cows
M. Ben Salem
Fifty-four high producing Holstein cows in early lactation were used in a complete randomized block design to determine the effects of calcium salts of palm fatty acids and protected methionine supplementation on Dry Matter Intake (DMI), milk yield and composition and on selected reproductive parameters starting week 2 post partum through week 17 of lactation. Cows were blocked by body weight, milk production and lactation number and randomly allocated from blocks to 3 treatments. Treatments were: (1) concentrate only (Control, C) (2) control+added calcium salt (700 g/cow/day, CSFA) and (3) control+added calcium salt+protected methionine (700 g of calcium salt per cow per day containing 6% (40 g) of protected methionine, CSFAM). Cows were fed for ad libitum intake a basal diet consisting of tritical silage, rye-grass and oat hay. DMI and milk production were measured. Milk composition was determined and 4% Fat Corrected Milk (FCM) was calculated. Body condition scores were monitored every three weeks. Reproduction data were recorded and major reproductive parameters were computed. Results showed that calcium salt supplementation decreased DMI and milk protein content, but increased milk yield, FCM, milk fat content and yields of milk fat and protein. DMI decreased (p<0.05) by 1 to 1.5 kg/cow. FCM was 34.2 kg day- for the control and increased an average of 3 to 4 kg day-, respectively with fat and fat plus protected methionine supplementation. Feed efficiency was higher for cows fed the calcium salt and methionine added calcium salt diets (1.84 and 1.77 versus 1.56 kg milk kg- DM for the CSFAM, CSFA and C treatments, respectively). Percentages of milk fat were significantly higher (p<0.05) for cows fed fat added diets (36.3 and 36.1 versus 35.1 g kg- for the CSFA, CSFAM and C treatments, respectively). However, the protein content of milk was lower (p<0.05) for the calcium salt supplemented cows (30.4 versus 31.2 g kg-), but the addition of protected methionine to calcium salt did prevent the decrease in milk protein that was induced by supplemental fat alone. Yields of milk fat and protein were lower for the control cows. Body condition scores were higher for cows fed diets supplemented with fat and fat plus methionine (2.81 and 2.73 vs. 2.48 for the CSFAM, CSFA and C treatments, respectively). Supplemental fat significantly increased (p<0.05) the first service and overall 150 day conception rates and reduced the number of services per conception. The addition of methionine to calcium salts further improved these indices. Overall results suggest that the use of 700 g of calcium salts of palm fatty acids/cow/day in the concentrate supplement improves major reproductive indices and milk yield of high producing dairy cows during early lactation and that adding ruminally protected methionine to calcium salt not only helps alleviate the milk protein depression commonly observed with added fat, but further improves the performances of cows.
Dairy cows in early lactation require tremendous amount of energy to achieve high milk yield. However, typical diets fed to cows in Tunisia are based on low quality cereal forages such as oat and tritical silages and hays. Such constraint combined with the low feed intake of cows in early lactation make a big challenge to local dairy producers in meeting animal requirements. Alternative solutions are therefore required to increase the energy density of the diet. So far, the main adopted strategy was the increase in the proportion of concentrate in the ration. However, when excess amounts of cereal grains are fed to increase the energy density of the diet, fermentation may exceed the buffering capacity of the rumen, which can lead to acidosis, health problems, decreased fiber digestion and low milk fat content. Alternatively, there has been a lot of interest in feeding fat to high yielding dairy cows in many parts of the world to increase the energy density of dairy rations. Research has demonstrated that adding fat to dairy diets improves milk production and increases persistency of lactation (Moallem et al., 2000; Bojalil et al., 1998; Weiss and Wyatt, 2004; Kokkonen et al., 2004; Casper et al., 1990; Kim et al., 1991; Schingoethe and Casper, 1991). In many trials, improvements in milk production by 2 to 10% were reported in cows fed fat supplemented concentrates compared to control diets containing no fat. However, studies on the effects of fat feeding to dairy cows in Tunisia are very limited, especially its effects on milk production and on major reproductive indices. The objective of this study is to determine, under Tunisian feeding conditions, the effects of calcium salts of palm fatty acids with and without protected methionine supplementation on Dry Matter Intake (DMI), milk production and composition and on major reproductive parameters in dairy cow during early lactation.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Experimental Design and Dietary Treatments
Fifty four high producing Holstein cows in early lactation were used in
a complete randomized bloc design to determine the effects of calcium salts
of palm fatty acids and protected methionine supplementation on Dry Matter Intake
(DMI), milk yield and composition and on selected reproductive parameters starting
week 2 post partum through week 17 of lactation. The study was conducted on
a commercial large dairy herd farm in Northern Tunisa during late spring early
summer of 2005. Animals used for the experiment were kept separately from the
remaining herd. Cows were blocked by body weight, milk production and lactation
number and randomly allocated from blocks to 3 treatments. Treatments were:
(1) concentrate only (Control, C) (2) control+added calcium salt (700 g/cow/day,
CSFA) and (3) control+added calcium salt+protected methionine (700 g of calcium
salt per cow day containing 6% (40 g) of protected methionine, CSFAM). Cows
were fed for ad libitum intake a basal diet consisting of tritical silage,
rye-grass and oat hay. Ingredients and nutrient composition of the feed are
shown in Table 1. DMI and milk production were measured. Milk composition was
determined and 4% Fat Corrected Milk (FCM) was calculated. Body condition score
and body weight were monitored every three weeks using a scale from 1 (thin)
to 5 (fat) according to (Sniffen and Fergusson, 1993). Reproduction data were
recorded and major reproductive parameters were computed.
The calcium salt of palm fatty acids used in this study is commonly marked
under the name Magnapc produced by the Norel Company in Egypt (Norel, Misr).
It contains, on a dry matter basis, 87% fat and 12.5% ash of which 9.5% calcium.
While the calcium salt plus protected methionine is 80 fat, 13.5 of ash of which
9.3 calcium and 6.5% protected methionine. Their relative contents of net energy
of lactation is 5.57 and 5.4 Mcal kg- of dry matter, respectively.
That is the equivalent of about 3.3 feed units for lactation (UFL) kg-
Ingredient, chemical composition and nutritive values of feeds
|1UFL: feed unit for lactation: 2PDIE,
true protein truely digested in the small intestine when degraded nitrogen
in the rumen is not limiting: 3PDIN: true protein truely digested
in the small intestine when energy in the rumen is not limiting
Measurements and Chemical Analysis
Refusals were weighed and recorded daily before the morning feeding. They
were periodically sampled and dried at 110°C to determine average DM. For
each group of cows, DMI was calculated from feed offered, refusals and the appropriate
DM percentages. Feed samples were collected weekly throughout the study. They
were analyzed for DM, Crude Proteins (CP), Crude Fiber (CF) and minerals or
ash contents according to AOAC (1990).
Cows were milked twice daily and milk yield of individual cows was recorded once a week using true tests. Milk was sampled weekly from consecutive milkings, preserved with potassium dichromate and composited as a percentage of the amount of milk produced at each milking. Composite milk samples were analyzed for contents of crude protein and fat using a Foss 4000 Milko Scan (Foss electronic, France) at the central milk testing laboratory and for total solids by drying at 110°C for 24 h.
Feed efficiency, expressed in terms of kg of milk per kg of consumed feed, is calculated as the ratio between milk production and total dry matter intake.
All data were subject to least square analysis of variance for a complete
randomized bloc design by the general linear models of SAS (1988). Differences
were considered to be significant at p<0.05.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
DMI, Milk Yield and Milk Composition
Calcium salt supplementation at 3% of total dry matter intake did significantly
(p<0.05) affect both DMI and milk production. Cows fed calcium salts had
decreased DMI, but increased milk yield, FCM and milk fat content. DMI decreased
by 1 to 1.5 kg/cow. Such a decrease was observed for forage dry matter intake
Such finding is in agreement with previous results reported by Mansbridge et
al. (1998), who observed a decreased DMI when oil was added to dairy rations
and by Son et al. (1996) and Schneider et al. (1988) using, respectively
tallow and calcium salts of fatty acids. However, Sklan et al. (1991),
Salfer et al. (1995), Markus et al. (1996) and Rebecca et al.
(1997) have showed no difference in DMI when fat was fed as a part of the concentrate
||Dietary effects on average dry matter intake, milk production and composition
and on yields of milk fat and protein
|a,b,cMeans in the same row with different superscripts
Fat Corrected Milk (FCM) was 34.2 kg day- for the control and increased
an average of 3 to 4 kg cow day-, respectively with fat and fat plus
methionine supplementation. Clapperton and Steele (1983) reported a 5 to 10%
increase in milk production when cows received additional fat in their diet.
However, Schingoethe and Casper (1991) and Doherty and Mayne (1996) indicated
lower increases in both milk production and FCM. In the present study the use
of supplemental calcium salts, alone or added with protected methionine resulted
in about 10% increases in milk production, compared to the control treatment.
Similar increases were reported by Schneider et al. (1988). Feed efficiency
was higher for cows fed the calcium salt and methionine added salt diets (1.84
and 1.77 vs. 1.56 kg milk kg- DM for the CSFAM, CSFA and C treatments,
Increased energy density of the diet reduced body weight loss during early lactation as depicted by the values of body condition scores. Indeed, body condition scores were higher for cows fed diets supplemented with fat and fat plus methionine (Table 2). Schneider et al. (1988) and Sklan et al. (1989) reported increased weight gains in cows supplemented with calcium soaps in early lactation.
Percentages of milk fat were significantly higher (p<0.05) for cows fed the fat added diets (36.3 and 36.1 vs. 35.1 g kg-). Similar results were reported by Kokkonen et al. (2004). However, Schingoethe and Casper (1991), Doherty and Mayne (1996) and Keady and Mayne (1998) reported a decrease in the milk fat content when using non protected oil fats. Such a decrease in milk fat may have been due to a lower C2/C3 ratio in the rumen as a result of a lower fiber digestion due to an altered fermentation pattern (Schingoethe and Casper, 1991; Doreau and Ferlay, 1995). Reduction in milk fat percentage does not always occur whenever cows are fed added fat. Indeed, Clapperton and Steele (1983) reported increased milk fat percentage when tallow was added to the concentrate mix. Similar results were reported by Kokkonen et al. (2004) when cows were fat supplemented during week 1 to 4 of lactation.
Percentage of crude protein in milk was lower (p<0.05) for the calcium salt
supplemented cows (30.4 vs. 31.2 g kg-), but the addition of protected
methionine to salts did prevent the decrease in milk protein that was induced
by supplemental fat (30.4, 31.2 and 31.5 g kg- for CSFA, C and CSFAM,
respectively). This is in agreement with major published results which indicate
that increasing fat content of diets has generally decreased milk protein concentrations
(Wu and Huber, 1994; Elliott et al., 1995), but contradictory with the
findings of Keady and Mayne (1998). However, it should be indicated that for
most of these trials, fat content in supplemented diets ranged from 5 to 8%
of total dietary dry matter, such levels were higher than the 3% protected fat
content used in the present study. Wu and Huber (1994) proposed that the decrease
in milk protein concentration during fat supplementation could be attributed
to an inadequacy of critical AA available to the mammary gland for milk protein
synthesis as milk yield increases during fat supplementation probably as a result
of a decreased feed intake. Increased milk yield during fat supplementation
will increase the requirement for AA just to maintain constant milk protein
concentrations. Additional fat in the diet resulted in a significantly higher
(p<0.05) milk crude protein yield which confirms most previously published
results. This high protein yield for the experimental cows resulted from the
greater milk yield of these cows compared to those fed the non-fat added concentrate.
||Dietary effects on body condition scores, first service conception and
pregnancy rates and services per conception
|a,b,cMeans in the same row with different superscripts
Fat supplementation has significantly improved reproductive performances
of dairy cows (Staples et al., 1998). In the present study significant
improvements were observed for conception and gestation rates and for the number
of services per conception (Table 3). Similar results were
reported by Ferguson et al. (1990) and Sklan et al. (1991). In
this study, first service conception rate increased from 14 to 45% as a result
of calcium salt supplementation. Added protected methionone to calcium salts
further improved first service conception rate to be as high as 58%.
Similarly, gestation rate was significantly improved by fat and fat plus methionine supplementation. It went from 43% for cows receiving the control treatment to 61 and 75% for those receiving the CSFA and CSFAM treatments, respectively. Moreover, the number of services per conception was reduced from 2.86 to 2.36 when cows were supplemented the protected fat.
Mechanisms involved in such improvement are not well understood. However, several hypotheses were suggested by Staples et al. (1998). The first is that feeding fats in early lactation reduces the negative energy balance of the cows allowing them to resume estrus earlier after parturition and therefore have better reproductive performances. The second hypothesis is that cows fed fat have increased progesterone production the so called hormone of pregnancy. Increased concentrations of plasma progesterone have been associated with improved conception rates of lactating cows (Staples et al., 1998). The last hypothesis is that specific fatty acids found in fats inhibit the synthesis of prostaglandin F2α, which prevents the regression of the corpus luteum and thus improves embryos survival. In our case, observed improvements in reproductive performances were obtained in conjunction with improvements in milk production. It is therefore plausible to suppose an improvement in the energetic status of the fat supplemented cows which allowed them to early resume reproductive function after calving and to have an improved synthesis of steroid hormones favorable for a better fertility. Such improvement is more likely the result of a better supply of essential fatty acids involved in the reproductive function coming from the supplemental fat (Staples et al., 1998). Indeed, usually energy deficient cows have poor reproductive performances and fat supplemented increases blood progesterone and gestation percentage (Sklan et al., 1991).
Results in this study suggest that the use of 700 g of calcium salts of palm fatty acids /cow/day in the concentrate supplement (about 3% of the total diet dry matter) improves major reproductive indices and milk yield of high producing dairy cows during early lactation and that adding ruminally protected methionine to calcium salt not only helps alleviate the milk protein depression commonly observed with added fat, but further improves the performances of cows. Such management strategy is a valuable nutritional alternative for dairy producers in Tunisia who are in a continuous search for improved reproductive performances of their herds and an increased profitability of their dairy enterprises, particularly under common feeding conditions characterized by low quality forages.
The authors wish to thank Helali Hichem for management of the cows and Marouani Hassen for technical assistance. Sincere appreciation is also extended to the Feedna Company, Ennasr, Tunis for its support of this study.
Official Methods of Analysis. 14th Edn., Association of Official Analytical Chemist, Arlington, VA., USA., pp: 503-515
Casper, D.P., D.J. Schingoethe and W.A. Eisenbeisz, 1990.
Responses of early lactation cows to diets that vary in ruminal degradability of carbohydrates and amount of fat. J. Dairy Sci., 73: 425-444.Direct Link |
Clapperton, J.L. and W. Steele, 1983.
Effects on concentrate with beef tallow on food intake and milk production of cows fed grass silage. J. Dairy Sci., 66: 1032-1038.PubMed |
Doherty, J.G and C.S. Mayne, 1996.
The effect of concentrate type and supplementing lactic acid or soya oil on milk production characteristics in dairy cows offered grass silage of contrasting fermentation type. Anim. Sci., 62: 187-198.Direct Link |
Doreau, M. and A. Ferlay, 1995.
Effect of dietary lipids on nitrogen metabolism in the rumen: A review. Livest. Prod. Sci., 43: 97-110.CrossRef |
Elliot, J.P., J.K. Drackley, G.C.J. Fahey and R.D Shanks, 1995.
Utilization of supplemental fat by dairy cows fed diets varying in content of nonstructural carbohydrates. J. Dairy Sci., 78: 1512-1525.PubMed |
Ferguson, J.D., D. Sklan, W.V. Chalupa and D.S. Kronfeld, 1990.
Effect of hard fats on in vitro
and in vivo
rumen frmentation, milk production and reproduction in dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci., 73: 2864-2879.Direct Link |
Garcia-Bojalil, C.M., C.R. Staples, C.A. Risco, J.D. Savio and W.W. Thatcher, 1998.
Protein degradability and calcium salts of long-chain fatty acids in the diets of lactating dairy cows: Productive responses. J. Dairy Sci., 81: 1374-1384.CrossRef | PubMed | Direct Link |
Keady, T.W.J. and C.S. Mayne, 1998.
An examination of the effects of fish oil inclusion in the diet of forage intake, milk yield and composition of lactating dairy cattle offered two levels of concentrates. Br. Anim. Sci., 20: 56-56.Direct Link |
Kim, Y.K., D.J. Schingoethe, D.P. Casper and F.C. Ludens, 1991.
Lactational response of dairy cows to increased dietary crude protein with added fat. J. Dairy Sci., 74: 3891-3899.CrossRef | PubMed | Direct Link |
Kokkonen, T., J. Taponen, M. Tuori, S. Lohenoja and M. Kulcsar et al
Effects of fat supplementation in early lactation dairy cows. J. Anim. Feed Sci., 13: 499-502.Direct Link |
Mansbridge, R.J., S.J. Blake and C. Collins, 1998.
The effect of feeding high levels of fish oil and additional vitamin E on intake, milk yield composition and fatty acid content in high yielding dairy cows. Anim. Sci., 64: 221-221.Direct Link |
Markus, S.B., K.M. Wittenberg, J.R. Ingalls and M. Udini, 1996.
Production responses by early lactation cow to whole sunflower seed or tallow supplementation of a diet based on barley. J. Dairy Sci., 79: 1817-1825.PubMed |
Moallem, U., Y. Folman and D. Sklan, 2000.
Effects of somatotropin and dietary calcium soaps of fatty acids in early lactation on milk production, dry matter intake and energy balance of high yielding dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci., 83: 2085-2094.PubMed |
Rebecca, J., D. Mdison-Anderson, J. Schingoethe, M.J. Brouk and R.J. Bean et al
Response of lactating cows to supplemental unsaturated fat and niacin. J. Dairy Sci., 80: 1329-1338.PubMed |
Salfer, J.A., J.G Linn, D.E Otterby, W.P. Hansen and D.G. Johnson, 1995.
Early lactation responses of holstein cows fed a rumen-inert fat prepartum, postpartum or both. J. Dairy Sci., 78: 368-377.PubMed |
SAS User’s guide: Statistics. SAS Institute Inc, Cary, NC, USA.
Schingoethe, D.J. and D.P. Casper, 1991.
Total lactational response to added fat during early lactation. J. Dairy Sci., 74: 2617-2622.PubMed |
Schneider, B.H., D. Sklan, W. Chalupa and D.S. Kronfeld, 1988.
Feedin calcium salts of fatty acids to lactating cows. J. Dairy Sci., 71: 2143-2150.Direct Link |
Sklan, D., E. Bogin, Y. Avidar and S.Gur-Arie, 1989.
Feeding calcium soaps of fatty acids to lactating cows: Effects on production, body condition and blood lipids. J. Dairy Res., 56: 675-681.Direct Link |
Sklan, D., U. Moallem and Y. Folman, 1991.
Effect of feeding calcium soaps of fatty acids on production and reproduction responses in high producing lactating cows. J. Dairy Sci., 74: 510-517.PubMed |
Sniffen, C. and J. Furguson, 1993.
Body Condition Scoring Guide. 1st Edn., Church and Dwight Co., Inc., Church
Son, J., R.J. Grant and L.L. Larson, 1996.
Effects of tallow and escape protein on lactational and reproductive performance of dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci., 79: 822-830.PubMed |
Staples, C.R., J.M. Burke and W.W. Thatcher, 1998.
Influence of supplemental fats on reproductive tissues and performance of lactating cows. J. Dairy Sci., 81: 856-871.CrossRef | PubMed | Direct Link |
Weiss, W.P. and D.J. Wyatt, 2004.
Digestible energy values of diets with different fat supplements when fed to lactating dairy cows. J. Dairy Sci., 87: 1446-1454.PubMed |
Wu, Z. and J.T. Huber, 1994.
Relationship between dietary fat supplementation and milk protein concentration in lactating cows: A review. Livest. Prod. Sci., 39: 141-155.CrossRef | Direct Link |