Microbial Hazards Associated with Fermented Milk (Roub and Mish) Processing in Sudan
Wigdan Mahmoud Abdalla
Ibtisam E.M. El Zubeir
The present study was conducted to evaluate the hygienic properties during manufacturing of fermented milk by isolation and identification of some potential pathogens and it also aimed for evaluation of some fermented dairy products (roub and mish in a modern dairy factory). It was based on collection of six batches of samples from the whole milk, skim milk, yoghurt and their mixture; which enter for the processing of roub and mish; roub and mish from a modern dairy factory in Khartoum State (Sudan). The 1st and 2nd batches were collected from the factory commercial production. The 3rd and 4th were done in the factory laboratory as an experiment following the same procedure, while in the 5th and 6th batches pasteurization of whole milk was done. Comparison and the counts of each of E. coli, Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus spp. and Salmonella spp. were estimated in those products. Higher counts were obtained for the factory commercial samples compared with those manufactured as experiment in the factory. Moreover pasteurization of the whole milk revealed lower counts, which could be attributed to elimination of contamination. When comparing roub and mish significant differences were obtained only for E. coli (p<=0.05) and S. aureus counts (p<=0.05). Similarly, between mixture and roub significance variations were reported for E. coli (p<=0.05) and S. aureus counts (p<=0.001). However, non-significance differences were found for the measurements between the different groups. This could be due to fermentation in roub and addition of spices (black cumin, fenugreek and garlic) and salt in mish. Hence the present study supported the previous reports, which stated the role of those spices as antimicrobial agents against some pathogenic bacteria.
Fermented milks are products prepared by controlled fermentation of milk to produce acidity and flavour to desire level, fermented milks are the most common products from which other dairy products are also made (Thapa, 2000.). Fortunately, the dominant bacteria in fermented milks were progressive type, lactic acid streptococci and lactobacilli, which generally suppers the spoilage and pathogenic organism very effectively (Kosikowski, 1982). In the earlier days, fermentation was used to control the growth of harmful bacteria and some pathogens while making indigenous milk products (Thapa, 2000).
Fermented milk products are of a considerable economic and dietary importance to the people of Sudan (El-Mardi, 1988; Abdel Gadir et al., 1998). The milk for roub (sour butter milk) is either boiled or used raw in Sudan (Abdel Gadir et al., 1998). Although yoghurt is highly nutritious and easily digestible due to the predigested nutrients by bacterial starter, it is less perishable in view of its unused lactose content which can be utilized for the growth of undesirable microorganisms responsible for spoilage (Durga et al., 1986). Mish is a special spicy fermented milk (black cumin; Nigelia sativa and fenugreek; Trigonella foenum-graecum and occasionally garlic; Allium sativa (El-Mardi, 1988).
Spices and medicinal plants have been economically valued since immemorial times (El-Hussein, 1984). Black cumin seeds are found to be acceptable without any health hazards associated with their consumption (El-Jassir, 1992. ). Similarly, garlic was used since ancient times as food, spice or remedy, in the Middle Ages; it was used as antibiotic and is registered as a drug in several European countries (Grinwald, 1992). In Asia, fenugreek seeds (Trigonella foenum graecum) are consumed as spices and also as medicines (Patil et al., 1997).
Bacteria spoil foods as well as causing diseases to man and animals and because of their unseen activities; man is unaware of them (Singleton, 1992). Poor milk hygiene is mostly caused by pathogenic microorganism, which may result from infections of dairy animals or from secondary contamination by either milkers or soiled equipment (Chabo et al., 2000). Also water, which is essential commodity on dairy farms, could also have contributed significantly to the microbial quality of milk and to the occurrence of clinical or sub-clinical mastitis. Moreover, dairy cows are known to act as reservoirs of enteric pathogens like Salmonella, E. coli, Compylobacter spp. and Listeria spp. (Adesiyun et al., 1997.). However, during and after milking, the milk is subjected to organisms from various sources and with extended storage of milk products at refrigerated temperatures, psychrophilic or psychrotrophic organisms cause spoilage (Murphy et al., 2000).
Milk borne human infection or in toxications due to Escherichia coli, Staphylococeus aureus, Listeria monocytogenes and other pathogens have been well documented (Kosikowski, 1982). Similarly, various zoonotic agents can be transmitted to human through milk (Giovannini, 1998).
Contamination of raw milk by salmonella, usually takes place from external sources and the reduction in salmonella numbers due to freezing temperatures is limited, since it can survive a prolonged time in frozen foods (Asperger et al., 1994). Similarly, the survival of salmonella for at least 63 days in cultured buttermilk stored at 8°C (Wilson and Tanner, 1945). However, salmonella are readily destroyed during milk pasteurization (Asperger et al., 1994).
The ranges in mean counts of E. coli per milliliter of bulk milk and composite milk were 8.4x103 to 2.0x105 and 2.1x101 to 2.0x102 cfu mL-1, respectively and it could pose a health risk to consumers (Adesiyun et al., 1997). Moreover the sufficient number of E. coli to produce illness, is suggested to be 106 cells or more (Asperger et al.,1994).
The present study was a contribution to the evaluation and comparison of the hygienic quality (isolation and identification of some pathogenic organisms) of fermented milk (Roub and Mish) in Sudan.
Materials and Methods
Source of Samples
The present study was conducted during the period from January to March
2002. Two batches of whole milk, skim milk and yoghurt, which used for processing
of roub and mish from one of the dairy factory in Khartoum North city, were
analyzed. Similarly roub and mish samples, obtained from the same products,
were also collected and analyzed during this study. On another trail a total
of four experiments as an attempt to process roub and mish in the factorys
laboratory were tried following the same procedures of the factory for two batch.
However in the other pasteurization for whole milk was done before the processing.
The same conditions for these fermented milks were nearly applied by incubating
the mixtures at room temperature (30±2°C for 18±1 h) after
addition of starter culture to obtain roub. Further fermentation of roub to
mish with the addition of salt, fenugreek, garlic and black cumin, was done.
Collection of the Samples
Samples from each of whole milk, skim milk and yoghurt were collected after
through mixing, in sterile bottles (10 mL) and transported quickly to the laboratory
for microbiological examination. Each batch of sample was done on a separate
week, since the collection of roub was done on the next day after collecting
original samples (whole milk, skim milk and youghurt) used for its mixture.
The mish was collected on the third day.
All the samples were enumerated for the same pathogens. Escherichia coli
count was done on MacConkey agar, Staphylococcus aureus count on mannitol
salt agar and Salmonella spp. count was done using Deoxycholate Citrate
Agar (DCA) (Barrow and Feltham, 1993). Similarly Streptococcus spp. counts
on modified Edward's medium (Asperger et al., 1994).
Serial dilutions of the samples were prepared (10-1-16-10) (Richardson, 1985). The enumeration was carried out aseptically by plating the selected dilution into duplicate plates of the selected media. Purification and identification of each organism was done (Asperger et al., 1994).
All data were analyzed statistically using Complete Randomized Design by
SPSS program (Statistical Packages for Social Sciences). The LSD test was used
to detect difference between means (Snedecor and Cochran, 1980).
Incidences and Frequencies of Some Pathogens Isolated During Different Processing
The number of individuals of E. coli, S. aureus, Streptococcus
spp. and Salmonella spp. isolated from processed samples were 15, 12
and 7, respectively (Table 1). Similarly the factory commercial
products showed high counts of microorganisms than the samples, which were manufactured
in laboratory. Moreover, E. coli was not isolated from the pasteurized
|| Incidences and frequencies of total pathogens isolated during
different processing procedure
|Lab. (1) = Processing following the same procedure of factory
Lab. (2) = Processing after pasteurized of whole milk
|| Comparison of the differential counts of pathogenic bacteria
isolated from milk and fermented milk products
Microbial Properties of Samples
The means log counts of Escherichia coli, Staphylococcus aureus,
Streptococcus spp. and Salmonella spp. in whole milk were 2.31±2.77,
1.29±1.99, 1.48±3.30 and 1.15±1.93 cfu mL-1
(Table 2). Similarly, skim milk samples revealed means log
counts of 1.85±2.43, 2.06±2.46, 1.75±3.50 and 1.84±2.35
cfu mL-1 for E. coli, Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus
spp. and Salmonella spp., respectively (Table 2). In
yoghurt samples (Table 2) the mean log count of E. coli
was 2.11±2.65, for S. aureus was 0.48±1.19 cfu mL-1,
for Streptococcus spp. was 1.79±2.78 and for Samonella
spp. was 1.12±2.74 cfu mL-1. The mixture samples revealed
mean log count for E. coli of 2.31±2.59, S. aureus of 1.04±1.63
cfu mL-1, Streptococcus spp. of 1.76±2.74 and Salmonella
spp. of 1.48±2.19 cfu mL-1 (Table 2). In
Roub samples E. coli revealed a mean log counts of 0.35±0.88 cfu
mL-1, for Streptococcus spp. a mean log counts of 1.49±2.43
cfu mL-1 and Salmonella spp. a mean log counts of 2.36±3.67,
however S. aureus was not detected. Mish samples revealed mean log for
E. coli counts of 1.55±2.42, S. aureus mean log count of 1.00±2.45,
Streptococcus spp. mean log count of 1.52±2.44 cfu mL-1
and Salmonella spp. mean log counts of 1.11±2.71 cfu mL-1
Comparison Between Mixture, Roub and Mish
Comparing mixture and roub there were significant differences observed between
E. coli (p≤0.05) and S. aureus (p≤0.001). However, non significant
variations were found between Salmonella spp. counts and Streptococcus
spp. counts. Also comparison of mixture and mish revealed non significant
variations for all measures. Comparing roub and mish revealed non significant
differences for all measures except for E. coli (p≤0.01) and S.
The presence of some pathogens in the dairy products (E. coli, S. aureus, Streptococcus spp. and Salmonella spp.) during different processing procedures indicated the lower standards of hygiene in the selected dairy factory. This could be due to the traditional method of distribution of milk to consumers, retailers and factories, which were transported into large plastic containers that still practiced in Sudan. In addition, those containers are opened frequently that milk is subjected to contamination (Murphy and Boor, 2000). It might also be due to unrefrigerated transportation of milk from dairy farms, through collection centers, to the major processing plant may have been responsible for the high counts of E. coli and S. aureus in milk (Asperger et al., 1994).
The higher incidences of Salmonella spp. in the samples collected from factory compared to that made by the student supported the previous report, which stated that the human handler could also play a role in contributing to health risk by contaminating milk (Giovannini, 1998). Moreover, E. coli was not isolated from the pasteurized milk samples. This could be due to that generally, the Enterobacteriaceae do not survive pasteurization but contamination can be due to poor post pasteurization control (Manie et al., 1999).
The mean log count of Escherichia coli, Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus spp. and Salmonella spp. in whole milk demonstrated that raw milk could be a source of pathogenic bacteria (Giovannini, 1998). The presence of pathogenic organisms in samples could be due to unhygienic conditions on practice during production or may be due to inadequate cleaning of utensils (Jay, 1986). Similarly, inadequately sanitized milk utensils are the most common sources of coliform in raw milk (Murphy and Boor, 2000).
Mish samples revealed increase in the means log counts for E. coli, S. aureus and Streptococcus spp., while counts of Salmonella spp. were decrease compared to roub samples (Table 2). This might be due to the fermentation effect as one of the potential health benefits of lactic acid bacteria is the protection against enteric infections (Perdigon et al., 1995). Moreover, the present results for S. aureus (Table 2) were lower than that obtained for roub and mish (Manal, 2001). The results reported during this investigation showed a remarkable effect of the spices on the growth of Staphylococcus aureus (Table 2), which were supported the findings that the volatile oil in the black cumin inhibited the growth of Staphylococcus aureus (Hanfey and Hatem, 1991). Moreover, the bacterial count of Staphylococcus aureus decrease from log 7.45 to log 7.34 cfu mL-1 in mish samples (Manal, 2001). Hence it is suggested that detail studies should be conducted on the fate of pathogenic bacteria due to fermentation and spices that traditionally added as a preservative.
The present study concluded that heat treatment of milk, proper handling and strict hygienic measures before manufacturing of dairy products should be very well monitored. Fermentation and addition of traditional spices proved to have a very significant effect of pathogenic organisms. Further studies are needed to estimate the different concentrations of spices in order to inhibit the growth of some pathogenic bacteria such as E. coli, S. aureus, Salmonella spp. and other food-borne pathogens.
Abdelgadir, W.S., T.K. Ahmed and H.A. Dirar, 1998.
The traditional fermented milk products of the Sudan. Int. J. Food Microbiol., 44: 1-13.CrossRef | PubMed | Direct Link |
Lam, D.S., D.S. Fan, W.M. Chan, B.S. Tam, A.K. Kwok, A.T. Leunq and H. Parsons, 2005.
Prevalence and characteristics of peripheral retinal degeneration in Chinese adults with high myopia: A cross-sectional prevalence survey. Optom. Vis. Sci., 82: 235-238.Direct Link |
Asperger, H. 1994. Staphylococcus aureus
in the Significance of Pathogenic Microorganisms in Raw Milk. International Dairy Federation, Brussels, Belgium
Barrow, G.I. and R.K.A. Feltham, 1993.
Cowan and Steal Manual for the Identification of Medical Bacteria. 3rd Edn., Cambridge Press, London
Chabo, R.G., C.B. Habanoand and K.K. Mosethanyane, 2000.
Milk hygiene in commercial dairy farms in South Eastern Botswana. J. Agric. Sci. Technol., 3: 45-47.
Durga, L.C., D. Sharda and M.P. Sastry, 1986.
Effect of storage conditions on keeping quality, riboflavin and niacin of plan and fruit yoghurts. Ind. J. Dairy Sci., 39: 404-409.
El-Mardi, M.A., 1988.
A study on fermented milk Roub. M.Sc. Thesis, University of Khartoum, Sudan.
El-Hussein, S.A., 1984.
Essential oil crops of Sudan. Acta Hortic., 143: 213-220.
El-Jassir, S.M., 1992.
Chemical composition and microflora of black cumin Nigelia sativa
seeds growing in Saudi Arabia. J. Food Chem., 45: 239-241.Direct Link |
Giovannini, A., 1998.
Importance of milk hygiene to public health. MZCP/workshop on the management of milk-borne zoonoses surveillance and control in the MZCP countries, Cephalonia Island, Greece.
Grinwald, J.H., 1992.
Garlic the best documented medicinal plant in the prevention of cardi vascular disease. Acta Hortic., 332: 115-119.
Hanfey, M.S. and M.E. Hatem, 1991.
Studies on antimicrobial activity of Nigellia sativa
seeds black cumin. J. Ethnopharmacol., 34: 275-278.Direct Link |
Jay, M.J., 1986.
Sources, Types, Incidence and Behivour of Microorganisms in Food. In: Modern Food Microbiology, Van Nostrand (Ed.). Reinhold Co., New York, USA, pp: 13-32
Abbasi, K.U., 1982.
Fermented Milk,Cheese and Fermented Milk Foods. 2nd Edn., Chap. 4, Edwards Brothers, Inc., USA., pp: 38
Manal, M.A., 2001.
Studies on the microbiological characteristics of mish in the Sudan. M.Sc. Thesis, University of Khartoum, Sudan.
Manie, T., V.S. Brozel, W.J. Veith and P.A. Gouws, 1999.
Antimicrobial resistance of bacterial flora associated with bovine products in South Africa. J. Food Prot., 62: 615-618.Direct Link |
Murphy, S.C. and K.J. Boor, 2000.
Trouble-shooting sources and causes of high bacterial counts in raw milk. Dairy Food Environ. Sanitat., 20: 606-611.Direct Link |
Patil, S.P., P.V. Niphadkar and M.M. Bapat, 1997.
Allergy to fenugreek Trigonella foenum groecum
. Ann. Allergy Asthma Immunol., 78: 297-300.
Perdigon, G., S. Alvarez, M. Rachid, G. Aguero and N. Gobbato, 1995.
Immune system stimulation by probiotics. J. Dairy Sci., 78: 1597-1606.CrossRef | Direct Link |
Richardson, G.H., 1985.
Standard Methods for the Examination of Dairy Products. 15th Edn., American Public Health Association, Washington, DC., ISBN-13: 9780875531182, pp: 133-150
Singleton, P., 1992.
Introduction to Bacteria. 2nd Edn., John Wiley and Sons, New York
Snedecor, G.W. and W.G. Cochran, 1980.
Statistical Methods. 7th Edn., Iowa State University Press, Iowa, USA., ISBN-10: 0813815606, Pages: 507Direct Link |
Thapa, T., 2000.
Small-scale milk processing technologies: Other milk products. Report of the FAO E-mail Conference on Small-Scale Milk Collection and Processing in Developing Countries, May 29-July 28, 2000. FAO, Rome, Italy.
Wilson, F.L. and F.W. Tanner, 1945.
Behaviour of pathogenic bacteria in fermented milks. Food Res., 10: 122-134.