Herbicidal Effects of Marine Animal, Trochus tentorium from Gulf of Mannar, Southeastern India
T. Prem Anand,
The plants, animals and microorganisms of the marine environment with their wide range of chemical diversity are still an unexplored resource for the development of new agro-chemical agents. Works related to the herbicidal activity of the marine organisms are too scanty. Compared to the search for new pharmaceutical compounds, very little effort has been devoted to the exploration of agrochemical compounds from marine natural products. In the present study, the herbicidal activity of the crude extracts and partial purified fractions of Trochus tentorium was assayed using the duckweed, Lemna minor L. following a bench top bioassay. The crude acetone extract of T. tentorium decayed the fronds of Lemna plants at the concentration of 1000 mg mL-1 on the 4th day, while the results of same concentration of ethyl acetate, dichloromethane and methanol extracts showed decay of the plants on the 5th day of the experiment. This study reveals that the column-purified acetone fraction of the gastropod was able to decay L. minor to a better degree in comparison with the crude extracts. Hence, from the present study, it was noted that not only the 100% acetone fractions but also the 20:80 hexane: methanol and 80:20 acetone: methanol fractions showed a higher degree of activity against L. minor.
Received: October 31, 2011;
Accepted: December 29, 2011;
Published: January 14, 2012
An ideal herbicide should have potent activity against weeds, minimum toxicity
against living things other than plants, high selectivity between crop plants
and weeds and cause no damage to the environment by residual material. The weeds
often form a green blanket on the water surface and highly reduce light penetration.
Among the aquatic weeds, the duckweed, Lemna minor L. is considered as
one of the important weeds. Thick populations of L. minor are often found
in association with other aquatic plants, particularly with those that provide
protection from wind and wave action (Vernon and Vandiver,
2005). Hence, the usage of herbicides for weed control against this weed
has thus become apparent. Herbicides for practical use today are mostly synthetic
compounds which inhibit the photosynthetic electron transfer and affect plant
hormonal action. However, sooner or later weeds acquire resistance to the existing
herbicides and thus the continued development of new and potent drugs to control
the weeds is always required. Hence, the development of herbicides must always
take into consideration the problem of environmental pollution (Okuda,
Compared to the search for new pharmaceutical compounds, very little effort
has been devoted to the exploration of agrochemical compounds from marine natural
products (Fenical, 1993). One of the major impediments
to successful herbicide development is obtaining compounds capable of penetrating
the cell membrane of target plant (weed) (Lyewellyn and
Burnell, 2000). The plant, animals and microorganisms of the marine environment
with their wide range of chemical diversity are still an unexplored resource
for the development of new agro-chemical agents (Crombie,
1990). In the hunt for new agro-chemical agents, the plants, animals and
microorganisms of the marine environment with their wide range of chemical diversity
prove to be an unexplored resource. Works related to the herbicidal activity
of the marine organisms are too scanty. However, there is relatively limited
number of reports on the herbicidal activity of some marine natural products
(Burnell et al., 2000; Wagner
et al., 2002; Hylleberg and Kilburn, 2002;
Omura et al., 1990) and to date, research focused
on isolating herbicidal prototype leads from marine origin has resulted in the
report of about 40 active compounds. Many important herbicides are isolated
from marine algae (Einhellig et al., 1985). Of
the marine organisms, in particular, the molluscs have always proven to be potential
sources of marine natural products with vast array of diversified bio-activities.
There are massive evidences to witness marine molluscs as potential supply of
potent metabolites (Ganambal et al., 2005; Hocklowski
and Faulkner, 1983; Hubert et al., 1996).
In the present study, the crude as well as partial purified extracts of the
gastropod, Trochus tentorium associated to corals was screened for herbicidal
activity against Lemna minor (duckweed).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Extraction of mollusc: The Gastropod, Trochus tentorium were
collected by hand picking using SCUBA diving from the intertidal area at a depth
of 3-5 m in Tuticorin coastal waters (Lat 8°45 and Long 78°13E)
of Gulf of Mannar, southeast coast of India. They were immediately brought to
the laboratory and identified up to species level using standard keys (Hubert
et al., 1996; Riguera, 1997). The identified
shells of Trochus tentorium were broke open by a hammer to remove the
soft parts. The whole body of the samples (20 g) were cut in to small pieces
and air-dried for 24 h at room temperature before extraction with solvents.
Then the tissues were rinsed with sterile distilled water and the tissue samples
were used for extraction using different solvents such as ethyl acetate, dichloromethane,
acetone and methanol. The extracts were cold steeped overnight at -18°C
and filtered with Whatman No. 1 filter paper. The filtrate was poured in previously
weighed Petri plate and evaporated to dryness in rotary evaporator (Becerro
et al., 1994; Riguera, 1997; Wright,
1998). The dried crude extracts were used for herbicidal activity.
Column purification of the active crude extracts: Partial purification
of the crude extract of T. tentorium was carried out by the method of
Chellaram et al. (2009). After initial screening,
the higher activity was shown by acetone extract and it was fractionated by
normal phase silica gel column chromatography by employing a step gradient solvent
system from low to high polarity. Sequence of 100% hexane, 20% acetone: 80%
hexane, 40% acetone: 60% hexane, 60% acetone: 40% hexane, 80% acetone: 20% hexane,
100% acetone, 80% acetone: 20% methanol, 60% acetone: 40% methanol, 40% acetone:
60% methanol, 20% acetone: 80% methanol and 100% methanol was used for elution.
Each fraction thus obtained was once again evaporated, concentrated and assayed
for herbicidal activity.
Features of duckweed Lemna minor (Arales: Lemnaceae): Lemna
minor L. (duckweed) is a miniature aquatic monocot, Lemna plant,
which consists of a central frond or mother frond with two attached daughter
fronds and a filamentous root. Under normal conditions, the plant reproduces
exponentially with budding of daughter fronds from pouches on the sides of the
mother fronds. The sizes of the fronds generally range from 1.7 to 4.0 mm in
length and from 0.80 to 4.0 mm in width. Fronds occur solitary or in groups
of two or more. There is a single root extending from the base of each frond.
Seen from a distance, it is difficult to distinguish individual plants in a
body of water infested with duckweed because the surface of the water appears
green. Earlier reports by Einhellig et al. (1985)
provided the general guidelines for developing a Lemna bioassay to screen
a large number of plant extracts and chemical substances for their effects on
Herbicidal assay: The herbicidal activity of the crude extracts of T. tentorium was assayed against the duckweed, Lemna minor following a bench top bioassay described by McLaughlin et al. (1991). To assay the herbicidal activity, 20 mg of the dried crude extracts (Trochus tentorium) was dissolved in 20 mL of their respective solvents (ethyl acetate, dichloromethane, acetone and methanol). From this solution, 1000, 500, 100, 50 and 10 μL were pipetted into dram vials corresponding to 1000, 500, 100, 50 and 10 μg mL-1, respectively in triplicates. Controls were added with appropriate solvents alone without the extracts. The solvents of the control and test vials were allowed to evaporate overnight and 2 mL of E-medium (consisting of KH2PO4 -680 mg, KNO3 -1515 mg, Ca (NO3)2.4H2O-1180 mg, MgSO4.7H2O -492 mg, H3BO3 -286 mg, MnCl2.4H2O -3.62 mg, FeCl2.6H2O -5.40 mg, ZnSO4.7H2O -0.22 mg, CuSO4.5H2O -0.22 mg, Na2MoO4.2H2O -0.12 mg and EDTA -11.2 mg in one liter of distilled water) was added into each vial. A single healthy L. minor plant containing a rosette of three fronds was introduced into each vial and were placed in glass chamber with about 2-4 cm water at the bottom to maintain the moisture content of the chamber and sealed with glass plate. The fronds per vial were counted daily up to 6 days and symptoms of damage to the frond such as yellowing and decaying were also noted.
The column purified fractions were assayed for herbicidal activity and the
bioassay was performed to find out which of the fractions were found to be more
active in decaying the plant. The herbicidal activity of crude and column fractions
of T. tentorium was tested at different concentrations 500, 300,
200, 100, 50, 25 and 10 mg and changes in the appearance of the fronds were
The present study reveals that out of the different solvents, the acetone extract
of T. tentorium decayed the fronds of Lemna plants at the
concentration of 250 mg mL-1 on 6th day and ethyl acetate, dichloromethane
and methanol extracts decayed the plants on 5th day of experiment at a concentration
of 1000 mg mL-1 (Table 1). The acetone crude extracts
of the gastropod, shown prominent herbicidal activities against L. minor.
The column purified (100% acetone, 20:80 hexane: methanol and 80:20 acetone:
methanol) fractions of T. tentorium shown complete decay of the Lemna
plants (Table 2), however, 100% acetone fraction of the extract
showed activity at a concentration of 100 mg mL-1 on the 5th day
of the experiments. But the plants were found to be healthy till the 3rd day
of experiment at a concentration of 10 mg mL-1. The plants were decayed
by all the fractions at a concentration of 500 mg mL-1 on the 4th
day of the experiments. This study reveals that the column-purified acetone
fractions of gastropod were able to decay L. minor to a better degree
in comparison with the crude extracts. Hence from the present study, it was
noted that not only the 100% acetone fractions but also the 20:80 hexane: methanol
and 80:20 acetone: methanol fractions shown a higher degree of activity against
||Herbicidal activity of the crude extracts of T. tentorium
against the Lemna minor
|Note: A- Acetone; EA- Ethyl acetate; DM- Dichloromethane and
M- Methanol. GH- Green and healthy; G- Green; LY- Light yellow; Y- Yellow
and D- Dead
||Herbicidal activity of the 100% acetone column fractions of
T. tentorium against the Lemna minor
|Note: A- Acetone, H- Hexane and M- Methanol. GH- Green and
healthy; G- Green; H- Healthy; LY- Light yellow; Y- Yellow and D- Dead
The Lemna assay data agreed with antitumour activities. McLaughlin
et al. (1991) have reported that using Lemna assay, the search
for biodegradable herbicides may be extended to include natural compounds and
this is a simple screen for such activity. Reports are available on the herbicidal
activities of 9 purified algal metabolites (Fenical, 1997).
Lyewellyn and Burnell (2000) had stated that the number
of free growing plants is low on coral reefs; therefore, the chemicals produced
by these coral reefs can be widely developed as herbicides. Peng
et al. (2003) identified 18 structurally diverse marine-derived compounds
and examined for herbicidal activities and it was concluded that several new
classes of compounds have been shown to be herbicidal in nature. In the present
study, the acetone extracts of Trochus tentorium were found to be efficient
in decaying the fronds of Lemna minor at a concentration of 1000 mg mL-1
on the 4th day of the experiment. Chellaram et al.
(2004) observed that different solvents like ethyl acetate, acetone and
dichloromethane were used for the extraction of the winged oyster, Pteria
chinensis, however, the acetone extract was able to cause decaying of the
fronds of Lemna minor at 5th day at a concentration of 1000 mg mL-1
which is same concentration to the present study and so the extracts of T.
tentorium are assumed to be potent producers of novel metabolites. Anand
(2002) isolated bacterial strains from the surface of sponges, seaweeds,
crabs, ascidians and cephalopod eggs and reported that they were able to bring
forth 90% inhibition against L. minor.
In conclusion, the results indicate that the crude and column fractions (100% acetone, 20:80 methanol: acetone and 80:20 acetone: hexane) of T. tentorium screened for herbicidal activity and extracts of 100% acetone may possess some biologically active compounds. The activity of the column purified fractions was found to be prominent in comparison to the crude counterparts. So the partially purified fraction of the 100% acetone T. tentorium undeniably provides a tool for the development of novel herbicides.
Authors thank sincerely the Director, Suganthi Devadason Marine Research Institute, Tuticorin, for providing laboratory facilities and diving kits for sample collection. We are also grateful to Prof. Chancellor Dr. R. Rangarajan, Vel Tech Dr. RR and Dr. SR Technical University and Director and Principal, Vel Tech Multi Tech Dr. Rangarajan Dr. Sakunthala Rangarajan Engineering College, for their unremitting encouragement and valuable advices.
1: Anand, P.T., 2002. Screening for bioactive metabolites producing marine bacteria from Tuticorin coastal waters, Southeast coast of India. Ph.D. Thesis, Manonmaniam Sundaranar University, Tirunelveli.
2: Becerro, M.A., N.I. Lopez, X. Turon and M.J. Uniz, 1994. Antimicrobial activity and surface bacterial film in marine sponges. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol., 179: 195-205.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
3: Burnell, J.N., J.R. Doyle, J.R. Woodward and L.E. Llewellyn, 2000. Rapid throughput biomolecular screening for marine derived C4 plant specific herbicides. Proceedings of 5th IBMC Conference, September 29-October 4, 2000, Townsville, Australia, pp: 24-
4: Chellaram, C., K.M.E. Gnanambal and J.K.P. Edward, 2004. Antibacterial activity of the winged oyster Pteria chinensis (Pterioida: Pteridae). Indian J. Mar. Sci., 33: 369-372.
Direct Link |
5: Chellaram, C., R.S. Sreenivasan, S. Jonesh, T.P. Anand and J.K.P. Edward, 2009. In vitro antibiotic bustle of coral reef associated gastropod, Drupa margariticola (Broderip, 1832) of tuticorin coastal waters, Southeastern India. Biotechnology, 8: 456-461.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
6: Crombie. L., 1990. Natural Models for the Design of Insect Control Compounds: The Mammerins. In: Recent Advances in the Chemistry of Insect Control II, Crombie, L. (Ed.). The Royal Society of Chemistry Special Publication, Cambridge, UK., pp: 23-51
7: Wagner, D.I., W. Beil, S. Lang, M. Meiners and H. Latch, 2002. Integrated approach to explore the potential of marine microorganisms for the production of bioactive metabolites. Adv. Biochem. Eng. Biotechnol., 74: 207-238.
8: Einhellig, F.A., G.R. Leather and S.L. Hobbs, 1985. Use of Lemna minor L. as a bioassay in allelopathy. J. Chem. Ecol., 11: 65-65.
Direct Link |
9: Fenical, W., 1993. Chemical studies of marine bacteria: Developing a new resource. Chem. Rev., 93: 1673-1683.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
10: Fenical, W., 1997. New pharmaceuticals from marine organisms. Trend. Biotechnol., 15: 339-341.
11: Ganambal, M.E., C. Chellaram and J. Patterson, 2005. Antibacterial activity of whole body extracts of Trochus radiatus (Mollusca: Gastropoda). SDMRI Res. Publ., 9: 182-186.
12: Hocklowski, J.E. and D.J. Faulkner, 1983. Antibiotics from marine pulmonates, Siphonaria diemenensis. Tetrahedron Lett., 24: 1917-1920.
13: Hubert, F., V.D.W. Knaap, T. Noel and P. Roch, 1996. Cytonic and antibacterial properties of Mytilus galloprovincialis, Ostrea edulis and Crassostrea gigas (bivalve, molluscs) haemolymph. Aquat. Living Res., 9: 115-124.
14: Hylleberg, J. and R.N. Kilburn, 2002. Annotated Inventory of Molluscs from the Gulf of Mannar and Vicinity. In: Zoogeography and Inventory of Marine Molluscs Encountered in Southern India, Hylleberg, J. and A. Nateewathana (Eds.). PMBC, Thailand, pp: 1970
15: Lyewellyn, L.E. and J.N. Burnell, 2000. Marine organisms as sources of C4-Weed-Specific herbicides. Pestic. Outlook, 11: 64-67.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
16: McLaughlin, J.L., C.J. Chang and D.L. Smith, 1991. Bench-Top Bioassays for the Discovery of Bioactive Natural Products: An Update. In: Studies in Natural Products Chemistry, Rhaman, A.U. (Ed.). Elsevier, Oxford, pp: 383-409
17: Okuda, S., 1992. Herbicides: The Search for Bioactive Compounds from Marine Microorganisms. Springer-Verlag, New York, pp: 224-236
18: Omura, S., Y. Tanaka, I. Kanaya, M. Shinose and Y. Takahashi, 1990. Pthoxazolin. A specific inhibitor of cellulose biosynthesis produced by a strain of Streptomyces sp. J. Antibiot., 43: 1034-1036.
19: Peng, J., X. Shen, K.A. El-Sayed, D.C. Dunbar and T.L. Perry et al., 2003. Marine natural products as prototype agrochemical agents. J. Agri. Food. Chem., 51: 2246-2253.
CrossRef | PubMed |
20: Riguera, R., 1997. Isolating bioactive compound from marine organisms. J. Mar. Biotechnol., 5: 187-193.
Direct Link |
21: Vernon. V. and J. Vandiver, 2005. Biology and control of duckweed with herbicides. http://taylor.ifas.ufl.edu/docs/Marine_NatRes/Aquaculture/BiologyControlDuckweedWithHerbicide.pdf
22: Wright, A.E., 1998. Isolation of Marine Natural Products. In: Methods in Biotechnology, Natural Products Isolation, Cannell, R.P.J. (Ed.). Humana Press Inc., New Jersey, ISBN: 978-0-89603-362-7, pp: 305-408