Role of Fisheries Sector on Sustainable Development of Maldives: How Can Education Help?
Gazi Mahabubul Alam,
Abdul Jalil Othman,
Talukder Golam Rabby
Pradip Kumar Mishra
Proper utilization of natural resources has been considered as one of the key
tools for development. Experience confirms that while a few countries have become
industrialized through the proper usage of natural resources by expanding other
sectors with the alignment of global development phenomena, some countries are
only consuming the wealth of natural resources and expending pleasurable daily
life without working for fundamental sustainable development required to meet
the future challenges. Maldives is one of the developing countries having some
potential natural resources. A country of islands must have an ample prospect
of fisheries sector. There is a shortage of competent manpower both at the level
of policy making and at the grass root level. The fisheries sector of Maldives
is yet to be developed with a long run vision that is connected with the national
development goal. Countrys borrowed
British education system is not necessarily catering to the local need. Given
the nature of this short communication research letter, this study will explore
some issues with an aim of offering some suggestions towards a solution.
Criteria of development and approaches towards development and their schemata
have evolved out of historical social practices (Alam et
al., 2009; Rabby et al., 2011a; Birdsall,
1993; Kaplan and Celik, 2008). Interpretation of
social events is guided and constrained by the prevailing rationality which
itself reflects the dominant constellation of power (Alam,
2009; Rabby et al., 2011b). Living in the
era of globalization, denying the definition of development and its patterns
(economic, social and human need) prescribed mainly by Western school of thought
would not only make a country isolated but also dysfunctional (Alam
et al., 2009; Rabby et al., 2011a).
Approaches towards development process may vary from one country to another
(Rabby et al., 2011a). A country which lacks
natural resources is in a disadvantaged position in the running competition
of development compared to other counterparts which have been enjoying the benefit
of natural resources (Nargis and Hossain, 2006; Scoones,
1998). However, evidence also asserts that over dependency on natural resources
makes a nation lethargic which can be a greater hindrance for development. None
can repudiate the need of competent manpower for the developmental process (Alam
et al., 2009; Al-Amin et al., 2012).
A country where natural resources are in place should use this as an extra support
to open and operate other sectors that can sustain even after a sudden collapse
of the naturally established sector or a sector supported by the nature.
RESEARCH CONTEXT AND ISSUES
Maldives is a country of islands. The size and shape of the Islands vary albeit
the lifestyle, climate, living-hood and income pattern amongst the Islands
population are almost same (Adam, 2006). Almost all of
the islands are accommodating very less number of populations (MOPND,
2006a). Male the capital of Maldives accommodates one third of total population
(MOPND, 2008, 2006b). The south
named as Addu city (combined with a few Islands) contains the second largest
population (MOPND, 2006a). Operating educational establishments
in these two areas are less hassling compared to others in term of communication
and other administrative processes involved (World Bank,
Lack of competent academic force and atypical geographic disposition restrict
the country not to have its own distinct education system (World
Bank, 2002). Primary and secondary school system has been operating in the
country since long; however, the main purpose of these schools is to cater to
the students; so that after a certain period, they can qualify the British prescribed
O and A levels examination. It is thus a prodigious lacking of education system
to offer something concrete that is exclusively vital for the local developmental
needs (Alam, 2009). The students who obtain O and A
level qualifications are lucky enough to serve for public service (World
Bank, 2002). Due to lack of local tertiary education, students usually travel
overseas to study undergraduate and postgraduate levels (Mohamed,
2005; Chauhan, 2008; Middlehurst
and Woodfield, 2004). The number of candidates having undergraduate and
postgraduate qualifications is dramatically increasing with an employment placement
in public service, business and politics (ADB, 2012).
Higher education provides a podium of research helping the country to have a
secondary and primary education that ensure the supply of semi-skilled, upgrading
skilled manpower required targeting the local developmental needs (Castely,
2005). Lately, a few private institutions of higher education alongside
one public counterpart offer tertiary education. But unfortunately, these institutions
responses are towards meeting the demand posed through diploma disease
(Mohamed, 2005). It is therefore a knowledge driven
higher education which is still missing.
Given the nature of the primary, secondary and higher education, in-service
training has to play the vital role for preparing their employees ready for
the job (Alam et al., 2009). Although fisheries
sector needs both highly skilled and semi-skilled manpower, the quantity of
semi-skilled population is exceedingly higher and producing this manpower is
the main responsibility of secondary education (Al-Amin
et al., 2012). Understanding these statuses, this paper will map
the economics of Maldives focusing the fisheries sector with a view to outlining
some steps that education sector can consider to have a sustainable development
process in Maldives.
After drawing the introductory section, this paper will briefly post a research
design. Before making the concluding remark, this study will provide some insights
about Maldives economics and education.
This is short communication research paper which aims at generating a discourse
through the analysis of secondary data and intellectual debates. In order of
obtain information, a number of official web sites of Maldives government, scholarly
sites hosted by different organisation and blog sites are browsed. Moreover,
in order to understand economic development, a number of works of conducted
UN bodies (i.e., UNDP, UNICEF and UNESCO) are used. Data and references are
used as supplementary from earlier literature.
ECONOMICS OF MALDIVES
Maldives is a Muslim country earlier ruled by the British colonial system.
It is therefore often observed that both Islamic and British rules and regulations
ran parallel to each other to administrate the country (Mohamed,
2005). Lately, American domination in global administration process has
also been seen as an agenda of the country. Maldives is a south Asian country
that is passing an experimental process. Since the population is very small
and having huge income from the usage of natural resources, the setback of this
experimental process is yet to provide a harsh lesson for the community (Adam,
2006). But if this continues, it may take it in a course of action that
might bring the danger for the nation.
The country is yet to introduce a proper taxation process ensuring a balancing
between income and expenditure. The main income of the government is GST (goods
and services taxes) collected from every buyer. GST is imposed to everyone who
buys anything regardless the income level, location, type of the product and
need level of the product. Most of the people have to contribute a significant
amount of GST in order to buy the daily necessary items (Chen,
2010). Consequently, the contributions towards GST both by the rich and
the poor clusters are almost same. This kind of economics provides a harder
life for the poor and now many people are frustrated in balancing the necessity
of life. Since the poor cluster is less educated, they are yet understand the
shortcoming and flaws of the GST system even though they are fed up with it.
However, as the citizens have been paying GST hereditarily, they see it as a
culture without being too critical about it. An informal and optional system
named as Zakat (Islamic taxation) is in place (ADB, 2007).
The concept of contribution of Zakat in narrowing the gap between the poor and
the rich is somehow dysfunctional since the system is not developed officially
(ADB, 2007). The GST is the main income for the government
to use both for revenue and development budgets.
Cost of living in Maldives is extremely high as compared to the standard of
life style and the supports for citizenship received. Noting the high figure
of GDP (Gross Domestic Product/Income), it can be apparently considered that
life in Maldives are opulent. Unfortunately, the average income in Maldives
cannot ensure a modicum standard of living at all. It is because, (1) almost
100% dependency on import for both short and long term needs, (2) high expansive
inshore carrying cost and (3) very negligible number of consumer targeted by
one single market.
EMPLOYMENT SECTORS AND CONTRIBUTION TO DEVELOPMENT
The country has mainly depended on two sectors. They are tourism and fisheries
(Inception Report, 2007). Both of the sectors consume
the highest proportion of employment (MOPND, 2008). The
third largest sector of employment is public service locally known as civil
service which also includes teaching profession (MOPND, 2008).
Apparently data shows that tourism contributes largely towards GDP sharing (DNP,
2011). It is thus the government which provides a favourable condition for
tourism sector. Even though, fisheries sector provide a larger employment, the
income and contribution towards GDP sharing is slower than tourism (DNP,
2011). Negligence towards fisheries sector both by the government and societal
levels is the main constraint for the institutionalisation of fisheries sector
of the country. However, if data of informal and part-time engagement on finishing
and their income were to be added, the figure would change significantly.
Tourism sector may largely benefit the country. However, a few important facts
need to be noted, (1) the business of tourism is always in mobilisation for
a number of natural and global contrived reasons, (2) full time employment with
tourism may hinder a decent family life which may bring social problems and
(3) a country with faith in Islamic value may produce different conflicting
and rival groups in the society. One important fact remains silent in the discourse
of tourism business in Maldives. Although this sector provides a large share
to GDP, the key portion of the income of this sector goes to the hand of the
foreigners (who own these enterprises). It is therefore providing a negligent
amount to GDP sharing, with the bulk of the income going overseas. This situation
also makes the life of Maldivians very hard since the citizens of Maldives are
losing out against the competition of global purchasing power. On the other
hand, foreigners, earning from Maldives, enjoy a life of luxury. Despite all
these shortfalls, it is the reality of Maldives to bank upon and survive on
this sector. However, country needs to have another parallel industrial sector
in order to confront any sudden drawback that they may need to face in the future
with the change of global era.
EDUCATION IN MALDIVES
Most of the schools are combined schools providing access both to boys and
girls (MOE, 2010). There are some separate schools for
both the genders. Almost all the schools impart education from primary to secondary
levels. Schools in the atoll also provide education up to higher secondary level.
Currently the operation with a provision for higher secondary education is gradually
on in most of the schools. These days, most of the islands have a school. The
age range of school population varies. However with regard to age policy, every
school has its own policy prepared in the light of national policy. Since appearing
for O and A level examinations has no age limit, it is thus a neglected agenda
in school system especially at the secondary and higher secondary levels. It
is worth noting that an age based policy for formal education system is also
vital to consider for economic and taxation policy of a country. Without ensuring
a minimum standard on it, it is hard to make an economic plan and it is also
unfeasible to provide a school system with a view of demographic needs.
The dropout rate is high at the secondary level. These primary or semi-secondary
graduates may join with the labour force after being dropped out from secondary
provision. Many of them also cannot join the labour force as their knowledge
and skills (that they have acquired) are not saleable in the labour market.
Moreover, age restriction for work is also a core cause for not being part of
the employment force immediately after being dropped out. These days, a significant
portion of school aged population (either in school or dropped out) are addicted
to drugs (UNDP, 2009). Whatever, the fact is; at some
point many of these primary or semi-secondary graduates join the labour force
with the involvement of two major sectors, (1) tourism and (2) fisheries.
CURRENT SYSTEM OF EDUCATION
Little initiative in developing the human resources for both sectors, (1) tourism
and (2) fisheries can be observed at secondary school provision (MOPND,
2008). However since then, schools mainly cater to the students for the
need of passing the examination of British system conducted O and A level examinations.
The endeavours for the development of human resources in both sectors never
see the light of success (Castely, 2005; World
Bank, 2002). Delivery of such education is just an official agenda but not
a pragmatic reality in practice. While employees in tourism sector may receive
some in-house training (with the training provided by the private sector) the
workforce involved in fisheries sector remains untrained.
THE NECESSITY OF TRAINING
In order to ensure the long term and sustainable fisheries sector, fishermen
need to know the right time and right category of the fishes that they can hunt
without interrupting the production cycle (Al-Amin et
al., 2012). A number of casualties always occur for fishing in an adverse
situation (Rabby et al., 2011b). Training on
it may help to reduce the number of casualties. Fish preservation and fish preparation
and preservation for international community without harming the climate are
hard but important tasks (Al-Amin et al., 2012).
Without having a well outlined training, knowledge in due course cannot be accrued.
These kinds of activities would be the tasks of secondary schools while higher
education needs to find out a way of research in this area that would directly
contribute to the sector and also would find out a way in supporting the education
and training offered in the secondary school.
STRATEGIC PLAN AND POLICY
Arguments may convince that providing this kind of training may increase the
productivity of an individual fisherman which would ultimately provide a higher
sharing of GDP of this sector. This also may help to reduce gap of income amongst
different professionals. However, as the way forward to direct policy makers,
a few issues need to be revisited with a rigorous consultation before making
policy and regulatory framework. The issues are: (1) Does Maldives need some
specialized schools exclusively for this kind of training? (2) What could be
the course and curricula and how will they be designed? (3) How will this programme
be incorporated into the existing system? (4) How to encourage the students
to be attentive in such programme? (5) Where to find the qualified competent
instructors? (6) What will be the mode and module of theory and practical sessions?
(7) What will be the commencing grade for this training?
Answering all these questions may need a wider consultation and discussion
with an in-depth analysis of a huge amount of government documents in connection
with economic, public and education policies. As and when necessary, government
should initiate micro researches with an engagement of competent researchers
from various fields (i.e., economics, education, public policy) before drawing
policy and regulatory measure. However, with regard to the first issue, we argue
that given the geographical pattern of Maldives, this training needs to be a
part of the secondary school provision in order to ensure that all the pre-mature
graduates of different regions are covered.
With the current status, this is a neglected area. Legislators and policy-makers
are reluctant in prioritising this sector as it is seen as an orthodox and non-prestigious
profession. It is now time to think that this sector could be a fundamental
industrial sector that would be able to contribute to the global fundamental
needs to a great extent. For constitutionalizing this sector, a national body
needs to be established which would look after the research and developmental
activities of fisheries sector. Under the operational guidance of this department,
centre needs to be established at each atoll to mobilize field level activities.
Demands for the fundamental needs will always be in place even if sudden global
crisis may bring down the demand craving of man-made items (Alam,
2009). Therefore, providing preference for institutionalisation of such
industry will contribute for national sustainable development.
ADB, 2007. Social protection index for committed poverty reduction, volume 16: Maldives country report-final version. Asian Development Bank (ADB), pp: 1-64. http://www2.adb.org/documents/reports/consultant/39261-reg/39261-01-reg-tacr-16.pdf.
ADB, 2012. Maldives: Employment skills training project. Project No. 33217, Asian Development Bank.
Adam, M.S., 2006. Country Review: Maldives. In: Review of the State of World Marine Capture Fisheries Management: Indian Ocean, De Young, C. (Ed.). FAO., Rome, Itlay, pp: 383-391.
Al-Amin, A.Q., G.M. Alam and C.H. Hasanc, 2012. Analysis of offshore economic benefit and growth through the proper uses of the utility and scope of fisheries and livestock (animal and veterinary): A guideline to the MOFL in Bangladesh. J. Anim. Vete. Adv., 11: 866-872.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Alam, G.M., 2009. The role of science and technology education at network age population for sustainable development of Bangladesh through human resource advancement. Sci. Res. Essays, 4: 1260-1270.
Direct Link |
Alam, G.M., K.E. Hoque, M.T.B. Khalifa, S.B. Siraj and M.F.B.A. Ghani, 2009. The role of agriculture education and training on agriculture economics and national development of Bangladesh. Afr. J. Agric. Res., 4: 1334-1350.
Direct Link |
Birdsall, N., 1993. Social development is economic development. Policy Research, The World Bank, Working Paper No WPS 1123.
Castely, R., 2005. Human resource needs study. Final Report March 2005, Republic of Maldives.
Chauhan, C.P.S., 2008. Higher education: Current status and future possibilities in Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan and Sri Lanka. Anal. Rep. Int. Edu., 2: 29-48.
Direct Link |
Chen, E., 2010. What is GST? TAYORI, JAGAM Newsletter, Selangor, Malaysia.
DNP., 2011. Department of national planning: Republic of Maldives. Ministry of Finance and Treasury.
Inception Report, 2007. Employment needs assessment study for social services sector. Inception Report, Social Services Sector, Clique Associate Trainers and Consultants Pvt. Ltd., pp: 1-12.
Kaplan, M. and T. Celik, 2008. The impact of tourism on economic performance: The case of Turkey. The Int. J. Applied Econ. Finance, 2: 13-18.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
MOE, 2010. School statistics 2010. Ministry of Education, Republics of Maldives. http://www.moe.gov.mv/.
MOPND, 2006. Statistical year book of Maldives 2006. Ministry of Planning and National Development (MOPND). http://www.planning.gov.mv/publications/yrb2006/intro.htm.
MOPND, 2006. Population and housing census of Maldives 2006. Ministry of Planning and National Development (MOPND), Maldives. http://www.planning.gov.mv/publications/Population%20and%20Housing%20Census%202006/home.htm.
MOPND, 2008. Statistical year book of Maldives 2008. Ministry of Planning and National Development (MOPND). http://planning.gov.mv/yearbook2008/yearbook.html.
Middlehurst, R. and S. Woodfield, 2004. Summary report: The role of transnational, private, and for-profit provision in meeting global demand for tertiary education: Mapping, regulation and impact. Report Commissioned by the Commonwealth of Learning and UNESCO.
Mohamed, A.M., 2005. Country report from Maldives, regional convention on recognition of qualifications. Proceedings of the 8th Session of the Regional Committee for the Regional Convention on Recognition of Qualifications, May 24-25, 2005, Kunming, China -.
Nargis, N. and M. Hossain, 2006. Income dynamics and pathways out of rural poverty in Bangladesh, 1988-2004. Agric. Econ., 35: 425-435.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Rabby, G.T., G.M. Alam, L.J. Fredericks, S. Nair and N. Azam et al., 2011. What offers solution to the poverty reduction of the Haor people in Bangladesh? Seasonal migration or a new inshore economic livelihood policy? Afr. J. Bus. Manage., 5: 9979-9991.
Direct Link |
Rabby, T.G., G.M. Alam, P.K. Mishra, K.E. Hoque and S. Nair, 2011. Different economic and policy perspectives in micro population for sustainable development: A study of the haor livelihood in Bangladesh. Afr. J. Bus. Manage., 5: 2475-2492.
Direct Link |
Scoones, I., 1998. Sustainable rural Livelihoods: A framework for analysis. IDS Working Paper 72, Institute of Development Studies, University of Sussex.
UNDP, 2009. Konne Kameyyes Vedhaane-Anything is possible: A comprehensive audience analysis for HIV risk in the maldives with recommendations for communication. http://www.undp.org.mv/v2/publication_files/4b3b2505d0afe.pdf.
World Bank, 2002. Project performance assessment report-Maldives: Education and training project (credit 1981) and second education and training project (credit 2701). Report No. 25117: Document of The World Bank. http://lnweb90.worldbank.org/oed/oeddoclib.nsf/DocUNIDViewForJavaSearch/A2B5EB7F276345B385256C860071A654/$file/Maldives_PPAR.pdf.