Developmental Malformations in Avian Species. Manifestations of Unknown or Genetic Etiology-A Review
The anomalies which occur during the development of the avian organisms result in structural and functional abnormalities. In the present review, the majority of surveyed reports on developmental malformations are related to wild birds and secondarily to poultry birds. Regarding their etiology, spontaneous and genetic aberrations were surveyed. The great part of malformations refers to the skeletal system. Among them, the most frequently occurring types were beak deformities, absent, supernumerary or deformed limbs. Embryonic conjoined duplications were also recorded. Anomalies of structure, number and coloration of feather were highlighted. Abnormalities of the heart and ocular malformations were compiled. Also, malformations of the gastrointestinal as well as of the uro-genital system were collected. The malformations which were briefly described constitute a database which could be a useful tool for the further study of embryology, experimental toxicology and teratology of animals.
Received: May 27, 2010;
Accepted: July 02, 2010;
Published: September 30, 2010
The birds represent a big part of animal diversity. They constitute a section
of the wild fauna, are used for meat and egg production and also as pet animals.
Additionally, many of them are utilized as experimental animals. During the
development of an avian organism appear malformations which mainly occur during
the pre-hatching period as well as during the post hatching period. Hence, developmental
malformations are defined as abnormalities of structure and many times of position
present at hatching (congenital malformations or congenital deformities-anomalies).
Most defects are recognized at hatching but some go undetected until somewhat
The causes of congenital malformations can be divided into 3 categories: unknown,
genetic and environmental. The cause of a majority of animal malformations is
unknown. A significant proportion of congenital malformations of unknown cause
is likely to have an important genetic component.
The knowledge of normal and abnormal development of avian organisms has intrigued
the scientific community from the very old years. Romanoff
(1972) published a classical textbook on the pathogenesis of the avian embryo.
Through a few thousands of references the developmental procedures and abnormalities
of the fowl and other poultry birds were analyzed. A review on the developmental
disorders of the skeleton of domestic chickens and turkeys (Ridell, 1975) summarized
in a great extend the skeletal malformations of these poultry species. Consequently,
Crawford (1990) in his textbook Poultry Breeding
and Genetics included many chapters dealing with the inherited abnormalities
of avian species with special reference to species which are used in animal
production. The authors of the relevant chapters surveyed in extent as well
as in depth the abnormalities in Domestic fowls, Geese, Turkeys, Japanese quails,
Ring-necked pheaseants, Domestic ducks, Guinea fowls and Muscovy ducks. Additionally
the authors focused mainly in abnormalities of genetic etiology. However, enough
publications of spontaneous or experimental embryological-teratological nature
were omitted. Since that time many more records have appeared in the literature
and simultaneously many of them shifted towards the impact of Toxicology and
environmental pollution on birds.
In the present review the literature survey will fill the gaps between the
works of Romanoff and Crawford with the up to date bibliography on this subject.
The aim of the survey is to provide a broad and thorough database of information
regarding the major proportion of such malformations.
Early lethal conditions: Blood ring is an early embryonic lethal condition
initially observed in fertilized Wrolstad Medium White turkey eggs after 10
days of incubation. The blood ring (blr) had a discernable embryo and
a sinus terminalis (Savage and Mirosh, 1992). Another
early embryonic lethal condition was observed in dwarf Single Comb White Leghorn
chickens (Savage et al., 1992). The disorder
called blastoderm degeneration is macroscopically evident at 32 h of incubation.
Microscopically is characterized by a series of retarded developmental processes.
The symbol bld was proposed for this recessive gene.
Conjoined twins: Twin avian embryos occur rarely. Two symmetrical double
malformations with four legs and two anuses were described in a Sex-Sal chick
(Hoffmann, 1968). The supernumerary shorter legs were
located laterally to the normal legs and connected by connective tissue with
the scapulae. Both anuses were functional. A conjoined twin mallard (Anas
platyrynchos) has been reported during an experiment. The embryos were joined
at the head and neck region (Batt et al., 1975).
The avian double monsters occur frequently in ducks where about 2% of all fertilized
eggs form such malformations (Ulshafer and Clavert, 1979).
The authors observed a great amount of duck eggs between 48 and 72 h of incubation
and categorized the double monsters in four different groups. In Group 1 the
notochords approached each other medially. The twins shared a common cephalic
extremity, having one well formed prosencephalon with one set of optic rudiments
and one or two hypophyses. In Group 2, the notochords approached each other
medially. Each embryo had its own forebrain which had either both or only one
lateral optic rudiment. In group 3 the notochords approached each other frontally.
Both embryos lacked all forebrain structures. In some cases rhomboencephalic
structures of both embryos were normal while frequently one or both twins lacked
otic rudiments and/or hindbrain entirely. In Group 4, the secondary embryo approached
the first somewhat perpendicularly. The primary embryo was normal while the
twin lacked optic vesicles and frequently other brain structures. During a study
of embryonic respiration in the Wedge-tailed shearwater (Puffinus pacificus),
an egg was collected and found to contain a double conjoined twin embryo. The
body of the embryo was completely duplicated except for a common head with one
eye absent and the brain exposed on the left side (Pettit
and Gousey Whittow, 1981). Malformed chick embryos encountered during experiments
on embryos at the 2nd and 3rd day of incubation have been collected by Nakamura
and Itasaki (1991). Among them, conjoined twins in which the two embryos
shared a head and each embryo extended in opposite directions were observed.
Also parallel twins with fused heart tubes were described. An Arbor Acres female
X Peterson male crossbred 6 week-old female broiler chicken possessed four legs,
two cloacae and three ceca (Ebako et al., 2002).
The intestines occupied the caudo-dorsal portion of the abdominal cavity with
three ceca attached to the terminal end of the ileum. The left lateral cecum
was larger and had a divided distal end that terminated into 2 cm-long blind
sacs. The rectum was dilated and divided into two cloacae. The two extra legs
were attached to the pygostyle. The extra legs were smaller in size compared
with the normal legs.
A case of conjoined cephalopagus twinning in an ostrich (Struthio camelus)
has been described by Mazzullo et al. (2007).
The twins displayed one head containing a single brain, two spinal cords and
deviated vertebral columns. Both twins possessed two upper and lower limbs each.
Beak deformities: Abnormal bills in wild birds are rare, with a frequency
estimated at less than 0.5% (Pomeroy, 1962). Pomeroy
reviewed the literature concerning species with abnormal bills and their probable
causes. He listed the types of deformities as crossed mandibles upper mandible
decurved, lower mandible upcurved, upper mandible upcurved and/or lower mandible
decurved, elongation, lateral curvature and locked bills. Abnormalities of the
beak are also seen in poultry species (Riddell, 1975).
According to the majority of surveyed deformities a genetic basis was assigned.
Bill deformities seem more prevalent in certain groups of passerines (Craves,
1994). According to the author the families Icteridae and Mimidae as well
as species such as European starlings (Sturnus vulgaris) and House sparrows
(Passer domesticus) present high incidence of reported deformities. Craves
provided tables which summarized a considerable number of these reports. Table
1 summarizes some old reports which were omitted from previous publications
as well as updated reports of beak malformations.
Short beak is a new semi-lethal mutation of Japanese quail (Coturnix japonica).
The affected birds are characterized externally by short beaks, shanks and digits.
Genetic analyses revealed that the short beak mutation is controlled by an autosomal
recessive gene. The proposed gene symbol is sbk (Tsudzuki
et al., 1998).
|| Beak malformations in avian species
Feather: Much has been written about the structure, number and pigmentation
of the feathers of birds. Bird plumage aberrations can be restricted to a single
feather, a group of feathers or may concern the entire body which changes radically
the appearance of an individual bird. The most striking anomalies in plumage
are albinism resulting from the total lack of pigment production and leucism
resulting from some other deficiency in the pigmentation process. Leucism is
a form of incomplete partial albinism in which the eyes, bill and legs remain
normally colored, while the plumage contains no color pigments or decreased
pigmentation (Sage, 1962). Sage compiled 3134 records
of albinism in British birds. The great bulk of records (67%) have occurred
in the Turdidae, Corvidae, Hirundinidae, Passeridae, Sturnidae and Fringillidae.
Gross (1965a) published two accounts on the incidence
of albinism and melanism in North American birds. Regarding the
albinism, Gross (1965a) classified albinos birds into
four groups: 1. Total or pure, 2. Incomplete, 3. Imperfect, 4. Partial. Also,
he listed 54 families in which albinism have occurred and found 304 albinistic
species represented by 1847 individuals. Regarding melanism, Gross
(1965b) noted only 29 species in which this abnormality occurred. In his
paper referred also to two other types of color anomalies in feathers. He mentioned
the erythrism (intensification of red pigment) and the xanthochroism (abnormal
coloring of the plumage in which yellow color replaces the normal coloring).
Table 2 summarizes color abnormalities of feather in various
A new mutation has been identified in the turkey that inhibits the rate of
feathering (Zakrzewska and Savage, 1997). The abnormality
affected the number, size and structure of feathers. At hatch the affected birds
lacked flight feathers. As the birds grow, the expressivity of the disorder
may vary. The symbol K*IF was proposed for the mutation. A case of an
urban-breeding pair of northern goshawks (Accipiter gentiles) that produced
five aberrant offspring with diluted plumage coloration and severe locomotory
disorders has been published by Rutz et al. (2004).
Abnormalities in the number and structure of feathers have been frequently
described involving many species. Stresemann (1963)
published an account on the variation of primaries. He reviewed the available
literature and examined 4 specimens with abnormal number of primaries. The specimens
were a Horned screamer (Anhima cornuta), a Cassin's auklet (Ptychoramphus
aleuticus), a Bar-tailed godwit (Limosa lapponica baueri) and a Glossy
ibis (Plegadis falcinellus).
|| Anomalies of feather coloration in avian species
In a thorough examination of 200 Saw-whet owls (Aegolius acadica),
a bird was found to possess only 9 primaries whereas other birds had unequal
number of restrices (Mueller and Berger, 1966). A case
on the lack of feathers in a juvenile Brown noddy (Anous stolidus) has
been recognized by Schreiber (1975). The complete absence
of coverts and flight feathers characterized the individual. Down feathers appeared
to be of normal length but were sparsely distributed.
A generalized feather abnormality (pinching off syndrome) has been described
in various European birds (Bijlsma and van der Burg, 2006).
The nestlings develop malformed remiges and/or restrices. Malformed feathers
are often symmetrically positioned in wing and/or in tail. In the Netherlands
this syndrome has been recorded in Northern goshawk (Accipiter gentilis),
Common buzzard (Buteo buteo) and European Honey-buzzard (Pernis apivorus).
In Germany this syndrome has been described in White-tailed eagles (Haliaeetus
Ocular malformations: Developmental abnormalities affecting the eye
have been infrequently reported in birds. Anophthalmia (the bilateral absence
of eyes) and microphthalmia (the reduction in development of one or both eyes)
are fairly common anomalies in embryos of the domestic fowl. A condition called
colaboma or coloboma is usually congenital and is characterized by an absence
of some portion of the eye. An adult Rough-legged hawk (Buteo lagopus)
and a Red-tailed hawk (Buteo jamaicensis) both exhibited colabomas which
involved a lack of development or an atrophy of approximately three fourths
of the iris, lens, retina and choroids (Lord, 1956).
Wallace (1956) described a case of microphtahlmia in
an American robin (Turdus migratorius) and Wetherbee
(1958) described unilateral microphthalmia in a Common Grackle (Quiscalus
quiscula) and synophthalmia (cyclopia) in a Mockingbird (Mimus polyglottus).
Another case of anophthalmia in an American Robin was recognized by Berger
and Howard (1968). The eyeless bird exhibited a beak with the upper mandible
being slightly shorter than the lower mandible. A potential eye-slit between
the incipient eyelids was about 1 mm in maximum length in the anteroposterior
direction bilaterally. In a survey of spontaneous ocular developmental abnormalities
of raptors, various anomalies were recorded (Buyukmihci
et al., 1988). These malformations together with other cases appear
in Table 3. Varying forms of partial cryptophthalmos (a condition
in which the eyelid skin is continuous over the orbit) have been reported in
four cockatiels (Nymphicus hollandicus) by Buyukmihci
et al. (1990). A new mutation of the chicken that causes a reduction
in eyeball size, was described (Somes, 1992). Eyeball
size reduction was extreme in over 80% of affected individuals. Two thirds of
affected chickens had bilateral expression while the rest was unilaterally affected.
Data from various crosses indicated that this condition is inherited as an autosomal
recessive with expression being limited primary to females. The name microphthalmia-4
and the gene mi-4 were proposed for this trait. Unilateral anophthalmia
with beak deformation was found in a Western bluebird (Sialia mexicana)
by Eltzroth (1996). In a 6-month-old Red-vented cockatoo
(Cacatua haematouropygia) a congenital cause was considered for symblepharon
between third and upper eyelids with secondary lagophthalmos (Kern
et al., 1996). An inherited ocular anomaly was reported by Salter
et al. (1997). Affected chicks had ocular lesions varying in number
and severity, but both eyes were always affected. The earliest and most frequent
lesions were dilated pupils, malformed lenses, buphthalmos and dysplasia of
the pecten. Table 3 summarizes ocular defects in various birds.
|| Ocular malformations in avian species
Cardiovascular anomalies: Cardiovascular anomalies have been reported
rarely in birds as clinical or post-mortem findings. In contrary, cardiac anomalies
have been induced experimentally in chicken embryo models.
Siller (1958, 1967) cited a
few references of congenital cardiac abnormalities such as ectopia cordis (displacement
of the heart), duplicitas and multiplicitas cordis, aplasia, malposition and
patent foramen ovale. The author (1958) recorded 288 cases of Ventricular Septal
Defects (VSD) in domestic fowls. Most cases (97%) were confined to birds of
only three inbred lines. Great variation existed in the general conformation
of these septal defects and in the size of the communication between left and
right ventricles. Three distinct types were differentiated: 1 large patent defects,
2 Small patent defects, 3 Completely closed defects. The study, on the incidence
of congenital heart disease, in broiler chickens, continued by Siller
and Hemsley (1966). The following forms of malformations were encountered:
10 cases of uncomplicated VSD, 8 cases of uncomplicated Atrial Septal Defects
(ASD), 2 with combined ASD and VSD, 7 cases with septal defect and overriding
aorta, 2 cases with transposition of the aorta to the right ventricle and one
case of cor triloculare biatrium. In one chicken the carotid artery arose anomalously
from the aortic arch. Consequently, the anatomical defects of previous study
(Siller and Hemsley, 1966) as well as new cardiac cases
were further analyzed (Siller, 1967).
Siller (1968) found an association between sternal
fissure and congenital heart disease in the embryos and newly hatched chicks.
Transposition of aorta to the right ventricle was observed in many chicks. Ventricular
septal defects were observed in young Broad-Breasted White turkeys. In 2 cases
a VSD was seen, but in another case gross structural evidence of naturally occurring
closure of the defect was detected (Einzig et al.,
1972). Nakamura and Itasaki (1991) found 4 chicken
embryos in which the lateral endothelial heart tubes did not fused at the midline.
In all the embryos, each heart tube looped independently, the right one to the
right side and the left one to the left side. An umbrella cockatoo (Cacatua
alba) had a ventricular septal defect and persistent truncus arteriosus
whereas a Mollucan cockatoo (Cacatua moluccensis) had a subvalvular septal
defect and aortic hypoplasia (Evans et al., 2001).
In a juvenile Houbara bastard (Clamydotis undulate macqueenii) that died
suddenly, ventricular septal defect was found during the post-mortem examination
(Bailey and Kinne, 2001).
Gastrointestinal malformations: Abnormalities of the gastrointestinal
system have been documented in the avian veterinary medicine. In Gregory
and Greaves (1947) reported a case of intestinal herniation in a 7 days
old chicken which involved the duodenum, the pancreas and a major portion of
the ileum and ceca. Later, A 6 day old White Leghorn male with a malformation
involving the small intestine was described (Glick and Ellis,
1962). Duplication of the ileum was observed in a 4-month old Babcock pullet.
Adjacent to the small persistent Meckels diverticulum, a side branch projected
out from the ileum and opened into a blind-ended sac-like structure near the
cloaca (Grewal et al., 1976). The same authors
described a case of aplasia of the left caecum in a 20-week old White Leghorn
pullet. A case of a duplicated lower intestinal tract in a broiler chicken included
a branched ileum (Chapman et al., 1997). The
ileum of the malformed branch was swollen and attached to paired caecae that
were grossly enlarged. The rectum was a swollen blind sac disconnected from
the exterior of the bird. Congenital intestinal incarcerations were recorded
in commercial broilers including Cobb, Arbor Acres and Ross breeds. The etiology
of the problem assigned to the incomplete closure of the abdominal wall (Wojnarowicz
and Olkowski, 2009).
Abnormalities of the liver and pancreas are rare. Grewal
et al. (1976) described a case of vesica fellea occulta where the
gallbladder was almost completely surrounded by liver tissue in a 7 month old
White Leghorn pullet. In a 30 week old White Leghorn hen a bifurcation of the
pancreas was recorded. Absence of liver lobes as well as missing or misplaced
gall bladders in poultry birds reported by Tudor (1979).
Additionally, a gall bladder anomaly in a 7-week old broiler cockerel referred
as a spontaneous manifestation (Anderson and Miller, 1986).
The cystic lumina contained multiple elongated papillary epithelial projections
and plicae composed of epithelium and lamina propria, abutting normal lining
Skeletal anomalies: Several localized skeletal abnormalities have been
reported in birds, but a genetic etiology is usually difficult to prove especially
when the number of cases is small. In many cases, abnormalities in a skeletal
element are combined with other malformations.
A Herring gull (Larus arginatus) presented a grossly deformed bill (Threlfall,
1968). Thorough examination of the specimens anatomy revealed malformations
of head skeleton. The dentary and suprangular of the right half of the lower
mandible were turned outwards and downwards. The left and right nasal bones
and premaxillae were twisted to the right and downwards. The skull kinetics
in birds attracted the attention of Burton (1972). In
his study, a skull of a Rufescent Tiger-Heron (Trigrisoma lineatum) and
a skull of a Black-necked Aracari (Pteroglossus aracari) were examined.
The first specimen had a deformed orbital process of the right quadrate, whereas,
the second specimen had a complicated anomaly involving the quadrate and the
associate musculature. Particularly, the greater part of the orbital process
of the quadrate was missing and the left M. pseudotemporalis profundus consisted
of several portions. Research on the breeding biology and populations genetics
of lesser snow geese (Chen caerulescens caerulescens) revealed developmental
abnormalities of the head. A specimen displayed duplication of both upper and
lower mandibles with the lower ones being medially fused. There were two normal-sized
eye sockets and eyes on the lateral sides of the head and a single fused medial
socket in the front of the skull that contained two eyes (Rockwell
et al., 2003). Examination of the skull of a pink pigeon (Columba
mayeri) revealed a failure of the right supraorbital ridge and the right
premaxillary process of the nasal bone to develop and an abnormal small and
incompletely formed scleral ring (Waine, 1998).
The two elongated hyoid horns, composed of the ceratobranchial and epibranchial
bones, extend posteriorly from the posterior end of the basihyal, curving around
the occipital region and roof of the skull and extending forward along the dorsal
cranial surface toward the nostrils (Wallace, 1974).
Wallace (1974) studied several species of melanerpine
woodpeckers and found that a surprising number of birds showed abnormal tongue
development. The study involved examination of the Red-bellied woodpecker (Centurus
carolinus), Golden-fronted woodpecker (Centurus aurifrons), Red-headed
woodpecker (Melanerpes erythrocephalus), Hispaniolan woodpecker (Centurus
striatus) and Puerto Rican woodpecker (Melanerpes portoricensis).
The abnormalities in every case involved the position or relative size of the
epibranchial horns with their attached branchiomandibularis muscles.
Deformities of the spine have been reported in poultry birds. Most of these
reports describe scoliosis which is a malformation of multiple etiology including
primarily genetic factors. Scoliosis has been described in the chicken (Chlumsky,
1924; Rigdon and Mack, 1968a) and in the white Pekin
duck (Anas platyrhynchos) (Rigdon and Mack, 1968b;
Rigdon, 1971). The spinal defect has been attributed
to a persistent notochord and improper differentiation of spinal segments.
Rib anomalies in avian species were examined by Lucas (1888).
His observations are listed in Table 4.
In a 22-week old White Leghorn hen a hernia-like swelling in the middle of
the breast bone was observed. The caudal medial projection of the sternum (metasternum)
was bifurcated in the middle into two small projections (Grewal
et al., 1976) The same authors described another case of keel abnormality
in a female White Leghorn chicken. The major defect was the absence of the whole
of the sternal keel and the imperfect development of the major part of the metasternum
ventrally (Grewal et al., 1980).
A four winged adult female Green-winged teal (Nettion carolinense) has
been described from Johnson (1915). The supernumerary
wings appeared as a miniature set springing from the under side of the primary
wings at the region of the elbow. Stanton Grant Ernst (1943)
reported a case of deformation in the wing of a pied-billed grebe (Podilymbous
podiceps podiceps).The left wing was stunted with an apparent fusion of
the carpal articulation.
Rogers and Dauber (1977) reported a case of a male
with all toes missing on the right foot and the front middle toe missing on
the left foot and a female with right rear talon missing. A spur 2 cm long was
found in a 64-week old White Leghorn hen.
|| Rib abnormalities in avian species
Post-mortem examination revealed a well developed ovary. Grewal
and Singh (1978). Developmental abnormalities in two British falcons were
recognized by Cooper (1984). In the first case an immature
female peregrine falcon (Falco peregrinus) exhibited duplication of hind
digit (digit 1) on the left leg. The two digits, which appeared to be higher
up the leg than normal, were joined by a web of skin. The bird also appeared
to have two accessory digits on the left carpus. In the second case, a male
merlin (Falco columbaris), a fusion of digits 3 and 4 on the right foot
was detected. Three wingless pullet hens were discovered at an egg-production
ranch. Two of the birds were amelic and one was ectromelic and all of them had
also scoliosis (Ruble et al., 2002). A tawny
owl chick (Strix aluco) with multiple congenital malformations in the
limbs was studied (Barreiro et al., 2003). The
animal had dislocation of radius and carpometacarpus with abnormal nonfunctional
fixation of ligamentum propatagialis. Also, most parts of the bones of the manus
in both wings were absent.
Two cases of unilateral micromelia were described in wild juvenile little penguins
(Eudyptula minor). The bird's left flipper was reduced in length and
radiography demonstrated severe shortening and dysplasia of the humerus. Clinical
examination revealed that the second bird was underweight (0.55 kg) but otherwise
in good condition with subadult plumage and had probably only recently fledged.
The left wing was markedly reduced in size and had limited range of elbow and
carpal joint movement but sensation and motor control were normal. Radiography
demonstrated a severe reduction in size and distortion of the humerus and shortening
and fusion of the ulna, radius, metacarpals and phalanges. The furcula was asymmetrical
because the left clavicle was slightly thinner and more radiolucent than the
right and was also slightly deviated to the right side (Raidal
et al., 2006).
In a House finch (Carpodacus mexicanus) total absence of the right leg
was reported (Michener and Michener, 1936). No scar
was visible and feathers were growing over the area where the leg should have
been. Two similar teratological specimens of the Red-winged Blackbird (Agelaius
phoeniceus), from different geographical areas were found in the course
of artificially incubating eggs of this species (Wetherbee,
1960).The defect was observable in the neonates only by corrosion-staining-clearing
techniques. The femora and humeri were crooked, the ilia and ischia were much
shortened and delayed ossification at the distal ends of tibiae, tarsometatarsi,
ulnae and radii was observed. A one-legged adult male brown-headed cowbird (Molothrus
ater) has been described by Manwell (1964). The
right leg was completely missing. Also, the pubis was absent whereas the ilium
and ischium were defectively developed. No signs of musculature normally associated
with the proximal end of the femur were detected.
A Mourning dove (Zenaidura macroura carolinensis) with three legs was
described by Frankowiak (1962). One of the legs was
normal whereas the second had another small leg growing from its tibia-tarsus
joint. The third leg had only an inner and outer toe. Similar case was reported
in a Sooty tern (Sterna fuscata) (Austin, 1969).
In a male common snipe (Capella gallinago) an extra digit on the hallux
(toe 4) on each foot was recorded. The right and left extra digits were 4 mm
and 3.5 mm respectively (Fogarty, 1969). Polydactyly
was observed in a ring-billed gull (Larus delawarensis). The extra foot
elements on each leg originated distally from the median anterior portion of
the tibiotarsus (Ryder and Chamberlain, 1972). Forsythe
(1972) described in a long-billed curlew (Numenius americanus) a
supernumerary digit attached to the medial aspect of the left hallux. The extra
toe arose at the base of the hallux; it measured 4.5 mm with the claw whereas
the hallux was 7.5 mm with claw. Changed phalanges in form and number were found
on both wings (Trinkaus et al., 1999). In a female
kestrel (Falco tinnunculus tinnunculus) polydactyly was described. The
bird had extra toes on the right foot and three extra toes in the left one.
Additionally the bird presented an extra finger on the right wing. The occurrence
of an ostrich (Struthio camelus) chick which hatched with four temporarily
functional legs has been reported by Horbanczuk et al.
(2004). The one day old chick was fully developed with complete feathers.
The first pair of legs was normally developed whereas the second pair was thinner,
pale but almost the same size as the first pair. Between the sacrum and the
tail, a short vertebral column emerged ventrally out of the normal one. Attached
to it on either side were apparently normal and functional lower legs from the
tibiotarsus to the toes, while the femur was missing on both sides. An extra
symmetrically located toe was found on each foot of one Vauxs swift (Chaetura
vauxi) (Sakai, 2006). The author reported from his
bibliographic survey 10 other cases of polydactyly in mallard duck (Anas
platyrhynchos), Wilsons snipe (Gallinago delicate), Sooty tern
(Sterna fuscata), Long billed curlew (Numenius americanus), Ring-billed
gull (Larus delawarensis), Common nighthawk (Chordeiles minor),
Common loon (Gavia immer), Common swift (Apus apus), Eurasian
kestrel (Falco tinnunculus) and Eastern Screech-owl (Megascops asio).
Apart from the supernumerary limbs there are also cases of diminished limbs.
An apparently new mutation that is associated with abnormal limb development
appeared in a strain of Light brown Leghorn chickens (Smyth
et al., 2000). Mutants were characterized by the complete absence
of the tarsometarsals, while severely hypoplastic development of the metacarpals
was also present. The phenotype of the mutant (ametapodia-2) is inherited as
an autosomal recessive (AMET*A).
Uro-genital anomalies: A hen presented two vents with the oviduct opening
through the left and the rectum through the right. The two passages were separate
throughout (Crew, 1928). Next year three cases of double
vents associated with other malformations in the fowl were reported (Roberts
et al., 1929). In the first case, the two vents were of normal size,
symmetrically placed and opened into a common cloaca. Aplasia of the right kidney
and hypoplasia of the corresponding ureter was found in a 4-month old Babcock
pullet (Grewal et al., 1976). The same authors
described a case of aplasia of the right kidney and ureter in a 10-week old
White Leghorn pullet. In an extended survey of autopsies (Tudor,
1979), kidney tissue was reported absent on one side, or from posterior,
middle, or anterior lobes, or from combinations of all three. Ureters were dilated
in some birds whereas others displayed only remnants of ureters. The author
discussed extensively the kidney anomalies in birds including quails and pigeons.
Morgan and Kohlmeyer (1957) have described an inbred
line of Rhode Island Reds with persistent right oviducts. The nesting behavior
of a wild Giant Canada goose (Branta canadensis maxima) led Lumsden
and Vernon (1983) to examine the genital system of the bird. The failure
of the goose to lay was a result of a deformed and blocked oviduct. The funnel-
shaped infundibulum was missing. Hereditary, persistent, right oviduct manifested
in an inbred line (PNP/DO line) from the Fayoumi breed of chickens was investigated
(Wakamatsu et al., 2000). Females had varying
lengths of elongated right oviducts, besides the normal left ovary and oviducts
that generally possess, irrespective of their total length, regions similar
to those normally observed in a left oviduct.
In the present bibliographical survey, the malformations of spontaneous and
genetic nature were reviewed. The great part of the malformations involved the
skeletal system. Another part refers to ocular anomalies, feather anomalies
and abnormalities of the heart, gastrointestinal and urogenital system. The
majority of the developmental malformations that have been surveyed in the present
review refer to anomalies that are easily observable by persons who are not
necessarily specialized scientists such as ornithologists or avian veterinarians.
Malformations which can not be recognizable and identifiable usually are disregarded.
The deformities of the birds reflect the status of their health as well as
the status of their habitat. The abnormalities of the poultry populations are
related mainly to inherited diseases. The abnormalities of the wild populations
are related to more complicated situations which involve spontaneous, genetic,
toxicological and environmental factors.
The present review summarized reports which together with the accounts of Romanoff
(1972), Riddell (1975) and Crawford
(1990) provide an extended database of developmental abnormalities. The
report of such abnormalities serves to enrich the knowledge about the normal
and abnormal development of avian species and in extension of the other animals
and human beings. The scientists, ornithologists, veterinarians, foresters,
bird-banners are encouraged to observe and refer such malformations to the authorized
centers. The use of the data on abnormalities could be a potential bio-monitoring
tool to assess changes in environmental conditions that are sufficient to have
biological impact. This is the next scientific challenge of avian embryology
1: Anderson, W.I. and D.M. Miller, 1986. Gall bladder anomaly in a young chicken. Cornell Vet., 76: 380-385.
2: Austin, O.L., 1969. Extra toes on a Sooty tern chick. Auk, 86: 352-352.
3: Bailey, T.A. and J. Kinne, 2001. Ventricular septal defect in Houbara bustard (Clamydotis undulate macqueenii). Avian Dis., 45: 229-233.
4: Barreiro, A., P. Fdez. D. Troconiz, M. Vila, A.M. Lopez-Beceiro and J.L. Pereira, 2003. Congenital skeletal abnormalities in a Tawny owl chick. Avian Dis., 47: 774-776.
Direct Link |
5: Batt, B.D.J., J.A. Cooper and G.W. Cornwell, 1975. The occurrence of twin waterfowl embryos. Condor, 77: 214-214.
6: Batts, H.L., 1954. An American bittern with a deformed bill. Wilson Bull., 66: 142-142.
7: Berger, A.J. and D.V. Howard, 1968. Anophthalmia in the American robin. Condor, 70: 386-387.
8: Bijlsma, R.G. and A. van den Burg, 2006. Feather abnormalities in nestling raptors. De Takkeling, 14: 194-198.
Direct Link |
9: Blight, L.K. and S. Stevens, 2000. Partial melanism in King penguins (Aptenodytes patagonicus). Mar. Ornithol., 28: 83-83.
Direct Link |
10: Burton, P.J.K., 1972. Two bird specimens showing abnormalities of the quadrate. Auk, 89: 882-885.
11: Buyukmihci, N.C., C.J. Murphy and T. Schultz, 1988. Developmental ocular disease of raptors. J. Wildlife Dis., 24: 207-213.
Direct Link |
12: Buyukmihci, N.C., C.J. Murphy, J. Paul-Murphy, D.V. Hacker, L.J. Larrata and D.E. Brooks, 1990. Eyelid malformation in four cockatiels. J. Am. Vet. Med. Assoc., 196: 1490-1492.
13: Chapman, H.D., J.N. Beasely and A.B. Hacker, 1997. Broiler chicken with a duplicated lower intestinal tract. Avian Dis., 41: 1003-1005.
Direct Link |
14: Chlumsky, V., 1924. About the scoliosis in house birds. Z. orthop. Chir., 44: 470-478.
15: Ciach, M., 2009. The first record of melanism in the Red-backed Shrike Lanius collurio. Ornis Svecica, 19: 55-55.
16: Clark, W.S., 1998. First North American record of a melanistic osprey. Wlison Bull., 110: 289-290.
Direct Link |
17: Cooper, J.E., 1984. Developmental abnormalities in two British falcons (Falco spp). Avian Pathol., 13: 639-645.
18: Craves, J.A., 1994. Passerines with deformed bills. North Am. Bird Bander, 19: 14-18.
Direct Link |
19: Crawford, R.D., 1990. Poultry, Breeding and Genetics. Elsevier, Amsterdam
20: Crew, F.A.E., 1928. A hen with two vents. Vet. J., 84: 363-365.
21: Cringan, A.T., J.C. Cringan, W. Jefrey Blume and E.R. Podell, 2006. A melanistic Northern flicker (Colaptes auratis) in Colorado. North Am. Birds, 60: 306-306.
22: Dukes, T.W. and G.A. Fox, 1983. Blindness associated with retinal dysplasia in a Prairie falcon, Falco mexicanus. J. Wildlife Dis., 19: 66-69.
23: Ebako, G.M., T.Y. Morishita and J.S. Mattoon, 2002. Four-Legged broiler chicken with two cloacae and three ceca. Avian Dis., 46: 234-238.
PubMed | Direct Link |
24: Einzig, S., E.F. Jankus and J.H. Moller, 1972. Ventricular septal defect in turkeys. Am. J. Vet. Res., 33: 563-566.
25: Eisermann, K. and K. Omland, 2007. Coloration anomaly of a male Collared trogon (Trogon collaris). Acta Zool. Mex., 23: 197-200.
26: Eltzroth, E., 1996. Cross-beaked Western Bluebirds. Sialia, 18: 3-4.
27: Evans, D.E., T.N. Tully, K.N. Strickland, J.F. Williams and G.A. Rich, 2001. Congenital cardiovascular anomalies, including ventricular septal defects, in 2 cockatoos. J. Avian Med. Surg., 15: 101-106.
Direct Link |
28: Fogarty, M.J., 1969. Extra toes on the halluces of a Common Snipe. Auk, 86: 132-132.
29: Forsythe, D.M., 1972. Long-billed curlew with supernumerary hallux. Auk, 89: 457-457.
30: Frankowiak, R.G., 1962. Mourning dove with three legs. Auk, 79: 278-278.
31: Glick, B. and L.L. Ellis, 1962. An apparent embryological malformation involving the small intestine of a chick. Poult. Sci., 41: 425-426.
32: Gochfleld, M., 1975. Developmental defects in common terns of Western Long Island. N. Y. Auk, 92: 58-65.
33: Godfrey, W.E., 1967. Xanthochroism in the Cape may warber and evening grosbeak. Can. Field Nat., 81: 226-227.
34: Gregory, D.W. and R.E. Greaves, 1947. A case of intestinal herniation in a chick. J. Am. Vet. Med. Assoc., 110: 28-29.
35: Grewal, G.S., B. Singh and P.S. Sahota, 1976. Congenital anomalies of domestic fowl: Seven cases. Avian Dis., 20: 581-586.
Direct Link |
36: Grewal, G.S. and B. Singh, 1978. Skeletal abnormalities in domestic chicken. Avian Dis., 22: 519-521.
37: Grewal, G.S., G.S. Khaira and B.C. Deka, 1980. Two congenital abnormalities in domestic chickens. Avian Dis., 24: 504-506.
38: Gross, A.O., 1965. The incidence of albinism in North American birds. Bird Banding, 36: 67-71.
Direct Link |
39: Gross, A.O., 1965. Melanism in North American birds. Bird Banding, 36: 240-242.
Direct Link |
40: Helleiner, C.W., 1979. Xanthochroism in the evening grosbeak. Can. Field Nat., 93: 66-67.
41: Hicks, L.E., 1934. Individual and sexual variations in the European starling. Bird Banding, 5: 103-118.
Direct Link |
42: Horbanczuk, J.O., R. Parada, F.W. Huchzermeyer and K. Plaza, 2004. Four-legged ostrich (Struthio camelus) chick. Vet. Rec., 154: 736-736.
43: Howell, S.N.G., S. Webb, D.A. Sibley and L.J. Prairie, 1992. First record of a melanistic Northern harrier in North America. Westerns Birds, 23: 79-80.
44: Johnson, C.E., 1915. A four-winged wild duck. Auk, 32: 469-480.
45: Isted, D., 1985. A xanthochroistic male purple finch. Bull. Oklahoma Ornithol. Soc., 18: 31-31.
46: Kern, T.J., J. Paul-Murphy, C.J. Murphy, N.C. Buyukmiheri and K. Burling et al., 1996. Disorders of the third eyelid in birds: 17 cases. J. Avian Med. Surg., 10: 12-18.
Direct Link |
47: Lord, F.D., 1956. An anomalous condition in the eye of some hawks. Auk, 73: 451-453.
48: Lucas, F.A., 1888. Abnormalities in the ribs of birds. Auk, 5: 329-330.
49: Lumsden, H.G. and G.T. Vernon, 1983. Malformation of the oviduct in a Canada goose. Wilson Bull., 95: 311-313.
Direct Link |
50: Manwell, R.D., 1964. A congenitally one-legged cowbird. Auk, 81: 438-439.
51: Mazzullo, G., G. Montalbano, A. Augello, A. Germana and B. Macri, 2007. A case of conjoined cephalopagus twinning in an ostrich (Struthio camelus). Anat. Histol. Embryol., 36: 263-265.
52: Michener, H. and J.R. Michener, 1936. Abnormalities in birds. Condor, 38: 102-109.
53: Moore, P.A., J.F. Munnell, C.L. Martin, K.W. Prasse and K.P. Carmichael, 2004. Photoreceptor cell dysplasia in two Tippler pigeons. Vet. Ophthalmol., 7: 197-203.
54: Morgan, W. and W. Kohlmeyer, 1957. Hens with bilateral oviducts. Nature, 180: 98-98.
55: Mueller, H.C. and D.D. Berger, 1966. Abnormalities in the remiges and the restrices of the Saw-whet. Bird Banding, 37: 287-287.
56: Muller, K., R. Altenkamp and L. Brunnberg, 2007. Morbidity of free-ranging White-tailed sea eagles (Haliaeetus albicilla) in Germany. J. Avian Med. Surg., 21: 265-274.
57: Nakamura, H. and N. Itasaki, 1991. Analysis of cardiac loop formation in avian embryos with spontaneous heart malformations. Congenital Anom., 31: 315-322.
58: Pettit, T.N. and G. Gausey Whittow, 1981. Embryonic double monster in the wedge-tailed shearwater. Condor, 83: 91-91.
59: Pomeroy, D.E., 1962. Birds with abnormal bills. Brit Birds, 55: 49-72.
60: Guesada, J., 2006. Different pigmentary alterations of a carotenoid-based patch in the Great tit Parus major: Two cases to discuss. Rev. Catalana Ornitologia, 22: 9-13.
Direct Link |
61: Raidal, S.R., P.L. Shearer, B.L. Cannell and R.J. de B. Norman, 2006. Micromelia in little penguins (Eudyptula minor). J. Avian Med. Surg., 20: 258-262.
Direct Link |
62: Riddell, C., 1975. Pathology of developmental and metabolic disorders of the skeleton of domestic chickens and turkeys. I. Abnormalities of genetic or unknown aetiology. Vet. Bull., 45: 629-640.
63: Rigdon, R.H. and J. Mack, 1968. Spontaneous occurrence of scoliosis in the chicken. Avian Dis., 12: 530-543.
Direct Link |
64: Rigdon, R.H. and J. Mack, 1968. Spontaneously occurring scoliosis in the white Pekin duck (Anas platyrhynchos). Am. J. Vet. Res., 29: 1081-1087.
65: Rigdon, R.H., 1971. Scoliosis in ducks. Zentralblatt Fur Vet. Med. Reihe A, 18: 243-249.
66: Rindoul, D.A., 2005. Beak deformity in a brown-headed cowbird with notes on causes of beak deformities in birds. Kansas Ornithol. Soc. Bull., 56: 29-32.
Direct Link |
67: Roberts, E., L.E. Card and E.A. Boyden, 1929. Double vents, associated with congenital absence of the left kidney and persistence of the embryonic genital papilla, in the domestic fowl. Anat. Rec., 43: 155-163.
68: Rockwell, R.F., B.M. Pezzanite and P. Matulonis, 2003. Developmental abnormalities in wild populations of birds: Examples from lesser snow geese (Chen caerulescens caerulescens). Novitates Am. Museum, 3400: 1-14.
Direct Link |
69: Rogers, D.T. and M. Dauber, 1977. Instances of disease and abnormalities in American Kestrels. J. Bird Banding, 48: 73-73.
70: Romanoff, A.L., 1972. Pathogenesis of the Avian Embryo. Wiley Interscience, New York
71: Ruble, R., S. Silvermann, J. Pisenti and P. Wakenell, 2002. Amelia/ectromelia in association with scoliosis in three commercial layer hens (Gallus gallus forma domestica). Avian Pathol., 31: 429-433.
72: Rutz, C., A. Zinke, T. Bartels and P. Wohlsein, 2004. Congenital neuropathy and dilution of feather melanin in nestlings of urban-breeding Northern Goshawks (Accipiter gentiles). J. Zool Wildlife Med., 35: 97-103.
73: Ryder, J.P. and D.J. Chamberlain, 1972. Congenital foot abnormality in the ring-billed gull. Wilson Bull., 84: 342-344.
Direct Link |
74: Sage, B.L., 1962. Albinism and melanism in birds. Br. Birds, 55: 201-225.
75: Sakai, W.H., 2006. Polydactyly in a vaux`s swift. Wilson J. Ornithol., 118: 424-426.
Direct Link |
76: Salter, D.W, W.S. Payne, D.T. Ramsey, M. Blair and J.A. Render, 1997. A new inherited ocular anomaly in pigmented White Leghorn chickens. J. Vet. Diagn. Invest., 9: 407-409.
77: Savage, T.F. and L.W. Mirosh, 1992. Inheritance of blood ring, an early embryonic failure in the turkey. Poult. Sci., 71: 585-589.
78: Savage, T.F., L.W. Mirosh, J.L. Jones and E.T. Schneiderman, 1992. Blastoderm degeneration, an early embryonic failure in dwarf Comb White Leghorn chickens. J. Hered., 83: 249-254.
Direct Link |
79: Schreiber, R.W., 1975. Abnormal Anous stolidus from Christmas Island, Pacific Ocean. Auk, 92: 369-370.
80: Short, Jr. L.L., 1965. A melanistic pileated woodpecker specimen from Georgia. Wlson Bull., 77: 404-405.
81: Siller, W.G., 1958. Ventricular septal defects in the fowl. J. Pathol. Bacteriol., 76: 431-440.
82: Siller, W.G. and L.A. Hemsley, 1966. The incidence of congenital heart disease in seven flocks of broiler chickens. Vet. Rec., 79: 451-454.
Direct Link |
83: Siller, W.G., 1967. Aortic dextroposition complexes in the fowl: A study in comparative pathology. J. Pathol. Bact., 94: 155-170.
84: Siller, W.G., 1968. Congenital heart disease in the fowl. Proc. R. Soc. Med., 61: 1289-1289.
Direct Link |
85: Smith, R.W., 1966. A case of xanthochroism in the Yellow- faced grassquit Tiaris olivacea. Ibis, 108: 627-628.
86: Smith, J. and K.L. Diem, 1971. Incidence of deformed bills in California gulls (Larus californicus). Auk, 88: 435-435.
87: Smyth, J.R.Jr., G.P. Sreekumar, C.A. Coyle and J.J. Bitgood, 2000. A new recessive ametapodia mutation in the chicken (Gallus domesticus). J. Heredity, 91: 340-342.
Direct Link |
88: Somes, Jr. R.G., 1992. Microphtalmia-4: A sex-influenced inherited eye condition of the chicken. J. Heredity, 83: 152-155.
Direct Link |
89: Stanton Grant Ernst, 1943. Deformation in the wing of a Pied-billed Grebe. Auk, 60: 447-448.
Direct Link |
90: Stewart, P.A., 1963. Abnormalities among brown-headed cowbirds trapped in Alabama. Bird Banding, 34: 199-202.
91: Stott, R.S., 1970. A ruffed grouse with an abnormal bill. Auk, 87: 172-173.
92: Stresemann, E., 1963. Variations in the number of primaries. Condor, 65: 449-459.
Direct Link |
93: Threlfall, W., 1968. A herring gull chick (Larus argentatus) with an abnormal bill. Auk, 85: 506-508.
94: Trinkaus, K., F. Muller and E.F. Kaleta, 1999. Polydactylie bei einem turmfalken (Falco tinnunculus tinnunculus L,1758)-ein fallbericht. Z. Jagdwiss., 45: 66-72.
95: Tsudzuki, M., Y. Nakane and A. Wada, 1998. Short beak: A new autosomal recessive semilethal mutation in Japanese quail. J. Heredity, 89: 175-178.
Direct Link |
96: Tudor, D.C., 1979. Congenital defects of poultry. World Poultry Sci. J., 35: 20-26.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
97: Ulshafer, R.J. and A. Clavert, 1979. The use of avian double monsters on induction of the nervous system. J. Embryol. Exp. Morph., 53: 237-243.
98: Waine, J.C., 1998. Anatomical abnormalities of the skull of a pink pigeon (Columba mayeri). Vet. Rec., 142: 403-404.
99: Wakamatsu, M., T. Yamagata, T. Manikawa and M. Mizutani, 2000. Hereditary persistant right oviduct in the chicken PNP/DO line. Poult. Sci., 79: 1075-1081.
100: Wallace, G.J., 1956. A case of microphthalmia in the American robin. Wilson Bull., 68: 151-152.
101: Wallace, R.A., 1974. Aberrations in the tongue structure of some melanerpine woodpeckers. Wilson Bull., 86: 79-82.
Direct Link |
102: Wetherbee, D.K., 1958. Unilateral microphthalmia in Quiscalus quiscula and synophthalmia in Minus polyglottos. Auk, 75: 101-103.
Direct Link |
103: Wetherbee, D.K., 1960. A skeletal teratism in neonatal red-winged blackbirds. Auk, 77: 471-472.
104: Whittle, C.L., 1927. Malformation of a downy woodpecker`s bill. Bull. North East Bird-Banding Assocc., 3: 19-20.
105: Winter, J., 1985. Partial albinism in a melanistic mew gull. Western Birds, 16: 187-188.
106: Wojnarowicz, C. and A.A. Olkowski, 2009. Congenital intestinal incarceration in broiler chickens. Avian Pathol., 38: 509-512.
107: Zakrzewska, E.I. and T.F. Savage, 1997. Inhibited feathering: A new dominant sex-linked gene in the turkey. J. Heredity, 88: 238-247.
Direct Link |
108: Hoffmann, J.A., 1968. Doppelmiβbildungen (Polymelie und Anus duplex) bei einem Huhnerkuken. Deutsche Tierarztl. Wochen., 75: 512-514.