Background: This study was performed to determine ammonia oxidation ability of the livestock farm waste by a microbial consortium and to reduce the amount of ammonia gas from the manure. Materials and Methods: The study consisted of five treatments: Without the addition of isolates as control, the addition of Pseudomonas sp., LS3K, the addition of Candida sp., LS3T, the addition of Arthrobacter sp., LM1KK and the addition of microbial consortium. The observed parameters consisted of microbial growth and the oxidation ability of the microbial consortium to minimize the concentration of ammonia. The obtained data were analyzed using one-way analysis of variance and the mean differences between treatments were tested by Duncans Multiple Range Test (DMRT). Results: The results showed that determined by Optical Density (OD), the microbial consortium was capable of growing with the addition of more than 10% ammonia with a value of maximum growth (μ max) 4.02 h1. The number of colonies that grew on the addition of 0, 2.50, 5, 7.50 and 10% (NH4)2SO4 were 1.03×105, 0.94×105, 1.60×105, 0.82×105 and 0.86×105 CFU mL1, respectively. The reduction of the ammonia concentration in the liquid medium with (NH4)2SO4 was 15.37 ppm. Ammonia emission from the chicken excreta, dairy cows feces and beef cattle feces was lower after the treatment with the addition of microbial consortium which was 28.72, 71.47 and 56.50 ppm, respectively compared than that of the control. Conclusion: The result can be concluded that the ability of oxidation by the microbial consortium was the most optimal in the oxidizing ammonia in beef cattle feces. The capability oxidizing of microbial consortium can reduce as much as 15.34 ppm concentration of ammonia in beef cattle feces.
PDF Abstract XML References Citation
How to cite this article
Livestock farm produced animal by-product in the form of waste either solid, liquid or gas. However, feces, excreta and livestock waste at farms just were buried away on the ground and they were lived a long time there. Deposition of livestock waste has the potential for air pollutions and it also causes nitrate pollution in rainwater that would lead to acid rain1.
Major cases of environmental pollutions caused by farm businesses were from the content of NH3 that accumulated in animal manure. In the case of high humidity and low temperature conditions, synthesis of ammonia gas increased and large quantities of NH3 gas was emitted from manure2. Moreover, it was known that ammonia has high toxicity to all living things, for example, LD50 for fish is in the range of 0.20-2 mg L1 and the concentration of 0.20-9 mg L1 for higher organisms. In the past decade, several countries in Europe and America have discussed for their solutions in order to overcome the ill effects of farm waste, in particular, ammonia gas (NH3) emissions from agriculture-livestock activities1 and it has been expected to develop treatment process of reducing ammonia from livestock wastes.
Some microbes could oxidize ammonia existing environment and several researchers have tried to screen ammonia-oxidizing microbes in order to develop treatment process of reducing ammonia from livestock wastes using the microbes3. Until now, it has been reported some strains belonged to Nitrosospira tenuis, Nitrosomonas marina, Nitrosomonas eutropha and Nitrosococcus mobilis as ammonia-oxidizing microbes in aquaria4. Moreover, environmentally-friendly handling of the NH3 gas oxidation process has been carried out by using of commercial bacterial EM54. However, there was a few report described indigenous microbes in Indonesia for the ammonia waste oxidizing and it has not been constructed NH3 gas oxidation system using indigenous microbes in Indonesia in the farm wastes.
Until now, it already isolated several indigenous ammonia-reducing microbes, Pseudomonas sp., LS3K, Candida sp., LS3T and Arthrobacter sp., LM1KK. Those strains have been proven with specific capabilities to oxidize high concentration of ammonium (NH4OH) in the wastes. For example, on the addition of high ammonium stressor, Pseudomonas sp., LS3K is still able to grow optimally, Candida sp., LS3T can grow by utilizing excess ammonium stressor and Arthrobacter sp. LM1KK was able to grow optimally utilizing high ammonium concentrations as nutrient growth. It assumed that one alternative effort to reduce air pollution by waste ammonia can be overcome by the oxidation of ammonia using not only each strain, Pseudomonas sp., LS3K, Candida sp., LS3T and Arthrobacter sp., LM1KK, but also the microbial consortium consisting of these strains. In this study, it indicated that the indigenous microbial consortium of ammonia-oxidizing microbes was expected to break down farm waste efficiently and in a friendly way for the environment.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Cultivation and research design: Excreta was taken from the hen house layer of the Universitas Gadjah Mada (UGM). The feces of the dairy cow was taken from the stables of dairy cows in UPT Dairy Farm Faculty of Animal Science. Feces of beef cattle was taken from the shed of the fattening cow of each 100 g and then it was diluted with distilled water to a ratio of 1:1 and stirred to homogeny. Manure was divided into five erlenmeyer. Each erlenmeyer was added with microbial isolates of Pseudomonas sp., LS3K, Candida sp., LS3T, Arthrobacter sp., LM1KK and as much as 1% consortium as well as the control treatment without the addition of microbial isolates. Each treatment of each manure was cultivated for 5 days and research was repeated 3 times.
Measurement of ammonia concentration in the culture medium: Steps were performed by adding the isolates at 1 mL pre-culture in a liquid medium that has been added to the 5% (NH4)2SO4 and then shaker was cultivated at 120 rpm. In every day, 1 mL samples were taken at every 4 h to measure the optical density by putting in an eppendorf tube and were continued by centrifugation at the speed of 8000 rpm at 4°C for 10 min. After the cells had been separated from the supernatant and the precipitate formed, the supernatant was taken and put into the sterile eppendorf tube and added with 0.20 mL nessler reagent and allowed to stand for 10 min. Ammonia concentration of samples was measured using the spectrophotometer UV-1601 PC Shimadzu and recorded to the results. When the nessler reagent reacts with ammonium in an alkaline solution, it will form colloidal dispersions yellow-brown. The intensity of the color that will happen is in line to the concentration of ammonium. Color formed spectrophotometer was measured at a wavelength of 425 nm.
Measurement of ammonia gas emission in manure (excreta, feces of dairy cow, beef cattle feces): The total amount of 100 g manure samples from each treatment was put into the 500 mL erlenmeyer. The ammonia gas emitted from manure was driven by air from the constant speed aerator through the plastic hose into the other erlenmeyer which contained 200 mL of 0.02 N boric acids to capture the NH3 gas. The ammonia gas was dissolved in water and formed some ammonium ions. Furthermore, boric acid has the capability to maintain the low pH for the maximum absorption of ammonia gas. Periodically the ammonium concentration was measured spectroscopically using nestler reagent. The nessler solution will produce yellow to reddish brown when reacting with ammonium. The color formed was measured by a spectrophotometer absorbance at the wavelength of 425 nm.
Data analysis: The significance of differences between means of the data was statistically calculated by one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by Duncans new multiple range test. The difference between means was considered significant when p<0.05. The obtained data were expressed as means±standard errors.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Bacterial consortium has an ability to grow under high (NH4)2SO4 stressor: The growth of the bacterial consortium in the liquid medium was observed by optical density (Fig. 1).The bacterial consortium can grow well on the medium under the ammonium stress until a dosage of 10%, although they slightly showed growth defect under stress. This growth of microbes could be due to that microbial consortium was included in heterotrophic microbial species, that can utilize the source of nutrients from an inorganic material or organic compounds. The heterotrophic microbes have the ability for rapid growth in oxidized ammonium and can reach a long period of life6. The medium used in optical density observation contained 2.5-10% ammonium sulfate in each erlenmeyer flask and it was used as an inorganic nitrogen stress or which contained at 100% stock solution (the stock solution consists of 1 g meat extract, 1 g bacteriological peptone and 0.5 g NaCl diluted in 100 mL aquadest). The Pseudomonas played a major role in the process of nitrification and denitrification in aerobic conditions6. Currently aerobic conditions, Pseudomonas can oxidize ammonia to nitrite, nitrate and directly degrading nitrate into N2O and/or N2. Candida spp., was an organism that can oxidize ammonium to nitrate7. The Arthrobacter strains are the predominant bacteria found in the soil8. This microbial life in the soil that contained ammonium and it grew by degradation ammonium so that it has the capability of nitrification.
The result of the maximum growth of microbial consortium based on the absorbance values of optical density was equal to 4.02 h1 with Ks value (saturation constant) of 0.29 mg L1. The rate of microbial growth would be equal to the concentration of substrate in the medium9. The growth of bacteria will reach maximum stages in the high concentration of substrate. However, in a high dose of nitrogen in the medium, many of bacteria strain will be eliminated due to the poison of high concentration of nitrogen. Fortunately, all strain in the consortium could encounter the nitrogen stressor at the level of 10%.
Growth of bacterial consortium in liquid medium: From three replications of research which has performed, the number of colonies after 24 h of cultivation period from each treatment with additional of 0, 2.50, 5, 7.50 and 10% (NH4)2SO4 was observed 1.03×105, 0.94×105, 1.60×105, 0.82×105 and 0.86×105 CFU mL1, respectively (value of the number colonies is shown in Table 1).
Growth of the consortium bacteria in 1/100 meat extract liquid medium with the various addition of (NH4)2SO4 as inorganic N stressor. The growth was observed by Optical Density (OD600nm)
Growth of the consortium bacteria in 1/100 meat extract solid medium with various stressor of (NH4)2SO4. The growth is expressed in the number of colonies appeared in petri dish agar medium (105 CFU mL1)
|abDifferent superscripts in the same row shows a significantly different effect (p<0.05)|
The addition of 5% (NH4)2SO4 has given a significantly higher in the colony number (p<0.05) as an indication that the growth of the strains is better compared to the treatment with the addition 0 and 10% (NH4)2SO4. The number of colonies that grew in the addition of 2.50 and 5% (NH4)2SO4 was not shown a different effect to the treatment with the addition of 0 and 10%. The growth of consortium microbes with the addition of 5% (NH4)2SO4 showed the best result and faster acceleration compared to the other treatments. It was suggested that the optimal condition of consortium microbes for growing with the additional of an organic nitrogen supplementation was at dosage 5% and the growth will decrease when the addition concentration of (NH4)2SO4 was more than 5% (Table 1).
The number of colonies appeared in the solid agar medium after 24 and 48 h cultivation were 0.65×106 and 1.56×106 CFU mL1, respectively. The growth of Candida spp., was clearly observed after 24-48 h10. On the other hand, the optimal growth of Arthrobacter spp., was after 2 days11. Furthermore, Pseudomonas spp., was growing in less than 48 h and will increase the growth after 48 h12.
Ability of the consortium microbes for growing at acid condition: Based on the observation of counted colonies after 24 h cultivation period on 100% agar petri dish containing 1% stock solution of liquid medium for 72 h with the addition of 5% (NH4)2SO4 and adjustment pH to 5.50, the number of colonies of each microbial additions LS3K, LM1KK and consortium were 1.56×105, 0.97×105 and 1.18×105 CFU mL1, respectively, while the colony of strain LS3T could not be confirmed.
The growth characters of Pseudomonas spp., were optimum at the range of pH from 5.50-1113. The colonies of Candida sp., LS3T did not appear at pH 5.5 indicated that Candida sp., LS3T can not grow at pH 5.50. This result describes that the Candida sp., LS3T was not able to grow under acidic conditions. The growth of Arthrobacter sp., LM1KK was very low. However, Arthrobacter sp., LM1KK still able to grow at acidic pH conditions. Consortium microbial colony growth was better compared to the single strain. This condition could be due to the accumulation of growth between Pseudomonas sp., LS3K and Arthrobacter sp., LM1KK from the consortium.
Ability of the consortium bacteria for growing at alkali condition: Based on the observation of counted colonies after 24 h cultivation period on 100% agar petri dish containing 1% stock solution of liquid medium for 72 h with the addition of 5% (NH4)2SO4 and adjustment pH to 8, the number of colonies of each microbial additions LS3K, LM1KK and consortium bacteria were 1.14×105, 1.30×105 and 1.53×105 CFU mL1, respectively. While the colony of strain LS3T could not be confirmed. The colonies of Candida sp., LS3T was also unable to grow at pH 8.5. Candida sp., LS3T was also not able to grow under alkaline pH conditions. The growth of Arthrobacter sp., LM1KK was the significant amount to 1.30×105 CFU mL1, which means that Arthrobacter sp., LM1KK was accomplished by growing under alkaline pH conditions. This was in line with previous study which reported that Arthrobacter sp., could grow optimally at alkaline pH14. At pH 8, the colony of consortium microbes growth was the largest amount of 1.53×105 CFU mL1 compared to the single strain. It was due to the accumulation of growth between Pseudomonas sp., LS3K and Arthrobacter sp., LM1KK at the same level.
Decreasing of ammonia concentrations from liquid medium: Research to investigate a reduction of the ammonia concentration was carried out by the addition of 5% (NH4)2SO4 as nitrogen resources and data were shown in Fig. 2. It have decided to add 5% (NH4)2SO4 due to the best condition at previous research while the consortium microbes have a good ability to grow with the different kinds of ammonia concentration that has been observed by optical density measurement (Fig. 1). The consortium microbes growth with the addition of 5% (NH4)2SO4 in a liquid medium in100% meat extract medium were able to reduce the concentration of ammonia from the (NH4)2SO4. The growth of consortium bacteria that continued for 4 days can decrease the concentration of ammonia from 49.08-33.71 ppm. It was the evidence that the consortium microbes can metabolize ammonia which can be applied to the waste manure livestock. The consortium microbes that consisted of Pseudomonas sp., LS3K, Candida sp., LS3T and Arthrobacter sp., LM1KK were among the heterotrophic microbial species. Heterotrophic microbes can utilize organic and inorganic materials6. The benefits of ammonia oxidation carried by heterotrophic microbes were that nitrification rate was faster than the other types15.
Growth of the consortium bacteria and the decreasing of the ammonia concentration by a microbial consortium. aSame superscript in the figure shows the effects were not significantly different (p>0.05)
Comparison of the ability in reducing the ammonia emission from various treatment using chicken excreta as ammonia resources. The concentration of ammonia was measured after 5 days of microbes cultivation
Ammonia emissions from excreta treatment: Figure 3 shows the ammonia emission level from the chicken excreta after 5 days added by the microbes as a treatment. The overall ammonia emission was increased from the first day to the 5th day. Furthermore, from 2nd-5th day, the increasing of higher ammonia concentrations can be seen in the control treatment. The low C/N ratio of the excreta and the high N content also allow the releasing of ammonia from the excreta. The average emission of ammonia of three replication on five treatments oxidation of the control, LS3K, LS3T, LM1KK and consortium has confirmed 39.62, 35.05, 25.49, 26.97 and 28.72 ppm, respectively. The chemical composition of N in excreta was equal to 13,500 ppm with a C/N ratio of 17.71. The addition of microbial treatment strain LS3K, LS3T, LM1KK and the consortium gave effect for not significantly different compared to the control treatment on the emission of ammonia concentration in excreta. Candida sp., LS3T was the most efficient in reducing the emission of ammonia in the excreta but the overall capability of the microbial consortium was also quite effective to reduce ammonia in excreta.
Candida spp., was the type of microorganisms high levels of yeast species10. The nitrification conducted by Candida spp., for 7 days can reduce ammonium by producing nitrate as much as 20.10 ppm7. It was consistent with the results of the measurement of the ammonia concentration that was oxidized by Candida sp., LS3T. The results of ammonia oxidation by Candida sp., LS3T has a difference of 14.14 ppm lower than the control treatment.
Ammonia emission from dairy cow feces treatment: Figure 4 show the ammonia emission level from the dairy cow feces after 5 days added by the microbes as a treatment.
Comparison of the ability in reducing the ammonia emission from various treatment using dairy cow feces as ammonia resources. The concentration of ammonia was measured after 5 days of microbes cultivation. abDifferent superscripts in the figure shows a significantly different effect (p<0.05)
Comparison of the ability in reducing the ammonia emission from various treatment using beef cattle feces as ammonia resources. The concentration of ammonia was measured after 5 days of microbes cultivation. abDifferent superscripts in the figure shows a significantly different effect (p<0.05)
The overall ammonia emission was increased from the 1st-5th day. Furthermore, the 3rd-5th day, the increasing of higher ammonia concentrations can be seen in the control treatment. The content of the undigested N protein may affect the discharge of ammonia gas from feces. The chemical composition of N total feces was 0.70 g kg1 or equal to 700 ppm16. The average ammonia emission of three replications from five treatments oxidation by control, LS3K, LS3T, LM1KK and consortium was 87.27, 68.57, 70.31, 72.287 and 71.47 ppm, respectively. The addition of microbial treatment LS3K, LS3T, LM1KK, the consortium gave a significantly different effect (p<0.05) compared to the control treatment on the emission of ammonia concentration of feces of a dairy cow. Pseudomonas sp., LS3K was the most efficient to reduce the ammonia emission in the feces of dairy cattle, but the overall concentration of ammonia in the feces of the dairy cattle on the outcome of oxidation treatment by Candida sp., LS3T, Arthrobacter sp., LM1KK and the consortium were also quite effective to reduce the ammonia emission from each treatment. The optimal conditions for microbes to oxidize ammonia were in range at neutral to the slightly alkaline pH condition. Pseudomonas spp., grew optimum for ammonia denitrification in the condition of the ratio between carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) at the limit of 4-812. The result of the ammonia oxidation by Pseudomonas sp., LS3K has a slight difference of 18.69 ppm lower than the control.
Decreasing emission of the ammonia from beef cattle feces treatment: Figure 5 shows the level of ammonia emission from the beef cattle feces after 5 days cultivation by the microbes as a treatment. The result showed that the overall production of ammonia was increased from the first day till the 5th day. Start on the 1st day to the 5th, the increasing of higher ammonia concentrations can be seen in the control treatment. The ammonia gas was produced by the combination of nitrogen and hydrogen gas17. Millions of ammonia were produced annually. Undigested feed nitrogen and nitrogen soluble in the water came out with feces were 7.80 (7800 ppm) and 20.30 g kg1 (20300 ppm), respectively16. The average production of ammonia of three replication on five treatments oxidation by control, LS3K, LS3T, LM1KK and consortium was 71.84, 60.15, 59.87, 61.56 and 56.50 ppm, respectively. Control treatment has the highest concentration of ammonia that was 71.84 ppm.
The addition of microbial treatment of the consortium provided a significantly different effect (p<0.05) compared to the control. However, it was not significantly different with treatment LS3K, LS3T and LM1KK to the emission of ammonia concentration in beef cattle feces. The addition of microbial treatment LS3K, LS3T and LM1KK was not significantly different compared to the control treatment on the production of ammonia concentration in beef cattle feces. Microbial consortium oxidized ammonia of beef cattle feces at the most effective way and it was most widely in reducing the emission of ammonia from the waste of beef cattle feces compared to other treatments. The result of ammonia oxidation by the consortium microbes has a difference of 15.34 ppm lower than the control treatment. Production of ammonia from feces was quite high around the level from 70-80 ppm. The largest contributor to ammonia emissions from the agricultural sector was 50% from dairy farms, 20-22% from pork and 7-21% from the poultry. It was consistent with the production of ammonia generated from feces in the study18.
Based on the study, it can be concluded that the ability of oxidation by the microbial consortium was the most optimal in the oxidizing ammonia in beef cattle feces. The capability oxidizing of consortium microbes can reduce as much as 15.34 ppm concentration of ammonia in beef cattle feces. Ammonia was most reduced by Pseudomonas spp., that was added to the feces of dairy cow waste which can reduce to 18.69 ppm.
Mitigation for ammonia emission from animals manures using consortium nitrifying bacteria that consisted of 3 bacteria from Pseudomonas spp., Arthrobacter spp., and Candida spp., has not been performed yet by another researcher. This study shows how the consortium of bacteria, which isolated from the odorous region of a poultry farm at Yogyakarta city have the ability to reduce the ammonia emission from the chicken excreta, dairy cows manure and cattle beef manure. We hope that these three bacteria will have some advantages for ammonia reduction agent which can be implemented for odor reduction agent.
The authors would like to thank profusely and give a deep appreciation to LPDP Ministry of Finance (Republic of Indonesia) for the funding of the research.
- Patterson, P.H. and Adrizal, 2005. Management strategies to reduce air emissions: Emphasis-dust and ammonia. J. Applied Poult. Res., 14: 638-650.
- Patterson, P.H., A. Adrizal, R.M. Hulet, R.M. Bates and C.A.B. Myers et al., 2008. Vegetative buffers for fan emissions from poultry farms: 1. Temperature and foliar nitrogen. J. Environ. Sci. Health Part B: Pestic. Food Contam. Agric. Wastes, 43: 199-204.
- Ye, R.W. and S.M. Thomas, 2001. Microbial nitrogen cycles: Physiology, genomics and applications. Curr. Opin. Microbiol., 4: 307-312.
- Burrell, P.C., C.M. Phalen and T.A. Hovanec, 2001. Identification of bacteria responsible for ammonia oxidation in freshwater aquaria. Applied Environ. Microbiol., 67: 5791-5800.
- Swayne, D.A., W. Yang, A.A. Voinov, A. Rizzoli and T. Filatova, 2010. Effective Microorganisms (EM) technology for water quality restoration and potential for sustainable water resources and management. Proceedings of the International Congress on Environmental Modelling and Software, July 5-8, 2010, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
- Yao, S., J. Ni, Q. Chen and A.G. Borthwick, 2013. Enrichment and characterization of a bacteria consortium capable of heterotrophic nitrification and aerobic denitrification at low temperature. Bioresour. Technol., 127: 151-157.
- Alharbi, S.A., 2009. In vitro mineral transformations by the human pathogens Staphylococcus aureus and Candida albicans. J. Food Agric. Environ., 7: 655-657.
- Mongodin, E.F., N. Shapir, S.C. Daugherty, R.T. DeBoy and J.B. Emerson et al., 2006. Secrets of soil survival revealed by the genome sequence of Arthrobacter aurescens TC1. PLoS Genet., Vol. 2.
- Okpokwasili, G.C. and C.O. Nweke, 2006. Microbial growth and substrate utilization kinetics. Afr. J. Biotechnol., 5: 305-317.
- Staib, P. and J. Morschhauser, 1999. Chlamydospore formation on Staib agar as a species-specific characteristic of Candida dubliniensis. Mycoses, 42: 521-524.
- Flagan, S., W.K. Ching and J.R. Leadbetter, 2003. Arthrobacter strain VAI-A utilizes acyl-homoserine lactone inactivation products and stimulates quorum signal biodegradation by Variovorax paradoxus. Applied Environ. Microbiol., 69: 909-916.
- Deng, B., L. Fu, X. Zhang, J. Zheng and L. Peng et al., 2014. The denitrification characteristics of Pseudomonas stutzeri SC221-M and its application to water quality control in grass carp aquaculture. PLoS ONE, Vol. 9.
- Tarangini, K. and S. Mishra, 2013. Production, characterization and analysis of melanin from isolated marine Pseudomonas sp. using vegetable waste. Res. J. Eng. Sci., 2: 40-46.
- Holt, J.G., N.R. Kreig, P.H.A. Sneath, J.T. Staley and S.T. Williams, 1994. Bergey's Manual of Determinative Bacteriology. 9th Edn., Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, USA., ISBN-13: 9780683006032, Pages: 787.
- Shoda, M. and Y. Ishikawa, 2014. Heterotrophic nitrification and aerobic denitrification of high-strength ammonium in anaerobically digested sludge by Alcaligenes faecalis strain No. 4. J. Biosci. Bioeng., 117: 737-741.
- Althaus, B., G. Papke and A. Sundrum, 2013. Technical note: Use of near infrared reflectance spectroscopy to assess nitrogen and carbon fractions in dairy cow feces. Anim. Feed Sci. Technol., 185: 53-59.
- Fryzuk, M.D., 2004. Inorganic chemistry: Ammonia transformed. Nature, 427: 498-499.
- Bleizgys, R., I. Bagdoniene and L. Balezentiene, 2013. Reduction of the livestock ammonia emission under the changing temperature during the initial manure nitrogen biomineralization. Scient. World J.