Subscribe Now Subscribe Today
Fulltext PDF

Research Article
Heavy Metal (Cu, Zn, Pb) Contamination of Vegetables in Urban City: A Case Study in Lagos

K.A. Yusuf and S.O. Oluwole
Five leafy vegetable species (Talinum triangulare, Celosia argentea, Amaranthus viridis, Cucurbita maxima and Corchorus olitorius) sold in Lagos markets were investigated for Cu, Pb and Zn content by atomic absorption spectrophotometry. Both unwashed and washed leaves showed the highest amounts of heavy metals in the urban area. Unwashed leaves showed greater difference between urban and remote areas and among the urban sites than washed leaves for heavy metal concentrations. Water-washing resulted in a significant (p<0.001) decrease in vegetable concentrations of Cu, Zn and Pb. However, the levels of Cu and Zn did not indicate excessive contamination that could be considered a serious health hazard to the consumers.
E-mail This Article
Related Articles in ASCI
Similar Articles in this Journal
Search in Google Scholar
View Citation
Report Citation

  How to cite this article:

K.A. Yusuf and S.O. Oluwole, 2009. Heavy Metal (Cu, Zn, Pb) Contamination of Vegetables in Urban City: A Case Study in Lagos. Research Journal of Environmental Sciences, 3: 292-298.

DOI: 10.3923/rjes.2009.292.298



Vegetables constitute an important part of the human diet since they contain carbohydrates, proteins, vitamins, minerals as well as trace elements. The contamination of vegetables with heavy metals due to soil and atmospheric contamination poses a threat to its quality and safety. Dietary intake of heavy metals also poses risk to animals and human health. High concentrations of heavy metals (Cu, Cd and Pb) in fruits and vegetables were related to high prevalence of upper gastrointestinal cancer (Turkdogan et al., 2003). Many anthropogenic sources such as waste incineration, industrial processes and most importantly, vehicular traffic emit heavy metals into the atmosphere. Regulations have been set up in many countries and for different industrial set up to control the emission of heavy metals.

The uptake and bioaccumulation of heavy metals in vegetables are influenced by many factors such as climate, atmosphere depositions, the concentrations of heavy metals in soil, the nature of soil and the degree of maturity of the plants at harvest (Scott et al., 1996; Voutsa et al., 1996). Air pollution may pose a threat to post-harvest vegetables during transportation and marketing causing elevated levels of heavy metals in vegetables (Sharma et al., 2008). Elevated levels of heavy metals in vegetables are reported which such as long term uses of treated or untreated wastewater (Sharma et al., 2006, 2007; Adeniyi, 1996; Sinha et al., 2005). Other anthropogenic sources of heavy metals include the addition of manures, sewage sludge, fertilizers and pesticides which may affect the update of heavy metals by modifying the physico-chemical properties of the soil such as pH, organic matter, bioavailability of heavy metals in the soil (Yusuf and Osibanjo, 2006). Whatmuff (2002) and McBride (2003) found that increasing concentrations of heavy metals in soil increased the crop uptake. Cultivation areas near highways are also exposed to atmospheric pollution in the form of metal containing aerosols. These aerosols can be deposited on soil and absorbed by vegetables, or alternatively deposited on leaves and fruits and then absorbed. High accumulation of Pb, Cr and Cd in leafy vegetables due to atmospheric depositions has been reported by Voutsa et al. (1996) and De Nicola et al. (2008). The levels of heavy metals (Zn, Mn, Cu and Pb) in vegetable (Talinum triangulare) collected from dumpsites of Lagos, Nigeria were found to be high due to vehicular traffic emission (Adeniyi, 1996). The magnitude of heavy metal deposition of vegetable surfaces varied with morpho-physiological nature of the vegetables (Singh and Kumar, 2006). Jassir et al. (2005) have shown that unwashed leafy vegetables sold in road side of Riyadh city, Saudi Arabia had higher levels of heavy metals as compared to washed leafy vegetables. Demirezen and Aksoy (2006) have reported higher concentrations of Pb, Cd and Cu in Abelmoschus esculentus collected from urban areas of Kayseri, Turkey as compared to those from rural areas. The partitioning of heavy metals is well known, with accumulation of greater concentrations in the edible portions of leafy or root crops than the storage organs or fruits (Jinadasa et al., 1997; Lehoczky et al., 1998; Sharma and Agrawal, 2006).

Urban activities may significantly contribute to elevated heavy metal loads in atmospheric deposits and consequently in the edible portion of the vegetables. Thus the present study was conducted with the objectives to investigate the accumulation of heavy metals (Cu, Zn, Pb) on the (Talinum triangulare, Celosia argentea, Amaranthus viridis, Cucurbita maxima and Corchorus olitorius) leaf surfaces through the concurrent analysis of unwashed and washed leaves from urban and remote areas. Water-washing by shaking mechanically removes much of the particulate found on the leaf surfaces, allowing the fractions of particle-bound heavy metals to be estimated. This study therefore, aimed to distinguish the water-removable fraction of heavy metals and the fraction present in leaves, potentially supplying useful information on the pollutant fraction damaging to leaf physiological processes.


The present study was carried out between August and October 2004 in the urban areas of Lagos, located in the South Western Nigeria. The climate of the region is tropical with two distinct seasons i.e dry and rainy. The dry season (November to April) is associated with high temperature during the day ranging from a minimum of 30°C to a maximum of 36°C. Rainy season starts in May and continue till end of October. During the rainy season, the temperature varies from a minimum of 24°C to a maximum of 32°C.

Lagos is one of the most densely populated cities of Nigeria. There are several industrial estate located at the periphery of the city. Heavy traffic on narrow roads leading to frequent traffic congestion is of common occurrence within the city.

Vegetable Markets
Five multipurpose retail markets were sampled. The magnitude of urban activities such as industrial, residential, commercial and vehicular density varied between the sampling locations.

The characteristics and relative position of sampling locations are shown in Table 1.

Leafy Vegetables
Common vegetables sold to the local markets exclusively are Soko (Celosia argentea), green (Amaranthus viridis) Ugwu (Cucurbita maxima), ewedu (Corchorus olitorius) and water leaf (Talinum triangulare). These vegetables were purchased ostensibly for consumption. They were stored at 4°C till processed.

Table 1: Characteristics of market sampling sites located in the urban area of Lagos
DPRA: Densely Populated Residential Area, NIA: Near Industrial Area, HT: Heavy Traffic, CA: Commercial Area, LT: Low Traffic

Table 2: Wavelength and detection limits of each heavy metal measured by atomic absorption spectrophotometer (Mode 1 buck 200A)

Sampling and Pre-Treatment
Samples of edible portion of vegetables were collected from different outlets in each market locations. The samples were collected once in every two weeks between August and October 2004 for all the five vegetables. Samples were kept in pre-distilled water rinsed polyethylene bags, labelled and brought back to the laboratory. In the laboratory, the vegetable samples were chopped into small pieces divided into two groups.

The first group was oven dried at 65°C without washing, while the second group was washed in distilled water to remove airborne particulate before oven drying at 65°C until the constant weight was achieved. The dried samples were pulverized, sieved and kept at room temperature for further analysis. The water-removable heavy metal were calculated as the difference between unwashed and washed leaf concentrations.

Analytical Procedure for Heavy Metal Analysis
Aqua-regia mixture, 25 mL (70% high purity HNO3 and HCl ratio 3:1) and 5 mL 30% H2O2 were added to an empty 100 mL beaker and heated at 80°C till the solution became cleared (Rodrigues-Flores and Rodriguez-Castellon, 1982). The resulting solution was cooled and filtered. The filtrate was made up to 50 mL with de-ionised water and kept at room temperature for further analysis of heavy metals. For the heavy metal analysis of dry vegetable, 1 g sample was taken into a 100 mL acid washed beaker, 25 mL aqua-regia and 5 mL 30% H2O2 were added (Rodrigues-Flores and Rodriguez-Castellon, 1982). The mixture was digested at 80°C until a clear solution was obtained. After cooling, the digested samples were filtered and diluted to 50 mL with de-ionised water.

Determination of the heavy metals such as Cu, Zn and Pb in the filtrate of vegetables and blanks was achieved by atomic absorption, spectrophotometer (model: Buck 200A). The instrument was calibrated using manually prepared standard solution of respective heavy metals. An analytical grade of a nitrate salt of Pb and granules of Cu and Zn were used in the preparations of solutions used in the spiking of samples for Pb, Cu and Zn.

Acetylene gas was used as the fuel and air as the support. An oxidizing flame was used in all cases. Table 2 shows different parameters at which the instrument was set for each metal.

Quality Assurance
Blanks and source of quality control standards were measured at every five samples to detect contamination and drift. The elemental concentrations of procedural blanks were generally <5% of the mean analyte concentrations for all the metals. Precision and accuracy of analysis were ensured through replicate analysis of the samples, acceptable percentage recoveries (86.5%±0.005 to 96.4±0.003) were obtained from spiked digested vegetable samples.

Statistical Analysis
The data were processed using statistical package, SPSS 11.0. In order to compare for each pollutant the concentrations in unwashed and washed leaves for both urban and remote sites, a paired t-test was performed. All the correlation analysis were performed by Pearson or Spearnan test.


The concentrations of Cu, Zn and Pb of Celosia argentea, Amaranthus viridis, Cucurbita maxima, Corchorus olitorius and Talinum triangulare are shown in Table 3-7, respectively.

Table 3: Mean metal concentrations (μg g-1 dry weight) in washed and unwashed Celosia argentea at the urban and remote sites
aPercent reduction, bSource: FAO/WHO-Codex Alimentarius Commission (2001)

Table 4: Mean metal concentrations (μg g-1 dry weight) in washed and unwashed Amaranthus viridis at the urban and remote sites
aPercent reduction, bSource: FAO/WHO-Codex Alimentarius Commission (2001)

Table 5: Mean metal concentrations (μg g-1 dry weight) in washed and unwashed Cucurbita maxima at the urban and remote sites
aPercent reduction, bSource: FAO/WHO-Codex Alimentarius Commission (2001)

Table 6: Mean metal concentrations (μg g-1 dry weight) in washed and unwashed Corchorus olitorius at the urban and remote sites
aPercent reduction, bSource: FAO/WHO-Codex Alimentarius Commission (2001)

Table 7: Mean metal concentrations (μg g-1 dry weight) in washed and unwashed Talinum triangulare at the urban and remote sites
aPercent reduction, bSource: FAO/WHO-Codex Alimentarius Commission (2001)

The mean concentrations of heavy metals were highest for Zn followed by Cu and Pb. Among the vegetables, mean concentration of Zn (36.76 μg g-1) was highest in Amaranthus viridis, but mean Cu concentration (18.28 μg g-1) was highest in Talinum triangulare, while mean Pb concentration (13.0 μg g-1) was highest in Corchorus olitorius.

Both unwashed and washed leaves showed lower metal concentrations at the remote than the urban sites (Table 3-7), with significant differences (at least p<0.05) in all the investigated heavy metals. However, for washed vegetables the differences in concentrations for each heavy metal between urban and remote sites were narrower than those shown for unwashed vegetables. The greatest differences between urban and remote sites were observed for Pb, both for unwashed and washed vegetables.

The unwashed leaves showed higher metal concentrations than washed leaves (Table 3-7). At the urban sites, the differences were significant (p<0.001), moreover, the concentrations of metals in unwashed leaves were correlated (at least p<0.01) to those in washed leaves.

Over the investigated period, mean water-removable heavy metal concentrations (calculated as the percentage ratio of the difference between unwashed and washed leaf metal concentration to unwashed leaf metal concentrations) decreased in the order of Pb>Zn>Cu at the remote sites and Pb>Cu>Zn at the urban sites (Table 3-7). Percentages of Zn, Cu (Amanranthus viridis and Talinum triangulare) and Pb (Corchorus olitorius and Talinum triangulare) water removable concentrations were similar at the urban sites whereas water removable concentrations of Cu, Zn and Pb were higher at the urban sites.


Urban area of developing countries often receive atmospheric depositions of heavy metals resulted in contamination of fresh vegetables at the time of transportation and marketing. Consumption of contaminated vegetables may pose risk to human health. Heavy metals determined in different vegetables showed that the concentrations of Pb exceeded the safe limits (FAO/WHO (Codex Alimentarius Commission, 2001) standard Cu and Zn concentrations, however, did not exceed the safe limit of the test vegetable. Exceedence of safe limits was highest for Amaranthus viridis, where, 60% of the sampling locations showed Pb safe limit exceedence of FAO/WHO standards.

The variations in the concentrations of the heavy metals in vegetables may be ascribed to the heavy metals concentrations of soil, air and irrigation water of their production sites and also the absorption of heavy metals from aerial depositions during transportation and marketing.

The water-removable proportion of heavy metals provides information about both the prevailing metal source (natural or anthropogenic) and the leaf absorption amount for each metal. The results of speciation studies on air particulate suggest that metals from anthropogenic sources are mainly in water-soluble forms (Fernandez Espinosa et al., 2002). The water removable proportions for Cu, Pb and Zn were more noticeable at the urban than remote sites showing greater atmospheric depositions on vegetables during marketing are a major source of heavy metal contamination in urban sites. The observed trend of the proportion of water removable heavy metals at the urban sites (Pb>Cu>Zn) is confirmed by other researchers for Quercus ilex leaves in Italy (De Nicola et al., 2008), for Petunia leaves in Madrid (Caselles et al., 2002) and Holm oak leaves in fome (Gratani et al., 2000). Cu and Zn are present in airborne particulate as water-soluble sulphate salts (Huggins et al., 2000; Heal et al., 2005; Karthikeyan et al., 2006) and it is generally reported that the leaching of each metal is related to the kinds of liaisons between metals and the solid matrix (Chester et al., 1993; De Nicola et al., 2008).

Foliage analysis has often been used in heavy metal biomonitoring studies and concurrent analysis of unwashed and washed vegetables allow external composition to be distinguished from internal (Dasch, 1987; De Nicola et al., 2008). The differences between unwashed and washed leaves with regard to the heavy metal concentrations suggest that heavy metals reach leaves by aerial deposition and adhere to the leaf surface. The water-washing procedure mechanically removes particles deposited on the leaf surface, hence a large amount of the heavy metals bound to particles and water-soluble aerosols (Kos et al., 1996; De Nicola et al., 2008; Sharma et al., 2008).

In the present study, the mean concentrations of Cu, Zn and Pb (18.28, 24.48 and 3.85 μg g-1, respectively) in Talinum triangulare were found higher than the concentrations reported in Talinum triangualare (2.76, 22.11 and 0.44 μg g-1, respectively for Cu, Zn and Pb) collected from dump sites at Lagos, Nigeria (Adeniyi, 1996).


From this study, it can be concluded that urban activities in Lagos have elevated the levels of heavy metals in urban atmospheric deposits, which consequently increased the concentrations of heavy metal in test vegetables during marketing. Variations in the magnitude of reductions in heavy metal contamination due to washings of vegetables also depicted or showed the variations in heavy metal depositions at various market sites. Vegetables sold in local markets of the city still looking healthy and fresh, may pose a risk to human health particularly due to Pb contamination. Based on safe limit data Corchorus olitorius is maximally contaminated with Pb followed by Amaranthus viridis. The study suggests that washing technique can be used as a tool to assess the heavy metals load in vegetables through atmospheric depositions. The present study further suggested that to reduce the health risk, vegetables should be washed properly before consumption as washing can remove a significant amount of aerial contamination from the vegetable surface.

Adeniyi, A.A., 1996. Determination of cadmium, copper, iron, lead, manganese and zinc in water leaf (Talinum triangulare) in dumpsites. Environ. Int., 22: 259-262.
CrossRef  |  

Al Jassir, M.S., A. Shaker and M.A. Khaliq, 2005. Deposition of heavy metals on green leafy vegetables sold on roadsides of Riyadh city, Saudi-Arabia Bull. Environ. Contaminat. Toxicol., 75: 1020-1027.
CrossRef  |  Direct Link  |  

Caselles, J., C. Colliga and P. Zornosa, 2002. Evaluation of trace elements pollution from vehicle emissions in petunia plants. Water Air Soil Pollut., 136: 1-9.
CrossRef  |  

Chester, R., K.J.T. Murphy, F.J. Lin, A.S. Berry, G.A. Bradshaw and P.A. Corcoran, 1993. Factors controlling the solubilities of trace metals from ono-remote aerosols deposited to the sea surface by dry depsition mode Mar. Chem., 42: 107-126.
CrossRef  |  

Codex Alimentarius Commission, (FAO/WHO), 2001. Food additives and contaminants. Joint FAO/WHO Food Standards Programme, ALINORM 01/12A: 1-289.

Dasch, J.M., 1987. Measurement of dry deposition to surfaces in deciduous and pine. Environ. Pollut., 44: 261-277.
CrossRef  |  

De Nicola, F., G. Maisto, M.V. Prati and A. Alfani, 2008. Leaf accumulation of trace elements and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHS) in Quercus ilex L. Environ. Pollut., 153: 376-383.
PubMed  |  Direct Link  |  

Demirezen, D. and A. Aksoy, 2006. Heavy metal levels in vegetables in Turkey are within safe limits for Cu, Zn, Ni and exceeded for Cd and Pb J. Food Qual., 29: 252-265.
Direct Link  |  

Fernandez Espinosa, A.J., M. Ternero Rodriguez, F.J. Barragan De La Rosa and J.C. Jimenez Sanchez, 2002. A chemical speciation of trace metals for fine urban particles Atmos. Environ., 36: 773-780.
Direct Link  |  

Gratani, L., M.F. Crescente and M. Petruzzi, 2000. Relationship between leaf life-span and photosynthetic activity of Quercus ilex in polluted urban areas (Rome) Environ. Pollut., 110: 19-28.
Direct Link  |  

Heal, M.R., L.R. Hibbsa, R.M. Agiush and J.I. Beverland, 2005. Total and water-soluble trace metal content of urban background PM10, PM2.5 and black smoke in Edinburgh, UK Atmos, Environ., 39: 1417-1430.
Direct Link  |  

Huggins, F.E., G.P. Huffman and J.D. Robertson, 2000. Speciation of elements in NIST particulate matter SRMS 1648 and 1650 J. Hazardous Mater., 74: 1-23.
CrossRef  |  Direct Link  |  

Jinadasa, K.B.P.N., P.J. Milham, C.A. Hawkins and P.S.D. Cornish, 1997. Survey of Cd levels in vegetables and soil of greater Sydney, Australia J. Environ. Qual., 26: 924-933.
Direct Link  |  

Karthikeyan, S., U.M. Joshi and R. Balasubramanian, 2006. Microwave assisted sample preparation for determining water-soluble fraction of trace elements in urban airborne particulate matter: Evaluation of bioavailability Anal. Chimica Acta, 576: 23-30.
CrossRef  |  Direct Link  |  

Kos, V., B. Budic, V. Hudnik, F. Lobnik and M. Zupan, 1996. Determination of heavy metal conentrations in plants exposed to different degrees of pollution using ICP-AES Fresenius J. Anal. Chem., 354: 648-652.
CrossRef  |  Direct Link  |  

Lehoczky, E., L. Szabo and S. Horvath, 1998. Cadmium uptake by lettuce in different soils. Contaminat. Soil Sci. Plant Anal., 28: 1903-1912.
Direct Link  |  

McBride, M.B., 2003. Toxic metals in sewage sludge-amended soils: Has proportion of beneficial use discounted the risks. Adv. Environ. Res., 8: 5-19.
CrossRef  |  Direct Link  |  

Rodrigues-Flores, M. and E. Rodrigues-Castellon, 1982. Lead and cadmium levels in soil and palnts near highways and their correlation with traffic density. Environ. Poll. Ser. B, 4: 281-290.
CrossRef  |  

Scott, D., J.M. Keoghan and B.E. Allen, 1996. Native and low input grasses-a New Zealand high country perspective. New Zealand. J. Agric. Res., 39: 499-512.
CrossRef  |  

Sharma, R.K. and M. Agrawal, 2006. Effects of single and combined treatment of Cd and Zn on carrots: Uptake and bioaccumulation J. Plant Nutr., 29: 1791-1804.
Direct Link  |  

Sharma, R.K., M. Agrawal and F.M. Marshall, 2006. Heavy metal contamination in vegetables grown in wastewater irrigated areas of varanasi, India. Bull. Environ. Contaminat. Toxicol., 77: 312-318.
CrossRef  |  Direct Link  |  

Sharma, R.K., M. Agrawal and F.M. Marshall, 2007. Heavy metals contamination of soil and vegetables in suburban areas of Varanasi, India. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Safe., 66: 258-266.
Direct Link  |  

Sharma, R.K., M. Agrawal and F.M. Marshall, 2008. Heavy metal (Cu, Zn Cd and Pb) contamination of vegetables in urban India: A case study in varanasi. Environ. Pollut., 154: 254-263.
PubMed  |  Direct Link  |  

Singh, S. and M. Kumar, 2006. Heavy metal load of soil, water and vegetables in peri-urban Delhi Environ. Monitor. Assess., 120: 79-91.
CrossRef  |  Direct Link  |  

Sinha, S., K. Pandey, A.K. Grupta and K. Bhatt, 2005. Accumulation of metals in vegetables and crops grown in the area irrigated with river water Bull. Environ. Contaminat. Toxicol., 74: 210-218.
CrossRef  |  Direct Link  |  

Turkdogan, M.K., F. Kilicel, K. Kara, I. Tuncer and I. Uygan, 2002. Heavy metals in soil, vegetables and fruits in the endemic upper gastrointestinal cancer region of Turkey. Environ. Toxicol. Pharmacol., 13: 175-179.
CrossRef  |  

Voutsa, D., A. Grimanis and C. Samara, 1996. Trace elements in vegetables grown in an industrial area in relation to soil and air particulate matter. Environ. Pollut., 94: 325-335.
CrossRef  |  

Whatmuff, M.S., 2002. Applying biosolids to acid soil in New South Wales: Are guideline soil metal limits from other countries appropriate. Aust. J. Soil Res., 40: 1041-1056.
Direct Link  |  

Yusuf, K.A. and O. Osibanjo, 2006. Trace metals in water and sediments from Ologe Lagoon, Southwestern Nigeria Pak. J. Sci. Ind. Res., 49: 88-96.
Direct Link  |  

©  2014 Science Alert. All Rights Reserved
Fulltext PDF References Abstract