The Influence of Size, Sex and Season on the Feeding Regime of Synodontis membranaceus (Osteichthyes: Mochokidae) in Jebba Lake, Nigeria
Olufemi D. Owolabi
The influence of size, sex and season on the feeding regime of S. membranaceus were examined over a period of 24 months in Jebba Lake, Nigeria using frequency of occurrence, numerical, gravimetric and index of Relative Importance (RI) methods. Dietary composition and feeding intensity were sex dependent. RI established that there was a progression from a detritivorous diet in fish below 20 cm Standard Length (SL), through a transitional planktivorous phase (20-27 cm, SL), to a predominantly molluscivorous/insectivorous diet in fish above 27 cm SL; thus indicating a switch from a relatively passive filter-feeding habit when young to an active predatory habit at adult stage. Food preference also varied with season hence intraspecific competitions were low. Abundant food and ability to evolve trophic strategies that ensure optimum foraging in spite of seasonal changes enable S. membranaceus to maintain its overwhelming prominence and wide distribution in Jebba Lake.
Synodontis membranaceus (Geoffroy Saint Hilarie) is ubiquitous throughout the local waters of Northern Nigeria and also common throughout the year (Reed et al., 1967) and perhaps more important in the commercial catch than any other species in the region. It is mostly sought after because of the excellent flavour of its flesh either fresh or dried. It is particularly suited to making into the popular Nigerian dish of peppered soup. S. membranaceus performs an important trophic role in their habitat (Reed et al., 1967) where they serve as food for other commercially important fishes and hence the need for their conservation. They are also important as aquarium exhibits (Otubusin, 1986; Teugels, 1996), as their habit of swimming up side down makes them beautiful and interesting to behold.
Quantitative and qualitative dietary compositions of tropical fish species have been reported to vary with size (Fagbenro et al., 1991; Ezenwaji, 1999), sex (Fryer and Iles, 1972; Jobling, 1981; Ezenwaji, 2002) and season (Tudorancea et al., 1988; Ugwumba and Adebisi, 1992; Odum and Anuta, 2001; Saliu, 2002). Equally important factors attributable to changes in the quantity and quality of fish diets include time of feeding, kinds of food available, types of digestive enzymes in gut, life history stage, morphological changes in feeding apparatus due to age and the locality in which the fishes are found (Imevbore and Bakare, 1970; Ikusemiju and Olaniyan, 1977; Fagade, 1978; Akinwumi, 2001; Ogbeibu and Ezeunara, 2005). Although, S. membranaceus has been reported to be omnivorous, subsisting on any readily available food items in Jebba lake (Owolabi, 2005), the influence of size, sex and season on the trophic strategies of the species has not been reported. Biological information to keep track of any ecological alterations as it affects the species in their environment is necessary for their management and conservation. Information on the size related changes in diets of fishes, in particular, might facilitate the understanding of appropriate dietary requirement of fishes, as they grow from larva, juvenile to adult in any culture system.
This study was intended to examine the feeding strategies of S. membranaceus in relation to their size, sex and seasonal changes in Jebba Lake, Nigeria.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Jebba Lake (9° 10 to 9° 55 N and 4° 30 to 5°
00 E) was formed in August 1983 as an impoundment in the valley of River
Niger. It extended from the dam-site at Jebba to southern tip of Kainji dam.
The lake is therefore unique as the first and the only man-made lake in Nigeria
that has a direct inflow from another man-made lake located upstream to it.
It is bounded by Kwara State on the west and Niger State on the east. The lake
has a surface area of 303x106 m2, length of 100 km, maximum
depth of 33.0 maximum width of 10.0 km and maximum volume of 1,000x106
m3 (Adeniji, 1991). One sampling station each was selected from each
of the three zones (basins) i.e., Dam-site from the Southern basin (maximum
depth: 23.0 m), Old Gbajibo from middle basin (maximum depth: 27.0 m) and Faku
from the Northern basin (maximum depth: 33.0 m).
Bi-monthly collection of 1,208 fish specimens was carried out for 24 months (April 2002-March 2004) using gill nets of various mesh sizes ranging from 5.08 to 10.16 cm. Fishes caught were identified using the meristic features provided by Willoughby (1974) and were put in ice chest to reduce post humous digestion. In the Laboratory, the total and standard lengths and weight of each specimen were measured following the procedure of King (1996) after blotting out excess water on the fish. Each specimen was slit open and its degree of stomach fullness rated as 0 (empty; ES), 1 (quarter-full; QFS), 2 (half-full; HFS), 3 (three quarter-full; TQF) or 4 (full stomach; FS). The contents of the stomachs were emptied into separate petri dishes and identified to the lowest taxonomic level according to the method of Ward and Whipple (1950). The contents were analyzed instantly, but when this was not possible, the contents were preserved in 4% formaldehyde. Frequency of occurrence, numerical and gravimetric methods (Ricker, 1968; George and Hadley, 1979) were employed in the analysis of the gut contents. To reduce bias, dietary importance of food items was determined using the Relative Importance (RI) index (George and Hadley, 1979; Hyslop, 1980). Food items with RI > 5.0 were considered major or important food items. Each specimen was grouped into different size categories based on the analysis of growth rings on the opercula bones (Owolabi, 2005). Feeding intensity and food composition data were analyzed using students t-test.
There was a significantly higher FS (t = 7.62, p<0.001) in males and higher
ES (t = -7.19) in females (Table 1) than in their opposite
sexes. There was no significant difference in QFS and TQS (p>0.001) between
sexes. Table 2 shows that the qualitatative compositions of
food in both sexes were similar. The RI of dietary compositions of males was
significantly higher in plant parts, seeds and coleopteran larvae and lower
in detritus, Aspatharia species, gastropod and insect appendages than
females (t-test, p<0.05) in each case. Variations in the RI of other food
items were not different (p>0.05) between sexes. Changes in stomach fullness
condition with size (Table 3) shows that FS and TQS were both
highest and QFS lowest in the size group 28-35 cm SL, while 20-27 cm SL group
had the lowest incidence of ES. All the size categories examined fed on all
the food items except Aspatharia, gastropod and copepod (Table
4). The obtained RI values established detritus as the most important food
item for fish below 20 cm SL with a value of 26.88, while copepod, adult
Povilla adusta and gastropod were the most prominent food items in fish
between 20-27 cm SL, 28-35 cm SL and 36-43 cm SL with corresponding RI values
of 22.61, 21.44 and 20.06, respectively.
||Sexual variation in stomach fullness condition of S. membranaceus
from Jebba Lake, Nigeria
|P* Significant level for t-test between sexes; ns: Non significant;
ES: Empty Stomach; QFS: Quarter Full Stomach; HFS: Half Full Stomach; TQS:
Three Quarter Full Stomach; FS: Full Stomach
||Sexual variation in RI of dietary composition of S. membranaceus
from Jebba Lake, Nigeria
|RI: Relative Importance Index; P*: Significant level for t-test
between sexes; ns: non-significant
||Size variation in stomach fullness condition of S. membranaceus
from Jebba Lake, Nigeria
|ES: Empty Stomach; QFS: Quarter Full Stomach; HFS: Half full
Stomach; TQS: Three Quarter Full Stomach; FS: Full Stomach
RI values of detritus and Spirogyra decreased with increase in length,
while RI values of Aspatharia increased with increase in size. Similarly,
RI values of plant parts, seeds and coleopteran larvae increased with length
except a decline in the length group 36-43 cm SL. The Table further shows that
there was a progression from detritivorous diets in fish below 20 cm SL through
a transitional planktivorous diets in fish between 20-27 cm SL to a predominantly
insectivorous/molluscivorous diets in fish above 27 cm SL.
Table 5 shows that there was a significant rainy (wet) season
increase in ES (t = 5.01, p<0.001), QFS (t = 4.04, p<0.001), TQS (t =
-5.67, p<0.001) and FS (t = -4.24, p<0.001). S. membranaceus fed
on different food items during both seasons (Table 6). RI
established that detritus, P. adusta, coleopteran larvae, copepods, seeds
and plant parts were extensively consumed during the rains (April- October).
More gastropods, Spirogyra and Aspatharia were, however, consumed
during the dry months (November-March). Insect appendages showed no general
variation with seasons as their RI values did not show much difference. In wet
season, obtained RI values indicated that detritus were the most important food
items in fish below 20 cm SL while fish between 20-27 cm SL showed preference
for a mixed zooplankton (copepods) and detritus diets (Table 7).
In fish above 27 cm SL, insects (adult P. adusta) contributed significantly
to the diets. During the dry season, detritus, zooplankton (copepods) and molluscs
(gastropods and Aspatharia) were found to be the most prominent and important
diets for fish below 20 cm SL, between 20-27 cm SL and above 27 cm SL, respectively
||Relative Importance Index of major food items in the stomach
of various size groups of S. membranaceus from Jebba Lake, Nigeria
|* Arranged in order of importance
||Seasonal variation in stomach fullness condition of S.membranaceus
from Jebba Lake, Nigeria
|P*: Significant level for t-test between seasons; ns: non
significant; ES: Empty Stomach; QFS: Quarter Full Stomach; HFS: Half Full
Stomach; TQS: Three Quarter Full Stomach; FS: Full Stomach
||Seasonal variation in relative importance index of the major
food items in the stomach of S. membranaceus from Jebba Lake, Nigeria
||Seasonal variation in the relative importance index of the
major food items in the stomach of various size groups of S. membranaceus
from Jebba Lake, Nigeria
The variation in feeding intensity and dietary composition with sex may be due to the larger sizes attained by the females, thus enabling them to utilize relatively larger and nutritionally profitable food items such as Aspatharia and gastropod at the expense of the males. The lowest incidence of ES and QFS noted among the size groups 20-27 and 28-35 cm SL, respectively and the highest incidence of FS, TQS and HFS that fall between 20-35 cm SL indicate more intense feeding at this size group than others. The diversity in prey preference of the fish in all the size categories could be due to partitioning of food resource in a bid to avoiding intraspecific competition. This plasticity in diet composition of S. membranaceus in Jebba Lake reflects the availability of preferred prey organisms within a particular niche. The same reason could also be advanced for the progressive decline or increase in relative importance of the food items, as the fish grew older (Table 4). The establishment of detritus as the main food items in the juveniles (12-19 cm SL) suggested a filter-feeding habit. The ventral location of the mouth encourages a detritivorous mode of feeding. However, the inclusion of varied and large size food items in larger specimens indicated a switch from a filter feeding to increase reliance or active predation on appropriately sized prey that are probably selected individually. This may have been informed by the development of strong pharyngeal teeth and jaws. The diversity thus observed in the dominant food items as well as the mode of feeding agreed with Nikolskii (1969), Ayinla (1988), Fagbenro et al. (1991) and Fagbenro (1992).
The switch from filter feeding to a predatory habit with increasing fish size is a common phenomenon in catfishes (Lowe-McConnell, 1975; Welcomme, 1985) and same phenomenon observed in S. membranaceus is not strange. Also, the progression from detritivorous diets through a transitional planktivorous phase to active predation on relatively bigger-sized prey with increasing fish size agrees with the observations of Ikusemiju and Olaniyan (1977), Willoughby (1979), Ochieng (1982) and Fagbenro (1992) that catfishes show a high degree of plasticity in their diets utilizing different food items as they grow. Preference for molluscs at adult stage could possibly be due to their small size, cylindrical shape and their high population in the reservoir. Being predominantly molluscivorous as adults suggests that S. membranaceus may provide a suitable non-chemical tool in the control of water molluscs and thus reducing molluscs transmitted diseases such as schistosomiasis. The significant rainy season increase in ES and QFS and a significant dry season increase in HFS, TQS and FS show that S. membranaceus fed less actively in the wet season than in the dry season. Owolabi (2005) reported that S. membranaceus bred in the wet season (April-October) in Jebba Lake. Therefore, the higher feeding activity in the dry season may be aimed at building up more fat stores in preparation for breeding in the wet season. The apparent changes in the relative importance index of food items with season suggests that the feeding habits of the fish changed at different times of the year depending on whatever food is available. Detritus, P. adusta, coleopteran larvae, copepods, seeds and plant parts were mostly consumed when gastropod; Spirogyra and Aspatharia were seemingly of less significance in the diets of the species (Table 6).
The transition from insectivorous diets in the rainy season to benthophagous
diet in the dry season (Table 7) in specimen above 27 cm SL
is an indication of food selectivity depending on the relative abundance of
available food as well as the size spectrum. The size, which consumes more of
particular major dietary items, augmented its food with less of other items
as supplements. The consumption of food materials rich in supply at a particular
season and supplementing such when in short supply along with size variation
point towards means of avoiding or reducing possible competition within the
species in the lake system. Changes in fish diet associated with size and in
relation to seasonal availability have been reported by Arawomo (1976), Ugwumba
and Adebisi (1992), Odum and Anuta (2001) and Saliu (2002). The increase in
the quantitative composition of insects and their parts during the rainy season
is attributed to the life history patterns of the insects and probably to the
foraging efficiency of S. membranaceus. Detrital particles together with
allochtonous food such as plant seeds washed by flood from the surrounding vegetation
into the lake might have been responsible for the high incidence of each of
these diets during the rainy season. The prominence of seeds in the rainy season
raises the matter of their dispersal by S. membranaceus. Dispersal of
seeds has been suggested for a number of fish species (Gottsberger, 1978; Goulding,
1980; Souza-Stevaux et al., 1994; Ezenwaji, 2002). The more dependence
of S. membranaceus on detrital materials in the rainy season than dry
season disagrees with the observation of Welcomme (1985) and Ezenwaji (2002).
The mixed diet in the intermediate size (20-27 cm SL) emphasizes the importance
of supplementary diet at ensuring optimal growth of the fish during artificial
The feeding strategies of S. membranaceus permit the exploitation of all the food niches in the lake, i.e., the bottom, mid water and water-air interface. Although, the species subsists on any available dietary items in the lake, but seems to have propensity to feeding on molluscs when adult stage is attained. The wide distribution of the fish in the lake is therefore, consequent upon the rich variety and high quality food available to it and its ability to switch to available food items despite seasonal changes.
Adeniji, H.A., 1991. Limnology and biological production in the pelagic zone of Jebba Lake, Nigeria. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Ibadan, Nigeria.
Akinwumi, F.O., 2001. Food and feeding habits of Tilapia zillii (Pisces: Cichlidae) in Ondo State University Fish Farm. Proceeding of the16th Annual Conference of FISON, November 4-9, 2001, IEEE Xplore, London, pp: 195-198.
Arawomo, G.A., 1976. Food and feeding habits of three Citharinus species in lake Kainji, Nigeria. J. Fish Biol., 9: 3-10.
Ayinla, O.A., 1988. Nutrition and reproductive performance of Clarias gariepinus (Burchell, 1822). Ph.D. Thesis, University of Ibadan, Nigeria.
Ezenwaji, H.M.G., 1999. The abundance and trophic biology of Clarias albopunctatus Nichols and La Monte, 1953 (Osteichthyes: Clariidae) in tropical flood river basin. Hydrobiologia, 392: 159-168.
Direct Link |
Ezenwaji, H.M.G., 2002. The biology of Clarias ebriensis Pellegrin, 1920 (Osteichthyes: Clariidae) in an Africa rain forest river basin. Fish. Res., 54: 235-252.
Direct Link |
Fagade, S.O., 1978. On the biology of Tilapia guineensis (Dumeril) from the Lekki lagoon, Lagos, Nigeria. Nig. J. Sci., 12: 73-87.
Fagbenro, A.O., 1992. The dietary habits of the clariid catfish, Heterobranchus bidorsalis (Geoffroy St. Hilaire 1809) in Owena Reservoir, Southwestern Nigeria. Trop. Zool., 5: 11-17.
Fagbenro, O.A., T.S. Olaniran and A.O. Esan, 1991. Some aspects of the biology of the catfish, Heterobranchus bidorsalis Geoffroy Saint Hilaire, 1809 (Clariidae) in river Ogbese, Nigeria. J. Afr. Zool., 105: 363-372.
Fryer, G. and T.D. Iles, 1972. The Cichlid Fishes of the Great Lakes of Africa. Their Biology and Evolution. Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh, pp: 105-172.
George, E.L. and W.F. Hadley, 1979. Food and habit partitioning between rock bass (Ambloplites rupestris) and small mouth bass (Micropterus dolomieni) young of the year. Trans. Am. Fish. Soc., 108: 253-261..
Gottsberger, G., 1978. Seed dispersal by fish in the inundated region of Humaita, Amazonia. Biotropica, 10: 170-183.
Goulding, M., 1980. The Fishes and Forest: Exploitation in Amazonian Natural History. University of California, London, pp: 280.
Hyslop, E.J., 1980. Stomach content analysis, a review of methods and their application. J. Fish Biol., 17: 411-430.
Ikusemiju, K. and C.I.O. Olaniyan, 1977. The food and feeding habits of the catfishes, Chrysichthys walkeri (Gunthe), Chrysichthys filamentosus (Boulenger) and Chrysichthys nigrodigitatus (Lacepede) in the Lekki lagoon, Nigeria. J. Fish Biol., 10: 105-112.
Imevbore, A.M.A. and O. Bakare, 1970. The Food and Feeding Habits of Non-Cichlid Fishes of the River Niger in the Kainji Reservoir Area. In: Kainji, a Nigerian Man-Made Lake, Visser, S.A. (Ed.). NISER, Ibadan, pp: 49-64.
Jobling, M., 1981. The influences of feeding on the metabolic rate of fishes: A short review. J. Fish Biol., 18: 385-400.
King, R.P., 1996. Length-Weight relationships of Nigerian freshwater fishes. Naga, ICLARM. Q., 19: 45-52.
Lowe-McConnell, R.H., 1975. Fish Communities in Tropical Freshwaters: Their Distribution, Ecology and Evolution. Longman, London, pp: 337.
Nikolskii, G.V., 1969. Fish Population Dynamics. Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh, pp: 323.
Ochieng, J., 1982. Reproductive biology and feeding ecology of predatory siluroid catfish: Bagrus docmac Forskall (Pisces: Bagridae) in Winam Gulf of Lake Victoria: East Africa. M.Sc. Thesis. University of Nairobi, Kenya.
Odum, O. and M. Anuta, 2001. The food and feeding habits of Phractolaemus ansorgii (Boulenger) from Warri River, Nigeria. J. Aquat. Sci., 16: 18-21.
Direct Link |
Ogbeibu, A.E. and P.U. Ezeunara, 2005. Studies on the food composition and feeding pattern of fish communities in the Ikpoba River, Southern Nigeria. J. Aquatic Sci., 20: 117-129.
Direct Link |
Otubusin, S.O., 1986. Some ornamental fish species in Lake Kainji and some tips on aquarium fish care. Fisheries enterprise and information brochure. Proceedings of the 5th Annual Conference of FISON, 1986, Kainji Lake Research Institute, New Bussa, pp: 35-37.
Owolabi, O.D., 2005. Some aspects of the biology of Synodontis membranaceus Geoffroy Saint Hilarie in Jebba lake, Nigeria. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Ilorin, Nigeria.
Reed, W., J. Burchad, A.J. Hopson, J. Jenness and I. Yaro, 1967. Fish and Fisheries of Northern Nigeria. 1st Edn., Ministry of Agriculture, Northern Nigeria, Pages: 226.
Ricker, W.E., 1968. Method of Assessment of Fish Production in Freshwater. Blackwell, Oxford, pp: 313.
Saliu, J.K., 2002. Size, sex and seasonal dynamics in the dietary composition of Brycinus nurse (Pisces: Characidae), from Asa reservoir, Ilorin, Nigeria. Rev. Biol. Trop., 50: 233-238.
Direct Link |
Souza-Stevaux, M.C.D., R.R.B. Negrelle and V. Citadini-Zanette, 1994. Seed dispersal by the fish Pterodoras granulosus in the Parana River basin, Brazil. J. Trop. Ecol., 10: 621-626.
Teugels, G.G., 1996. Taxonomy, Phylogeny and biogeography of catfishes (Ostariophysi, Siluroidei): An overview. Aquat. Living Resour., 9: 9-34.
Direct Link |
Tudorancea, C.C., H. Fernando and J.C. Paggi, 1988. Food and feeding ecology of Oreochromis niloticus (L.) juveniles in Lake Awassa (Ethiopia). Arch. Hydrobiol. Suppl., 79: 267-289.
Ugwumba, A.A.A. and A.A. Adebisi, 1992. The food and feeding ecology of Sarotherodon melanotheron (Rupell) in a small freshwater reservoir in Ibadan, Nigeria. Arch. Hydrobiol., 124: 367-382.
Ward, H.B. and G.C. Whipple, 1950. Freshwater Biology. John Wiley, London, pp: 650.
Welcomme, R.L., 1985. Fisheries Ecology of Flood Plain Rivers. Longman, London, pp: 317.
Willoughby, N.G., 1974. The ecology of the genus Synodontis (Siluroidei) in Lake Kainji, Nigeria. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Southampton.
Willoughby, N.G., 1979. Some aspects of the ecology of Synodontis (Pisces: Siluroidei) in lake Kainji during its early years. Proceedings of the International Conference on Kainji Lake and River Basin Development in Africa, December 11-16, 1979, IEEE Xplore, London, pp: 376-386.