In recent years, Malaysia is maintaining a high economic growth and therefore,
its energy consumption is increased dramatically. Mahlia
et al. (2004) conducted survey on energy consumption and estimated
that electricity consumption has increased from 326 GWh in 1970 to 9,471 GWh
in 2000 in the residential sector in Malaysia. Varman
et al. (2005) predicted that residential electricity consumption would
be increased in 35,360 GWh in 2020. Rahman and Lee (2006)
investigated that the energy demand increased almost 20% within the last 3 years
(1999 to 2002). The energy demand is further expected to increase almost 60%
within 8 years (2002 to 2010). Mahlia et al. (2001)
investigated that room air conditioners were 253,399 units in 1991 to 726,540
units in 2005 and expected will be 956,155 units in 2010. In Malaysia, air conditioners
accounted about 42% of total electricity consumption for commercial building
and 30% of residential building. Figure 1 shows that the electricity
increasing year by year from year 1998 which is 53.4 to 68.4 billion kWh in
2002. The usage of domestic electricity in Malaysia has increased rapidly due
to the enhancement in the standard of living of the household. The American
Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) had
originated the Overall Thermal Transfer Value (OTTV) as a thermal performance
index for the envelope of air-conditioned buildings in 1975.
Electricity consumption in Malaysia (Source: CIA World factbook
unless otherwise noted, information in this page is accurate as of January
OTTV is considered a better performance index than thermal transmittance (U-value)
because it takes into account the impact of direct solar energy on the envelope
of mechanically cooled buildings. Lam et al. (2005)
completed a survey and investigated the OTTV of 144 buildings in the month of
June during 1992-2001 in Hong Kong. The OTTV was varied from 27 to 44 W m-2
with a mean value of 37.7 W m-2.
In the survey, OTTV for the residential buildings in Malaysia is studied. The
effects on OTTV by varying the building envelope design parameters are considered
as well. Tenaga Nasional Berhad (TNB) has carried out a series of survey and
educational program to study the consumption pattern and raise the level of
awareness among consumers on the importance on energy savings. One of the ways
to reduce the energy wastage is mainly from reducing the wastage of electricity.
Household appliances such as air conditioner, computer, television and refrigerator
are some of the area of interest as these appliances are used by consumer in
a daily basis.
The energy efficiency of room air conditioners has increased substantially
around the world. In the US, the average EER (Energy efficiency ratio, kW kW-1)
has increased from 5.98 in year 1972 to 9.08 in year 1996. By the year of 2001
this average is likely to climb above 10.0, driven by new room air conditioner
minimum efficiency standards that take effect in the year 2001 cooling season
(Mahlia et al., 2001). In Malaysia, it is recommended
that a minimum EER for all room air conditioners irrespective of size, which
will be allowed to enter the Malaysian market in the year 2002, should be 10.
The program seems to be beneficial to be implemented in this country in order
to reduce future electricity demand in the residential sector as well as reducing
the environmental impact caused by burning fossil fuels. Some method of comparing
energy use which is energy index is explained. The index selected would depend
on the intended application of the index and the normalizing factor. Among Architects
the normalizing factor for comparing buildings is the gross floor area. The
most commonly used index for comparing energy use in buildings is the Annual
Area Energy Use Index (AEUI). This is usually expressed as kWh/m2/year
which measures the total energy used in a building for one year in kilowatts
hours divided by the gross floor area of the building in square meters.
Among the Asian countries, Singapore is the first country to develop Building Energy Standards (BES) which was implemented in 1979 for commercial buildings through the Building Control (Space, Light and Ventilation) Regulations. Malaysia also adopted in 1987 OTTV as a building envelope thermal performance index in its energy standard for new commercial buildings. Having found that the solar absorption of external wall surfaces would affect the chiller load by 8-9%, wall surface absorption was included as a multiplicative factor in the term for heat conduction through opaque walls and roofs in the OTTV equation. All of them adopted the basic OTTV concept on the building envelopes, but their OTTV methods have been refined to reflect local conditions and simplify compliance. The provisions for lighting, HVAC systems and electric power are similar in nature and follow the principles of the ASHRAE Standard 90 series.
The aim of the study is to investigate the OTTV and the effect of the building design parameters on the OTTV in the residential buildings in Malaysia.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This research data has been collected using questionnaire survey. The survey
was conducted by Mechanical Engineering Department, University of Malaya in
OTTV concepts: Energy is one of the indispensable factors for continuous
development and economic growth. Energy consumption increased rapidly. Residential
energy consumption is one of the major energy consumption sectors. Overall Thermal
Transfer Value (OTTV) is meant to measure the envelope thermal performance of
air conditioning buildings that is followed an energy efficiency standard. Yik
and Wan (2005) stated that the OTTV is an appropriate building envelope
energy performance index for use in regulatory control. Based of the climatic
parameters, OTTV is calculated for residential building envelope designs in
Malaysia. To standardize the residential energy consumption, the researchers
researched about many parameters. The American Society of Heating, Refrigerating
and Air-Conditioning Engineers was introduced the Overall Thermal Transfer Value
(OTTV). The OTTV is measured the heat transfer from outside to inside the building.
Lam (2000) stated that there are three components of
heat transfer from outside to inside the building such as conduction through
the opaque surface, conduction through the glass and solar radiation through
the glass that is shown in Fig. 2.
OTTV for the walls: The surfaces of an opaque wall, solar and thermal
radiation together with convection heat transfer causes a net conduction heat
flow into the wall material. Hui (1997) stated that as
walls at different orientations receive different amounts of solar radiation,
the general procedure is to calculate the OTTV of individual walls with the
same orientation and then given by the weighted average of these values.
||Heat conduction through opaque wall, window glass and solar
radiation through window glass in a building
general form of OTTV equation for buildings:
||OTTV of a wall (W m-2)
||The ratio of window area to gross wall area
|Uw and Uf
||U-value of the opaque part of the wall and fenestration, respectively
|Aw, Af and AS
||Area of the opaque part of a wall, a fenestration and a skylight, respectively
||Equivalent temperature difference for the opaque part of a wall (°C)
||Shading coefficient of a fenestration or a skylight
||Solar factor (W m-2)
||Temperature difference between exterior and interior design conditions
Lam et al. (2005) stated that WWR is the percentage
of results from dividing the total glass area of the building by the total wall
||Height of the wall
||Length of the wall
||Width of the wall
||Total gross area of the wall
||Total gross area of the window
OTTV for the roof: The roof is almost similar to the wall. The calculation
of the OTTV for the roof is similar to the calculation of the wall.
Lam et al. (2005) stated that the calculations for the roof are often
simpler because the roof usually does not contain a large amount of glazing,
except for skylights over an atrium and similar to the walls. Yik
and Wan (2005) considered the compliance criterion for the OTTV of roofs
and investigated that OTTV is a constant value of 26.8 W m-2.
|| Mean outdoor temperatures of Kuala Lumpur in Malaysia
|Climatologically information is based on monthly averages
for the 30 years period from 1971 to 2000 (Source: World weather information
Determination of the OTTV parameters: Three parameters: indoor and outdoor
temperature difference (DT), Solar Factor (SF) and equivalent temperature difference
(TDeq) are related to the outdoor ambient temperature and the solar
radiation. The outdoor temperature of Kuala Lumpur is shown in Table
1. Their values depend on the weather conditions and the period over which
the measured temperature and solar radiation data are averaged. A darker surface
would absorb more solar heat.
Solar Factor (SF) of a glass wall is the ratio of the total solar energy flux
entering the premises through the glazing to the total incident solar energy
radiation. The lower the solar factor, the better the performance of the product.
Equivalent temperature difference considers both the conduction heat gain due
to the temperature difference between the indoor and the outdoor environment
and the effect of solar radiation on opaque surfaces. Surapong
(2006) developed countries experience OTTV equation with building energy
code and energy efficiency in the existing buildings of Thailand, Malaysia,
Singapore, Indonesia and Philippines. The OTTV standard equation for Malaysia
where, α (solar absorption coefficient) is the degree to which a substance (wall) will absorb solar energy.
Shading coefficient of fenestration (SC) is the ratio of solar heat gain through
a particular glass type compared to the solar heat gain through a 3 mm clear
float glass. It measures the ability of window to reduce solar heat gain. The
shading coefficient is expressed as a number between 0 and 1. The lower the
shading coefficient, the less solar heat it transmits and the greater its shading
capability. Typical values of different parameters of building in Malaysia are
shown in Table 2.
||Typical values of different parameters to calculate OTTV in
|| No. and types of residential building in the survey
||No. and window glass types of residential building in the
For example a window with shading coefficient 0.4 will prevent about 60% of
solar heat gain.
Data collection: A survey is conducted on residential buildings from
different areas in Kuala Lumpur and its nearby areas for the purpose of calculating
OTTV in Malaysia. A survey questionnaire is prepared to get the information
for OTTV and energy consumption of air conditioner of the residential buildings.
In the survey the information includes residential types (such as flat house,
single storey terrace, double storey terrace, bungalow, traditional house, condominium),
the length, width and height of the walls and the windows, grass types of the
windows (such as normal glass, normal glass with coatings, black glass, black
glass with coatings) and energy consumption of the residential buildings are
collected that are shown in Table 3 and 4.
The respondent has filled in the questionnaire form concerning the above characteristics
of the residential buildings. Residential building and window glass types and
number of houses are shown below in Table 3 and 4.
The survey is conducted on 100 residential buildings with 16806 m2
of walls area and 924 m2 of windows area.
After the data has been collected, data is being analyzed and presented in the chart or graphic using SPSS and Microsoft Office Excel. A statistical analysis computer program SPSS version 12.0 is used to analyze the surveyed data. The effects of varied residential parameters, such as WWR, SC, wall U-value and wall absorption on OTTV were carried out.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
OTTV of the residential building: The OTTV of the residential buildings in Malaysia has been calculated and shown in the Fig. 3. The OTTV varied from 35 to 65 W m-2 with a distinct peak at 37-40 W m-2, which accounted above one-third of the residential in the survey. The mean of the OTTV is 41.7 W m-2. In the survey, about 90% of residential building OTTV ranges from 35 to 49 W m-2. From the Fig. 3, about 80% of the residential building has OTTV below 45 W m-2. That means, if legislative control of building envelope design is to be introduced for residential building in Malaysia and set at 45 W m-2, 80% of the building in Malaysia are meet the requirement. There are about 10% of residential buildings OTTV over 50 W m-2. There are 03 traditional houses with OTTV above 60 W m-2. The mean OTTV is 41.7 W m-2 and still meet the requirements which the OTTV limit for wall in Malaysia is 45 W m-2.
The mean OTTV is 41.7 W m-2 and still meet the requirements which the OTTV limit for wall in Malaysia is 45 W m-2. Whereas the maximum OTTV is 65.2 W m-2 which is very high compared with the OTTV limit. Table 5 shows maximum, minimum and mean value of WWR, wall conduction, window solar radiation and OTTV of the residential buildings in Malaysia. The mean window solar radiation is 8.9 W m-2 and the mean wall heat conduction is 32.9 W m-2 which is 4 times mean window solar radiation. Hence, it concludes that OTTV for residential mostly from heat conduction through wall and only 20% through window solar radiation. This is due to WWR for residential which ranges from 0.01 to 0.18, that means only 1.05 to 18.16% of window glass area compared to total gross area of wall. Hence, the major thermal transfer value is contributed from heat conduction through opaque wall.
Effect of building parameters on OTTV: Many building design parameters
are taken into consideration during the design of the building. In the survey,
the four main residential building parameters are considered that are window
to wall ratio, Shading Coefficient (SC), U-value for wall (Uw) and
solar absorption (α). The mean OTTV from the results is taken as the base
value which is 41.7 W m-2.
||Distribution of OTTV among the 100 residential
|| Effect of WWR on OTTV
||Maximum, minimum and mean value of WWR, wall conduction, window
solar radiation and OTTV of residential buildings in Malaysia
The mean OTTV from the result is taken to be 100% and used as a reference. For all the cases with change in the varied parameter, the OTTV is expressed as a percentage of the amount of the base case called relative OTTV.
Effect of window to wall ratio on OTTV: The value of the WWR is found from 0.01 to 0.18. All other parameters such as SC, wall U-value and wall absorption are kept constant and the relative OTTV against the varied WWR is plotted and shown in Fig. 4. It is found that lower WWR value affects the OTTV to reduce, but the WWR for residential is already very low where the mean WWR value is 0.06 (only 6% of total wall gross area). So, the WWR does not affect the OTTV significantly for residential and it does not reduce the WWR.
Effect of shading coefficient on OTTV: The Shading Coefficient (SC)
is varied from 0.3 to 0.9 but all other parameters are kept on the base value
from survey. Figure 5 shows that the effect of shading coefficient
is a large impact on the OTTV. With shading coefficient 0.3 only reduce nearly
around 15% of OTTV. It should be noted that the window shading coefficient can
be reduced by applying a coating on window glass.
|| Effect of shading coefficient on OTTV
||Effect of opaque wall U-value on OTTV
Effect of opaque wall U-value on OTTV: Figure 6 shows
the relative OTTV (%) against varied U-value. By changing the SC back to original
value from survey and all the other parameters to be same as survey values.
U-value of the opaque wall is varied from 1.0 to 4.0 W m-2K. Lowering
the wall U-value can reduce the heat conduction through wall. By reducing the
U-value to 1.0 W m-2K for opaque wall; the OTTV can be reduced up
Effect of wall surface absorption on OTTV: The wall absorption is also varied from 0.3 to 0.9. Its effect on the OTTV is plotted that is shown in Fig. 7. With lower the wall absorption, the lower is OTTV. When wall absorption is 0.3 it is reduced around 50% of OTTV.
Overall effect on OTTV: OTTV is measured from the average heat gain into a building through its envelope. It is measured in W m-2. An air-conditioned building with a higher OTTV imposes a greater load on the air conditioning system, which would have to expend more electrical energy in removing it. All air conditioned buildings must be designed to have an OTTV of not more than 45 W m-2. This is aimed at achieving adequately designed building envelopes to cut down external heat gains and hence reduce the cooling load of air conditioning systems.
Figure 7 are shown that the wall U-value and wall absorption
have much larger impacts on the OTTV than other parameters. That means the OTTV
for residential in Malaysia mostly affects by wall heat conduction compared
to solar radiation for window. Heat loss on solar radiation is not critical
due to low WWR for residential.
|| Effect of wall absorption α on OTTV
||Annual electricity consumption of air conditioner
||Max, min and average energy consumption of residential buildings
So, the OTTV can be reduced by using lower wall U-value and lower wall absorption. Wall U-value and wall absorption can be reduced by thermal insulation the concrete brick for wall and using the light colour of wall external surface finish. Moreover introducing shades and coating on glass can reduce solar heat gain. With choice of windows with a low thermal transmittance characteristic will also minimize solar heat gain.
Energy consumption for air conditioner: The annual electricity consumption
of air conditioners of residential buildings in Malaysia is shown in the Fig.
8. Figure 8 shows that about 14, 10 and 5% residential
building air conditioners annual electricity consumption are in between 500
to 1000 kWh, 1000 to 2000 kWh and 7500 to 10000 kWh, respectively. This is considered
very high electricity consumption for the residential buildings. From the survey,
this high electricity consumption of air conditioner of residential buildings
is in urban and high income family. The maximum, minimum and average annual
electricity consumption of the air conditioner of residential buildings is 22055.5,
136.1 and 3708.8 kWh, respectively (Table 6).
The air conditioner ownerships are expected that the living status and life style will be standardized according to economic growth in the near future. Due to the increase of the living status and life style, it is predicted that the ownership of air conditioner will increase. So energy consumption will increase. As a result, all these socio-economic factors should be considered in reflecting the energy consumption of air conditioners. It is essential to enhance the public awareness towards global environment in order to achieve energy saving objectives in cities.
In Malaysia, it is found that the OTTV varied from 35 to 65 W m-2 with a mean value of 41.7 W m-2. The OTTV for residential in Malaysia mostly from wall conduction compared to window solar radiation, this is due to low WWR for residential. An air conditioned building with a higher OTTV imposes more cooling load on the air conditioning system. The OTTV of the air conditioned residential building should be designed not more than 45 W m-2. The maximum, minimum and average annual electricity consumption of the air conditioner of residential buildings is 22055.5, 136.1 and 3708.8 kWh, respectively. The four important residential parameters are window to wall ratio, shading coefficient, U-value for wall and solar absorption. The sensitivities of these parameters have provided the guideline to design and optimize the thermal performance of residential buildings. It is found that there are greater effect on OTTV for the wall U-value and wall absorption compared to other parameters.