Effect of Addition of a Sudanese Herb (Cymbopogon proximus) on Drinking Water Fluoride, Nitrate and Total Dissolved Salts Concentration Levels
Abdelmonem M. Abdellah,
Hago M. Abdel-Magid
Nadia A. Yahia
The Cymbopogon proximus (CP) (Cymbopogon schoenanthus) is commonly used in Sudan to purify and give a favorable aromatic flavor to drinking water. In this study, we examined experimentally the chemical effect resulting from the addition of CP on drinking water F-, NO3¯ and TDS levels. Screening and confirmatory laboratory tests were conducted to investigate the changes of the concentration levels of F¯, NO3¯ and TDS. For screening tests, we used two types of water, (1) drinking groundwater that naturally contaminated with nitrate, (2) Deionized water that artificially (experimentally) contaminated by nitrate. For confirmatory tests, we used only artificially nitrated deionized water. The results obtained indicated that the addition of 3.3 g CP L-1 water entirely removed NO3¯ contamination, as a promising result and at the same time increased both F- and TDS levels by different magnitudes depending on CP weight added and immersion time after the first 24 h passed. Increase of fluoride content in drinking water increases the risk of dental fluorosis prevalence and the other related diseases.
to cite this article:
Abdelmonem M. Abdellah, Hago M. Abdel-Magid and Nadia A. Yahia, 2012. Effect of Addition of a Sudanese Herb (Cymbopogon proximus) on Drinking Water Fluoride, Nitrate and Total Dissolved Salts Concentration Levels. American Journal of Drug Discovery and Development, 2: 194-203.
November 04, 2011; Accepted: March 31, 2012;
Published: May 16, 2012
The natural water analyses for physical and chemical properties are very important
for public health studies (Jafari et al., 2008).
Groundwater contamination can be resulted from lack of proper waste management
(Nkolika and Onianwa, 2011). Domestic wastewater, surface
water discharge and industrial waste have been reported among main factors that
cause groundwater contamination (Baghvand et al.,
2006). Treatment of drinking water with herbal plants as traditional medicine
is worldwide. In particular, the CP is widely used in Sudan in a purpose of
folk medicine. The CP is a herbal plant springs from the family Poaceae (Gramineae)
with a sub-species proximus (Gramineae). Common name is camel's hay and is known
locally as maharaib. It is a perennial herb, erect, tufted 9 cm
long, culms slender, glabrous and 3-4 noded. Leaf simple, alternate, linear
5-7 cm long, 1 cm wide, sheathed apex spiny entire, inflorescence spikelets
highly branched 5 cm log (Eltahir and EReish, 2010).
The plant is widely distributed in Africa (northwest tropical, northeast tropical
and east tropical), temperate Asia (western Asia and Arabia) and tropical Asia
(Indin and Indo-China) (Clayton et al., 2005).
In addition, CP is found in Northern and Central Sudan (Andrews,
The CP is highly reputed in folk medicine as an antispasmodic and urolithiasis
(renal stone removal), for gout, diuretic agent (Boulos, 1983),
flatulent, biotonic, analgesic for gastrointestinal track (GIT) disorders and
menstrual pains as well; the plant is used externally as anti-rheumatic and
cosmetic herb (Jomaha, 1988). The methanolic extraction
of CP showed relaxant properties when investigated on isolated rabbit jejunum
without showing toxic manifestations on the tissue, confirming the safety for
the plant extract (Hamad-Alneel, 2006). The plant is
used in prostate inflammation, kidney disease, inhibits kidney shrinkages, anthelmintic
and for stomach pains (Eltahir and EReish, 2010). The
CP exerted antihyperglycemic effects and consequently alleviates liver and renal
damage caused by alloxan-induced diabetes (Mansour et
The CP contains essential oils e.g., citronellal, careen-2, piperitone and
sterol which are widely used as pesticides. The plant contains triterpenes and
coumarins when fractionated by different solvents with the absence of saponins,
tannins, alkaloids, anthraquionone glycosides and flavonoids. Studies on the
toxicological effect of the CP showed no toxicity effects when used in traditional
medicine (Hamad-Alneel, 2006).
Gas Chromatography (GC) and Mass Spectrophotometry (MS) analyses performed
on the oil prepared from samples obtained from Burkina Faso and Sudan revealed
significant differences in the composition of the herb. Piperitone was identified
as the major component in samples obtained from Burkina Faso while those of
Sudan were free from this component (Menut et al.,
Eight compounds were isolated from CP by preparative thin layer chromatography
(TLC). The isolated compounds were found are sesquiterpenes. Five of them (compounds
1, 2, 3, 5 and 7) are derivatives of eudesmol. While, compound 4 is a ketonic
monocyclic sesquiterpene and compound 8 is an alcoholic monocyclic sesquiterpene,
compound 6 was the only straight chain aliphatic unsaturated aldehyde (Al-Assiuty
et al., 2006). The eudesm compounds are: 5, 11 dihydroxy-1, 3- diene,
eudesm 4 hydroxymethyl-11-hydroxy 1, 4 diene, eudesm 7, 11 dihydroxy 3 ene,
atlantone, eudesm 4 methyleene-5-methoxy-11-ol, 2 methyl undec-2-ene-10-al,
eudesm-11-ol and elemol. The following compounds also were isolated from the
unsaponifiable fraction of the petroleum ether extract of CP: proximadiol, 5α-
hydroperoxy-β-eudesmol, 1β-hydroxy-β-eudesmol, 1β-hydroxy-α-eudesmol,
5α-hydroperoxy-β-eudesmol and 7α, 11dihydroxy cadin-10(14)-ene
(El-Askary et al., 2003).
As being observed, the treatment of drinking water with CP is widely spread in the Sudan and it is commonly used in folk or traditional medicine or for aesthetic reasons in order to add a favorable aromatic flavor. Therefore, this study, intends to examine experimentally the effect of CP on groundwater F¯, NO3¯ and TDS levels.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Collection of samples and materials: Adequate amounts of CP were purchased from Rufaa market, east of Gezira locality of Sudan. Large plastic container (4 liter volume) were used for collecting groundwater naturally containing 1.1 mg F¯L-1, 4.5 mg NO3¯ L-1 and 360 mg TDS L-1 from Umm-Dawanban, Sharkelneel Locality to be used for the screening test. Deionized water was used in both the screening and the confirmatory tests.
Chemical analyses: The determinations were carried out according to
the standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater (APHA,
1998) and Rhoades (1982). The electric conductivity
(EC) (dS m-1 at 25°C) in groundwater samples was measured by
Beckman Solu Bridge type equipment in 100 mL of the water sample. To convert
the EC readings to TDS, the results for the EC dS m-1 were multiplied
by 640 according to Rhoades (1982). Fluoride was determined
by Alizarin Visual method according to APHA (American Public Health Association):
1998. Nitrate is reduced almost quantitatively to nitrite (NO2) in
the presence of cadmium. The NO2¯ thus obtained is determined
colorimetrically using instrument model SPECORD 40-analytik Jenas spectrophotometer
Natural well drinking water screening test: Screening tests were
conducted to investigate the effect of CP on F¯, NO3¯ and
TDS concentration levels in a well drinking water sample. The F¯, NO3¯
and TDS levels in the groundwater sample were analyzed before and after the
addition of CP. A random weight of CP (5 g) was added to 4 liters of well water
test sample containing naturally 1.1 mg F¯ L-1, 4.5 mg NO3¯
L-1 and 360 mg TDS L-1 and allowed to stand for about
3 days (72 h) at room temperature (30-32°C). The treated sample was filtered
and the filtrate was kept in a plastic bottle in the refrigerator (4°C)
Artificially nitrated deionized water screening test: A laboratory-screening test was also conducted to investigate the effect of CP on F¯, NO3¯ and TDS levels in an artificially nitrated deionized water samples. A total of 0.36099 gram of potassium nitrate (KNO3) was accurately weighed, transferred into a one-liter volume long-neck flask, thoroughly dissolved and completed to the mark with deionized water and a solution containing 221 mg NO3¯ L-1 was thus obtained. This solution was divided into four equal portions, 250 mL each and then each portion was transferred into 600 mL volume plastic bottle, completed to volume with deionized water to achieve a solution containing 92.25 mg NO3¯ L-1. This solution was devoid of any F¯ and its TDS was found to be 600 mg L-1 which was substantially induced by the addition of KNO3 to the deionized water. Four different weights of the CP (2.5, 5.0, 10, 20 g) were carefully and gently washed with deionized water, in order to remove any adhering soil residues and were then immersed into the 600 mL plastic bottles containing the 92.25 mg NO3¯ L-1 and allowed to stand for about 3 days (72 h). The treated sample of each bottle was transferred into 600 mL plastic bottle and kept in the refrigerator at 4°C pending analysis.
Confirmatory laboratory test: A 0.902475 g weight of KNO3
was accurately and quantitatively transferred into one-liter volume long neck
flask and completed to the mark with deionized water. Thus, a solution containing
553.57 mg NO3¯ L-1 was obtained. About 150 mL of
this solution were transferred into each of six 1.5-liter plastic bottles and
the volume was completed to 1.5 liter with deionized water to obtain a final
concentration of 55.36 mg NO3¯ L-1 and was then allowed
to stand under laboratory conditions for 24 h. Five different weights of CP
(5, 10, 15, 20 and 25 g) were then weighed and immersed (after being washed
with deionized water) into each of five 1.5-liter volume bottles and the sixth
bottle was left untreated i.e., containing 55.36 mg NO3¯ L-1
solution for control. The six bottles (five treated samples and one control)
were allowed to stand under laboratory conditions (temperature 30-32°C).
After one day each of the 6 bottles was sampled. Sampling was repeated after
two and three days and all samples were kept in the refrigerator at 4°C
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Screening tests: Table 1 summarizes the results obtained
for the screening tests of the addition of CP on both natural groundwater (NGW)
and artificially nitrated deionized water (ANDW), devoid of fluoride.
||Effect of addition of CP on the levels of NO3¯, F¯ and TDS
in NGW and ANDW (i.e., screening test)
|NGW: Natural groundwater (Naturally nitrated, fluoridated
and salted), ANDW: Artificially nitrated deionized water (free from F¯ and
the 600 mg L-1 TDS level resulted from the addition of KNO3), SA: Study
analysis, CP: Cymbopogon proximus (Cymbopogon schoenanthus), *: Percentage
decrease in NO3¯ levels, #: Percentage increase in both F¯ and TDS levels,
NA: Not available
After the addition of 5 g of CP, nitrate level in NGW was decreased from 4.5
to 0.4 mg L-1 (1025%). On the contrary, both F- and TDS
were increased from 1.1 to 2.5 mg L-1 (127%) and from 360 to 850
mg L-1 (136%), respectively. In ANDW, NO3¯ level
was decreased from 92.25 to 91 mg L-1 (1.4%), 66 mg L-1
(28%), 54.5 mg L-1 (17%) and 1.7 mg L-1 (97%) with an
increasing weight of CP of 2.5, 5 g, 10 and 20 g, respectively. Conversely,
a gradual increase was observed in the concentration levels of both F¯
and TDS with an increasing weight of CP. According to Table 1,
F¯ level was increased from 0.0 to 1.5 mg L-1, 2.7, 3.5 and
4.9 mg L-1 while TDS level was increased from 600 to 810 mg L-1
(35%), 985 mg L-1 (64%), 1150 mg L-1 (92%) and 1560 mg
L-1 (160%) with an increasing weight of CP of 2.5, 5, 10 and 20 g,
Control sample: Table 2 shows the levels of F¯,
NO3¯ and TDS in ANDW control sample at zero time and after 24
h. No changes were observed in both F- and TDS levels while NO3¯
level was apparently affected. It has been confirmed that NO3¯
level in groundwater usually decreases as time progresses due to auto-dissolution
of NO3¯ (if the source of NO3¯ is eliminated)
(Alvarez and Illman, 2006); this is demonstrated and confirmed
in this study by observing the trend of control sample in Fig.
1 which showed the reduction of NO3¯ with time. The initial
calculated NO3¯ level in the control sample of the artificially
nitrated deionized water is 55.36 mg NO3¯ L-1. After
24, 48 and 72 h of incubation in the laboratory NO3¯ levels
were reduced to 38.4 (31% reduction), 36.6 (34% reduction) and 31.5 mg NO3¯
L-1 (43% reduction), respectively. The degradation of NO3¯
contaminant with time in control sample may be attributed to the redox reactions
involving electron transfer as follows:
|| Fluoride, nitrate and TDS changes in control samples in confirmatory
test of artificially nitrated deionized water (ANDW)
|ANDW is free from F¯, The 55.36 mg L-1 NO3¯
and the 410 mg L-1 TDS levels resulted from the addition of KNO3
|| Nitrate auto-dissolution in control sample
The contaminant is reduced if it gains electrons and the electron donor becomes
oxidized. Redox reactions are often mediated by microorganisms (Alvarez
and Illman, 2006).
Effect of CP on water NO3¯ level: A high level of NO3¯
is seen as a threat to both public health and natural waters, of these threats
the latter is the more immediate but the health issue has attracted more public
concern, as the presence of nitrate in drinking water has been linked to a number
of medical conditions such as blue baby syndrome (methaemoglobinaemia) in infant
(Curley et al., 2009). Nitrate is effective plant
nutrient and moderately toxic (Naeem et al., 2007).
Nitrate can be removed from drinking water by carbon. The denitrification depends
on the carbon source and reactor type (Magram, 2010).
It may be inferred from Fig. 2 that the addition of 5 g CP
to the artificially nitrated deionized water reduced NO3¯ level
from 55.36 mg NO3¯ L-1 to 31.1 mg NO3¯
L-1 (44% reduction) after the first period (24 h). The NO3¯
level was reduced to zero (i.e., the solution was free from NO3¯)
after each of the second and the third periods (48 and 72 h), respectively,
i.e., reduction percentage of 100%. The addition of 10 g CP to the nitrated
solution reduced NO3¯ level from 55.36 mg NO3¯
L-1 to 21.8 mg NO3¯ L-1 (60% reduction)
after the first period, reduction was 100% complete during the second and third
periods (48 and 72 h) of incubation. The addition of 15 g CP to nitrated solution
decreased the NO3¯ concentration level from 55.36 to 16.7 mg
L-1 ( 69.83% reduction) after the first period (24 h) while during
the second and the third period (48 and 72 h) the nitrated solution was devoid
of any NO3¯ i.e. (100% reduction). The addition of higher weights
i.e., 20 and 25 g of CP reduced NO3¯ concentration level from
55.36 mg L-1 to zero level after the first period (24 h) of incubation
i.e., 100% reduction. Noteworthy that, this reduction includes both nitrate
auto-dissolution (in control) and the effect of addition of CP). Commercially,
nitrate can be removed from drinking water by either standard anion resins or
|| Effect of addition of CP on NO3- level
of deionized water
|| Effect of addition of CP on fluoride level of deionized water
The functional groups of the synthesized standard anion resins commonly used
for nitrate removal are trimethylamine (NC3H9) and dimethyl
ethanolamine (NC4H10OH). In nitrate-selective resins,
the functional groups are tributylamine (NC16H33) and
triethylamine (NC6H15). The natural functional group in
the chemical compounds of CP could be the -C3H6OH group
that characterizes eudesmol which is the main component of CP herb (Al-Assiuty
et al., 2006; El-Askary et al., 2003)
and the nitrogen component may be offered by plant tissues. Thus, the CP herb
may acts as a natural anion exchange and/or nitrate-selective resin which, may
be obtained after immersing CP into water. In addition, redox reactions that
mediated by microorganisms (Alvarez and Illman, 2006;
Chitra and Lakshmanaperumalsamy, 2006) induced by addition
of CP to the water sample may be also contribute to NO3¯ reduction.
Effect of CP on water F¯ level: Figure 3 shows the ascending level trends of F¯ levels with the increasing CP weights. Obvious increase of F¯ level can be noticed with the progress of immersion time. Addition of 5 g CP to 1.5 liter F¯ free deionized water conferred 0.6 mg F¯ L-1 after duration of 24 h and this level was sustained during 48 h. Fluoride level increased from 0.6 to 1.0 mg L-1 during the 72 h incubation period and remained constant at this level even after the addition of 10 g CP. At the CP rate of 15 g F¯ level was increased to 1.2 mg L-1 and remained so at the 20 g CP rate during the incubation periods of 24 and 48 h, however, at the duration of 72 h, the F¯ level increased to about 2.5. At the rate of 25 g CP high levels of fluoride were observed amounting to 3.0, 3.5 and 4.0 mg F¯/l at the incubation periods of 24, 48 and 72 h, respectively.
It has previously been reported that plants can uptake and accumulate F¯
into their tissues (Elhadi, 2004). Therefore, CP plants
(herbs) that grow in soils with high F- content or irrigated with
water of high F- content may accumulate F¯ into their tissues.
This infers that when CP was immersed into or added to water, may add extra
amounts of F¯ to it, thus elevating its total F¯ content.
Effect of CP on water TDS level: The palatability of water with a TDS
level of less than 600 mg L-1 is generally considered to be good
(Matloob, 2011). It has been reported that continuous
pumping of groundwater increases TDS level (Al-Salamah and
|| Effect of addition of CP on TDS level of deionized water
The TDS level in control sample (deionized water) is 410 mg L-1
which resulted from addition of potassium nitrate. According to Fig.
4, the TDS level was positively affected by both immersion time and weight
of CP. In the control, as in F¯, the TDS levels remained constant at 410
mg L-1 with the progress of time. The TDS level increased to 899
mg L-1 after adding 5 g CP and remained constant at 899 mg L-1
during all of the incubation duration of 24, 48 and 72 h. At the rate of 10
g CP the TDS level increased to 1229 mg L-1 and remained constant
during all of the incubation period of 24, 48 and 72 h. At the rate of 15 g
CP, the TDS level remained at 1229 mg L-1 after 24 h, then the level
jumped to 1638 mg L-1 after 48 and 72 h of incubation and remained
at this level even after 24 h incubation at the rate of 20 g CP. Afterwards,
at the rate of 20 g CP, the TDS level was increased to 1843 and 2038 mg L-1
after 48 and 72 h, respectively. The TDS increased progressively to 2417, 2662
and 3072 mg L-1 after 24, 48 and 72 h of incubation at 25 g of CP,
respectively. The increase in the magnitude of the TDS in water, due to the
addition of CP, may be explained as follows: During immersion time of the CP
herb in water, chemical constituents in the CP herb may have been released into
the solution thus elevating the TDS level (Elhadi, 2004).
From the previous results pertaining to the effect of CP addition on the level of F¯, NO3¯ and TDS to deionized water, it can be concluded that the addition of CP to artificially nitrated deionized water entirely eliminates NO3¯ contamination and at the same time increases both F¯ and TDS levels. Addition of 5 g of CP to 1.5 liter of water (3.3 g L-1) entirely reduces NO3¯ contamination and at the same time increases both F¯ and TDS levels by different magnitudes depending on CP weight used and immersion time. It is advisable to add CP to drinking water of high level of NO3¯. Addition of CP to drinking water of high level of F- should be avoided. On the other hand, the CP may be added, cautiously, to drinking water deficient in F¯ in order to increase its F¯ content to the optimum level that removes the concern related to dental caries and at the same time to impart pleasant flavor to drinking water that preferable in the study area.
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
This study revealed that the addition of CP "maharaib" at the rate of 5 g CP/1.5 liter water (3.3 g L-1) to groundwater removes NO3¯ in 48 h and at the same time increases TDS and F- levels and consequently increases the risk of dental fluorosis incidence and other fluoride adverse effects.
The recommendation are as follows:
||Addition of "maharaib herb", as practiced in folk medicine,
to groundwater of high levels of fluoride should be avoided because as has
been demonstrated in this study, the herb increases water fluoride content.
On the other hand, the "maharaib herb" may be added, cautiously, to drinking
groundwater deficient in fluoride ion in order to increase its fluoride
content to the optimum level that removes the risk of dental caries
||It is recommended to add "maharaib herb" to drinking groundwater of high
levels of nitrate in order to reduce its nitrate level in communities where
nitrate ion contamination is excessively beyond the maximum permissible
level set by the SSMO (2002)
The authors acknowledge the assistance of all those who contributed to this study.
APHA, 1989. Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater. 17th Edn., American Public Health Association, Inc., Washington DC.
Al-Assiuty, E.M., F.M. Bekheet, Z.M. Fahmy, A.M. Ismael and T.S.M. El-Alfy, 2006. Potentiality of some isolated compounds from Halfa Bar (Cymbopogon proximus stapf.) against the Toxigenic Fungi Fusarium verticilioides and Asprgillus flavus. Egypt. J. Phytopathol., 34: 75-84.
Direct Link |
Al-Salamah, I.S. and I.N. Nassar, 2009. Trends in drinking water quality for some wells in Qassim, Saudi Arabia, 1997-2009. J. Applied Sci., 9: 3555-3561.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Alvarez, P.J.J. and W.A. Illman, 2006. Bioremediation and Natural Attenuation: Process Fundamentals and Methematical Models. Wiley Interscience, Inc., New Jersey, USA., ISBN: 987-0-471-65043-0, Pages: 609.
Andrews, F.W., 1963. The Flowering Plants of the Sudan. Vol. 3, T. Buncle and Co. Ltd., Arbroath, Scotland., Pages: 422.
Baghvand, A., G.R. Nabi, N. Mehrdadi, S. Givehchi and M. Ardestani, 2006. Contamination of ground water in heavy metals concentration of tabriz industrial zone. J. Applied Sci., 6: 1652-1658.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Boulos, L., 1983. Medicinal Plants of North Africa. Reference Publication Inc., Michigan, USA., Pages: 92.
Chitra, A.V. and P. Lakshmanaperumalsamy, 2006. Biodegradation of nitrate in wastestreams from explosives manufacturing plants. Res. J. Microbiol., 1: 142-151.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Clayton, W.D., K.T. Harman and H. Williamson, 2005. World Grass Species-Descriptions (Cymbopogon schoenanthus). Version 8, Royal Botanic Garden, Kew, UK.
Curley, E.M., M.G. O'Flynn and K.P. McDonnell, 2009. Nitrate leaching losses from miscanthus x giganteus impact on groundwater quality. J. Agron., 8: 107-112.
El-Askary, H.I., M.R. Meselhy and A.M. Galal, 2003. Sesquiterpenes from Cymbopogon proximus. Molecules, 8: 670-677.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Elhadi, H.A., 2004. Assessment of Fluoride Concentration in Drinking Water in Gedaref Town and its Uptake by Some Vegetables Plants. M.Sc. Thesis, Institute of Environmental Studies, University of Khartoum.
Eltahir, A.S. and A.B.I. EReish, 2010. omparative foliar epidermal studies in Cymbopogon citrates and Cymbopogon schoenanthus in Sudan. J. Chem. Pharm. Res., 2: 449-455.
Hamad-Alneel, E.I.M., 2006. Formulation and Quality Assurance of a Sudanese Herb. M.Sc. Thesis, Department of Pharmaceutics, Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Khartoum, Sudan.
Jafari, A., H. Mirhossaini, B. Kamareii and S. Dehestani, 2008. Physicochemical analysis of drinking water in kohdasht city lorestan, Iran. Asian J. Applied Sci., 1: 87-92.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Jomaha, H.F., 1988. Text Book of Medicinal: Aromatic and Toxic Plants in Arab Countries. League of Arab Countries for Agricultural Development, Egypt.
Magram, S.F., 2010. Drinking water denitrification in a packed bed anoxic reactor: effect of carbon source and reactor depth. J. Applied Sciences, 10: 558-563.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Mansour, H.A., A.S.A. Newairy, M.I. Yousef and S.A. Sheweita, 2002. Biochemical study on the effects of some Egyptian herbs in alloxan-induced diabetic rats. Toxicology, 170: 221-228.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Matloob, M.H., 2011. Fluoride concentration of drinking water in Babil-Irag. J. Applied Sci., 11: 3315-3321.
Menut, C., J.M. Bessiere, D. Samate, A.K. Djibo, G. Buchbauer and B. Schopper, 2000. Aromatic plants of Tropical West Africa. XI. Chemical composition, antioxidant and antiradical propartias of the essential oils of three Cymbopogon species from Burkina Faso. J. Essential Oil Res., 12: 207-212.
Direct Link |
Naeem, M., K. Khan, S. Rehman and J. Iqbal, 2007. Environmental assessment of ground water quality of Lahore Area, Punjab, Pakistan. J. Applied Sci., 7: 41-46.
CrossRef | Direct Link |
Nkolika, I.C. and P.C. Onianwa, 2011. Preliminary study of the impact of poor waste management on the physicochemical properties of ground water in some areas of Ibadan. Res. J. Environ. Sci., 5: 194-199.
Direct Link |
Rhoades, J.D., 1982. Soluble Salts. In: Methods of Soil Analysis, Part 2: Chemical and Microbiological Properties, Page, A.L., R.H. Miller and D. Keeney (Eds.). 2nd Edn., American Society of Agronomy Inc., Madison, Wisconsin, pp: 167-179.